Jedi Archive

Thread: CIVIL Discussion about a New FSCS system

The-OnlyAcid-Christ
Sun Jan 25, 2004 5:30 am
#105

Okay, I haven't read through all the posts but this is what I have come up with that would be a fair solution to the change in fact it happens. I don't know what the new way to open up your FSCS would be but as for the current way, when it switches over, those who have completed 1-4 holos should be given a hint as to what the last proffession will be. Not the exact proffession but along what tree. Say if it were to be Carabiner or Smuggler the hint would be "along the marksman proffession". For those who have completed 4 holos plus say 5+ proffessions the exact proffession that would open their FSCS should be given, Say if its Bio-Engineer it tells you "The proffession to master that will open your FSCS is Bio-Engineer". Of course I believe that those answers should be given after say a theme park style quest. As for those who have gone through 4 holo proffessions and are now at say proffession 12+ post silent, the very next proffession they master should in fact open their FSCS regardless of what it is or in their data base the closest proffession they have to mastering be the one that releases it for them. As for people who have gone into the 20+ proffession range post silent holo they should be given the option to master the next proffession and get their FSCS and give them the feeling of accomplishment and earning it or to just be lazy and have it given to them. After 24 proffessions I think they deserve this. Like I said for the new system, how it should work, I dont know, but im sure someone will think of something.



Once upon a midnight dreary, while I websurfed, weak and weary,...Over many a strange and spurious website of 'hot chicks galore',...While I clicked my fav'rite bookmark, suddenly there came a warning,...And my heart was filled with mourning, mourning for my dear amour...."'Tis not possible," I muttered, "give me back my cheap hardcore!" -
Quoth the server, "404"....


We Got Deathstar....Now In Special Edition Form Click Here
Nomdorn
Sun Jan 25, 2004 6:00 am
#106

Do we talking about keeping a Jedi Population low or about keeping a Jedi Population low, but i want make Jedi Slot or i quit?


Keeping a population low IS making the way harder than only mastering 5 Professions.


EagleShard
Sun Jan 25, 2004 6:58 am
#107

And just a couple more points from me...


I don't have the Dev-Quotes saved anywhere so I shall paraphrase several things they said in the run up to launch (watched the forums for the 4 months prelaunch) and since then:


1) The path to jedi might change if its decided that the current system is creating too many Jedi


2) Holocrons will always exist but they won't always tell you to master professions


3) It will take a casual player about a year to gain a FSCS


The first two are the important ones. Those of you who say that SOE told you to grind professions to get Jedi -they also told you that they might change the system. They dropt some pretty huge hints that they were going to change it in the run up to Christmas as well.


Personally until they brought Holocrons into the game I was going for Jedi - doing all the themeparks etc. Then they revealed what part of the current system was and I made the decision to wait until they changed it to continue - because they had been clear that it would change one day.


You have a month or two to finish grinding out professions. So get to it rather than moaning. You've got time if you are a long way along the path, if not make the decision to try and get it in the current system or prepare for the next system.


It was always known that the change was coming, waiting for the change was just as valid a strategy as commiting to the grind. And you know what, I've had a lot more fun not grinding and doing all the themeparks and quests





Lady Gemina, Mistress of the Crimson Talons
Proprieter of the Lucky Bantha Cantina, New Hamburg, Tatooine (Dancers, Spice and a whole lot more!)
loomis001
Sun Jan 25, 2004 8:48 am
#108

quote:


1) The path to jedi might change if its decided that the current system is creating too many Jedi

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



who said there was many jedi??, there are reason why they change the system other than many jedi's, perhaps they thought the holocrons a bad idea and want it to change to make to get to force slot simpilar than doing random professons



Member of the inqusitor of the Imperial Navy, imperial dark jedi
Mrjuice
Sun Jan 25, 2004 9:30 am
#109






Jedi_Jet wrote:




Ignorance is every hologrinder out there expecting the devs to focus on their needs when there are many other things wrong with this game.


Yet it seems the entire DEV team has been busy working for your needs to make it better for the few, while leaving many professions out in the cold without a fix in site (smuggler/chef/pikeman/ etc etc infinitum)


The above two posts contradict eachother. You state we are ignorant that the devs would focus on hologrinders, yet later, you state that that is in fact where their attention is focused according to the latest friday feature.


I did not post to be rude or ignorant, just because you don't like my viewpoint doesnt mean I am being ignorant....


I'm sorry you're still being ignorant. Except now you're being ignorant of being ignorant, I'm losing hope ...


If you dont like the change remember the side of the box, and the instruction Holocron, they both say GAME EXPERIENCE MAY CHANGE WHILE PLAYING!


WELL DUHHH !!! Do you think we all pay for every MMO out there in hopes that it will be the ultimate STATIC experience ??? The very nature of an MMO is about change both in structure/balance and bandwidth/graphical aspects.


Again you miss the point, you don't sell people a product from which they determine how to achieve specific goals and then pull the rug out from under them when the system has been in place for a 7month period. Not recognizing many of the hologrinders efforts is an extreme ignorance to their status as paying customers.








Here here ... ok I admit Ignorance may have not been the most correct term to describe your unproductive reply to this thread.


Actually your more Apathetic and Hypocritical with your latest post.




Deeper_Kyo
Sun Jan 25, 2004 9:36 am
#110



ArjunThakur wrote :


Thank you for all staying civil thus far!


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Well not anymore! I can get alot of *edit* edit edit words in here now because that is how i feel atm.


Been typing alot off things in all different forums about the new release and i am not gonna stop after this.


It is realy a good idea to change the system but that is gonna be to all newbies not to us that have been grinding master after master. Some sort of reward.. pahhh bull**edit** i say.. we will not get so much reward like they want us to belive and we should not get it either. If they reward all us out there with alot of master after silent then we gonna get overruned bye jedis.


And to all newbies! Let them do a quest system to unlock the fc slot but it is not gonna be easier like we have now.. the quest is good because in that wayit feels morerealistic way to get FC slot .. like now there is no logic at all.. grind master after master , be chef, TKM, Tailor.. what the **** has that to do with Jedi ? Nothing and that is so far from star wars you can get.


And the new permadeath! Stupid i say! They are doing to much and to easy for Jedis! JediShouldbe hard to get and when you at last get it then you gonna have a hell to try get skills and get higher lv.. and when at last you get Master Jedi then let them have there fun.. they are realy worth it.. no permadeath or penalty skill for them.. They should go around and rule the galaxie and do what ever they want. A Master Jedi is a MASTER and is gonna stay that way.. FFS


Deeper-Kyo 15 Masters, Europe-Farstar, Mos Sweden, Tantooine, CIA - Guild





Deeper-Kyo (-_-) Master WS/DE/Artisan 031015
Cristania (-_-) Dark Jedi Knight 040425
15th September 2003
The one and only is the one that are alone with the Dark side of the force!!
MasterJediBrim
Sun Jan 25, 2004 9:54 am
#111




3. Anyone who is in the middle of their holocron professions, especially those whose holocron is silent need to be either placed along the new path at an equal point or if that's not possible or undesirable they may finish the traditional holcron method.






I agree with this 110%. Instead of a "or" there should be a "an"



Brim



[url=http://profile.xfire.com/tanis1020][img:28b97f8fa4]http://miniprofile.xfire.com/bg/bg/type/0/tanis1020.png[/img:28b97f8fa4][/url]
DocMirrim
Sun Jan 25, 2004 10:39 am
#112

I believe the new system should require the equivalent effort of doing 20+ professions - including the EXPENSE. I think that ANYONE that has mastered more than, say 22, should get their slot. They would be more deserving than the MAJORITY of current jedi.



Now for the new system. THere is nothing wrong with mastering professions - selected, pointed professions. THe problem comes in when you have to grind them - and then grind throught the rest of them looking for a mystery prof. Holo'sthat tell professions can stay - but with an added twist - YOU ACTUALLY HAVE to make somethign and give it to your "guide" - something that requires mastery in a uiven professions. Or use that item in furtherance of the quest.Orfight a monster, AFTER you become a master tka and get a loot drop from it - and all of these quest mission should be individual spawns - like the Garm Bel Ibis missions - that CAN NOT BE CAMPED. Mastering professions gave me a greater understanding of the game - and I liked many of them - BUT did not like grinding ANY of them. And teh grind seemed so pointless - but if I had to ACTUALLY make myself some uber armor and wear it during part of a quest - or master doc - AND HEAL my jedi trainer of some strange disease, requiring rare flora, etc. THe possibilities here are endless - and could be varied greatly among individuals.



Also - I would love to see the opportunity taken here to add content for existing jedi.EVERY jedi inStar Wars was FOUND by another jedi and trained. I would LOVE to be able to role play andhave students - or force senstives seek me out.It is kind of done now with normal classes and their skill advancement - but it is optional. If Sony could pull this off and make it fun - it would be great. ANd give jedi something to do, other than kill thousands of creatures.



My suggestions are just elements...but many of the pieces are there - you should have to explore to find a trainer. I would actually suggest using LIVE, SONY employees to role play jedi, or some type of quest guide as trainers - to make the experience as interactive as possible. And fun. THne you should have to master professions -and ACTUALLY produce something or fight something or find something with the skills you have mastered. Then continue on the path.


ValleyJedi
Sun Jan 25, 2004 11:12 am
#113

One thing they can do is go back to what the FS slot was in the beginning. Allow the player to choose if they want to use it for a jedi or another character. Once that choice is made, then forever will it dominate your destiny. If I unlock my slot and choose a jedi character, then I will never be able to learn any of the other profession's skills. If I choose to make a non jedi character, then that character can never learn any jedi skills. The only way for me to change this would be to delete the character and start over.
Idawna
Sun Jan 25, 2004 11:20 am
#114


I wanted to put my 2 cents worth into this discussion. First, I notice the wording of the Dev's message was rather ambiguous, and that scares me mightily. However, taken from the perspective that they mean they are changing not only the Jedi class, but the path to unlocking the FSCS, I am rather perturbed.


I am still trying to grind my first holo profession. (Master Doctor) Now, had I actually done the grind thing (had someone tumble for me or whatever to get my med exps), I would be done by now and onto my second. I prefered to take it kind of slow and not get burned out . What bothers me about this, is that I have actually been doing the Jedi grind for months, just not for my character. We decided when the holocrons came out that it would be best to let our husband try to open his slot first. He ground all 4 of his holo professions and is now on his third post holo prof. We stood by him the whole time, providing support and encouragement. When his holo said master entertainer, we all mastered entertainer. When his holo said master Dancer, Eve mastered dancer and I mastered musician. It was hard and yes, we did it of our own free will, but according to some of you, our efforts do not deserve to be recognized. I disagree with this. I feel that if they change the method to unlocking the slot, we should still be able to unlock by finishing our profession grind, as much as that sucks.


I have seen many mentions of the EQ epic quest here, some say they want the Jedi slot to open like that, but most say no. The EQ epic quest is what made us quit that game. For those who never played EQ, I will try to explain our experience, starting from when it all went bad.


There is a class in EQ called Enchanter. Eve played this class, and loved her toon very much. We went all over the world, talking to NPCs and killing MoB's to advance her in this quest. We came to a point where we had only 2 MoB's left to kill before she finished the quest. Keep in mind, we were 2-3 months into the quest. One of the MoB's we had to kill was a rare spawn named Verina Tomb. She was VERY contested, many many enchanters needed the piece she dropped to get thier epic. She was on a random 2 day spawn timer, so we decided to sit at her spawn point constantly until she spawned. The problem arose when the server kept crashing. We sat in that dungeon for SIX days and 12 hours, before she spawned. And I am talking NONSTOP for 6 days, there was ALWAYS someone sitting there, 24/7. Verina finally spawned! We were so happy! We got all 3 of our characters logged in, and one of our friends who just happened to be nearby came to help too. We engaged, when lo and behold, here comes 4 other characters to try and steal the kill. If our wizard friend hadn't been there, there is a good chance this person would have gotten the kill and we would have had to start all over, but we got lucky, and our enchanter looted the piece. The string of profanities and promises of retribution from the other enchanter really put a damper on our happiness, though. It's hard to be happy you got something cool if you know that you have made a lifelong enemy from it.


Even after all that, our beloved Eve's enchanter never did get her epic, as the last MoB on her quest she had to kill was on a rarer timer of 12 hours in a zone we could not just sit in, that despawned when another mob in that zone spawned. (For those that played EQ, it was Plane of Fear, and everyone who played EQ knows the whole zone can despawn when Cazic Thule spawns.) It was a mess. She was depressed for days, weeks even, until she said "Screw it, I don't even want to play this game anymore" and we bought SWG.


PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE do not make this anything like the epic quest in EQ!!!





Idawna Day
SkarfaceNC
Sun Jan 25, 2004 11:36 am
#115






Raizzor wrote:

I'm still wondering where everyone got this information that the unlocking system is going to change. I saw NOTHING in the new anouncement that mentioned anything about a change to this system... Can someone please enlighten me???




The second phase will be to rebuild the Jedi system to be quest-oriented; and toinclude the familiar elements of Force Sensitivity, Jedi-oriented quests, as well as many other elements the developers and the community feel should make up the process of becoming a Jedi.




Thraxx // Radiant

I have nothing to declare except my own brillance.....
L8Knight
Sun Jan 25, 2004 11:45 am
#116




Like everyone else, I wanted to add my own $0.02.


My biggest complaint about this Jedi stuff is that they're changing it. I despise playing a game that I feel is still in the middle of development (that might just be the developer in me coming out). Its one thing to offer up bug fixes and new content, but to revamp major portions of the game (i.e. combat, Jedi, etc) because they lackedforesight in the beginning just bugs the heck out of me.


They started out with a grand idea about how to become Jedi which was somewhat merit based. They decided that scheme was too difficult to implement and went with aprofession-based system for the release. They stuck with the profession-based system for almost a year, encouraged it with holocrons and holocron holiday gifts -in essence, they showed people the light at the end of the tunnel. Now, they're going to take the light back and do things "the right way". I wish they would have done things right to begin with, especially when they had a "better" system in mind, but since we can't go back in time, why not just leave things the way they are?


This game frustrates me... almost to the point of quiting. I can't wait for Ultima X to come out.


Is this the world of MMORPG's? They just release the base system, bugs and all, and say well fix it later?


Edrope Wo'tah - Corbantis
Sn1pe
Sun Jan 25, 2004 11:50 am
#117

I am very glad to hopefully be done with all the holo grinding. I now get to play the game how I wish to play the game and how I set off to play it--to have fun! I hope for a long and drawn out quest system that does not involve much combat--so that non crafters can do it. I also hope for them to at least announce that profs are no longer the way to attain jedi -- so that I can finally pursue what I want to pursue and stop mastering profs I don't want. I don't really think you will find the galaxy strewn full of jedi if the jedi are balanced properly. A jedi should not be godlike, and when people find out that they are not they will no longer desire to play them. I can't wait to see what the new system holds--and can only hope for the end of prof grinding.



__________________________________________________________________________________
Kauri Server
RoK Corps - Republic of Kharras
Page 9 of 10