Bounty Hunter Archive

Thread: Bounty Hunter Feedback Requested: Armor Certification

Thassk
Tue Oct 18, 2005 4:19 am
#92


heres my honest opinion on the matter .. i say they just RAISE energy resists on BH armor ... thats all ...


leave all armor the way it is except BH armor ...give BH armor a super high energy resist cap .. 8200... even though its classified as assault armor .... if this cant be done create a seperate armor class for BH armor. so it can be done ...


as for mandolorian armor .. i dont see a need for that to be addressed at this time, the last thing id want to see is a bunch of BH running around with mando armor it would be more horrible than seeing a lightsaber around every corner ...let it stay as a super rare fun item ...( no i dont own mando armor) but i still think they should make it even HARDER to get heh ...


Message Edited by Thassk on 10-18-2005 04:58 AM



vThasskv
Thassk
Tue Oct 18, 2005 4:39 am
#93






Nakahs wrote:


1) Duel Exploit: Currently if a Jedi attempts to /duel a Bounty Hunter, the system will let him know if the hunter has his bounty. Needless to say this completely negates the element of surprise, stalking, and first strike <--this i agree with 100% this needs to be fixed ...


2) Faction Bases: Jedi can enter factional structures while the BH TEF is active. The Devs have acknowledged this as an issue<----this doesnt need immediate attention ... it is MORE realistic if jedi are able to run and enlist the help of their fellow corpsman to remain hidden .. this is expecially realistic for the rebels whom at this very time help shelter luke and obi-wan.. this does not need to be fixed at this time


3) House-Bounties: A large percentage of our bounties are located inside structures. It doesn't do us much good to waste much of our time running from planet to planet to find a target we can't even get to. I do not approve of removing any player from a structure they are already in, or shooting through walls, or allowing aBHto enterabounty's home. HoweverI still think an alternative needs to be found<---- this canot be fixed unless macros are taken out of the game completely .. even an AFK jedi can fool the game into thinking hes active by using macros ...so how would you identify which jedi needs to be taken off terms? forget this one .. concentrate on more important issues


4) Warp-Marks: Waypoints for NPC marks do not update for several minutes, and then suddenly the mark will be thousands of meters away<--minor annoyance not a big deal ... I DO THINK however once you near a BH mark .. you should automatically draw aggro within 50 meters ... and the NPC should run after you, or run away from you.. THIS would fix the issue of NPC marks spawning in trees or the middle of rocks. in that theyd be running away


5) Broken States: Dizzy should decrease offensive abilities and Stun should prevent action regeneration. Although this is a trans-profession issue, it hurts Bounty Hunters specifically as it makes Confusion Shot severely under-powered<---i agree with this 100%


6) Duelist Stance:is reflecting back a fixed amount of 25 damage only. Suggest a % of damage taken (10-25%<---- the MAIN thing id like to see with this move is the removal of the warmup timer ... it negates the abilities usefullness in a heated PVP confrontation totally ... when fighting a stronger opponent ( this means melee and jedi) if i stop kiting even for a moment im dead ...


i fought a swordsman yesterday who i barely beat, and it was not due to mylack of skill but awkwardnessin trying to cast duelist stance .. it did MORE damage than good ..and wasnt worth using..

as inwhen i stopped to try and cast duelist stance he easily caught up to me and did3000 damage in two quickshots ... for the duration of time duelist stance lasts and the benefit it gives me its not worth taking 3000 points of damage to cast.... ( granted my pants, left bicep and both bracers were padded armor geared for energy ... i admit i would have taken less damage if i was wearing all kinetic armor, which is something i guess i should consider when analyzing or weighingthis request)


itstill remains an awkwardskill for a RANGED proffession .. if i were in fact melee and a tanker .. then yes i can understand having to sit still while the duelist stanceis cast... but as a ranged proffession making us stop in the middle of a heated fight to use a move given to us to help our defenses is detrimental...i would petition to have it removed and just add more mods to the BH template or finally remove the warm up timer once and for all... BH need it for survival




Message Edited by Thassk on 10-18-2005 05:04 AM



vThasskv
Nakahs
Tue Oct 18, 2005 5:00 am
#94

1) Need to be fixed.




2) Not the biggest problem but annyoing and makes it again clever to hunt same faction jedi as these cant use this game mechanic to have an advantage. I remember when TEF was there and group hunt of the same factionwas in most casesthe bestway to kill a jediand avoid theirguards. Can be easy fixed by preventing Jedi from entering a faction structure as long as the BH mission is not incomplete or successful after TEF was generated first time.


3) Yes i agree it would be very difficult for our ingame noob devs to come to a good solution for this complicated mechanic. But if that ever gets attention i would suggest that the terminals should shownext to the faction of the jedi the info if a jedi is perma house sitting or not (a % of jeday do that just for annoyance). Lets say after 10min of being in a private structure the term says next to the faction (hiding).


4) Just make it so the NPC marks having constant routes to a Starport without warping which seems to be only a bug. In most cases if u wait at the Starport the mark comes to u or another Starport in range bya direct routeso the warping is only a bug....


5) States and State Defense need to be fixed as they dont mean anything atm. (Dizzy / Stun primarly)


6) the warmup timer is the only real problem with duelist stance so i agree 100% on your idea to remove it. The damage reflection is useless but dont need much attention compared to the warmup timer problem for a kiting ranged prof.



Cause of these facts i think i can point out the relevance of what is most important and what not :


1) ***** (biggest advantage killer "surprise")

6) **** (our most important reason why we are classified as a tank - not working for our advantage)

5) *** (our only state effects whithout dabbling in other profs - too low funcionality)

3) ** (biggest time waster and the time we play is what we pay SOE for)

2) * (can be easy fixed see above but is anyway not the case in most jedihunts)

4) -(this is a bug that exists since the BH proffession exists so i doubt it can ever befixed)

Message Edited by Nakahs on 10-18-2005 05:21 AM



First Mandalorian on Infinity
Cafa
Tue Oct 18, 2005 7:51 am
#95

This is on par with the usual SOE line. Wait till people spend months collecting the rarest SEAs, ADKs and armor components to make the best, then kickem' in the groin.


Only way this would be even somewhat fair is to allow people to remove SEAs from armor.


Fivo Asia





- Strength In Numbers - Loyal Subjects of the Empire
Asia Brothers Industries - Asia Hall SiN CiTY, Dantooine (Offers Vendor at -4703 -1404)
A player bodyguard can't protect you either, something agroes you, you are dead. The
only difference between a pet and the person, is you pay the person to stand there
and watch you die. -- Straker Atrella

Jaeryk
Tue Oct 18, 2005 7:56 am
#96






SamousNemo wrote:





#1 Our ideal armor appearances, Black Sun and Mandolorian, are not very practical in the type of combat we face. This leads both appearances to be used as more of a cosmetic suit to brag about than to actually serve as protection

Now although I cannot speak for other professions, I was curious to hear what you all thought. Primarily I am curious to hear what you think about possibly changing our armor certification to Recon or Battle. Keep in mind of course that Black Sun and Mandalorian armor would also need to be changed to Recon or Battletypes in order that we could wear them. This would alsogrant other professions access to our most coveted armor appearances.




What about other profession cert'ed for Mando armor? Do we just take it from them or do you suggest thier certs change too?

GriffinsMyth
Tue Oct 18, 2005 8:00 am
#97


To the guys saying pick up Rifleman if you want Recon, thats just plain wrong. The last thing any player needs is a restricted choice of template to be effective. Its simple, we should be able to equip the armour best suited for the job, just as we can equip the weapon best suited, or eat the food best suited, etc. I see no reason whatsoever not to have this in the game. The only reason we had compy clones previously was because composite was the clear cut best for any situation, now there are three types of armour and they all have thier stronge and weak points. In all realism, would you wear energy resist armour in a knife fight and kinetic in a gun battle. Take the profession reqs from the armour and let the player choose what to equip.


Also, Mando and BH armour should become battle armour, the everyday armour type, which will keep the effective for all BHing sorts.

Message Edited by GriffinsMyth on 10-18-2005 08:03 AM

Thadeus_Tempest
Tue Oct 18, 2005 8:27 am
#98

You know Assault armor would be GREAT...IF...big "IF" here...if PSG's were effective against Lightsabers. Then you could have the best of both worlds.

Primus layered Assault:
7500Kinetic
5500Energy

PSG: 2499 Energy

Giving a total of:
7500Kinetic
8000Energy

This would be the all around fair solution to the Armor Cert problem IMO.



Dept of Defense Armor
Shibboleth, Dantooine -5800 -1365
FlakJackett - 12pt *R.I.S. Certified* Retired Armorsmith
42 Mandalorian Armor Pieces Crafted DWB Guide 63 Mandalorian Armor Cores Supplied
Thadeus - Elder Jedi ggg Theseus' - Elder Bounty Hunter
Ayesaac - Elder Jedi ggg FlakJackett - Master Armorsmith
Xandr
- Master Spy
ggg Leadfoot WaddleWalker - Commando
Bociwen
Tue Oct 18, 2005 1:12 pm
#99



SamousNemo wrote:
  • Reconnaissance Armor receives a nominal bonus to energy protection and a nominal penalty to kinetic damage protection. This can be conceptualized as a free energy layer.
  • Battle Armor has an even protection against all damage types - no modifiers at all.
  • Assault Armor receives a nominal bonus to kinetic protection and a nominal penalty to energy damage protection. This can be conceptualized as a free kinetic layer.
  • As we all know Bounty Hunters are certified for Assault Armor types. Primarily this includes Composite, Chitin, Black Sun (aka Bounty Hunter), and Mandolorian armor.
    Unfortunately most of the combat Bounty Hunters see is against Energy weaponry (e.g. most blasters and all light sabers). This leads most Bounty Hunters to pick up an additional profession to get an armor cert that better suits his/her needs.
    Of course every combatant is required to pick up another profession to be viable, however our current certs have a few additional drawbacks
    #1 Our ideal armor appearances, Black Sun and Mandolorian, are not very practical in the type of combat we face. This leads both appearances to be used as more of a cosmetic suit to brag about than to actually serve as protection
    #2 Many hunters feel pigeon-holed into taking a certain secondary prof to gain the ideal armor cert
    Now although I cannot speak for other professions, I was curious to hear what you all thought. Primarily I am curious to hear what you think about possibly changing our armor certification to Recon or Battle. Keep in mind of course that Black Sun and Mandalorian armor would also need to be changed to Recon or Battle types in order that we could wear them. This would also grant other professions access to our most coveted armor appearances.

    For clarification and easy reference, the current professional certs are as follows

    Assault: Bounty Hunter, Commando, Squad Leader

    Battle: Carbineer, Combat Medic, Creature Handler, Doctor, Fencer, Pikeman, Ranger, Swordsman

    Recon: Pistoleer, Rifleman, Smuggler

    Message Edited by SamousNemo on 10-15-2005 11:20 AM





    Its probably already been said by someone, but if you remember back to just before CU, when asked why it seemed Bounty Hunter was getting all this cool nifty stuff, a ranged CoB for example.

    The Devs then revealed this nifty little diagram that stated BH are a Tank Class in CU. Seems to me that when they assigned these "roles" the Devs had PvE in mind, and the majority of the time, PvE is versus creatures, creatures do kinetic, thus assualt.

    Why change the cert to Recon, when all the other ranged (cept Carbineer) is cert'd for it? Noone is *just* BH, so it seems a moot point to me.




    B'wen Fornataro


    freedomwarrior
    Tue Oct 18, 2005 1:30 pm
    #100

    As an armorsmith, I would disagree with this. My reasons are 2 fold. First, alot more work for all the armorsmiths out there. j/k


    Seriously though, I understand the BH professions frustration with having comp when its primarily kin resists. But I think the reasons the devs did this, was to force the bh to pick up another combat profession, thus limiting say a BH/DOC/Combat medic. Can you imagine this template in the game? I think a little over powering would be understating this.


    Secondly, the changing of these certs around would be ungodly. I know the BH correspondant posted about just changing the stats around, but even that is a tremendous amt of work. To change certs around would involve not just changing the bh profession, but all combat professions which I dont think the devs will exactly be willing to do. I guess it would be possible to make recon the armor of choice for the bh, but then that involves changing the bh armor schematics to recon which in and of itself is now a large task.


    Personally as an armorsmith, what I would like to see, is any advance combat profession be able to wear any form of armor, but if say a straight bh were to wear battle, then he would incur large hinderances because he isnt certed for that armor. This would cause the player have to think about the reprocussions of wearing an armor he wasnt actually suited(no pun intended) too.


    Like another poster did state, this isnt really an issue though as most combat professions are more than just bh, so can have access to other forms of armor.





    -Ackire-

    THE Retired
    dMaster Armorsmithd
    Located on the wonderful Planet of Naboo
    Now located at -3256 3748, outside of Theed
    -=X=-

    Romulus76
    Tue Oct 18, 2005 2:40 pm
    #101






    freedomwarrior wrote:

    As an armorsmith, I would disagree with this. My reasons are 2 fold. First, alot more work for all the armorsmiths out there. j/k


    Seriously though, I understand the BH professions frustration with having comp when its primarily kin resists. But I think the reasons the devs did this, was to force the bh to pick up another combat profession, thus limiting say a BH/DOC/Combat medic. Can you imagine this template in the game? I think a little over powering would be understating this.


    Secondly, the changing of these certs around would be ungodly. I know the BH correspondant posted about just changing the stats around, but even that is a tremendous amt of work. To change certs around would involve not just changing the bh profession, but all combat professions which I dont think the devs will exactly be willing to do. I guess it would be possible to make recon the armor of choice for the bh, but then that involves changing the bh armor schematics to recon which in and of itself is now a large task.


    Personally as an armorsmith, what I would like to see, is any advance combat profession be able to wear any form of armor, but if say a straight bh were to wear battle, then he would incur large hinderances because he isnt certed for that armor. This would cause the player have to think about the reprocussions of wearing an armor he wasnt actually suited(no pun intended) too.


    Like another poster did state, this isnt really an issue though as most combat professions are more than just bh, so can have access to other forms of armor.








    How would this be more overpowering than MBH-MCM-0004 Pistols? That makes no sense. MCM and Doc add no speed or accuracy to your attacks. The MBH-MCM templates are to drain a jedi. They're not "overpowered" per se, so much as they are survivors. As a MBH-4440 Carb-4004 CM I'm stuck with making energy layered Assault armor. 1) I'm forced to be MBH if I want to hunt jedi (which I've done for 2 years now and don't want to give up so don't tell me to drop it if I don't like it) 2) I'm forced with a full profession with the worst pvp armor in the game thus making me get another profession to get viable armor. This is unacceptable. No other profession in the game requires a mastery for it's primary prey that also certs for the worst armor. Commando and Squad Leader Masteries are not needed for any in-game content. MBH is for us. Why are all melee prof's that are supposed to be tanks battle armor? Why can a jedi not have one single mastery and with the right combine be extremely effective? Why do smugglers get certed for recon armor, I think they should have innate, after all what's the point of the unarmed line then?


    Give us battle cert or move jedi missions to Invest 4.


    And Samous, I don't know what you're reading but over 65% of the posts here are requesting a new cert. The majority of the decenters are just doing so more vocally for god only knows why. More than likely they're not even BH's, and the one that is, is just here to argue cause it's clear he hasn't a clue. Go through the posts and right the login names down and do a tally. You'll see the majority wants a dif cert.








    NSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiN//Thylor Tubrokk
    SiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSi//Dark Jedi Enforcer
    NSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiN
    SiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSi//Skylor Tubrokk
    NSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiN//Rogue - Fence
    SiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSi
    NSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiN//Romulus'
    SiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSi//Stalker - Marauder
    NSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiN
    SiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSiNSi


    Dewdus
    Tue Oct 18, 2005 3:01 pm
    #102

    It has always made zero sense for a profession that deals primarily with Energy dealing oponnents (both PC and NPC) to be certified for strong Kinetic protection armor. Also I could care less what armor someone gets to dress their toon up in. I want to be effective, not dressed well. So I would be 100% behind switching the BH Armor certification to Recon and changing any and all necessary armors to be the same.



    Ruldon Otta
    Master Bounty Hunter
    InspGadgt
    Tue Oct 18, 2005 3:35 pm
    #103

    The logic behind the currentarmor system sounds good at first glance, but in reality it doesn't make much sense. My other character is a rifleman who lives primarily as a hunter. But Recon armor makes no sense to use against non-player creatures as it's best protection is against energy. Bounty Hunters get armor protection against kenetic but most our marks shoot at us and it makes even less sense against Jedi. This forces everyone, not just Bounty Hunters, to master more then one combat profession to have alternative armor choices. Limiting our choices in how we build our character and even worse for those who want to have a crafting class in addition to a combat class. I like the looks of the new armor but really haven't liked the new armor system anyway.



    Hei U-Guize
    Master Creature Handler
    Master Rifleman
    Intrepid Server

    Bean' Delphiki
    Bounty Hunter
    Combat Medic
    Valcyn Server
    Cpl_Fisher
    Tue Oct 18, 2005 4:28 pm
    #104

    This is the way I look at it... Bounty Hunters are med range tanks, How many enemies do you see running around throwing rocks at you? If you want to be a close range tank.... go melee, that is there job.


    I think the simpliest solution in terms of less disrupted gameplay would give MBH access to a quest that allowed them o put a powerup on there armor to switch the stats that also biolinked it to them (this would keep an after market from cropping up)





    Member of the Rock alliance.
    CO of DD 214
    Member of EC-p8r militia
    "Have faith in God, but believe in antimatter"
    Bounty Hunters kill for credits, Commando's kill for the hell of it!
    Page 8 of 11