Jedi Archive

I tried to post some of my concerns (above), then went back to see other reponses.

Baciacca - I hope you can read past all the garbage people put on here. Some of them need to be banned from these forums as they serve absolutely no purpose whatsoever and obviously shouldn't be posting at all.

People don't have to agree with an opinion, but keep the absolute garbage and HUGE font use out of here...Please!

---

dachiw wrote:

---

DarthINSANUS wrote:

AI (Avoid Incap) Is too easily counterd in pvp.

In J v J fighting :

Stasis lasting 45 seconds, and AI lasting 30, basically guarantees that if it is applied to an AI defender, that he has NO chance of ever recuperating from that.

Now take away Jedi duels, go to large scale pvp, and NOT ONLY stasis has this ability, also the Concussion shot from Smuggler, and Paralyze from CM.

These are great and tactical moves in and of itself, but with so many combat charcters having these skills, AI really has become useless in the pvp arena.

IMO Either AI should be immune to these "paralyze type moves" (It already has a snare)

OR AI needs changed totally.(So many people have complained of this move being to strong since its introduction)

Perhaps, AI should receive the 90 % damage reduce that FR2/3 get. This way a defender can tank for a moment without dying, but without the ability to kill anyone either..

The move is still usfull for pve encounters, but I dont think that should be a master skills only usefullness.

NO other skill in the game has such strong counters,rendering this a useless skill on the battlefield (pvp)..

---

oh sure, nerf us more. we cant force run away or stay and maybe damage someone enough to win?

---

As it is now, its useless in pvp, and if your using it in pve, then you better have someone help damage for you anyways..

I am just trying to make SOME suggestion, to get this skill back to a USEABLE state, or change/remove it totally, and put something there thats usefull, that wont be inballancing.

Oh and Bac, I hate to say it, but is there any chance of gettign this thread clened a little ?

Seems the trolls got up a bit early today

also> one thing that should be looked at is some level of resist against armor break for innate armor (and force armor) so that we don't completely fall behind crafted armors.

at master defender, i would consider matching the best sliceable armor - 75% against armor break.

same thing at masterenhancer - 75% against break.

at x4xx enhancer, maybe 50%against break(the dabble shouldn't be as powerful as the master, imo).

---

TorqueMonster wrote:

PVP: Area dominate mind, that causes all within a specific range to automatically have their targeting reticule switched to the master defender using it, even if they are attacking another Jedi. For example: Jedi A & B are attacking C. Jedi D shows up, Area Dominates A & B, in that instance, they instantly target Jedi D. Yes, even if they were attacking they might not even notice they switched targets if they were within melee range of Jedi D. They can immediately switch back to attacking Jedi C, but is he already gone? Did he force run away? Did he cloak?

---

---

Jeisyn wrote:

also> one thing that should be looked at is some level of resist against armor break for innate armor (and force armor) so that we don't completely fall behind crafted armors.

at master defender, i would consider matching the best sliceable armor - 75% against armor break.

same thing at masterenhancer - 75% against break.

at x4xx enhancer, maybe 50%against break(the dabble shouldn't be as powerful as the master, imo).

just some ideas -

---

---

lajduke wrote:
Personally I think its workin' fine.

---

---

floggerSG wrote:
Defender is great as is

---

---

jedimasterluck wrote:

its fine....

---

*Chokes and dies*

---

mindspat wrote:

Defender is the only workin discipline associated with Jedi.

---

*peeks up*

---

mauvros wrote:

The defender tree is working perfectly. It benefits people to Master the tree and also has some great reasons to dabble in it.

---

*rolls eyes, chokes and dies again*

Okay, on a slightly more serious note. DURNI are taking over the galaxy!

Now on a much more serious note.

First of all fix the state defense line making it resist useful states like CM debuffs or change the entire line all together and make it a LS Support line that goes with Valor as its peak ability. Who cares what it becomes, anything better than a usless line...!

Also I agree with SITHDUKE. Armour break resists unquestionably NEED to be looked at for MDefs as pretty soon it'll become as pointless to master as Force Healer currently is.

I got the impression that Avoid Incaps intention was to give the player a second to catch their breath, being un-incappable so they can do something to turn their situation around to turn the tide of battle or get the heck out of it all together.

Well, all it does is turn the player into a pinata, once AI is on whack 'em silly until all the juicy goodness from within falls out. What's the point? 0_o If they're getting beat on so much they need ot use it then a while of Pinataness wont help them do much. Now you can just say "Well don't use it then" but allow me to retort. It's a master box ability Why in the name of Zeus' bugole should it be usless when it really matters. (PVP)

Message Edited by LinkyTriforce on 07-29-2005 04:33 PM

---

jedimasterluck wrote:

its fine....

hummm dont know if ppl like this, but maybe put force aura like force run..... on / off

---

I like the toggling Aura idea.

---

Zorrion wrote:
Stasis shouldn't cause 300-400 dmg when applied. It should be 1 point just like every other mez.

---