Pikeman Archive

Thread: Dot Discussion

Gunman21
Sat May 22, 2004 5:43 pm
#1


So I see that a lot of people are commenting on our DOTs.


What is your take on our DOTS? Are they too powerfull, or just overrated?

If you think they should be re-balanced, do you think should DOTs take a 75% pvp reduction, or be balanced in other forms? (please list suggestions)


Please list any other issues you have withPikeman weapon DOTs.


This is a discussion thread, so feel free to debate with each other should you feel the need.I do ask one consideration though....when commentingplease list the number of months you have been a pikeman (be honest!)


Thanks

Message Edited by Gunman21 on 05-22-2004 05:44 PM




Aidelon Kejaci
Legends Among Warriors

Former pikeman correspondent December 2003 - August 2005.

R.I.P. Pikeman!

JLG88
Sat May 22, 2004 6:24 pm
#2

Our DoTs are rendered USELESS against doctors.....they are currently our only way to win a fight.


I think ALL dots should have a 75% reduction, BUT balance out armor and our weapons/moves in the combat balance to make up for this huge loss.



ULTRA- !!!!!
AgekVahoba
Sat May 22, 2004 6:30 pm
#3


I agree that DOT's should have a reduction, but maybe not 75% on looted wepons. On CM DOT's, yes, but the diffuculty of getting your hands on a decent DOT for PvP use is practicaly negated by how easily doctors can cure them.


In general DOT's are overrated, and most looted pikes are undrpowered. Just about every PvP player can shrug off a 50 point health disease.


The profession deffinantly needs a bump up in PvP. If we incur a 75% DOT reduction, throw us a bone in another area, like defense mods......



(*Master Pike for 2 1/2 months)


Message Edited by AgekVahoba on 05-22-2004 09:32 PM



_____________________________
Head Altar Boy in charge of Burnination
We got
Tiggs's 1337 and teh "In Testers" didn't!

avallo
Sat May 22, 2004 6:42 pm
#4



DOTs need a 75% PvP reduction regardless if they are CM or looted DOTs. This is absolutely 100% needed in my mind. However, to make up for the loss of DOTs in a pikemen's arsenal we need something to make up for our short comings in PvP and PvE when compared to other professions.



I for one am sick and tired of some lucky FoTM'er looting a 500 strength mind fire lance, then going pikemen and killing everything in sight. Perhaps more aggrivating is when an armor smith with 7564 million credits decides to take up pikemen, and then systematically purchases every lance on the server and trade forums.




This system of loot/buy-----> become pikemen--------> become god needs to stop.



Oh and Pikemen since August



Message Edited by avallo on 05-22-2004 06:43 PM

Message Edited by avallo on 05-23-2004 07:08 AM

BackBite
Sat May 22, 2004 7:16 pm
#5

Weapon DoTs are both overrated and overpowered. They need to be brought under control via the much-anticipated 75% PvP reduction, which will hopefull take place during the mythical "combat balance".


Hopefully, at the same time, pikemen will see their class brought up to the level of other melee professions so that they can be competitive without the use of looted weapons or DoTs.


(Of course, call me sadistic if you will butit would tickle my funny bone to the extreme for all those non-pikemen who spent 50 million credits on their DoT lances to find them suddenly useless for the reasons they bought them - mainly as a shortcut to PvP dominance.)






-------------------------
*Disclaimer: Opinions expressed in this post do not reflect those of anyone of immediate importance.
Bisshop Case - Proud to be a Pikeman Since Beta & Raising the Bar for Masochists Everywhere
ACCOUNT CANCELLED AS OF 7/15/04 DUE TO THE NUMEROUS DELAYS OF THE COMBAT BALANCE AND OTHER CRITICAL FIXES AND CONSTANT DISSEMINATION OF MISINFORMATION FROM SOE'S OWN REPRESENTATIVES
Cakins7005
Sat May 22, 2004 11:11 pm
#6

Pikeman is a class that relies on looted weapons with good dots to be good in pvp. However,you must note that you do not need to be a Pikeman to use most of the good Pikes. Icould still usemind poisonnightsister lanceswhen I dropped Master Pikeman to just Master Brawler. Looted weapon dots in PvP are way overpowered. However, Pikeman needs these for now until it is brought in line with other combatclasses. People with polearms 4 can use the best lances and reap all of the benefits of them simply because they are certified so low. If the devs want to keep ultra poweful dot pikes in the game, then they should move the certification of these weapons to Master Pikeman.



Eti Vauspavim
Dark Jedi Templar
Imperial Pilot Ace
ScDarkKnight
Sat May 22, 2004 11:18 pm
#7

Dots are definitly overpowered ... but so are Armor and Buffs ...


When they will nerf dots, armor and buffs has to be nerfed as well ...


Dots solutions ... bah we all know them I think


75% PvP reduction

Fixed Food

Fixed Skills tapes

Food that HEALS Dots

Poison/Disease resist in skills trees

Poison/Disease resist layer in armor

Basic heal in Medic tree

Ranged/AoE heal in Doc/CM tree

Droids with Poison/Diseases healing

Factionnal Medic with Poison/Disease healing


Not all of them at onceof course lol ...


I think dots in our hand are less dangerous than CMs ... after all we're melee (no 96m range here), our weapons usually has low potency (usually) and we have an accuracy roll before the potency roll ... also few of us have some 800+/tick


But even a 250/tick poison is way overpowered in a fight with fully buffed/armored players ... also if it was only Health/Action it wouldn't be so bad .. but Mind ... *shrug*


Also I'd like to see the 3 incaps bugs fixed ... lot of people get decayed because they get 3 incapped by my fire stuff.. and I definitly don't want to see that happen .. I'm about to stop using my fire stuff because it's unfun to get people decayed


In short .... Nerfing Dots has to be done, yes, butwith some Pikeman's fixes and with buffs/armors nerf ...



-=~=-=~=-=~=-=~=-=~=-=~=-=~=-=~=-=~=-=~=-=~=-=~=-=~=-=~=-=~=-
Ex Fingolfin Bull's eye
Ex Second Generation Commander
Ex Sentinel

Account Ended August 8th 2005
antares_Kauri
Sun May 23, 2004 1:13 am
#8


Conflict: DoTs are really the only way Pikemen can compete in the current state of PvP, and DoTs are very helpful in taking out higher-end PvE creatures/NPCs (i.e. elders can be soloed by a pikeman with the rigt DoTs even without having any energy or blast weapons)


As much as I love my DoTs in PvP and PvE, I agree with the previous posters, they are causing trouble and are overpowered. I've said it before and I'll say it again: The DoTs on the looted polearms will come back to haunt us if something is not done. People getting Polearms IIjust to usea mind poison/fire DoT are a source of problems for the pikemen profession.


The flip-side has already been stated, we hate the DoTs, but we need them to compete at all in PvP the way things are now. Even with 900+ LVAs, I still have trouble killing people in armor without DoTs, it's almost never done. I don't want to be a mini-CM, but that's the only way I can win in PvP at the moment as a pikeman. I'd rather not have to rely on them, I'd rather they didn't attract the wrong crowd into the profession, I'd rather people weren't selling them for millions on every trade board. I'd rather they be reduced in effectiveness and the need for them to go away.


(Oh, pikeman since early July, so 10.75 months)


antares

master pikeman

Message Edited by antares_Kauri on 05-23-2004 01:13 AM



|Pikeman non-stop since July, 2003|
|combatUpgrade::alpha :: JTL::beta :: RotW::beta :: ToOW::beta|
SOE Producer Dallas Dickinson says:
"I mean, what is a pikeman and why is it something in the game?"
rantboy
Sun May 23, 2004 10:07 am
#9

DOT's i think need to be reduced not 75% but maybe 50%or lower (75% would KILL the CM profession). or maybe have an area heal forpoisen and disies.but gimping cminto crappyness i think is alittle messedup



---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DEADESA
RECON
Bounty Hunter
Ranger
Imp-117
Sun May 23, 2004 12:58 pm
#10

DoT's but they shouldnt have nerfed bleeds



Korsso Seena
Throwin it down since day one.
The Quadruple Threat
Master Pistoleer, Desperado, Rogue, Novice Commando
antares_Kauri
Sun May 23, 2004 9:50 pm
#11

I think this is an important discussion. I for one cringe when I read people calling pikemen "mini-CMs". That bodes no good at all, I have also already seen occasions where people pointed to the DoTs as a reason why the class needs no help or any fixes.


antares
master pikeman





|Pikeman non-stop since July, 2003|
|combatUpgrade::alpha :: JTL::beta :: RotW::beta :: ToOW::beta|
SOE Producer Dallas Dickinson says:
"I mean, what is a pikeman and why is it something in the game?"
ALLEYSPADE
Mon May 24, 2004 3:36 am
#12

I started this game as a holo grinder didn't care about pvp but on my thirteenth profession I got scaned yet again and was turned overt so I head to the coronet cantina to become covert well guess what three overts were there at that moment I happened to be working onCarbineer so I quickly burst run the other way out of coronetfiring as I go but luck was with me twofriendly rebs show up now it's a battle, eventually more imps hop in then more rebs, I had so much fun I gave up Holo Grindin for Pvp that day. I chose melee as what I wanted so I mastered every melee profession including Brawler inFive days at the end of it Pikeman stood out for me (a.)I love the moves other than fencer it has the most intricate manuvers(b.) Multiple attacks are the *EDIT* in pve and (c.) Being under estimated in pvp is my greatest advantage people always tell me pikemen suckright before I send em' to the cloner.


Anyway back to the topicif we have a 75% reduction inpvp with dots I belive we will forever remain at the bottom of the totem pole even with ALL the fixes inrevamp. Pvp is a who can kill who's mind first competition the only way we can even affect the mind consecutively is dots we are the only melee prof with this problem.


Fencers:Scatter hitthey are so fast that theydeplete your mind pool fairly quickly with it even completely mind buffed.


Sordsman:Headhit 3 obvious a good power hammer can tear u up.


TerasKasi:Most I fight alway's do headhit if your buffed after trying knockdown.


Most pvper's nowadays are stackers incrdibly hard to knockdown, posture change, or even dizziedpretty much all our moves made useless. If your fight'in someone constantly attack'in one unhealable stat while your hitt'in all over the place mostly body which a lvl 40 stim C can hit for over1000 your dead even with canape,music,dancer, and vasarianmy mind is still the only thing that ever kills meand it's not just me it's what pvp is about don't know if they are somehow changin this but no dots no win just the way it is and will be as a doc I can have 200 hit points heal once and be back to full health.I hate dot's as much as everyone else but it's all we have to be competitiveIMHO. THnx


ALLEYSPADE
Mon May 24, 2004 3:42 am
#13

Reread after I posted it sry for the typos Just woke up
Page 1 of 4
Previous Next