Jump To Lightspeed Archive

Thread: Why do people continue to bring up Coruscant?

3D4D
Mon Jun 07, 2004 8:59 pm
#1

Every thread I look in seems to have at least one person who thinks it would be a good Idea to have Coruscant as a new planet. The Devs have said that Coruscant is impossible to do, due to lag / system limits.


Can we please stop with all the suggestions for Coruscant?


I know some people might flame me for being a realistic pessimist, but I needed to let my thoughts out.


To be honest I would love to see Coruscant in game as a habitable planet just as much as the rest of you, but I have to remain a realist. Perhaps in the future (we are talking beyond Galaxies, Possibly Galaxies 2) with better computer hardware Coruscant might be possible.


The only other possible way to have Coruscant in game would be to make it different than any other existing planet. Perhaps it could be an offline planet where lag would only depend on the computer you are running.



/meditate

Bria- Master Medic / Master Brawler / TKM ~(Hero of Tatooine)~

Scylla- Carbineer / TK ~(Hero of Tatooine)~

Tempest- Master Doctor / TKM
Numslap
Mon Jun 07, 2004 9:02 pm
#2

yeah i agree. when you think about it at first, it sounds fun. but what would you do?! there's no wildlife, so no hunting would be available, and cities like coronet are already uninhabited.[except for the spaceports, of course] it would be a waste of time.



Numcap Lock

TH, one month from now:
"We have decided to permanently cancel the GCW revamp and the Combat Balance in order to provide time for the 'comfortable chair' revamp. We are sorry for any inconvenience this may have caused"
LordVader27
Mon Jun 07, 2004 9:04 pm
#3

There'd be plenty of NPCs to gun down on Coruscant. Commandos could shoot rocket launchers into traffic for a bot of fun. C'mon guys, think a little, the possibilities are endless!



My Bounty Hunter System Proposal. Along with what other people think would be good expansions and such.
An Idea to Make Smuggler More Smugglerly
Hape Atwo--Rebel Corporal
Building a droid army one droid at a time.
Chancellor, you're under arrest. --Mace Windu to Palpatine, Ep. III
Malitevv
Mon Jun 07, 2004 9:05 pm
#4






3D4D wrote:

The Devs have said that Coruscant is impossible to do, due to lag / system limits.







Actually, that is false. Read the three dev interviews that are currently linked at the top of the SWG page. In one of them the developer is asked if we will ever have coruscant and the answer he gives is that it is currently on their top 10 list of things they would like to do.


I don't know where this notion that the devsbelieve it is impossible came from. It is clearly not true based upon the most recent developer interviews.


Read them yourself.



---------------------------------------------------------------------
In a minute there is time
For decisions and revisions which a minute will reverse.

T.S. Eliot
LordVader27
Mon Jun 07, 2004 9:08 pm
#5

This is really out of place I know. Flame me whatever. But um. How do you quote other people's posts?



My Bounty Hunter System Proposal. Along with what other people think would be good expansions and such.
An Idea to Make Smuggler More Smugglerly
Hape Atwo--Rebel Corporal
Building a droid army one droid at a time.
Chancellor, you're under arrest. --Mace Windu to Palpatine, Ep. III
Jordan_Karr
Mon Jun 07, 2004 9:12 pm
#6


Because its a Dead Horse Issue... as stated by the DEVs that Coruscant is impossable with todays technology...But no one cares to even stop and think anymore before they post another post of extra planets/Coruscant thread... (excluding this present thread)


DHI's are running ramped in this forum...


Lets see what post are to the DHI level!


1) TIEs with Hyperdrives
2) TIEs with Shields
3) TIEs with a Graphic Error on the back of the ship
4) Capital Ships
5) New Planets
6) New Species for JTL
7) Faction in JTL
8) PVP in JTL
9) Ships of JTL
10) Factional Ship Customization <EDIT>


Humm I may be forgeting some.. but I think that covers the top10 post that I have seen most of in the last few weeks...


All I am going to say right now is that we need a JTL Dev, Not a normal SWG Dev to take a day out of their busy production scheduel and compile a JTL update thread and give us some new topics to make into DHI topics...


Message Edited by Jordan_Karr on 06-07-2004 09:20 PM



Character Name: Chalvooka WOOKIEE FROM DAY ONE!! still a wookiee even after a small break from SWG!!! A Wookiee from before wookiee armors and ROTW or RTOS!!!!
Raptor2k1
Mon Jun 07, 2004 9:14 pm
#7

Actually, Coruscant would be easy to add in the SE...



The catch being that you can't land on anything other than the Golan Platforms orbitting the planet. It could easily be done as a large, central space sector full of trading ships, Imperial capital ships, platforms, etc.





Kyeran Halkyon

Master Gunfighter and Demolitionist of the Old Republic Navy
SWG Commando Forum


Malitevv
Mon Jun 07, 2004 9:20 pm
#8






Jordan_Karr wrote:

Because its a Dead Horse Issue... as stated by the DEVs that Coruscant is impossable with todays technology...But no one cares to even stop and think anymore before they post another post of extra planets/Coruscant thread...





sorry. i have to laugh at this. show me a link where the devs say it is impossible? the developers interviews that are currently linked on the main SWG page right now have a developer interview in which the developer states coruscant is on their top 10 list of things they would like to do.


you say no one cares to think, yet have clearly failed to do any reading yourself before accusing the rest of the community of not thinking.


/sigh



---------------------------------------------------------------------
In a minute there is time
For decisions and revisions which a minute will reverse.

T.S. Eliot
Jordan_Karr
Mon Jun 07, 2004 9:21 pm
#9

already working on it..


will post it when I find it...





Character Name: Chalvooka WOOKIEE FROM DAY ONE!! still a wookiee even after a small break from SWG!!! A Wookiee from before wookiee armors and ROTW or RTOS!!!!
3D4D
Mon Jun 07, 2004 9:21 pm
#10

God I wish I could dig up and quote the Dev that stated that we would not see Coruscant. I know what I read though.

Only way I can think of that the devs could add Coruscant would be to make it like 1/6th the size of a normal planet to reduce lag.



/meditate

Bria- Master Medic / Master Brawler / TKM ~(Hero of Tatooine)~

Scylla- Carbineer / TK ~(Hero of Tatooine)~

Tempest- Master Doctor / TKM
Malitevv
Mon Jun 07, 2004 9:25 pm
#11


well do look here:


http://swvault.ign.com/articles/521/521478p1.html


I'll quote it for you:






Question: Will Coruscant be put into the game?
Haden said that they all want it very much. It's on the list, just as is Hoth and Bespin. However right now development time is very well allocated and the bandwidth required to create this content is just not available. But we can count on the fact that these locations are on the top 10 wish list and will get done over time.




I know we can't put too much store in this, but if you read the reply there, the final answer to the question of Coruscant is this: "[it] will get done over time."




[edited for typos]

Message Edited by Malitevv on 06-07-2004 09:26 PM



---------------------------------------------------------------------
In a minute there is time
For decisions and revisions which a minute will reverse.

T.S. Eliot
LordVader27
Mon Jun 07, 2004 9:25 pm
#12

Is there a post where one could find where the Dev said the Top 10 list for what they want to do. There are 10 things I want in Galaxies other than JTL, I want to see if they get a 100%, They better LOL JK



My Bounty Hunter System Proposal. Along with what other people think would be good expansions and such.
An Idea to Make Smuggler More Smugglerly
Hape Atwo--Rebel Corporal
Building a droid army one droid at a time.
Chancellor, you're under arrest. --Mace Windu to Palpatine, Ep. III
AraDanBynobi
Mon Jun 07, 2004 9:53 pm
#13

You knowwhat; I would prefer the Devs tomake the current so-calledcities more lively before making yet another city where there is just pavement and tall unused buildings. Coronet is the perfect example of a whole lot of nothing spread out over 50 or so buildings. And as has been mentioned umpteen times by everyone else, Coronet Starport and the area surrounding out to about500m is the only heavily populated area in the whole game. Currently its the Doc buffing line ups and ad-spammers. Surely the devs could just say... "btw docs, we are makingyour buffs 50% better if you did this in the right place ie MEDICAL CENTRES!!!!!." But then perhaps the ever distant Combat Rebalance would fix this anyway.

We seriously need some rethought on how to spread people out in theNPC cities. I did hear somewhere a while back that there was a possiblilty of making buildings with floors and apartments, but that was probably a flash in the pan dev response. But then we don't even have reason to go into an NPC city at all do we?? What COULD they do in there that would make people have some adventure there.

The test bed for Coruscant would be Bespin and Kashyyyk, Bespin because it is a floating city with as much built up on the exteria as there would be inside a square block of Coruscant. Kashyyyk would be the test bed for having regions with really tall objects (roshirr trees??) both up close- lived on, and out in the distance that is unapproachable and wild. Its weird how you actually have more oppurtunity for road blocks and 'natural' barriers in a big industrialised city then you would in a open desert planet, yet we don't have an enclosed city map. And thats because there ain't much to do ina city (in SWG terms anyway). so we are back to my original gripe, why build a really huge city map where no one goes and only the Starport is useful??
Page 1 of 5
Previous Next