Jedi Archive

Thread: Which sabre is better?

Boscuia
Mon Sep 05, 2005 8:12 pm
#1
LS. A

2.25 Attack Speed
1.3 Modified A.S
591-687 Damage
206 Elemental Heat Damage
44.7% Wound
376.00 Estim. DPS
651.00 Mod. DPS
100 SAC
11 FC


LS.B

2.43 Attack Speed
1.4 Modified A.S
584-681 Damage
206 Elemental Heat Damage
47.45% Wound
343.00 Estim. DPS
595 Mod. DPS
95 SAC
10 FC



Lightsabre A is pre CU Lightsabre B is Post CU.



Mistress of Darkness
YBoscuia Loves ChebalisY
@r~~~Jedi Padawan 02/11/05 Radiant~~~r@
1763 PVP rating Pre-NGE
DeathKnightSoth
Mon Sep 05, 2005 8:15 pm
#2
A. would be my choice...



Death Knight Soth

Jedi

Master of his own destiny

The true death knight...

KevheJefra
Mon Sep 05, 2005 8:16 pm
#3
A



Kevhe Jefra
Jedi Knight
Defender of Innocents
Upholder of Freedom


(gn[[KEVHE[nnnWX9ggggggggggggggggggggg)


--Rodian Pioneer --




-I VOTED FOR KING KEVHE!
Ogathma
Mon Sep 05, 2005 8:17 pm
#4
Lightsaber A. I have used sabers with up to 114 SAC and havent had much an issue with action, so personally, the extra damage is worth it. I did a lot of playing around, and I have decided that for me, SAC of 100, and whatever is left into damage is how I craft them.



Ogathma
Orderof the Screaming Squill
Gondon
Mon Sep 05, 2005 8:17 pm
#5
a. There is not much of a difference between 11 and 10 fc. Same with the 5 pts of sac. Both sabers still woop mine lol.



Ubio Burnet
Jedi Padawan

DeathKnightSoth
Mon Sep 05, 2005 8:20 pm
#6
Looks pretty close though...Juz wondering if it really matters on stats that close in comparison?...Prob. not



Death Knight Soth

Jedi

Master of his own destiny

The true death knight...

Ogathma
Mon Sep 05, 2005 8:22 pm
#7




DeathKnightSoth wrote:
Looks pretty close though...Juz wondering if it really matters on stats that close in comparison?...Prob. not



The damage matters. Otherwise, not really.



Ogathma
Orderof the Screaming Squill
Bib-Fortuna
Mon Sep 05, 2005 8:22 pm
#8

Boscuia wrote:
LS. A

2.25 Attack Speed
1.3 Modified A.S
591-687 Damage
206 Elemental Heat Damage
44.7% Wound
376.00 Estim. DPS
651.00 Mod. DPS
100 SAC
11 FC


LS.B

2.43 Attack Speed
1.4 Modified A.S
584-681 Damage
206 Elemental Heat Damage
47.45% Wound
343.00 Estim. DPS
595 Mod. DPS
95 SAC
10 FC



Lightsabre A is pre CU Lightsabre B is Post CU.



B.
Although small that SAC and force cost could save you. Sometimes the difference between winning and losing is a single heal, you wanna risk losing just to have a tiny +6 damage?

Sandsifter
Mon Sep 05, 2005 8:29 pm
#9

Peeps always seem to flock to more damage but they would be wrong. Its simply not worth 6 extra damage points to risk running out of force or action.


And I had the same situation, oddly my sabers were nearly identical to yours. The lower action saber did make a difference in a long fight a few times.


Gondon
Mon Sep 05, 2005 8:34 pm
#10
its not the damage that people favor saber A. over B. here. Its the speed. There is a marked advantage to being able to hit faster. Itsthe ability to do more damage, over a short period of time, than your opponent can heal. If you can do this, than fc is not a problem.

Message Edited by Gondon on 09-05-2005 10:35 PM



Ubio Burnet
Jedi Padawan

Ryoma_Sakamoto
Mon Sep 05, 2005 8:34 pm
#11
a 



urakMDkankrriDDteDDMDuiraxeaDaaaMrnekauciMktcakakk [Mugatu - Elder Jedi - Radiant - Dark]
nietckkurerkaakaxarritMikakutiurricnDknkDixDDDkixt
ikuaekkMrntkaxkxcxDuxiinkiaxiuakaiecnuutMektektDae [Replochre - Officer - Radiant - Dark]
iinckkaniDDaDrcrkakixuiariDiuktcaxuakkixiDMarkktxM
DDauiaaixaMaiiMkDicekxkkaaiDurDiteDraratakDictkcua <Dark's Token Mexican>
iMriMarrrieictkxuktxuDaknkukMMkaicirDtuukekattkuer
krkrkceccDkeciextnaekkiMcixDuirktxkikekkaxrixikMkr ~Ryuzo's Mexican Diktakur~
naxecaxMkukiikencrittrukeMtitDnMkcrrMxDeDcciaknrar
tDtxaiunMaeuiauirxiutikiiDDaxauDckikDnctkekrkuacek
nekrkikMiiDakkaiDckiknrtiiankkkrikititkiiareiiikxu
kckkruaaDekktuDkDiiMniacrcarMiecxianixxeMaitkriiik

Elven_Prowler
Mon Sep 05, 2005 8:37 pm
#12
WHOA! I'd definately go with B. 1 FC not much?! Not if you are just grinding. But if you're going uber, and by the looks of these two, I'd say you are, 10 to 11 is 10% more FC. That'll mean when you go up against someone with a FC 10 you will run out of force 10% faster figure a good fight is 2 minutes... 12 seconds.Just my thought though. The damage and speed seem to be proportionally minimal. With good food I never run out of action in single target fighting. I only run out of action when I try to alternate Spin and Dervish.
Bib-Fortuna
Mon Sep 05, 2005 8:54 pm
#13

Gondon wrote:
its not the damage that people favor saber A. over B. here. Its the speed. There is a marked advantage to being able to hit faster. Its the ability to do more damage, over a short period of time, than your opponent can heal. If you can do this, than fc is not a problem.

Message Edited by Gondon on 09-05-2005 10:35 PM




Yeah, so you'll have higher force costs AND use it faster.
If your opponent is one of those extremely rare people that can heal then it doesn't matter if you attack a bit faster, they'll just wait for you to run out of force.

Page 1 of 2
Previous Next