Bounty Hunter Archive

Thread: Were Players forced to PvP?

ArclightX
Mon Nov 07, 2005 10:05 pm
#66


Dallow wrote:

I think there were three different type of jedi:

1) Those that enjoyed the power and the BH content.

2) Those that enjoyed the power and hated the BH content.

3) Those that enjoyed being a jedi(regardless of power) and hated the BH content.

All three groups knew the rules going in, however groups 2 and 3kicked and cried and came up with this 'forced' PvP argument to rally around. Unfortunately for us, group 1 and group 2, SOE has decided to force the group 3 playstyle on everyone.

I never had a problem with uber leet jedi. I never had a problem losing to a jedi. I got over the whole 'jedi are not suppose to be in this timeline' thing. But, to this day, the ones that whine about 'forced' pvp get under my skin to no end. The only thing worse are the ones that now come on this forum and rejoice the removal of player bounties. Hopefully it will be over soon.



Hmmmmm.... some pretty good points made here, well done fwiw.
btw, <---------- Jedi, just so you're aware of my bias. Having said that, I'd say I fall somewhere between 1 and 2 but not falling squarely on either side.
Regarding the whole timeline. were jedi around at this time? how about in the eu? if they were how did they act? how active in the gcw were they? how about the sith during this time? how did they act?, etc.. etc... Suffice it to say, basing swg the game on star wars the movie or the eu is a circular argument where both sides can be proven equally right and equally wrong, so personally I don't think that line of discussion that's gonna reward anyone with anything.
Most pre-cu jedi are simply angry at the fact that we went from being a force to be recon'd with to a force that couldn't outdmg a 4000cm's nvm a mstr doc or mster cm heals. BH's call it balancing, or rock paper scissors or whatever you'd like to brand it. I had/have no interest in being balanced or learning rock, paper, anything and I'd wager a guess most pre9 jedi don't either. I liked the novelty of being a jedi as much as I liked the novelty of being a tkm/rifleman w/pistoltechs4 and pharm4. Both could hold their own and kick butt vs. pretty much anything and everything you could throw at them. If I had an interest in being a fun loving but not very effective combat profession, I'd have been a pre-cu carbineer or pistoleer or something.
I didn't, I wanted power like all good dark jedi/sith and I make no apologies for it. (and before you ask, no I'm not 12yrs old, honest). Upon completing my template (pre-cu) mls, 4004hlr, 4004enchr, 3200powers, I had a very multifaceted template with lots of options, lots of defense, and unless you were packing an absolutely obscene looted weapon of some sort or you were just a master of master of pvp, you were going to have a pretty tough uphill battle to defeat me.
Again, and I stress, Most jedi (myself included) don't see the reality how things were in the past as something that needed fixing or balancing or correcting (bug fixes and fine tweaking perhaps but that's about it), I never gave a thought to my dmg being outhealed, at least not after I finished mls and had 4 near perfect pearls. When I finished my temp, my thought was simply, "yup, this is what I was expecting glad to seethis isthe case".
I really can't stress the fact strongly enough, I wasn't looking for a nerf, or a balance or anything of the sort, I had to grind my ass off and when it was done, the reward was pretty close to what I had hoped. In the end your own correspondant (tanks) realized that the more we got nerfed the more the chance that player bounties would go away, and low and behold here we are.
Let me sum up all the previous paragraphs with one simple sentence:
If you offered the jedi population as a whole to go back to how things were pre-cu with the power we had, the elegance jedi possesed, the "cool" factor still intact, but in doing so, you're willing to accept player bounties incl. multiple missions on a single target, etc.. etc.. I guarentee you there would be an overwhelming majority that would be just fine with it.
I know I would



Girls with Guns
Ahazians Love the NGE You can Too
Darka-ce
Mon Nov 07, 2005 10:22 pm
#67

Welcome to last year.. also known as the "dead horse" thread. Furthermore, in a scant few days, this will be also known as the "obsolete" thread.





______TK-99______
Stormtrooper

"Greedo did NOT shoot first !"

Darka-ce
Mon Nov 07, 2005 10:26 pm
#68



Digitalalchemyzt wrote:

you people are some real idiots who says jedi was not a pvp prof...when you unlocked as in pre cu, you GOT AN EMAIL FROM SOE THAT SPECIFICALLY STATES....okay, for you low brow types..are you ready...okay..are you ready...JEDI IS A PVP PROFESSION IT WAS STATED IN THE HOLOMAIL YOU GOT WHEN YOU UNLOCKED IN PRECU....

now, do my little shchool bus children understand now? thats why people say that.

you got an email stating that it was a pvp prof. fools. you got an email stating it was a pvp prof

sorry guys, theres just some really stupid people on these boards that dont know jack about the jedi prof...






Incorrect. Only Pre-village Jedi got an email stating that Jedi was "full of dangers". Anyone who unlocked post-CU got ZERO indication in game or email, that it was a PvP profession. Perhaps sir, it is YOU who either need to step onto the bus or learn, FULLY, about our profession.





______TK-99______
Stormtrooper

"Greedo did NOT shoot first !"

pussycat
Mon Nov 07, 2005 11:35 pm
#69



Darka-ce wrote:


Digitalalchemyzt wrote:

you people are some real idiots who says jedi was not a pvp prof...when you unlocked as in pre cu, you GOT AN EMAIL FROM SOE THAT SPECIFICALLY STATES....okay, for you low brow types..are you ready...okay..are you ready...JEDI IS A PVP PROFESSION IT WAS STATED IN THE HOLOMAIL YOU GOT WHEN YOU UNLOCKED IN PRECU....

now, do my little shchool bus children understand now? thats why people say that.

you got an email stating that it was a pvp prof. fools. you got an email stating it was a pvp prof

sorry guys, theres just some really stupid people on these boards that dont know jack about the jedi prof...






Incorrect. Only Pre-village Jedi got an email stating that Jedi was "full of dangers". Anyone who unlocked post-CU got ZERO indication in game or email, that it was a PvP profession. Perhaps sir, it is YOU who either need to step onto the bus or learn, FULLY, about our profession.





1. Did the e-mail say it was a pvp profession, or that it was subject to forced pvp? There is a difference between being a profession that can excel at pvp when and if it chooses, and being one which is basically forced to pvp.

2. As has been stated above, not all Jedi got the same gmail.

3. Regardless of what the devs said, or how they phrased their position regarding the Jedi profession, it still remained a forced pvp profession. That the possibility of forced pvp might have been mentioned in advance does not change the fact that it was forced pvp. Any time that you, as a player, do not get to pvp at the time, place, and under circumstances of your choosing, it is a form of forced pvp.
pussycat
Tue Nov 08, 2005 1:05 am
#70



scally wrote:


pussycat wrote:


scally wrote:


pussycat wrote:


atahualpa wrote:
Just give it a rest man. You lost, no more player bounties ever. Deal with it and enjoy the new game or quit.




QFE...


Shes Alive





You can try to demonize a person all you want... in the end, we're all players who shared this experience, that SWG had to offer during the first 2+ years of its original version (meaning pre-NGE). You like demonizing someone because simply for voicing an opinion.... and in the end, it all just goes to show that this Jedi/BH system did in fact serve to create hostility and animosity between players who otherwise would probably have gotten along just great. This is what you do not see, or understand... this is precisely why I'm glad the old system is coming to an end. I saw way too many ruined friendships over this issue on the live servers to think that it could possibly have been a good thing for the player base.

you dont need me to do that your doing a good job by yourself





And again, as I said before, this only perfectly illustrates the fact that the player bounty system just seemed to create tension, anger and hostility among the player base. Perhaps the game would have been better off if Jedi had never been introduced, if player bounties had never existed; we'll never know, of course, but at least we can look forward to a "new beginning" of sorts, even if the game dynamics are not all that some would wish for, then at least I'm optimistic that people will be more likely to come together instead of fighting with each other over game mechanics. Those who like pvp will still pvp, and those who don't like constant pvp (or simply no pvp at all) will be able to enjoy the game with their preferred game style.

I don't know if you had a BH alt or why you are so obviously upset at all of this.
pussycat
Tue Nov 08, 2005 1:34 am
#71



Angamarth wrote:


Dallow wrote:

I think there were three different type of jedi:

1) Those that enjoyed the power and the BH content.

2) Those that enjoyed the power and hated the BH content.

3) Those that enjoyed being a jedi (regardless of power) and hated the BH content.

All three groups knew the rules going in, however groups 2 and 3 kicked and cried and came up with this 'forced' PvP argument to rally around. Unfortunately for us, group 1 and group 2, SOE has decided to force the group 3 playstyle on everyone.

I never had a problem with uber leet jedi. I never had a problem losing to a jedi. I got over the whole 'jedi are not suppose to be in this timeline' thing. But, to this day, the ones that whine about 'forced' pvp get under my skin to no end. The only thing worse are the ones that now come on this forum and rejoice the removal of player bounties. Hopefully it will be over soon.



Forced non PvP on everyone? Hardly. If a Jedi wants PvP, they can declare SpecForce, and I'm sure they can find PvP quite easily. If they want to be hunted, just stay SpecForce and go about your business, someone will hunt you soon. If a bounty hunter wants to hunt Jedi, go SpecForce and go look for SpecForce Jedi. Simple.

The only thing removed is the ability to attack them when they are not prepared for PvP, and the little waypoint saying "target here!" and the payout if you happen to win. And, of course, the flawed system that probably generated more nerf calls, exploits, and developer headaches than everything else in the game combined.

The only way player bounties should ever return is as a completely voluntary signup at the bounty hunter mission terminals for people that enjoy being hunted. No 'put on the terms for doing something profession related,' no 'players taking bounties on other players,' and no 'bounties for getting too much negative faction from NPCs.' It should work, everyone touts how much they enjoy being hunted, or how many Jedi they know that will miss being hunted. There should be plenty of signups for prey if it's so fun.






/agree 100%

If the last two years have thought us anything, it is simply... "don't force players to pvp who don't want to pvp"... solves a lot of problems for both the players and the devs.
NewEye
Tue Nov 08, 2005 1:40 am
#72






Forced non PvP on everyone? Hardly. If a Jedi wants PvP, they can declare SpecForce, and I'm sure they can find PvP quite easily. If they want to be hunted, just stay SpecForce and go about your business, someone will hunt you soon. If a bounty hunter wants to hunt Jedi, go SpecForce and go look for SpecForce Jedi. Simple.


Stupid. If you are SpecForce ANYBODY or EVERYBODY could attack.


The only thing removed is the ability to attack them when they are not prepared for PvP, and the little waypoint saying "target here!"and the payout if you happen to win. And, of course, the flawed system that probably generatedmore nerf calls, exploits, and developer headaches than everything else in the game combined.


Not prepared? Geez. I must have been lucky to find only full temp Jedi that didn't need doc or med buffs. I got my butt handed to me more than I dished it out. So unprepared? I don't think so. I used to complain that I was a CL80 MCM / MBH with Doc and food buffs and STILL couldn't knock a dent in some of these guys.


The only way player bounties should ever return is as a completely voluntary signup at the bounty hunter mission terminals for people that enjoy being hunted. No 'put on the terms for doing something profession related,' no 'players taking bounties on other players,' and no 'bounties for getting too much negative faction from NPCs.' It should work, everyone touts how much they enjoy being hunted, or how many Jedi they know that will miss being hunted. There should be plenty of signups for prey if it's so fun.


The Jedi that I really want to kill are not the ones "acting true to self". Meaning that Jedi were not running around in starports flashing their sabers. Jedi were known to be mysterious. Jedi were also known to be secretive and mostly in hiding for fear of BEING PERSUED BY A BOUNTY HUNTER. It makes me sick of people playing this game and whining about certain aspects of it that apparently haven't even seen the movies! I became a Bounty Hunter because I WANTED to hunt Jedi. I also NEVER met a Jedi that moaned because I had their mission. THEY EXPECTED IT. So it ticks me off with the majority of Jedi are in favor of keeping player bounties and the select few that don't want it know how to cry loud enough for others to hear. The makeup of a MMORPG is interaction whether that is positive or negative. If you want a game were you feel "safe", go play something you can predict. COMPUTER VS. THE HUMAN MIND





pussycat
Tue Nov 08, 2005 1:45 am
#73



NewEye wrote:

Forced non PvP on everyone? Hardly. If a Jedi wants PvP, they can declare SpecForce, and I'm sure they can find PvP quite easily. If they want to be hunted, just stay SpecForce and go about your business, someone will hunt you soon. If a bounty hunter wants to hunt Jedi, go SpecForce and go look for SpecForce Jedi. Simple.

Stupid. If you are SpecForce ANYBODY or EVERYBODY could attack.

The only thing removed is the ability to attack them when they are not prepared for PvP, and the little waypoint saying "target here!" and the payout if you happen to win. And, of course, the flawed system that probably generated more nerf calls, exploits, and developer headaches than everything else in the game combined.

Not prepared? Geez. I must have been lucky to find only full temp Jedi that didn't need doc or med buffs. I got my butt handed to me more than I dished it out. So unprepared? I don't think so. I used to complain that I was a CL80 MCM / MBH with Doc and food buffs and STILL couldn't knock a dent in some of these guys.

The only way player bounties should ever return is as a completely voluntary signup at the bounty hunter mission terminals for people that enjoy being hunted. No 'put on the terms for doing something profession related,' no 'players taking bounties on other players,' and no 'bounties for getting too much negative faction from NPCs.' It should work, everyone touts how much they enjoy being hunted, or how many Jedi they know that will miss being hunted. There should be plenty of signups for prey if it's so fun.

The Jedi that I really want to kill are not the ones "acting true to self". Meaning that Jedi were not running around in starports flashing their sabers. Jedi were known to be mysterious. Jedi were also known to be secretive and mostly in hiding for fear of BEING PERSUED BY A BOUNTY HUNTER. It makes me sick of people playing this game and whining about certain aspects of it that apparently haven't even seen the movies! I became a Bounty Hunter because I WANTED to hunt Jedi. I also NEVER met a Jedi that moaned because I had their mission. THEY EXPECTED IT. So it ticks me off with the majority of Jedi are in favor of keeping player bounties and the select few that don't want it know how to cry loud enough for others to hear. The makeup of a MMORPG is interaction whether that is positive or negative. If you want a game were you feel "safe", go play something you can predict. COMPUTER VS. THE HUMAN MIND







The movies never showed or mentioned bounty hunters hunting Jedi. As far as the movies go, you only ever got to see BH's taking or working on missions to capture/hunt/kill smugglers, pilots and politicians. They never took a mission on a Jedi, when the Emperor issued order 66, he turned to Darth Vader and his army... he had no need for bounty hunters, he had a sith lord and a galaxy-wide army at his disposal, for crying out loud.
Tacola
Tue Nov 08, 2005 1:46 am
#74

Jedi's knew Bounty Hunters were after them , that is a fact. I am a full temp jedi, but avoided VIS , I have only had 4 BH encounters and I won 3. It was a rush, very fun and exciting. But some dont like PVP, usually the unskilled,and that is ok.As for this being a lost cause to protest or ask for BH PC mission to be put back in, I give you NGE. If they can changes stuff this much, there is no way Iwould believe further tuning isnt coming once this goes live for alot of professions.



So stand guard on what ever issues you want. I would ask anyone to just give this NGE a chance, because playing a MMPG by yourself sorta defeats the purpose.


P.







Tacola
MLS FEnh FHea FDefl
Sodlyvv
MBH MCM
Artttac
MChef BE Merchant Artisan
Drop winnings at 1219, -6861 just out of Agro on Dantoonie, Vendor:Glowies.
pussycat
Tue Nov 08, 2005 1:51 am
#75



Tacola wrote:

Jedi's knew Bounty Hunters were after them , that is a fact. I am a full temp jedi, but avoided VIS , I have only had 4 BH encounters and I won 3. It was a rush, very fun and exciting. But some dont like PVP, usually the unskilled, and that is ok. As for this being a lost cause to protest or ask for BH PC mission to be put back in, I give you NGE. If they can changes stuff this much, there is no way I would believe further tuning isnt coming once this goes live for alot of professions.

So stand guard on what ever issues you want. I would ask anyone to just give this NGE a chance, because playing a MMPG by yourself sorta defeats the purpose.

P.






Just because you knew that BH's could come after you, didn't make it any less of a forced pvp system... and seriously, there is no way to avoid visibility in the long run unless you want to miss out on all the content in the game. Tell me, how many quests can you do on Mustafar without any risk of gaining visibility? I can think of maybe a handful, but all of the big stuff, the quests you need to do to get to speak with Obi-Wan, the quests in the YT-2400 series, they all require you to do things that would obviously result in visibility. You can't tell a whole profession that they should just miss out on most of the game's content simply because the only option is forced pvp.

And for your information, being skilled or unskilled has nothing to do with how you feel about pvp... I wouldn't enjoy pvp even if I was the "uberest" player in the galaxy. Skill has nothing to do with it, it is about freedom of choice and being able to decide for yourself what you want to do in the game at any particular time and who you do or do not want to play with... it's as simple as that.
NewEye
Tue Nov 08, 2005 1:56 am
#76






[Seana Steelbone JEDI] [Seani Steamzone MEDIC]
- - - - - - - [Seara Soulstone ENGINEER] - - - - - - -
- - - - - - [MsNiL -AKA-Seana- [TC] JEDI] - - - - - -



JEDI


I am here to officially ask you to leave the Bounty Hunter Forum. You are not a Bounty Hunter so go away. I was given this same type of message when I attempted to post on a JEDI board. After I got flamed simply because of my profession and asking if anyone wanted to grind later that day. I found their methods rude and uncalled for. So, if you are not a Bounty Hunter I ask you to cease posting in this forum as I will report you if it continues.


Thank you


Also Pussycat if you are not a BH please go away.
pussycat
Tue Nov 08, 2005 1:59 am
#77

My first profession was BH... back in the days when it was the toughest profession to grind, back in the days before mounts, vehicles, player cities, back in the day of 10-minute shuttle waits.

I am looking forward to the new BH profession, especially since it will not be associated with pvp'ers the way it was in the old game.

Have a nice day.

P.S. In case you didn't realize this, a lot of BH's currently are Jedi alts....

Message Edited by pussycat on 11-07-2005 01:01 PM

ChefRubio
Tue Nov 08, 2005 2:16 am
#78






pussycat wrote:





Darka-ce wrote:





Digitalalchemyzt wrote:

you people are some real idiots who says jedi was not a pvp prof...when you unlocked as in pre cu, you GOT AN EMAIL FROM SOE THAT SPECIFICALLY STATES....okay, for you low brow types..are you ready...okay..are you ready...JEDI IS A PVP PROFESSION IT WAS STATED IN THE HOLOMAIL YOU GOT WHEN YOU UNLOCKED IN PRECU....


now, do my little shchool bus children understand now? thats why people say that.


you got an email stating that it was a pvp prof. fools. you got an email stating it was a pvp prof


sorry guys, theres just some really stupid people on these boards that dont know jack about the jedi prof...










Incorrect. Only Pre-village Jedi got an email stating that Jedi was "full of dangers". Anyone who unlocked post-CU got ZERO indication in game or email, that it was a PvP profession. Perhaps sir, it is YOU who either need to step onto the bus or learn, FULLY, about our profession.




1. Did the e-mail say it was a pvp profession, or that it was subject to forced pvp? There is a difference between being a profession that can excel at pvp when and if it chooses, and being one which is basically forced to pvp. 2. As has been stated above, not all Jedi got the same gmail. 3. Regardless of what the devs said, or how they phrased their position regarding the Jedi profession, it still remained a forced pvp profession. That the possibility of forced pvp might have been mentioned in advance does not change the fact that it was forced pvp. Any time that you, as a player, do not get to pvp at the time, place, and under circumstances of your choosing, it is a form of forced pvp.





It pretty much said if you didnt stay out of sight you would be hunted by the empire and by bh. I'm not sure 100% what it said, but it said there would be consequenses of that sort if seen by the public eye, so yes it did say there would be pvp encounters.







Priest |Aenemia
~Jedi Elder~
|||FEDS|||
One of the few, the proud, the pre patch 9.
Page 6 of 13