Musician Archive

Thread: Either the Buffbots go or our profession is doomed.

jodocow
Thu Apr 29, 2004 7:52 pm
#14







Sylune_heart wrote:

Some people are even advertising on the galaxies forums that they have a buff bot running at a location. I even read somewhere that some are even setting up camps now near POI's to get traffic to the bots. Its getting far to out of hand now. Even people that were die hard atk entertainers are now buying second accounts and having there entertainer account as a personal buff machine.


Now people buying second account just so they can have a buff whenever they feel like it wherever they feel like it. This alone causes problems, thats why orginally the devs decided to make it single character per server on a single account. To get rid of "Mules"



Either of these two above will work, which will the devs choose down the road? I dont know. I am hoping its number 2. But if it isnt i will still play an entertainer and still have fun doing it. Regardless



Ceta







Wow after reading all that I was shocked to see it came from you. I really hope you read this.



I'm pretty sure I'm the one your talking about with the advertising on the galaxy forums since I'm the only one I see. Also I'm pretty sure I'm the one your talking about when you mention setting up a camp to get more traffic.



Would it make you feel any better to know that I'm the same guy that jammed with you and sky in front of the coronet starport the other night just for fun because I actually enjoy being an entertainer.


Orhow about ifpeoplewere at the keyboard spamming to give buffs instead of being afk.


How about if I told you that my character isn't a mule and I only use him as a buffbot when I'm sleeping to make some extra cash since no one is at these places providing this service you seem to hold so dear. If you want to make this better really you should head out to these outposts and offer buffs and healing and provide a "service" to the people who want it out in these remote areas. Trust me the demand is there and maybe most people would want live interaction with their entertainers I know I like it better when people are around.



The point is for some of us it isn't just about having a mule account to recieve or give buffs. I actually enjoy providing this service and helping out where I can. Whether its doing a little afk buffbotting or busting out the horn to play a few notes while waiting for the shuttles.



To be perfectly honest I just got home after working 14 hours I'm kinda tired but I'm still going to log in so I can help the players on yavin if they need healing or buffing.



Message Edited by jodocow on 04-29-2004 07:55 PM

Message Edited by jodocow on 04-29-2004 07:57 PM

Warryyr
Fri Apr 30, 2004 12:03 am
#15

OK, fine. You're all right. It's the end of the profession, we're all doomed. Game over.


I'm just giving my perspective on my gameplay on Starsider server, which is about every night, all night,and I make a lot of money at NPC cantinas, even with buffbots around. Maybe I should have specified that, sorry that I didn't. I see so many people totally ignore AFK entertainers and walk straight up to me. I think the predominant reason people are using buffbot macrotainers for player cities is because foot traffic in player cities is rapidly decreasing. They're desperate for some business/visitors. Free buffs, well- it's easy with entertainers because there's no overhead. Might not be right to the profession, I admit.


I'd just rather not bring doom and gloom to the situation, and deal with it as best we can. Statements like "Either the buffbots go or it is the end of our profession as we know it." are not productive, and besides I'm sure there are fixes in the works as we speak. So, I really don't think it's the end of our profession as we know it - maybe we won't make insane amounts of cash in a night anymore, but the cash comes and goes.


My experience has been that it's not so big of a problem, not sure about your server or your particular experiences. My business income from buffing hasn't been affected whatsoever. And if it does, I guess I'll just find another way to make money, there's plenty of ways in this game.


I'd just rather see ideas of how we could remedy this, or work around the buffbots, than have a thread proclaiming the demise of our profession because of AFK people. I'll just exit this negative thread right now, as I don't feel any need to be flamed just because I'm enjoying my game experience and I'm still making lots of credits per night through being a non-AFK buffer.


sorry if i upset anyone.


Warryyr





Civil_CH
Fri Apr 30, 2004 12:13 am
#16


I don't mean to ruffle and feathers, however I can't count the number of times Ive been to a non-buffbot city and couldn't find a Master Dancer or Musician in order to get a buff. When I did finally find one, they wouldn't return any of my messages. I'm sorryto those of you who aretrying to earn a living and finding it difficult due to buffbots, howeverI for one am extremely thankful they are there.



Civil~ Intergalactic Man of Mystery ~

Warryyr
Fri Apr 30, 2004 12:48 am
#17

Thanks, Civil, for expressing your experiences in-game. This is what I'm talking about. Somedays I'll go to Coronet Cantina and see 3 buffbots, but still make a lot of money (many folks just mock the buffbots). However, if things are slow, I'll sometimes wander into a player city and find an empty cantina. Time for me to actually do some laundry, watch some tv, etc. I set up my operation, let a buffbot macro go, sometimes i'm right there at the keyboard (noting moochers who don't tip and adding them to "the list") and sometimes I'm not. Sometimes I advertise my vendors. Wandering people drop by, or see my messages, and I find that very handy.


But, I figure, if just one guy comes in all beat up and thinks "oh good! an entertainer, thank god!" and utilizes my services, they'll remember that the next time they see me online and not AFK. I have actually grown a decent business of customers through my occasional buffbot sessions. They /tell me "are you buffing?" and i say yeah, they show up and pay. A few have even apologized for not tipping me awhile back (if i call em on it) and make up for it. The usual reason is "i just forgot."


I understand this phenomenon frustrates people, I'd just like to hear what ideas people have to alleviate the potential threat of the buffbots.

jodocow
Fri Apr 30, 2004 3:45 am
#18

I'll agree that the need isn't huge and that I don't see as much of a need as I thought there would be. I'm not sure what the solution is though. But its time for work so I'll have to get back to you on the rest of my thoughts.
JohnMarble
Fri Apr 30, 2004 4:17 am
#19

The buffbots are awful, and it keeps getting worse. I travel to the deserted cantinas, too, and find buffbots set up. And the guys running the buffbots say, well, there's nobody there... but I would have been there. The buffbots cheapen the profession.


They'll never nerf macros, because you could just download an external macro program.


I agree with Sinjen. There needs to be a cost involved in giving a buff. You should have to actually find a resource and craft something which you would use to give out a buff. As it is now, there is no cost, and that's why there's a problem. Docs have buffbots, too, but they aren't set up in front of every startport or in every medical center because they would be losing money. So the doc buffbots are parked in their own private med centers where they charge you to enter, and this contains them.


I've posted this before, and usually everybody disagrees. Nobody likes the idea that they willn have to spend credits to do something they can do for free. But, if we had this cost, if we had to rely on a resource of some kind, our buffs could be of varying quality, making us unique. People tend to want to tip cheap because they know buffing costs us nothing. If we had overhead, we would be able to charge more. And it would remove the buffbots giving out our service for free. They'd all be in the cantinas with cover charges.


I wish everybody would realize the wisdom of having to spend credits to buff, it sounds like it would be bad for us at first, but it would be great for us because it would solve so many problems.
jodocow
Fri Apr 30, 2004 7:43 am
#20

I'd be willing to spend the money to get resources to do buffs. And I'd probably stil use my character as a buffbot when I'm not playing. I don't get stiffed that much to make a difference on it to be honest. The amount of money I make more then makes up for the 1-2 times i got stiffed so far this week(6 days made over 250k and only got stiffed once or tiwce.)


If you want me to do it in a private house so it doesnt take away from you doing it in the cantina thats perfectly understandable but I don't think it would help you out any if my house was closer to the places these people go.

Or if i set up a camp to do it instead.


Personally I think we should be able to use droids that allow us to buff in starports like doctors have.


But hey thats a different argument all together sinceit would probably stop me from buffbotting since I could make money quicker while at the keyboard and then just continue on my way instead of buffing while I sleep.



NewJedi
Fri Apr 30, 2004 8:26 am
#21

I really wish SWG didn't have looping macros at all. Surely AFK combat is the last straw. Has that been fixed yet?A couple months ago,I knew of people who hadcharacters logged on for days at a time, auto-targeting and auto-killing mobs.


Sure, it can be hard to find a live entertainer -- but part of the reason for that is the AFK plague in the first place. Were there no AFK'ers, being a Musician would be more valued and prized, and there would be more of us around. Were there no AFK'ers, I'd be more interested in hanging out in Coronet cantina again. As it is now, I prefer to hang in my player city cantina.
jodocow
Fri Apr 30, 2004 9:00 am
#22

I think its unending cycle. If there were no afk entertainers and all of the entertainers went back to coronet and other major starports then players in the outskirts wouldn't have a way to get healed or buffed.


In an ideal world there would entertainers in all cantina's but its going to take alot more then removing afk entertaining to get that to happen.



I'm still not convinced that removing holo grinding and afk entertaining is the solution to all the problems you guys have.


Mariki
Fri Apr 30, 2004 9:09 am
#23

Being an officer of an entertainers PA I have watched as our membership has declined. Everyone who is a serious entertainer is leaving the field in droves as anyone with any self respect is not going to compete with a spamming bot doing our job. Sure I could create a bot and let it run when I'm not on but thats just going to drive off even more people for my own personal gain. For the people who are not into the unfullfilling combat in this game, they have been leaving the game entirely. The state of our profession is grim. In the course of just a month and a half our membership has gone to over 90 percent inactive and finding dedicated new members has become near impossible as our ranks go afk.
This is going to become a pure AFK profession the ways its going as they are driving away live entertainers who entered this field for the social and RP aspects. That's when one has to question if its worth playing at all. What fun is it playing an AFKer... I was going to be leaving myself on the first but was convinced to give it another month... But I'm not optimistic anything is going to change in a month... I think things will decline even more because I have a feeling nothing will be done and everything I play this game for will degrade even more. Perhaps I will see the dismantling ofour PA... I see that coming soon.



Mariki Lee, Ex Rifleman
Last day Dec 2nd
Death by NGE
- All Hope Gone
KelnMacil
Fri Apr 30, 2004 1:47 pm
#24

I'm a master musician, and I like doing buffs when I can. But that isn't the only aspect of the game for me, I am also into combat. The toughest thing for me is getting a mind buff myself. When I go into a Cantina, I start asking other musicans if they will buff me and for how much. If they don't answer I move onto the next one. I don't even consider one that is afk so personally, I havent noticed any of these "buff bots". Honestly if I saw a buff bot and, as usual, there weren't any master musicians buffing, I'd use one. Simply put, a mind buff helps me train with my sword more easily, instead of popping muons to quickly recover mind, only to hit a muon downer at the worst possible moment. So for right now, buff bots are fine by me. Until more musicians start actually buffing more often like the docs do, I'll not say a word against a buff bot. I buff every chance I get, sometimes I just setup in whatever town I'm in and start shouting for people to come get in a group and I will buff them all. I don't charge a dime for buffs either. If you are trying to make a living off of this profession, good luck. I just set down harvesters and sell resources. I've been playing close to 2 months now and I've made over 2mil creds in that time by selling resources...and I'm not even a real dedicated miner.



[Ì[[[[≡≡≡≡≡[F]]]°ggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg)


The Darkside of the Force is neither Evil nor Good, it is simply an aspect of the Force, just as the Light side is neither Good nor Evil. The Darkside is an offensive and powerful side of the Force, where the Light is defensive and mundane. One is reached through emotion, the other through the absence of emotion. Hatred, Love, and Passion are the most powerful of emotions. Embrace them and you will be able to draw upon the true power of the Force.

....

TavBarlous
Fri Apr 30, 2004 4:34 pm
#25


Hrmmm...I'd have to say I disagree with the notion that buffbots and AFKMacro-tainers are the end of the profession...

I've mastered Musician 3 times with three different characters because of a draw to the profession. However, the last time I mastered Musician it was for a more selfish reason...You see, I have this Master TK who likes to go out and get into more trouble than he can handle...by doing so, he gets more XP, he becomes a stronger character, I have more fun, I have the opportunity to get more rare loot(which is a thrill to me, even if it's just a sunguard in a really nice color )...My problem was, there was never a Master Musician around to give me buffs when i needed them, and Brandy doesn't seem to suffice...Your suggestion that we not really on buffs is an assault on your profession, because it's one of the things that keeps us TKMs coming into the cantina...As a TK, i can go out for hours and only collect a handful of BF, so there's never much reason to stop in to the cantina...

If everyone relied on Brandy and Muon and other such enhancements, but ceased to rely on music/dance buffs, there'd be nothing to draw us non-ents to the cantina for interaction with horses of a different color

As for the AFK Macro-Tainers...well, they're merely an /addignore away, and most every player knows about this feature, and utilizes it...then, they merely become colorful backgrounds...If you're concerned that it slows your framerates down too much, then work harder for a better computer...

The Big, Bad point to all of this is that you really shouldn't complain about the way other people choose to play a "game"...It's an on-line community, and implicit in the meaning of the word community is a necessity to satisfy as large a group as possible, without neglecting anyone in the process...If it bothers you so much that these "non-ent"-types are invading your cantina territory(amd that's what your argument boils down to), then you may need to find another game to play, maybe one that isn't on-line, maybe one that isn't multiplayer...

I pay 30 dollars a month to play a game on-line with friends, and I'll be damned if i'm not going to make a character that I want to make for whatever reason i want to make it...If i want a buffbot for when you're off crying behind your boyfriend's harvester about the unfairness of the galaxy, then I'm going to have me a buffbot...

If you have legitimate problems with the game(your character is consistently buggy, the game crashes on you even though you have a pentium 8 56.4 gig terminator machine of the future, or you simply tire of the limited selection of tunes available to your musician), then complain about those...If you have issues with people playing as they wish...well...I'm afraid you may be disappointed when they continue to do what they want, regardless of your wishes...

/addignore me for having a buffbot ,

Sarki'sra, MasterMusican/MasterDancer/MasterEnt

Mastered Artisan, Mastered Weaponsmith(yes, I contributed to my community...i don't just sit and b*^ch)/

Phi Sigma'Pi, TKM/Master ID,

mastered medic, mastered marksman, mastered CH, mastered Doc

~P.S.~ Not a hologrinder
Tralmek
Fri Apr 30, 2004 10:59 pm
#26






TavBarlous wrote:

Hrmmm...I'd have to say I disagree with the notion that buffbots and AFKMacro-tainers are the end of the profession...

I've mastered Musician 3 times with three different characters because of a draw to the profession. However, the last time I mastered Musician it was for a more selfish reason...You see, I have this Master TK who likes to go out and get into more trouble than he can handle...by doing so, he gets more XP, he becomes a stronger character, I have more fun, I have the opportunity to get more rare loot(which is a thrill to me, even if it's just a sunguard in a really nice color )...My problem was, there was never a Master Musician around to give me buffs when i needed them, and Brandy doesn't seem to suffice...Your suggestion that we not really on buffs is an assault on your profession, because it's one of the things that keeps us TKMs coming into the cantina...As a TK, i can go out for hours and only collect a handful of BF, so there's never much reason to stop in to the cantina...

If everyone relied on Brandy and Muon and other such enhancements, but ceased to rely on music/dance buffs, there'd be nothing to draw us non-ents to the cantina for interaction with horses of a different color

As for the AFK Macro-Tainers...well, they're merely an /addignore away, and most every player knows about this feature, and utilizes it...then, they merely become colorful backgrounds...If you're concerned that it slows your framerates down too much, then work harder for a better computer...

The Big, Bad point to all of this is that you really shouldn't complain about the way other people choose to play a "game"...It's an on-line community, and implicit in the meaning of the word community is a necessity to satisfy as large a group as possible, without neglecting anyone in the process...If it bothers you so much that these "non-ent"-types are invading your cantina territory(amd that's what your argument boils down to), then you may need to find another game to play, maybe one that isn't on-line, maybe one that isn't multiplayer...

I pay 30 dollars a month to play a game on-line with friends, and I'll be damned if i'm not going to make a character that I want to make for whatever reason i want to make it...If i want a buffbot for when you're off crying behind your boyfriend's harvester about the unfairness of the galaxy, then I'm going to have me a buffbot...

If you have legitimate problems with the game(your character is consistently buggy, the game crashes on you even though you have a pentium 8 56.4 gig terminator machine of the future, or you simply tire of the limited selection of tunes available to your musician), then complain about those...If you have issues with people playing as they wish...well...I'm afraid you may be disappointed when they continue to do what they want, regardless of your wishes...

/addignore me for having a buffbot ,

Sarki'sra, MasterMusican/MasterDancer/MasterEnt

Mastered Artisan, Mastered Weaponsmith(yes, I contributed to my community...i don't just sit and b*^ch)/

Phi Sigma'Pi, TKM/Master ID,

mastered medic, mastered marksman, mastered CH, mastered Doc

~P.S.~ Not a hologrinder







I'm disturbed by a couple of your assumptions here...


You stated one of our main points almost exactly and then veered off from it. you said "It's an on-line community, and implicit in the meaning of the word community is a necessity to satisfy as large a group as possible, without neglecting anyone in the process" and "If you have issues with people playing as they wish...well...I'm afraid you may be disappointed when they continue to do what they want, regardless of your wishes..." As some of my entertainer collegues have noted, the point is AFKers don't contribute to the community. They are not people and they are not playing...they are computers driven by endlessly looping mindless emotionless macros.


Second, you made it sound as though all entertainers are female or otherwise attracted to males...again, this is not true. Many of the great entertainers are male. (don't believe me, check out the 2004 Men of Galaxies calender) The entertainment community is highly diverse and we welcome anyone who has a desire to help people to join us in it.


Finally, you seem to think that people with low-end computers are the only ones affected by lag...again, this is untrue. I experience server latencyoften and my computer is a Pentium 4 with dual 3.06 gig processors, 2 gigs of RAM, 256 MB video card, 240 Gigs of harddrive space over 2 disks with lots of space left over on both.I'm on aT1 connection. I guarentee nothing's wrong on my end, but I still lag sometimes especially when I enter the macrotinas in Coronet and Theed.


BTW,you gave us permission to /addignore you, but I don't see a server mentioned anywhere in your post... jk, I wouldn't ignore you unless I came across you in-game and you were abusive in some way which I assume you wouldn't be.





Feeling no connection with the Force since 2003
*feels an outer glow*. The HAWT side is with me
Have a question? Read the Stickies!
Remember: Only YOU can prevent forum fires
!
Official AFKophobe


Page 2 of 3