Weaponsmith Archive

Thread: SAC means NOTHING! Stop BSing us guys!!

ShugFlurry
Mon May 30, 2005 10:11 am
#14

Takes my mbh/mpistoleer alt about 10seconds to run out of action while spamming improved body/adv crit shot.



Shug
12pt Master WeaponSmith Master Force Crafter
-843 2827 Dantooine, Mining Outpost
Darth-Kevlar
Mon May 30, 2005 10:43 am
#15






ShugFlurry wrote:
Takes my mbh/mpistoleer alt about 10seconds to run out of action while spamming improved body/adv crit shot.




Ditto. No matter what combination of spices /foods/buffs I get, if I cicle between my most powerfull /usable specials with the shortest delay possibe, my action bar will run out in 10-15 seconds. Only way I 'm able to get it stable is to use a PRE CU weapon with 84 sac, then use a -% action cost, getting the SAC on the weapon to 53.


It is sad that the gross majority of the SWG player base is uneducated to a point where they only look at max damage. Thats probably the reason why on most of mylatest duels, after checking the combat log, many of my opponentsended up discharging 6/7 specials in a row and then 4 or 5 ranged shots, when I was able to spam specials till they went down. Eventually every one learns.





_________________________
Darkness & Shade are the burden;
Sweat, Pain, Blood & Tears tools that forged the mind,
within a soul countless times scoorched by Niquel & Lies.
And yet I continue to Breathe, Rise, Feel & Fall.
samijx
Mon May 30, 2005 11:03 am
#16

I have a weapon with high DPS and another with Low SAC. I use both with reularity. The key is getting a weapon with a SAC around 70 - 75 that way you can spam specials without running out of green. (I use the power-up that lowers action cost) It's a great help.



Sami-jx (Naritus)
Master Weaponsmith, Master Armorsmith, Master Artisan, Merchant 4043

Sambacca (Naritus)
Master Bounty Hunter, Master Combat Medic, Carbineer 0400, Reflexes 0300
Standardlager
Mon May 30, 2005 11:13 am
#17






ShugFlurry wrote:
Takes my mbh/mpistoleer alt about 10seconds to run out of action while spamming improved body/adv crit shot.




Straight to the point yet again Shug.


/cheer;

/agree;



Boondizzle/Saxamaphone/Shogun/Slayre/Phu/Phu-
Mor-Dan
Mon May 30, 2005 11:32 am
#18






UrdlenThorn wrote:



What happened to a correspondent who has useful info-- Mor-dan is in SOE's pocket, all he cares about is a bug--- well the important stuff isn't bugs it the Flummoxed system that works as they designed it...


Between Mor Dan and the liars who post here about how important SAC is, I have come to dislike the WS forum passionatly... What is going on?




and




what about (sorry MOR DAN but These issues MAY NOT BE BUGS... I suggest you call Teminex right away... You're in Bed with them)






Thank you for that. I haven't laughed that hard out loud since I can't even remember when. You have ready very few of my past posts, that is very evident. There are stories I could tell if it weren't for an NDA that would certainly have you singing a different tune. Few people are still around have been more vocal against the Dev team than I have. It is one reason whywhen people ask me how I got chosen I tell them it was because I am the only one who submitted for the position. They took a huge chance on naming me, and they know it. but my job right now isn't to stir up controversy...


my job, in case you didn't know since you are not a weaponsmith by trade, is to take bugs and other issues from within the weaponsmith community and present them tot he Dev team, and then work with them to find ways to fix the issues. Right now the biggest problem in this game is bugs, so I am focusing on bugs. once bugs are under control, we can start looking at content, because i would much prefer the bugs to be fixed before new content brings new bugs. if i get a loud response fromt he community asking for something else, then that is what i will focus on.


if i am anybody's b!tch right now, it is the Weaponsmith community. they say, i verify, i do. the verify part is because when you get really upset about something it is more emotion speaking than logic or intellect. we need to cut through emotional outbursts and get tot he heart of the problem. if the heart of the problem is your anger, then there is nothing the Dev team can do. if it is something that is within the structure of who a weaponsmith is and what they should be, then that is an issue i will take to the Dev team.



What is your real issue here? Are you upset about high damage, low SAC weapons? Are you infuriated by people making posts about how great low SAC is when you are unable to see the benefit? Let me go ahead and set the record straight. If you are a single combat prof master, SAC is the least of your worries. You need speed. my CH/Smuggler has a pistol speed mod of 70 or 75, something like that. His biggest concern is how fast he can get a shot off, not how much action will it cost. The same goes for this player in PvP. what good is reserved action if you're dead and unable to use it? this new combat system has actually opened more doors for the Weaponsmith than it has closed.


There are a variety of different fighting styles, and now a weapon can be made for each one of them. There are those who do lots of PvP with solid double master templates. they need low SAC. that's right, NEED it. i have tested it myself and spoken with the best PvPers and Jedi hunters on my server and they all say low SAC is the way to go. Some players have one combat prof and then another prof that does not contain any combat skills. These players need speed. Action means little if you die before it used. You need to get your shots off as quickly as possible and worry about action later. plus, there are several ways to fight that will allow you to regen action without being attacked. learn these tactics and you will be suprised at what you can solo.




as for being in SOEs pocket, well, i think even the Dev team would argue SOE needs to open their pockets a little more than they currently are. Correspondents, however, are paid nothing. it is a complete volunteer position, and is not for those who get stressed easily *cough* *cough*. i could actually couldn't care less about your comments towards me; you don't know me from adam and you don't play on my server. i just wanted to thank you for the laugh and clear up any misconceptions you had about what it is a Correspondent does.



Vendor Locations:
-1560 120 in Soal Valley, Corellia
-4700 5600 north of Theed, Naboo
CorenLanra
Mon May 30, 2005 11:48 am
#19

We don't have to justify ourselves to anyone in _our_ forum. It is obvious through many threads already existing that this person is just trying to get a rise out of us. The fact is SAC is very important and trying to "prove" this to him when the data is already known is pointless. This is the kind of thread I usually completely ignore, but the ignorance is on a level we don't see very often here, and that is saying a lot.



Stettin Palver - Master Weaponsmith
Chilastra - Corellia, South of Coronet 275 -5959
Stettin's X-Force Weapons | 6/26/03 - 12/20/05
-=Official Homepage=-
"The Crafting Menace" - Goodbye to SWG Video
The Science Fiction Review - Books, Movies, TV

jason67
Mon May 30, 2005 11:57 am
#20

I'll make my point short and sweet.


Crappy guns are crappy guns, it doesn't matter if you make them with low SAC or with high max damage, if they suck no one will buy them. Based on the intelligence of your post I am guessing this is your issue, not that you didn't make them right. I craft both types of weapons because what may work well for me, may not work well for another. I've also found that most my PvP clientelle use low SAC weapons while most my PvE customers use high DPS weapons.


However keep in mind that I only do custom work and it's all enhanced. So what is a crappy gun for me may be considered a good gun by many. My best possible damage pistol is a 347 DPS scatter with 102 SAC (unsliced, no pup). On the other end my best SAC weapon is a 68 SAC 289.99 DPS scatter pistol. You can hit slightly lower sac (65) but I was hitting closer to 270 DPS doing that and felt that the 68 SAC version was a better investment.


Some people have problems with SAC while others don't appear to have issues with it at all. I think a couple things play into this. First is their combat profession, different weapons are available for different professions and some are more SAC friendly than others. Second thier choice in skills to use. For example if I was a BH/Pistoleer and I simply spammed one shot (critical shot) then I would have fairly long delays in between my shots and I probably wouldn't run out of SAC as fast because of the time between each shot. However, if I used critical shot then immediately used body shot then my critical shot is ready almost as soon as I'm ready to use it again. This means that I am nonstop shooting specials and that will suck up my action bar twice as fast as the first example.


Needless to say, you should by no means make and sell only one type of weapon, that's just poor business planning on your part. Low SAC weapons sell well, but only to a certain group of players (usually your PvP players) so you need to cater your weapons to what works well for them. The general public, like yourself, still believes that high DPS is the way to go, so if that's your target audience then you should make your weapons accordingly. My weapons are all custom ordered so I have a buyer lined up 80% of the time before the weapon is ever made. I don't roll in the money but I make enough to support my characters. Any personal weapons that I make for my ALT I will normally sell if they don't meet my satisfactions, or I'll sell the extras that didn't turn out as good as I would have liked, or if I just have more than one weapon of the same type with basically the same stats.


if you get two good PvPer's together, and given that they are identical builds and you give one a low SAC weapon and the other a high DPS weapon you'll find that the high DPS combatant will run out of action much sooner and will be forced to use regular shots, drastically reducing his DPS. While the low SAC fighter will start out slightly lower on the DPS, but will stay consistant long term, meaning that ultimately he will be doing higher DPS than the high DPS combatant.


ok so maybe it wasn't so short but at least it's sweet


I also thought I would edit and add this link in for the last weapon I auctioned so you can tell me again how no one is buying low SAC weapons.


Low SAC weapon auction

Message Edited by jason67 on 05-30-2005 12:04 PM





HostageH
Master Lightsaber /3003Enhancer /4100Healer /0044Defender
/0044Force Reflexes /Master Force Combat

Arisa
MasterWeaponsmith(125exp/130assembly/25repair/22weapons repair) /MasterArtisan(14pt) /MasterShipwright /4400Force Crafting
Vendor Location 2355, -3922 just outside Coronet
maxsmelling
Mon May 30, 2005 1:18 pm
#21

im m pistol, m smug, n commando. to me low sac is more important than high damage. after special mods, i do more damage if i keep applying bodyshot than having a high damage weapon that can only apply 3 specials b4 i run out of action, u r obviously not a good weaponsmith, u dont't know your market and ur attitude sux.
Godly-Weapons
Mon May 30, 2005 2:41 pm
#22

Ok this is the f*ucking last straw with you little punks saying that DPS is king. I try to teach you all and you just keep going on about DPS and I wish I could come kick your little a$$'s.

Sorry for getting angry but I have had enough of this.
ShugFlurry
Mon May 30, 2005 4:29 pm
#23

I <3 Mor-dan LOL



Shug
12pt Master WeaponSmith Master Force Crafter
-843 2827 Dantooine, Mining Outpost
boceifus2000
Mon May 30, 2005 4:43 pm
#24

I think everybody tries to over analize everything.



Colonel Boceifus Gadian (BotD)
Retired
Quote: I have seen too much death in my lifetime...

Balanor Gadian
Retired
Quote: I have made so many credits I can buy my own galaxy...
Godly-Weapons
Mon May 30, 2005 4:47 pm
#25



ShugFlurry wrote:
I <3 Mor-dan LOL



me 2
Munitionsmaster
Mon May 30, 2005 6:10 pm
#26






UrdlenThorn wrote:

NO ONE asks for low SAC and I have NEVER run out of it on my combat characters.... Just like ALL my customers, thee only thing that matters is DAMAGE.


Crowd control profs such as Pistoleers and to a degree carbiners want low SAC so they can have lots of specials at their disposal.

You Jerks would have the unitiated making unsaleable weapons while you laugh and rake in the dough with your High damge low speed superior product...


WSing has always been like this. Starting out as a noob WS in one of the hardest points in the game. It is not until you grind master and have lots and lots of high quality resources that you can even think about selling weapons


I can't believe no one has pointed this out yet!!

Because it has always been like that.

Its been Two months!


What happened to a correspondent who has useful info-- Mor-dan is in SOE's pocket, all he cares about is a bug--- well the important stuff isn't bugs it the Flummoxed system that works as they designed it...


Between Mor Dan and the liars who post here about how important SAC is, I have come to dislike the WS forum passionatly... What is going on?

If this fourm angers you, do yourself a favor and stop browsingthrough it before you have a stroke. Your heart will thank you.

You guys must be from planet Hell...
No, I am from the planet earth. Welcome.






Ternel-

Former Master Weaponsmith for over 2 years
Citizen of the Tempest Server
"Think of how stupid the average person is, and realize that half of them are stupider than that." -George Carlin

Page 2 of 5