Smuggler Archive

Thread: Just waxing intellectual on the future of SWG...what's YOUR opinion?

MISTagent01
Wed Jul 06, 2005 1:14 pm
#1


First, I don't want this to turn into a flaming post, so please keep the fighting out of here.



So...I've been thinking a lot about the recent turn of events in this game. The CU, the patches we've recieved as a whole, and every other thing that we've seen changed since launch.


The developers made a decent point about why the CU needed to happen. It was "because the game couldn't go on the way it was going forever. DoT weapons and uber armor were making PvP completely pointless..." and so on. They have also admitted to "looking the other way" about the number of Jedi (this was a LucasArts rep at Fan Fest) and that they want the game to be "more fun" for everybody.


We've also seen the number of Jedi grow exponentially over time, for two fundamental reasons:


  • One side are the people that truly desire to be a Jedi because they feel that's the profession they belong to;


  • The other side are PvPers that see Jedi as just the next step in the evolution of their character's toon.


So my question is this: What happens when everyone becomes a Jedi? What happens when everyone that loves their profession so much finally gives up when they realize that they're not getting content, but it's being taken away from them? What happens when everyone that wants to participate in the GCW can't unless they have a Jedi? When will we see a 'regular'profession become totally extinct (as so many seem to be currently?)


If everyone finally becomes a Jedi, and then makes their alt the profession that's truly in their heart...aren't we back at square one? Wouldn't it have been better to have never had Jedi? Whatare the development team and LucasArts thinking by making changes to Jedi that allow them to level up easier? Where do they see the future of SWG, if this is their plan?


If the CU was a fix for the combat system because management didn't believe that SWG could have survived in that model....I'm terrified to see where they see it going now.



So SOE, LucasArts...I'm asking you:


Where do you plan on taking this game as a whole with the current production cycle of makingcertain professions"more fun" and "easier to play," while taking away professions like Entertainers'usefulness (because it isn't "fun" to heal BF, or it's not "exciting" togo into a cantina and sit down/talk to someone that's not AFK)? Where do you draw the line on making the game "fun" for certain professions, but removing other professions' content and happiness?


Sorry if I seem like I'm ranting, I've just been really thinking about this the last week or so, and the advent of Patch 20 kind of pushed me over the edge.

Message Edited by MISTagent01 on 07-06-2005 01:26 PM



V E E L A "her royal hawtness"
I am Jack's Smirking Revenge. I am Jack's Ignored Profession.
Theed was a bustling commerce city...people hawked their wares, danced, laughed, dueled, and had a rollicking good time. Cantinas packed with Entertainers of every race, shape and size...along with scoundrels, Stormtroopers, and drunks. People grouped up and stuck together in the wilderness, and you ALWAYS took a Scout or a Ranger with you. We lived our own Star Wars saga. We created our own personas, our own histories, and it all blended into this wonderful, magical experience that I will always remember...


That magic is gone now, but I'd pay 50 bucks a month to have it back.

Editor's Note: The author of the above post has quit giving SOE her money. She suggests you do the same, because this game will never be what you want it to be.


Kells
Wed Jul 06, 2005 1:17 pm
#2

I've been really down on this game lately. So much so, I think I might pack it in. I really can't see how this game can be saved. Star Wars Galaxies II might do it......



Bo' Tinsu
Ternque01
Wed Jul 06, 2005 1:26 pm
#3






Kells wrote:
I've been really down on this game lately. So much so, I think I might pack it in. I really can't see how this game can be saved. Star Wars Galaxies II might do it......





I wouldn't buy that game if it had Jedi in it.



Axob Freelight
The non-Jedi are extinct. Their fire has gone out of the universe.
maxtheusher
Wed Jul 06, 2005 1:30 pm
#4

/agree. Publish 20 is really coming off as the "We're making all your worst fears come to fruition" Publish.

A catchier title could be.

"Publish 20: Revenge of Some idiotic guy who's never played the game and has no idea how the game should be but still has ideas about it."

Stop marketing this game to people weaned on The Phantom goddam Menace, your core market is TRUE fans of Starwars. People familiar with the lore, NOT people looking to be Darth Vader or Luke Skywalker. Not people with a Jar Jar lunchbox.

/Cacophanyofmortalscreams.



大胆框
赏金猎人

动 性交 你 SOE
JWing
Wed Jul 06, 2005 1:33 pm
#5

we need to roll up into the publish 20 thread, and wreck havok in there.

This is terrible



SYBOOTH...A Zombie stole my PANTS !!
________________Jorras Thri v lvl 31 Imperial Medic

Virrago - (9/21/2006)
[Stating that the subpar smuggling system would be pushed to LIVE]
"...and to clarify.... It would require another publish (in other words not chapter 3)"
Smugglers History - Written by the DEV'sv Imperial Holo-ReportvMerchant ~ Talus -2310 36 -2164
cpz
Wed Jul 06, 2005 1:36 pm
#6






Ternque01 wrote:





Kells wrote:
I've been really down on this game lately. So much so, I think I might pack it in. I really can't see how this game can be saved. Star Wars Galaxies II might do it......





I wouldn't buy that game if it had Jedi in it.






Same here, and for me to say that shows what a poor state the game is in currently.


I wanted to be the guy who had a death penalty intwelve systems. I wanted to own the rival cantina in Mos Eisley, the guy who's bar was so poor he welcomed droids in and couldn't afford to have a No Blasters! policy.



Instead, I have a game shell I love but everything about itthat should have been vital iscriminally underdeveloped, and everything that should have been on the frignes is massively over stated. The Star Wars I worship doesn't have Jedi everywhere. It doesn't have herds ofKrayt Dragons gently mooching around waiting to be farmed for pearls. It doesn't have rancors wondering around ready for slaughter.


How much longer I'll persist with this is really dependant on one, just the slightest glimmer of HOPE. I have none at the moment, but a single design document or mission statement would go a long way.



oooooooooooooooooo
Colonel Narayan Darkfly (RIP)
Master Smuggler
Eclipse

The Awful Truth [now santized for family friendly fun]: One Two Three Four Five Six
JediArashi
Wed Jul 06, 2005 1:36 pm
#7

I had a similar thought Veela. I mean, they made jedi so easy to attain, and now Jedi Knight easy to attain....what is the next step. When a new player can grind to Jedi in 6 days, then to Knight in 10...where does that leave everyone else? At some point, you are right, everyone will have a jedi, but why? Only because that is the path laid out to us by LA.


I am all for allowing people to play a jedi if that is what they truly want to play, it is difficult to shut out a player base simply because they want them to be rare. I only play a couple of hours a week, if I wanted to play a jedi up until they ditched the hologrind I was pretty much SOL. Now, I can easily follow the path and become a jedi without any difficulty. I like that idea but not the implementation or the ramification.


The main problem is that they are too far down the road now. They can't turn back now, they would lose too much. They never should have done what they did, but now that it is done it will take a drastic change to make things right again. We all know how well those go over don't we?


One of the draws of this game when first announced and through beta was how they were handling jedi. They had always said even a casual player could discover the path if they were lucky. That gave me hope within a rarity system. Now it is an abundance system, and I don't have the heart to do it...I haven't since somewhere around Dec/Jan 2003/2004.


My solution (tongue firmly in cheek):


Star Wars Galaxies: Episode IV: The Jedi Purge


All the jedi get moved to their own server, either one big one, or a mirror of existing ones with an option to go to another during initial release. Then when a regular server player goes through the path to becoming a jedi, instead of unlocking a second slot on the same server, they unlock a slot on the jedi server for a chance to play there beginning as a FS.


Then institute a new, secret, unknown, intuitive way to unlock a jedi character on regular servers where it is so rare that there would only naturally be a dozen or so at a given time (maybe with perma-death).



Seriously though, I would like to know where SOE/LA think the endgame for this MMORPG lies? In Jedi? In the GCW? Dopes a disinterest in either of those automatically preclude the game isn't for you?





Arashi - The one and only "Agent Zero"

Proud member of the greatest community around....Smuggler for life!
GanymedePharuu
Wed Jul 06, 2005 1:37 pm
#8

the future looks bleak.

i thought i was dissappointed in the direction the game was going with publish 19...

but now publish 20? ugh...

i think i may seriously quit... it won't be easy.
if i do leave, can someone call me and let me know if they ever make Smuggling missions? only call me if they're actually fun and interesting. don't bother calling if they went to "Plan B".



cccccccccccccccccccc
Kohs V'sto
I wanted Smuggling for Christmas
but all i got was
<--- this stupid hat.

I am Jack's ignored profession.
Luke Skywalker is DEAD!
Ipseck
Wed Jul 06, 2005 1:47 pm
#9

maybe i'm missing something.. but what's so bad about publish 20?





7Ipsecki Tunnel8
eMaster Smuggler - "Deliverer of goods"e
N"Captain Moody"N
rexan
Wed Jul 06, 2005 1:51 pm
#10






MISTagent01 wrote:



If everyone finally becomes a Jedi, and then makes their alt the profession that's truly in their heart...aren't we back at square one? Wouldn't it have been better to have never had Jedi? Whatare the development team and LucasArts thinking by making changes to Jedi that allow them to level up easier? Where do they see the future of SWG, if this is their plan?

Message Edited by MISTagent01 on 07-06-2005 01:26 PM





You are correct, this is the logical conclusion to the current situation. Everyone will be able to play a Jedi.


So what are the problems with this? Everyone who has a Jedi also has a regular character to play as well.


There has to be a reason NOT to play a jedi in the game. Currently in the GCW, this seems to be accomplished by the Base Capping method. You need to have 5 non-jedi professions to destroya base.


The Jedi issue seems to be more a PvP problem than a PvE problem, unless im mistaken. (ie, if you don't want to go hunting with a Jedi, join a different hunting party)



In the future, some people are hoping that the new FRS system will help. Basically give Jedi large penalities in the FRS for doing damage to non-jedi characters. This would only work in PvP, and only if the jedi were concerned about FRS status. So the FRS has to be desirable, which again is more content for Jedi.


I've been of the mind that giving jedi a limited number of 'deaths' a day would be good (like 3). Once a jedi hit that magical 4th death, they would have to log off, and pull out their non-jedi character. Again, this would have a much better ballancing effect on PvP, but not be as determental to PvE jedi play.


Just some random thoughts.

Message Edited by rexan on 07-06-2005 01:52 PM



Rexan Ryu
Master Smuggler
Flurry Server
maxtheusher
Wed Jul 06, 2005 1:52 pm
#11

Thought I'd add. There are very few professions worth being right now, to me at least. Most of them are just, bleh. Some of them, are painful to even think about. Bh has their missions, but as they revolve around jedi, we have our long-promised smuggling... well not yet we don't, but it's promised... maybe. What is there left. Jedi?

It's funny. The general idea behind the moves seems to be to make the game more attractive to Luke/Vader wannabes. Well, okay whatever, I disagree with that, but I can't fight the marketing department. But everything they're doing isn't just making Jedi easier to obtain, and play, it's making Jedi the ONLY choice to be. EVERYONE eventually must turn to Jedi. Everything else is just a stepping stone. Just choose your method of XP grinding and go at it for like 6 months and then that's when the real game starts...



大胆框
赏金猎人

动 性交 你 SOE
Ragnaat
Wed Jul 06, 2005 1:54 pm
#12

i say just add perma double (i mean quadruple) FS xp and get the thing over with already



:: Retired... For the moment ::
-I support going slow and being careful.
focus thread (n.): there for us to focus on while they went behind our backs and did whatever they wanted to, anyway. (Source: AngusMacGregor)
maxtheusher
Wed Jul 06, 2005 1:58 pm
#13



Ragnaat wrote:
i say just add perma double (i mean quadruple) FS xp and get the thing over with already




HELL YEA! DO IT! Oh wait, NO! BAD FLAKY WOOKIEE BAD!



大胆框
赏金猎人

动 性交 你 SOE
Page 1 of 8
Previous Next