Dancer Archive

Thread: In Development: Recursive Macros are going away.

Utess
Sun Aug 01, 2004 9:34 pm
#53

I'm pretty sure they aren't going to just remove afk without making some other changes to professions to compensate. Which was probably the whole point of TH's question of "how will this affect you." So they can get a better idea of what might need tweaking.



________________________________

'Tess

- Utess Pero: Master Entertainer, Master Dancer, Master Musician, ID
- Andria Pasretti: Master Artisan, Master Merchant, Teras Kasi Master
- Tatiyana Karkuf: Master Medic, Master Combat Medic, Master Doctor
lore7
Sun Aug 01, 2004 9:34 pm
#54






kirah_ashlin wrote:

Well, TH does admit in a post above the one I submitted that he has mixed feelings about removing the recursive macro . . . still I appalud him and the devs for taking a strong stand against AFK exploits. Once this is dealt with other means can be examined to compensate for losses in other areas.






and i hope you relize they are going to lose between 5,000 and 20,000 a month.



Rakesh,-Rakesh,Bluesbakka and Khosk
,Rip when ever all my accounts run out
,Now Lore 56 Priest on Skullcrusher in WoW.
Utess
Sun Aug 01, 2004 9:44 pm
#55

Short term loss, you bet. Long term gains? Huge. This will bring some players back. And help encourage new players to stick around. Will it hurt, yes. But the devs are doing this for the long term health of the game. Better a short term loss now than having the game slowly bleed itself to death in the long run.



________________________________

'Tess

- Utess Pero: Master Entertainer, Master Dancer, Master Musician, ID
- Andria Pasretti: Master Artisan, Master Merchant, Teras Kasi Master
- Tatiyana Karkuf: Master Medic, Master Combat Medic, Master Doctor
PoetDancer
Sun Aug 01, 2004 9:54 pm
#56

--Maybe you'll have to get a few more entertainers in your guilds.


--Maybe you'll have to encourage players to pick up these professions.


--Maybe you'll have to tip players to stay in the cantinas instead of going out on missions to pay the maitenance pool.


--Maybe players will take up these professions because--heavens forbid--they can make credits by doing it.


--Maybe you see an entertainer and say, "Hey! Come with us to Dathomir!"


....and maybe....just maybe...you'll stick around if it actually takes time to reach the "endgame."



Madame Sirii Ajaan
August 2003-September 15, 2005
"There is a difference between being /watched and being WATCHED."
CodeBreaker007
Sun Aug 01, 2004 11:16 pm
#57

There is going to be a problem with stopping looping macros:


1: It's apart of the community which create macros for other community members, which keeps people interested. Just as with other games where people build maps/mods and so on.


2: For those Dancers/musicians moaning about looping macros, you've destroyed a big part of the community when it comes to guilds and having to search for people buffing, you also forget that guilds pay for an extra acc to enable them to have a buff bot as you call them. I myself have two acc's and use a looping macro for when I go to bed.. You've also made an already boring profession even more boring because people won't sit infront of their pc just to watch a character dance or play instruments all day just to become an entertainer.


3: Creating macros is apart of the dancer profession, and soe should also realise that swg community does not revolve around these forums, so I would suggest they have listened to a small part of the community and not considard the whole. As most older people should know, forums have always been a place for moaners in many games, and doesn't talk for the whole of swg community..


4: I think if soe are going to remove looping macro's, then they better add alot more to keep people interested in doing it, because otherwise you'll end up where people can't get battle fatigue fixed as their won't be enough dancers to go round, it's called cause and effect.. Soe must also remember they created this situation with their hologrinding to make people jedi, so now entertainers are suffering.


5: I'd also like to point out it's darn hard to find people mind buffing, so why some people moan about buff bots is beyond me, their is only one buff bot I know off on darth on my server, and I'm on theed and won't keep traveling just for a buff, and will go localy to get one from anyone online. So people saying buffbots are out of control is a load of rubbish from what I've seen.



Teras Kasi Master
Master Dancer
Brawler 4/0/0/0
Entertainer 0/0/4/4
Scout 0/0/4/0
Drygo
Sun Aug 01, 2004 11:39 pm
#58






CodeBreaker007 wrote:

There is going to be a problem with stopping looping macros:


1: It's apart of the community which create macros for other community members, which keeps people interested. Just as with other games where people build maps/mods and so on.


There's still going to be tons of macros. People will still use macros. They just won't be able to loop them. They'll just have to hit F1 every once in awhile.


2: For those Dancers/musicians moaning about looping macros, you've destroyed a big part of the community when it comes to guilds and having to search for people buffing, you also forget that guilds pay for an extra acc to enable them to have a buff bot as you call them. I myself have two acc's and use a looping macro for when I go to bed.. You've also made an already boring profession even more boring because people won't sit infront of their pc just to watch a character dance or play instruments all day just to become an entertainer.


You forget who you're talking to here. We're theentertainers, the real ones. We are absolutely going to sit in front of our pc and watch our character dance or play music, among other things. We've been doing it for months and we'll continue to do it. To us, thisstyle ofgameplay is not boring. If it was, then we wouldn't be here trying to save it. Buffbots have completely and utterly destroyed our community. Any destruction of your guild because of your loss of a buffbot is going to be minimal if you have a good guild. The idea that your guild is held together by a buffbot is kinda...sad. If that's true, then perhaps you need to look at ways to improve your guild.


3: Creating macros is apart of the dancer profession, and soe should also realise that swg community does not revolve around these forums, so I would suggest they have listened to a small part of the community and not considard the whole. As most older people should know, forums have always been a place for moaners in many games, and doesn't talk for the whole of swg community..


Guess this means they shouldn't listen to all the people whining about the loss of the recursive macro then?


4: I think if soe are going to remove looping macro's, then they better add alot more to keep people interested in doing it, because otherwise you'll end up where people can't get battle fatigue fixed as their won't be enough dancers to go round, it's called cause and effect.. Soe must also remember they created this situation with their hologrinding to make people jedi, so now entertainers are suffering.


Well, the hologrind's going away, but the buffbots won't. That has to be fixed in order to make our profession viable. And, I still fail to believe that there will not be one person in one Cantina in one of the major NPC cities when you need BF healing.


5: I'd also like to point out it's darn hard to find people mind buffing, so why some people moan about buff bots is beyond me, their is only one buff bot I know off on darth on my server, and I'm on theed and won't keep traveling just for a buff, and will go localy to get one from anyone online. So people saying buffbots are out of control is a load of rubbish from what I've seen.


Your server is very lucky then. There are *countless* buffbots on my server now. There's one in particular who's there 23/7 in the Coronet Cantina. She's singlehandedly destroyed and monopolized the buffing business there.









- I support hawtpants
FuschiaD
Sun Aug 01, 2004 11:41 pm
#59






CodeBreaker007 wrote:

There is going to be a problem with stopping looping macros:


1: It's apart of the community which create macros for other community members, which keeps people interested. Just as with other games where people build maps/mods and so on.


They're not getting rid of macros completely, you know.


2: For those Dancers/musicians moaning about looping macros, you've destroyed a big part of the community when it comes to guilds and having to search for people buffing, you also forget that guilds pay for an extra acc to enable them to have a buff bot as you call them. I myself have two acc's and use a looping macro for when I go to bed.. You've also made an already boring profession even more boring because people won't sit infront of their pc just to watch a character dance or play instruments all day just to become an entertainer.


Excuse me? Just because you find it boring, that makes it universal? I don't think so, Mr. Ego-Pants. This change would never have come about if it weren't for the people in the entertainer forums who were slowly being choked to death, bogged down in a swamp of buffbots. We LOVE our profession. We don't think it's boring. Of course, if you don't actually *play* the profession, I can see how you might not understand this concept.


3: Creating macros is apart of the dancer profession, and soe should also realise that swg community does not revolve around these forums, so I would suggest they have listened to a small part of the community and not considard the whole. As most older people should know, forums have always been a place for moaners in many games, and doesn't talk for the whole of swg community..


The people who post on the forums are the people who are instrumental in bringing this change about. AFKing was slowly killing the entertainer professions. This game is revolutionary in that you have so many non-combat options, and this is the first game to have entirely social professions like this one. Having put them into the game, SOE has a responsibility to maintain them and fix what's wrong. That's what they've done, and I am very grateful.


4: I think if soe are going to remove looping macro's, then they better add alot more to keep people interested in doing it, because otherwise you'll end up where people can't get battle fatigue fixed as their won't be enough dancers to go round, it's called cause and effect.. Soe must also remember they created this situation with their hologrinding to make people jedi, so now entertainers are suffering.


This argument makes zero sense. There's no limit to how many people can heal with one entertainer. Even if a cantina has just one dancer or musician, everyone will still be able to heal their BF and mind wounds. If they're able to buff, everyone will still be able to buff as well.


5: I'd also like to point out it's darn hard to find people mind buffing, so why some people moan about buff bots is beyond me, their is only one buff bot I know off on darth on my server, and I'm on theed and won't keep traveling just for a buff, and will go localy to get one from anyone online. So people saying buffbots are out of control is a load of rubbish from what I've seen.

Your server definitely does not have only one buffbot. The fact is, they're making live entertainers' gameplay a serious pain in the ass, and for that, it needs to end. I applaud SOE's decision to do this, they had to have known it wouldn't come without some backlash, but it's absolutely the right thing to do. They're rectifying a situation that never should have been allowed to happen in the first place.


In summary... don't whine to us, because we really don't care about the loss of your buffbots.








~*~ F U S C H I A D A R K W A L K E R ~*~
Yes, I'm a respec Jedi. Get over it.
~*~ A V A D I H A L O N A - S O E P ~*~
Entertainer For Life - COMPNOR Eye Candy

"You don't really rank around here unless you've been flamed by Oben, trolled by Mono, set straight by Geen, got caught in a love triangle between Cherry and Anoq, had your house decorated by Kipera, hugged by Esin, fondled by Fuschia, had IG respond with something inane and nonsensical, or at the very least been (a.) asked "can I have your stuff" or (b.) been accused of being a Todd by any number of random Tarquinian posters." --TalonKarrdeTN/Tyndaleon


DarkY0da
Sun Aug 01, 2004 11:43 pm
#60

.......



*blinks*



.... U....



*coughs*


Wow.


I have tears in my eyes... they do care. I honestly thought they didn't care at all.


Wow.


That being said I do hope that they are very careful in how they go about altering the macro system. And also take very good notes on good uses for loops that may need changes so they aren't nerfed by this.


I'm just honestly shocked. Why do they hide and take so long to show us they really care ? darn it why is this making me cry



Oh-Orb Rizo Twi'lek
Just hanging out... watching with interest what changes do or don't happen.

I support the NDE. (New Drygo Experience)
Server Pop Snap-Shot Feb. 06 link















FuschiaD
Sun Aug 01, 2004 11:49 pm
#61






DarkY0da wrote:

I'm just honestly shocked. Why do they hide and take so long to show us they really care ? darn it why is this making me cry





Hey, you go ahead and cry. When I read this post, I felt like we'd finally emerged victorious from a long and vicious war.

*cries with you*




~*~ F U S C H I A D A R K W A L K E R ~*~
Yes, I'm a respec Jedi. Get over it.
~*~ A V A D I H A L O N A - S O E P ~*~
Entertainer For Life - COMPNOR Eye Candy

"You don't really rank around here unless you've been flamed by Oben, trolled by Mono, set straight by Geen, got caught in a love triangle between Cherry and Anoq, had your house decorated by Kipera, hugged by Esin, fondled by Fuschia, had IG respond with something inane and nonsensical, or at the very least been (a.) asked "can I have your stuff" or (b.) been accused of being a Todd by any number of random Tarquinian posters." --TalonKarrdeTN/Tyndaleon


DarkY0da
Sun Aug 01, 2004 11:49 pm
#62

And as a note I would like to point out that honestly I doubt they did this "Just" for Entertainers this is a fix that helps with a lot of different things in this game. And if they are really willing to take this step I believe that they will then not just stop there but also go a step farther and ADD content and tools to help replace all the needed and useful functions this change may nerf.( I have a feeling though that it won't really nerf that many really honestly useful and needed things).




I LOVE YOU DEVS!!!! Thank you Panthu, Tiaga and NewJedi very very very much. And a Huge hug to TH for taking the brunt of a lot of the bashing that is going on because of this.



Oh-Orb Rizo Twi'lek
Just hanging out... watching with interest what changes do or don't happen.

I support the NDE. (New Drygo Experience)
Server Pop Snap-Shot Feb. 06 link















Drygo
Mon Aug 02, 2004 12:56 am
#63


Most of the people complaining about it don't seem to realize that all they need to do is write a longer macro, put it in the hotkeys and click F1 every 15-30 minutes or so. The arguments against this change are very poor in my opinion.


But, hey, /happydance


Guess I gotta resubscribe now, huh?




- I support hawtpants
khamafeu
Mon Aug 02, 2004 2:20 am
#64


K, so no more recursive macros... Why is thisa good thing? The only ppl I see rejoicing are entertainers and I can't even figure out why... More and more I see ppl playing/dancing AFK without flourish macros. I get there do Watch/listen and still get healed. Will this change? No. As to buff bots, they exist because the system allows then to exist, if entertainers actually had to use resources to buff ppl then they would not exist. A better change IMO would be to make somekind of consumable item needed for buffing, this would make buffbots unviable and would actually put entertainer buffs on par with other service providers.


Removing looping macros has a lot of effects not all related to entertaining and I can't think of a good reason for the change. If you play enough SWG you realise that beeing able to use macros to powerlevel is irrelevant if you're a doc you won't earn medical xp very fast, if you a rifleman you'll stop earning rifle xp and combat xp very fast etc... so the actual process you used to get there is of no consequence. Who cares is X powerleveled Doctor in 8 hours while asleep and Y earned the xp by actually healing ppl? Are they having fun? That's what matters.If Y is bitching because he choose to play a "real" Doc he must respect those who don't want to play a "real" Doc, they want to buff.


Examples of Macros I use/used:


Ticket macro: I usully wait for shuttles and talk to ppl, say jokes, sing, etc... while on shuttle waits... sometimes I'm not in the mood so I run a macro that loops itself and presses the shortcut where the ticket is... I go to the bathroom, I go eat, I do whatever and when I'm back there I am at my destination...


CoB MAcro: Do CoB over and over again...


Dancing Macros to level: I did this twice and I always got to know at least 3,4 ppl while doing it... Yup macros and socializing at the same time...


Macro to run around Jumping: /jump /pause /macro... run around trying to take off is cool....


Change clothes while dancing macro: Pretty cool, ppl liked me more for it...


I don't know what devs are trying to achieve here but I'm pretty sure it has nothing to do with entertainers... Oh yeah and good luck grinding crafting professions with no recursion... lol


Arianrhod



Visit Pookie Mall, Naboo - Theed (-4494 , 3164) 1000m out of theed.
We Sell All Architect goods, Artisan items, Smuggler Goods, We have 2 richly stocked Loot vendors and our UNIQUE all furniture vendor both crafted and looted furniture!
Sill_Voth
Mon Aug 02, 2004 3:41 am
#65

Well, I guess its a good idea, but I have a musician who is always on a macro. He stands in the hotel in Mos Entha and plays his heart out. He's macroing because I'm a very social animal, and am always in a conversation with someone. Now this macro does repeat, but I simply don't want to have to keep hitting my flourishes in the middle of typing a tell, spatial or email. He's not an afker, except when getting coffee, or having a shower, etc. If I'm not playing for more than 30 minutes, I logoff.


Does this mean what I'm doing is no longer allowed? And if so, will I find myself banned, or will a CSR just step in and turn my macro off?


So I can now forever be looking over my shoulder with my finger hovering over my stop macroing, macro key, waitintg to see a CSR log in, just so I don't get into trouble.


So, while AFK macros are a blight on our good game(especially forentertainers), and personally I really only see them as a means to get a character xp while the player is not around, I have seen and used macros legitamately and not merely for the gaining of xp and/or creds.


But while this would affect my character, I guess he'll just have to put up with it, and I'll go back to hitting the flourish keys, or make a really long macro, which would pretty much be the same as a looping macro.


But don't get me wrong, overall I think it is a good move, as the non-afk entertainers really need some help.





"Treat friends with kindness, enemies with respect, and strangers with caution"
Page 5 of 17