Weaponsmith Archive

Thread: Weaponsmith ethics question from a customer

BloodMonk
Tue Oct 04, 2005 12:47 am
#27

you're still a conman....there's no way you can talk yourself out of it...


charging 1 mil AND stealing loot components = you're a scamming tard





Proud Member of -BLOOD-

I HATE GRINDING)

"Invader's blood marches through my veins like giant radioactive rubber pants! The pants command me! Do not ignore my veins!"

Managing the Bloodmonks Weapon Facility (aka Sly's Slavepit), Producer of fine specialty weapons.
Whrlwnd13
Tue Oct 04, 2005 5:58 am
#28

This guy is an outright cheat!


I had an extra power cell the other day after crafting a Flamer for a client. It was a really nice cell +188 dmg. we hadn't agreed on price before crafting so I was hoping that he'd give it to me. I offered to take the cell as compensation or he could pay for the flamer and keep the cell. He decided that he wanted a DL 44 made with the remaining cell (i would have made a scatter).


I would have rather had the cell then the cost that I charge for crafting when clients provide the components. But he's the client and I would never consider taking advantage of any of my clients! Any weaponsmith that wouldcheat his clients should be banned from the galaxy!


I love the idea of placing an AFK toon by his shop and spamming that he's a cheater. You might get in trouble for greiving but it'd be worth it IMO. i'd be sure to include the url to this thread if you spam at his shop.




Xyrek Lok
Master Weaponsmith
12pt WS, +20 FS Experimentation
Crafting High Quality Weapons Since 03/2004

WP 1190 -3620 1km NE of Coronet at the Omega Force Guildhall

- I supported keeping & balancing the old combat system SOE didn't care and gave us the WoW/EQ2 clone anyway
-Stinks-
Tue Oct 04, 2005 11:06 am
#29

Thanks for putting your vendor location in your sig... got an ahazi toon on the way to spam at your front door... good luck keeping business going.




Atz_Breh wrote:


first of all i don´t care about any of your forum posts, some nerd tried to ruin my buisness before coz he couldn´t place a order and failed miserably, i even got2 orders for RIS armor coz of his post


2 days after the assembly you emailed me about the remaining scopes i told you i allready used them in other weapons while assuming u don´t want any of them back as u didn´t say anything about the scopes when i made the weapons, if u said u want the scopes back i´d of courz given them back...


i was afk for the whole weekend so i didn´t reply to your emails...now i asked you what u want in exchange for the scopes, you said u don´t want money, u want equivalent scopes back, i told u that i can´t provide the scopes...and now you make this post


i offered money, you don´t want it,...so:


i won´t deal with you anymore...



i may be ignorant but i don´t deal with ppl that try to flame on the forums anymore



this doesn´t affect all my other customers wich are 100% satisfied with some of the finest weapons on ahazi...









the original Radiant chars of Stinks, Precision, Malfunction (2nd player)

All accounts cancelled - this is working as intended

Stinks - City of Villians (Justice Server)

/flail
WCjtace
Tue Oct 04, 2005 11:22 am
#30



Whatever happened to the buyer being responsible for knowing what he was buying??? You guys sure are quick to jump on and condemn the WS. Even though the price was high, it sounds like it was agreed on and you can't just decide you don't like it anymore after you've paid it. I'd consider the price to be a little steep buy the buyer paid for it so that's his responsibility to know what he's paying for. I think the extra scopes are just a lack of communication and some bad luck, he wouldn't be in business now if he was out to cheat everyone. But it's not like the scopes actually do anything for you in combat, tests I've seen show they really don't matter.




Message Edited by WCjtace on 10-04-2005 01:26 PM

Elorha
Tue Oct 04, 2005 11:27 am
#31






WCjtace wrote:


Whatever happened to the buyer being responsible for knowing what he was buying??? You guys sure are quick to jump on and condemn the WS. I'd consider the price to be a little steep buy the buyer paid for it so that's his responsibility to know what he's paying for. I think the extra scopes are just a lack of communication and some bad luck. But it's not like the scopes actually do anything for you in combat, tests I've seen show they really don't matter.









Whether they are effective or not is not the point, if someone steals something from you, they should be held accountable. This is about ethics, or the lack thereof, not whether or not they worked



Before Having a Weapon or Armor crafted, Check the reputation of your chosen crafter. Most are ethical and do an outstanding job, Others will rip you off and Lie. Buyer Beware!
EdOWar
Tue Oct 04, 2005 11:35 am
#32






WCjtace wrote:



Whatever happened to the buyer being responsible for knowing what he was buying??? You guys sure are quick to jump on and condemn the WS. Even though the price was high, it sounds like it was agreed on and you can't just decide you don't like it anymore after you've paid it. I'd consider the price to be a little steep buy the buyer paid for it so that's his responsibility to know what he's paying for. I think the extra scopes are just a lack of communication and some bad luck, he wouldn't be in business now if he was out to cheat everyone. But it's not like the scopes actually do anything for you in combat, tests I've seen show they really don't matter.





Message Edited by WCjtace on 10-04-200501:26 PM





The issue at hand is not the price paid. The issue at hand is that the WS in question took extra scopes without agreeing before hand with the customer. Most non-WS have no idea how many of each component is required in making a weapon, and it is the WS job to inform the customer. Also, if the WS would like to keep extra components, it is the WS job to ask the customer if it's okay to do so (or to offer to take extra components as payment instead of credits). It sounds like the WS in question here did neither.


The WS took advantage of a customers ignorance about weaponcrafting. At the very least it was unprofessional, if not unethical.


Slim Vargo, Corbantis
WCjtace
Tue Oct 04, 2005 2:03 pm
#33

Unprofessional, yes for sure. I don't deny the customer got taken advantage of. I'm just dissapointed the buyer didn't exercise due dilligence, and then several days after the fact go back and say oh yeah you screwed me, pay up. Once a deals done, it's done, a few hours is one thing, but a few days...
Elorha
Tue Oct 04, 2005 2:12 pm
#34







WCjtace wrote:
Unprofessional, yes for sure. I don't deny the customer got taken advantage of. I'm just dissapointed the buyer didn't exercise due dilligence, and then several days after the fact go back and say oh yeah you screwed me, pay up. Once a deals done, it's done, a few hours is one thing, but a few days...




If you go back through the post, I started trying to contact him at once. He was "AFK" for several days or so he says

Message Edited by Elorha on 10-04-2005 02:15 PM



Before Having a Weapon or Armor crafted, Check the reputation of your chosen crafter. Most are ethical and do an outstanding job, Others will rip you off and Lie. Buyer Beware!
ShugFlurry
Tue Oct 04, 2005 2:26 pm
#35



WCjtace wrote:

But it's not like the scopes actually do anything for you in combat, tests I've seen show they really don't matter.

Message Edited by WCjtace on 10-04-2005 01:26 PM





You wouldn't have a NS bicep would you? That doesn't do anything for ya, if you could be so kind as to offer give it to me I'd be very grateful.



Shug
12pt Master WeaponSmith Master Force Crafter
-843 2827 Dantooine, Mining Outpost
maigy
Tue Oct 04, 2005 2:44 pm
#36

Wow this IMO would be completly un-acceptable.... Many times I have had to explain exactly what it is that goes into a weapon. I never charge anything for doing these kind of custom orders... I inform them that I would appreciiate any left overenhancers if they don't want them, but if they do then I have no problem giving them back.... I even tell than that if I need to make a schematic for a component and there will be left overenhancers that they can keep the schematic for future use or if they dont want to I will try to hold onto the schematic for awhile incase they want something else made.

If he hadnt charged such an insane amount for crafting it for you, I could understand why he would think that it was ok to keep the extra scopes, but since he did rip you off with the 1 million, I can't believe he thought it was OK to screw you again on the scopes.



Offer all auction winnings to one of my vendors at my store.
Maigrey Master Weaponsmith, Master Droid Engineer, Master Merchant

Zayra Master Pistoleer, Master Smuggler, CM 4000

Maigrey's Weapons Coronet(radiant) WP -251, -5676
WCjtace
Wed Oct 05, 2005 8:28 am
#37

I would make sure you always get everything that you want back, back before you pay him and accept the weapon. Once that happens, I would consider the deal completeand it's much more difficult to modify the deal after that.



Shug, actually I know a friend who no longer plays that has one.


IonovTeutonian
Wed Oct 05, 2005 11:10 am
#38

Hey charletan!!!!!!!!


Plain and simple you knew what you were doing. You kept the scopes hoping the person was too ignorent to know what they were orthere inherent value. This temptation happens to us all. But to do it is wrong. Forget this offering money or whatever, you knew what you were doing and it is Incredibly unethical todo so. You ruined the 'Weaponsmith - Customer trust'. Why would anyone else want to come to you for anything?


Oh and charging 1 million credits to craft a weapon or two or three?? C'mon man thats just crazy.


This is how I look at it. Yes this is a game. And making money is a goal in the game. But aside from that it's also the quality of the game. You go around screwing people and this makes for a bad game experience. Perhaps you should be banned.



Ionov Teutonian
Master Elder Weaponsmith
Curator Founder - Jundland MemorialWeapons Museum
Nikkolai Teutonian
Master Spy
Zhalistan Izzossk
Commando - Cannon Fodder

Ladywolff
Wed Oct 05, 2005 4:32 pm
#39

hmm, this is interesting. I think its a mis communication between client and crafter.


I crafted full time for about 1.5 years (i.e. I think i went to 3-4 planets during those 1.5 years), then took some time off, and restarted on a very part time basis only for very high end weapons. i try not to accept custom crafts anymore because of the need to keep track of what is made, where the parts are etc. (i am cursed with full inventory problems lol!). however, where i do take parts,i make the weapon then usually throw it in a factory for them to pick up unless they are nearby. Some regular customers provide me with all their bh loot because they don't need credits and simply want a high end weaponsmith to provide them with whatever weapons they wish on a priority basis at no cost.


I assume that I am dealing with sophisticated clients. they request specific weapons, with specific stats usually. If i had to give a number, i'd assume that 95% of the people I deal with know exactly what is needed in the weapons they request. I assume the material they drop off is for the weapon and the additional (and it could be anything. ..and i really mean anything to do with weaponsmithing...sometimes cubes, sometimes casings, etc. material irrelevant to their weapon, sometimes cells, sometimes accuracy scopes) are meant as payment.sometimes they are so happy at getting the weapon they provide a tip, sometimes they are happy at getting the weapon and they don't provide a tip. Sometimes people ask me about custom crafts and i say whatever u think is fair is fine with me. thats my favorite line as you are guaranteed a happy customer. I don't craft for a profit, i craft because I love it. sometimes we talk about parts sometimes we talk about credits. I have never had a single complaint that i can ever recall, and Ive made a lot of weapons for a lot of people over the years. When we still had crit fails, if i critted on krayt, i always felt so bad i replaced the tissue for free without telling the customers. That included replacing the tissues for a krayt t21 (at a cost of many millions for 11 identical tissues), for a 100k job heh!. Those were the fun days. All I'm saying is I don't know if I would have automatically assumed that scopes, even high accuracy ones (these are not 60+),dropped off weren't payment for a high end custom craft. I often get old customers, and even people whos names i don't recognize dropping off bags of parts saying they dont' want any of it and to keep what is good and delete what isn't. I don't think the fact that the thread's crafter initially kept the scopesmeant he was dishonest. I think where the problemlies is in the follow up...i.e. when the customer talked to the crafter and the crafter realized there was a problem. anyway, just my opinion.






--Ladywolff-
**Sith Apprentice - Syrene**
(Vendor "Ladywolff"on Tatooine, Bantha Plains (4748,8,-6586))
**Katrin'a Blade - 12pt AS/WS**
**Kristoff - Elder - Commando**

Page 3 of 4