Droid Engineer Archive

Thread: Sodan's Hybrid DE Proposal

Sodan-droiddreamer
Fri Mar 12, 2004 12:02 am
#417






Kollos wrote:

Thank you, too, Sodan. There was a time when I would have expected you to follow Shian's lead. You seem to havechanged a bit, and I respect you more for it. You haven't lost your passion for what you believe in, though, and that's a good thing. /salute




I believe in the first amendment very strongly, man. I also believe in working out deals on the basis of a good compromise. Also, I am bolstered by all the positive "good job; great idea" PMs I have been getting which have outweighed some of the seriously negative sh*t I've seen in this thread. It's hard not to answer it, but I find when you do it just keeps coming.There is no point in that. I don't like to step in it.


The focus has been to build consensus amongst a majority of the active community on these boards and now we need to wait and see what the devs will say. The differences have been noted. The commonalities have bubbled to the top like diamonds on sand.




Sodan Droiddreamer (GEGN)
Sodan's Exotic Droidgarten - In Bohemian Grove (Geigen Shuttle), Tatooine (6156 7275)
Sodan-droiddreamer
Fri Mar 12, 2004 4:36 pm
#418

In light of the droid armor nerf, I think a system that brings in CL10+ droids is sorely needed.



Sodan Droiddreamer (GEGN)
Sodan's Exotic Droidgarten - In Bohemian Grove (Geigen Shuttle), Tatooine (6156 7275)
Virtanis
Fri Mar 12, 2004 5:46 pm
#419




Sodan-droiddreamer wrote:
In light of the droid armor nerf, I think a system that brings in CL10+ droids is sorely needed.





You and me both... how can any plan be seriously pitched if the droids we build today look nothing like what we'll be able to build next week?






"You Droid Engineers have had to suffer through some tough times. The Devs do not hate the profession and have plans to address some of the larger concerns."
- Q-3PO 10/23/03 1st Annual Droid Engineering Academy Awards

- Fortium - Master Droid Engineer - Master Artisan - Grumpy Advocate for Droids and DE's -
- Proprietor of CF Industries Droidworks -
Naboo: -6600, 3450; Tatooine: -680, -4290; Dantooine: -772, 2860; Corellia: -140, -5500;

Sodan-droiddreamer
Fri Mar 12, 2004 5:48 pm
#420






Virtanis wrote:




Sodan-droiddreamer wrote:
In light of the droid armor nerf, I think a system that brings in CL10+ droids is sorely needed.





You and me both... how can any plan be seriously pitched if the droids we build today look nothing like what we'll be able to build next week?





Well, things are in flux. If things are headed where we think they are headed, we need this plan even more to be viable. Higher lvl droids could have good armor and special attacks.




Sodan Droiddreamer (GEGN)
Sodan's Exotic Droidgarten - In Bohemian Grove (Geigen Shuttle), Tatooine (6156 7275)
Shian_Tavkin
Fri Mar 12, 2004 11:17 pm
#421






Sodan-droiddreamer wrote:





Kollos wrote:

Thank you, too, Sodan. There was a time when I would have expected you to follow Shian's lead. You seem to havechanged a bit, and I respect you more for it. You haven't lost your passion for what you believe in, though, and that's a good thing. /salute





I believe in the first amendment very strongly, man. I also believe in working out deals on the basis of a good compromise. Also, I am bolstered by all the positive "good job; great idea" PMs I have been getting which have outweighed some of the seriously negative sh*t I've seen in this thread. It's hard not to answer it, but I find when you do it just keeps coming.There is no point in that. I don't like to step in it.


The focus has been to build consensus amongst a majority of the active community on these boards and now we need to wait and see what the devs will say. The differences have been noted. The commonalities have bubbled to the top like diamonds on sand.









Lol well if he can change his mind so can I


Still I wont comment on the crux of his 'love letter', be careful who you let woo you Sodan, lest you recieve a mighty surprise when you least expect it..my mother warned me about sweet talking guys .


Oh btw, whats this First Amendment thing about? Does it apply to Europeans who have had it since can't remember when..nevermind.


It's over now, the devs are in the think tank, and the hamburger has been sent..just not sure to where. Pray it is not the 45% cereal version.


Whoever and Whatever, we are all DE's...and yep thats a peace offering Kollos if you want.



Message Edited by Shian_Tavkin on 03-12-2004 10:21 PM



Shian -- Master Droid Engineer/ Master Artisan
Kollos
Sat Mar 13, 2004 2:08 pm
#422






Shian_Tavkin wrote:




Oh btw, whats this First Amendment thing about? Does it apply to Europeans who have had it since can't remember when..nevermind.


Well, yeah it does apply to Europeans, at least when you're in the USA. Which I suspect applies even when you're using a message board or playing a game as long as the server is hosted in the USA. Or something like that. I'm sure there's pages & pages of potential legal wrangling that could be done on the issue.



Whoever and Whatever, we are all DE's...and yep thats a peace offering Kollos if you want.


Accepted. I may anger easily, but I forgive and forget easily too.





You guys may be happy to hear that I may be reaching my breaking point on all this as well. It is difficult, even for me, to maintain a positive attitude toward eventual utility in droids in the face of such blatant misinformation from the Devs. (See the new wallpaper for the latest atrocity.)


I could handle combat droids being resticted to CL 10 while the Probot was still unique and distinct from creature pets. Its former armor and HAM gave it a distinct role that it could fulfill in a way that no creature pet could. For me, that was sufficient (though I acknowledge that it was not sufficient for others).


But what they're doing now is total crap. These two patches ( I refuse to call them "publishes" until the new content in them is greater than the number of bug fixes) were supposed to HELP Droid Engineers and bring us up to the level of the other previously re-worked professions. Instead we're getting a massive nerf and a few bug fixes.


They're going to need to at least double the utility being added in patch 8 if they want any chance of earning respect from Droid Engineers. I used to hold out hope that the Entertainer Module was just an example and that other cool new utility modules were in the works... but I'm no longer optimistic about that.


I still don't think that a hybrid DE is the right answer and probably never will. But come on, SOE, throw us a bone! You want to know where all the negativity comes from? Take a look in the mirror! We just can't trust anything you guys tell us. Hell, half the time we can't even figure out for sure what you meant.


/sigh



Kollos Orcslayer : Master Droid Engineer : Master Artisan

Droids by Kollos -840, 3980 Seacht, Naboo (NW of Keren)
Bounty Hunter Droids by Kollos 4924, 6107 550m SW of Kaadara
Vehicles and Master Artisan Components also available
paying 250k/point for Droid Assembly Skill Tapes, minimum of +4

Virtanis
Sat Mar 13, 2004 2:14 pm
#423




Kollos wrote:


But what they're doing now is total crap. These two patches ( I refuse to call them "publishes" until the new content in them is greater than the number of bug fixes) were supposed to HELP Droid Engineers and bring us up to the level of the other previously re-worked professions. Instead we're getting a massive nerf and a few bug fixes.




Yep... and I'm already typing up my message to the Corbantis server regarding the mega armor nerf. I'll be damned if my players, friends, and customers get blindsided by this nerf on Tuesday, so I'm going to make a PSA with all the gritty details now.






"You Droid Engineers have had to suffer through some tough times. The Devs do not hate the profession and have plans to address some of the larger concerns."
- Q-3PO 10/23/03 1st Annual Droid Engineering Academy Awards

- Fortium - Master Droid Engineer - Master Artisan - Grumpy Advocate for Droids and DE's -
- Proprietor of CF Industries Droidworks -
Naboo: -6600, 3450; Tatooine: -680, -4290; Dantooine: -772, 2860; Corellia: -140, -5500;

Kollos
Sat Mar 13, 2004 3:00 pm
#424

Ooh... post it here, too, so that we can all copy it and post it on our respective Galaxy boards.



Kollos Orcslayer : Master Droid Engineer : Master Artisan

Droids by Kollos -840, 3980 Seacht, Naboo (NW of Keren)
Bounty Hunter Droids by Kollos 4924, 6107 550m SW of Kaadara
Vehicles and Master Artisan Components also available
paying 250k/point for Droid Assembly Skill Tapes, minimum of +4

Sodan-droiddreamer
Tue Mar 16, 2004 6:07 pm
#425




EnigmaBSc wrote:
I agree to the ideas in principle, although non-combat utility is also required (I.e. this must not REPLACE the entertainer/merchant/bomb modules + hopefully others in the long term).
I prefer variant #2 or a #2/#4 combo.

I hope you will forgive me a small question which I don't believe has been addressed so far. Under any of these variants, what type of experience is required to advance through the tactician tree? It can't be droid crafting experience because 0040's can't craft droids and it shouldn't be combat-droid usage experience because then DE's have to fight to gain Master. Perhaps combat droid experience gained through crafting or using a combat droid?

EnigmaBSc




Thanks for your support. At this time, crafting exp is all that is required for the 0040 DE tree. That is to allow pure crafters to progress in DE WITHOUT having to engage in combat.


I'd love for combat droid exp to exist and somehow be a factor, but at this point we are staying away from it because there is a substantial component of the DE community that understandably does not want to engage in combat. Under the current plan, combat/weapon exp is all that is required.


Your suggestions for how to incorporate this combat droid exp into the plan would be welcome. Pls take some time to review the discussion thus far.





Sodan Droiddreamer (GEGN)
Sodan's Exotic Droidgarten - In Bohemian Grove (Geigen Shuttle), Tatooine (6156 7275)
EnigmaBSc
Tue Mar 16, 2004 6:09 pm
#426

Apologies for posting this in the voting thread. I had though you meant general discussion should not be in that thread and didn't realise that specific questions should be posted elsewhere as well. Perhaps this could be made clearer in the original thread (OK, looking back it is pretty clear - but it still wouldn't hurt to have big flashing neon text saying 'Any discussion about this proposal or any other related issues should be posted in <thread> ).

My original post was in relation to Sodan's Hybrid DE Proposal 2.0:

I hope you will forgive me a small question which I don't believe has been addressed so far. Under any of these variants, what type of experience is required to advance through the tactician tree? It can't be droid crafting experience because 0040's can't craft droids and it shouldn't be combat-droid usage experience because then DE's have to fight to gain Master. Perhaps combat droid experience gained through crafting or using a combat droid?

EnigmaBSc
EnigmaBSc
Tue Mar 16, 2004 6:14 pm
#427

Could you just clarify, by 'crafting exp' do you mean general crafting experience or droid crafting experience. I'm assuming the former. Sorry if it's been mentioned somewhere in this thread already, but it's a very long thread and I don't have time to read it all right now.

EnigmaBSc
Sodan-droiddreamer
Tue Mar 16, 2004 6:16 pm
#428

I meant DE craftign exp.


At the same time an either/or approach would be cool. Grinding to 0040 DE with DE crafting exp OR combat droid exp might be cool.





Sodan Droiddreamer (GEGN)
Sodan's Exotic Droidgarten - In Bohemian Grove (Geigen Shuttle), Tatooine (6156 7275)
Kollos
Tue Mar 16, 2004 6:21 pm
#429






Sodan-droiddreamer wrote:

I meant DE craftign exp.


At the same time an either/or approach would be cool. Grinding to 0040 DE with DE crafting exp OR combat droid exp might be cool.




Is Combat Droid Exp required to climb the Ranged Support Tree in Marksman (under this proposal... it's obviously not true currently)?


I can't decide if that would be appropriate or entirely sick and twisted given the current (patch 7 Droid Implosion) state of "combat" droids.



Kollos Orcslayer : Master Droid Engineer : Master Artisan

Droids by Kollos -840, 3980 Seacht, Naboo (NW of Keren)
Bounty Hunter Droids by Kollos 4924, 6107 550m SW of Kaadara
Vehicles and Master Artisan Components also available
paying 250k/point for Droid Assembly Skill Tapes, minimum of +4

Page 33 of 36