Weaponsmith Archive

Thread: SAC means NOTHING! Stop BSing us guys!!

UrdlenThorn
Mon May 30, 2005 4:38 am
#1

NO ONE asks for low SAC and I have NEVER run out of it on my combat characters.... Just like ALL my customers, thee only thing that matters is DAMAGE.


You Jerks would have the unitiated making unsaleable weapons while you laugh and rake in the dough with your High damge low speed superior product...


I can't believe no one has pointed this out yet!!


Its been Two months!


What happened to a correspondent who has useful info-- Mor-dan is in SOE's pocket, all he cares about is a bug--- well the important stuff isn't bugs it the Flummoxed system that works as they designed it...


Between Mor Dan and the liars who post here about how important SAC is, I have come to dislike the WS forum passionatly... What is going on?


You guys must be from planet Hell...



Thorn, Architect; Henriette, Weapons; Viathen, Droids
Vendors Hall B Brenn (long, long ago)
Vendors Knytes Gate
GrooperNugent
Mon May 30, 2005 4:55 am
#2

/disagree


I have gone back and remade my 'personal' weapons for my rifleman alt specifically targeting SAC because, even loaded on food and drugs, I would start to see that -Too Tired- message pop up over my head during a long fight.


My guildies (BH's and PvP'ers in particular) have asked me to remake thier enhanced weapons to get the SAC down 20 or so points before working on damage.


And just yesterday, I made 2 special orders for different people who gave specific targets for thier SAC, again, because it was an issue during long fights.



Lastly, I don't see where the venom towards Mor-Dan comes from, if you want a pistol maxed out on damage with no regard to SAC, simply ask your friendly weaponsmith to make you one. I'd be also be willing to bet you can find many such guns for sale across the galaxy with no regard given to SAC. Leftovers from early post-CU crafting where we were all trying to max-out damage. I know I've got quite a few running around out there.






Grooper/LEEROY
*Fishstick* Weapons
-1656, 4483 Babylon, Dantooine Mining Outpost
Puttley
Mon May 30, 2005 5:00 am
#3

you're too much of an a55hole to ignore. perhaps you're right, no one buys low SAC weapons, but it does work. i'm in a guild where we are all riflemen - ie lots of us to test lots of different weapons, with low and high damage and sac costs, on one of the higer SAC cost proffesions. SAC DOES MATTER PERIOD. try compairing a high SAC cost toa low SAC cost with a action reducing power up. or are you to stupid and enjoy insulting people. get off your horse and shut up
Summerflame
Mon May 30, 2005 5:03 am
#4






UrdlenThorn wrote:

NO ONE asks for low SAC and I have NEVER run out of it on my combat characters.... Just like ALL my customers, thee only thing that matters is DAMAGE.


You Jerks would have the unitiated making unsaleable weapons while you laugh and rake in the dough with your High damge low speed superior product...


I can't believe no one has pointed this out yet!!


Its been Two months!


What happened to a correspondent who has useful info-- Mor-dan is in SOE's pocket, all he cares about is a bug--- well the important stuff isn't bugs it the Flummoxed system that works as they designed it...


Between Mor Dan and the liars who post here about how important SAC is, I have come to dislike the WS forum passionatly... What is going on?


You guys must be from planet Hell...






No need to use this tone, that certainly aint a good ground for discussion.

To your points

SAC might not be of importance to you, but I surely can say without doubt that id go for SAC over DPS any day with my combat alt and there has been plenty of non ws combattants stating the same at these very boards.

Low SACs gives you the option to spam specials more often. Specials deals more damage (or has another desired effect, like root or knockdown).

Im pretty sure theres a time to use DPS and a time touse low SAC weapons, however for me, when fighting Gorax and krayts I have found that low SAC takes them down the fastest.


To your second consern. Im absolutely sure Mor-dan would tell us if there were any news, but if the devs havent answered his questions well what is he supposed to do? Make something up to satisfy the community.

While Im very conserned of the state of our profession atm I realize that there is 32 other professions out there, most of which hurts as badly or worse than us.

Im not defending SOE here I think they pushed the CU way to soon and we are now dealing with the consequenses of that decision.

Im hoping they will fix the new system so it becomes more enjoyable to be a crafter, but the choice atm is either have patience whilethey get their act together or leave to return when things looks better.

Atm I myself am staying, deciding from day to day wether it seems worth it to wait it out.


On a final note, theres no need to insult the entire Weaponsmith community because you are frustrated. I think most of us are frustrated, but if looking at these very boards makes you angry, then just stop coming here its that easy




----------[N*W]Weaponry (+2 and FS)----------
@Danevang City Corellia 3434 -5534 and Danevang Mall 3325 -5633@
{{{Summerflame k Nalai{{{
{{{Angelic deliverer of Pboys pimp weapons{{{



UrdlenThorn
Mon May 30, 2005 5:53 am
#5

No one has figured out how to beat the cyclopian system instagated after the combat update and have a great deal of fun in this game... There were way to have great times in SWG at various points in the game-- but post CU no one can do it.


You must track down and fight things your level... If you want ANY XP.


You can not solo things...


That caused the 4th and 5th in command of my guild of 75 peeps on Shadowfire to quit in disgust.


There was a time you could have fun in this game with the GCW but the GCW update ruined that by making bases pointless. A PVP base is impossible and a NPC base is simple.


Ksahyyykis full of stuff thats either too easy and give no XP or is impossible.. What a disappointment-out of 11 accounts my wife and I could not find one with a combat template who could have fun the day we went to Kashyyyk the first time.


But what really makes me mad is the way the community is learing to LIVE WITH IT.


AND the people who seem to form opinions on the weaponsmith board (Mor Dan, Vocal SAC weapon nuts) pretend to have a clue on what they are really dicussing rather than lookingt at the ELEPHANT IN THE LIVINGROOM.


there are like 19 posts dicussing 1/100 of a percent variance on a stat for a COMPONENT in the top 5 issues forum...


what about (sorry MOR DAN but These issues MAY NOT BE BUGS... I suggest you call Teminex right away... You're in Bed with them)


!. Scythe Blades which are the coolest looking weapon in the game, funnest to quest for, and once were the best now are USELESS.


2. Geonosian Blasters-- similar issue as above, but who could ever get in to the Geonosian Cave to get anything now...


3. USELESS WEAPONS Make Useless USELESS PROFESSIONS-- who would be a pole arm specialist if you can only lay out half the damge as a pistoleer and 1/3 the damage of a bounty hunter? What about the fencer? Where are the maces we saw in the Test center? Will they make the fencer like the Swordsman, who's only decent with one weapon, a powerhammer (SWORDsman uses a hammer FENCER uses a mace? STUPID STUPID STUPID!!!)


4. What the heck happened to squad leader rocket launcher? (this is just one particculat example). In my arrogance I spent DAYS making a run of rocket launchers after thinking there must be SOME weapon that does a bit of good damge for a squad leader. MAX 325. But 15 components, though. Oh, YEAH, I'll be making a lot of rocket launchers for all the squad leaders out there dying to do 325 max damge every 3 seconds as a master of their elite profession.


5. Impossible Foes-- Tell me one group of 8 80th-level who have done the Corvette... or a group of Nova Troopers, for that matter. Their wepaons are so much better than anything we have, half the stuff in this game is suicide....


What have they done?


My list goes on and on.. I don't have the time or the inclination to try to type out a full list? This is rediculous-- GET BUSY PEOPLE! I'll be playing Neverwinter Nights over and over again till it starts to look playable... poking my head in enough to keep my guild in stiches... LOL! you are awefully quick to call me an ... when it is soo Obvious that I am... try to think outside the box and come up with something helpful... look in the less obvious place like THE NOSE ON YOUR FACE!




Thorn, Architect; Henriette, Weapons; Viathen, Droids
Vendors Hall B Brenn (long, long ago)
Vendors Knytes Gate
Muzz
Mon May 30, 2005 6:26 am
#6






UrdlenThorn wrote:

My list goes on and on.. I don't have the time or the inclination to try to type out a full list? This is rediculous-- GET BUSY PEOPLE! I'll be playing Neverwinter Nights over and over again till it starts to look playable... poking my head in enough to keep my guild in stiches... LOL! you are awefully quick to call me an ... when it is soo Obvious that I am... try to think outside the box and come up with something helpful... look in the less obvious place like THE NOSE ON YOUR FACE!






Can I have your stuff?


That's one thing you're right about. It's obvious you are.


If you posted your concerns in a reasonable manner, and without resorting to personal attacks on our new correspondent, then you would be entitled to reasonable responses.




Orgama

Weaponsmith (12pt), Artisan (14pt), Merchant, Force Crafting Master
ludio ludius utpote 2003, in pello utpote 11/2005
Shaina
Mon May 30, 2005 6:33 am
#7






UrdlenThorn wrote:

NO ONE asks for low SAC and I have NEVER run out of it on my combat characters.... Just like ALL my customers, thee only thing that matters is DAMAGE.


You Jerks would have the unitiated making unsaleable weapons while you laugh and rake in the dough with your High damge low speed superior product...


I can't believe no one has pointed this out yet!!


Its been Two months!


What happened to a correspondent who has useful info-- Mor-dan is in SOE's pocket, all he cares about is a bug--- well the important stuff isn't bugs it the Flummoxed system that works as they designed it...


Between Mor Dan and the liars who post here about how important SAC is, I have come to dislike the WS forum passionatly... What is going on?


You guys must be from planet Hell...






I sell low-sac, high-dps and high-damage weapons on my vendors. They all sell.


I also being a Master Rifleman/Master Bounty Hunter, with foods, drinks and all that in me to help my action costs, still run out of Action really fast when spamming specials.


low-sac does make a difference. If i can save 20-30 action points each special I use, maybe I can get an extra special off before I run out of Action.


But if your customers only want high-damage, then by all means sell only high-damage to them.


Never make a bunch of weapons in the hopes they will sell. make a few of each type and see what sells and replace what sells. You can also look at your galaxy trade forums on here and see what most people are buying up there and what they are asking for.


I also think getting bugs fixed is much more important than how the system works. It works how it works and thats it, we work within how it works and make weapons the best we can with what we are given.


what is better...high dps? low sac? high damage? who knows. I dont see anything one way or the other what is better. my test is, if i'm taking down low level npcs for loot, i use high damage(1 shot kill them.) I'm going in for a pro-longed battle..(ie a krayt) i use a low-sac, as i need to keep my action from running out.


anyways Have a most wonderful day.








Sandstorm
Jaeven
Summerflame
Mon May 30, 2005 7:17 am
#8




UrdlenThorn wrote:

No one has figured out how to beat the cyclopian system instagated after the combat update and have a great deal of fun in this game... There were way to have great times in SWG at various points in the game-- but post CU no one can do it.


I believe you will find a lot of people who would say the opposite of this, so cant we just agree that this is a matter of personal opinions. I myself like the combat system better, but hate what they have done to crafters/entertainers


You must track down and fight things your level... If you want ANY XP.


You can not solo things...


Well, this is jsut a matter of you finding out how to do it. Noone could solo elders when the game was first launched either. I personally am able to solo both krayts and goraxes and might I add a lot faster than in the old system.


That caused the 4th and 5th in command of my guild of 75 peeps on Shadowfire to quit in disgust.


Ive had my share of friends quit over the CU, but Im exspecting most to return as there really isnt an alternative to SWG on the market.


There was a time you could have fun in this game with the GCW but the GCW update ruined that by making bases pointless. A PVP base is impossible and a NPC base is simple.


Never pvped in my entire life, so Im gona have to take your word on this, thou Ive heard several people proclaiming that PVP is now much more fun than it was before the CU.


Ksahyyykis full of stuff thats either too easy and give no XP or is impossible.. What a disappointment-out of 11 accounts my wife and I could not find one with a combat template who could have fun the day we went to Kashyyyk the first time.


Well Ive stopped going to Kashyyk as it reminds me that we cannot craft the new quest reward weapons, however Kashyyk was never ment to be a grind planet. Its a giant themepark and is packed with content. Do the quests forget the Xps for a sec


But what really makes me mad is the way the community is learing to LIVE WITH IT.


Anyone who has followed my posting during the introduction of the CU, know that I had major issues with it. I am not however so stupid as to believe they will take it back. If the CU fails I believe they will just shutdown the game. Therefor I have now when they decided to implement it started trying to higlight the issues that needs correction for the game to be fun for me again and I believe that the dedication is much better used in that department.


AND the people who seem to form opinions on the weaponsmith board (Mor Dan, Vocal SAC weapon nuts) pretend to have a clue on what they are really dicussing rather than lookingt at the ELEPHANT IN THE LIVINGROOM.


there are like 19 posts dicussing 1/100 of a percent variance on a stat for a COMPONENT in the top 5 issues forum...


Post your own issues to make an impact. For the people who have psoted there clearly that is the most important issue for them. If you want to be heard make valied arguments in the designated thread instead of making a thread blaming the WS community.


what about (sorry MOR DAN but These issues MAY NOT BE BUGS... I suggest you call Teminex right away... You're in Bed with them)


!. Scythe Blades which are the coolest looking weapon in the game, funnest to quest for, and once were the best now are USELESS.


2. Geonosian Blasters-- similar issue as above, but who could ever get in to the Geonosian Cave to get anything now...


3. USELESS WEAPONS Make Useless USELESS PROFESSIONS-- who would be a pole arm specialist if you can only lay out half the damge as a pistoleer and 1/3 the damage of a bounty hunter? What about the fencer? Where are the maces we saw in the Test center? Will they make the fencer like the Swordsman, who's only decent with one weapon, a powerhammer (SWORDsman uses a hammer FENCER uses a mace? STUPID STUPID STUPID!!!)


4. What the heck happened to squad leader rocket launcher? (this is just one particculat example). In my arrogance I spent DAYS making a run of rocket launchers after thinking there must be SOME weapon that does a bit of good damge for a squad leader. MAX 325. But 15 components, though. Oh, YEAH, I'll be making a lot of rocket launchers for all the squad leaders out there dying to do 325 max damge every 3 seconds as a master of their elite profession.


5. Impossible Foes-- Tell me one group of 8 80th-level who have done the Corvette... or a group of Nova Troopers, for that matter. Their wepaons are so much better than anything we have, half the stuff in this game is suicide.... In all fairness this isnt really a WS bug now is it... its a question of the corvette mobs being to highlevel and thus a combat balance issue


What have they done?


My list goes on and on.. I don't have the time or the inclination to try to type out a full list? This is rediculous-- GET BUSY PEOPLE! I'll be playing Neverwinter Nights over and over again till it starts to look playable... poking my head in enough to keep my guild in stiches... LOL! you are awefully quick to call me an ... when it is soo Obvious that I am... try to think outside the box and come up with something helpful... look in the less obvious place like THE NOSE ON YOUR FACE!


Have you even had a look at this thread? Cause a lot of the issues you point out have been adressed here and has been submitted to the DEVs


Oh and I may not allways agree with Mor-dan but Ive noticed that even thou he disagrees with suggestions and issues he still submits them (as would be exspected of course) so to me hes doing very well as a correspondent.









----------[N*W]Weaponry (+2 and FS)----------
@Danevang City Corellia 3434 -5534 and Danevang Mall 3325 -5633@
{{{Summerflame k Nalai{{{
{{{Angelic deliverer of Pboys pimp weapons{{{



mka
Mon May 30, 2005 7:45 am
#9






UrdlenThorn wrote:

4. What the heck happened to squad leader rocket launcher? (this is just one particculat example). In my arrogance I spent DAYS making a run of rocket launchers after thinking there must be SOME weapon that does a bit of good damge for a squad leader. MAX 325. But 15 components, though. Oh, YEAH, I'll be making a lot of rocket launchers for all the squad leaders out there dying to do 325 max damge every 3 seconds as a master of their elite profession.







If you were a serious WS you'd know that Squad Leaders are not certified for Rocket Launchers.



And you still didn't prove why experimenting on SAC was useless.



Jeswin Esqui - Master Smuggler - Master Commando - Master Pilot - Chimaera Galaxy
dsurfman
Mon May 30, 2005 7:58 am
#10

I am a carbineer (master). I have run out of combat que before. maybe you arent finding difficult enough MOBS...But mainly I just make low SAC weapons on request. I make a damage/speed balance.



Celehorn
Imperium Securis
EdOWar
Mon May 30, 2005 8:09 am
#11






UrdlenThorn wrote:

NO ONE asks for low SAC and I have NEVER run out of it on my combat characters.... Just like ALL my customers, thee only thing that matters is DAMAGE.


You Jerks would have the unitiated making unsaleable weapons while you laugh and rake in the dough with your High damge low speed superior product...


I can't believe no one has pointed this out yet!!


Its been Two months!


What happened to a correspondent who has useful info-- Mor-dan is in SOE's pocket, all he cares about is a bug--- well the important stuff isn't bugs it the Flummoxed system that works as they designed it...


Between Mor Dan and the liars who post here about how important SAC is, I have come to dislike the WS forum passionatly... What is going on?


You guys must be from planet Hell...






This guy isn't looking for serious debate here. He's just trolling. So ignore him, and he'll probably move on...or maybe even quit the game, which would be fine by me.


And for the record, Correspondents aren't miracle workers. They don't have a red phone hotline to Devs to address all of YOUR needs. They pass questions and suggestions along to the Devs, and then maybe, someday, the Devs will deign to give them a response. They're basically meatshields to keep jerks like you off the Dev'sbacks. See how venomous you were towards Mor-dan, but hardly one bad word for the Devs? The Correspondent system is brilliant, when you look at it from that perspective. And to judge from posts like this, it apparantly works very well.


Slim Vargo, Corbantis


Aerobio
Mon May 30, 2005 8:09 am
#12






Summerflame wrote:




UrdlenThorn wrote:

2. Geonosian Blasters-- similar issue as above, but who could ever get in to the Geonosian Cave to get anything now...










Have you been to the Geo caves lately? It's very reasonable and seems balanced about right for a small/medium sized group....but Geo blasters are still useless.


Re: SAC


My alt M. Carbineer constantly runs out action. The "special" weapons I make for that character are all low SAC. Maybelow SAC weaponsdon't sell as well to the general public, but those who know will want a low SAC weapon in their arsenal.







AERO'BIO
Mayor of Confluentes, Dantooine
Master Weaponsmith (12pt), Artisan, and Merchant
Vendor: AERO Weapons Headquarters and Vehicles in Confluentes, Dantooine 1324 -2217
bgold4
Mon May 30, 2005 9:17 am
#13

so basically you dont like the cu and you're blaming mor-dan for not getting us a rollback to pre-cu?



; Silentone Ikeef ;
r Master Pistoleer r
r Master Bounty Hunter r
r 32.33%, Of course repeating r

Page 1 of 5
Previous Next