Jedi Archive

Thread: Mdef or MLS?

TaloKarrde
Tue Sep 20, 2005 6:40 pm
#1

Mdef
0404 Lightsaber
4000 Healing
3004 Enhancer

OR

MLS
0040 Defense
4000 Healing
3404 Enhancer



_______________________
Talo Karrde - Elder Jedi
Ronen Karrde - Elder Bounty Hunter Extraordinaire
Still missing pre-cu (and now CU as well)...

SWG Starter Kit

Click here to support the Dream Patch!

In response to the NGE, I shall quote Darth Vader: "NNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!"
Skwall
Tue Sep 20, 2005 6:57 pm
#2

Depends,


#2 is a pretty well rounded FOTMish template and has little downside. I'd drop to 3402 in Enhancer and put those 2 boxes into 2040 Defender for the added innate armor because Force Meditate sucks.


When I say depends, I'm saying that it relies on one important factor. Do you have a Decent saber? A lot of jedi out there a pretty oblivious to the fact that they are wasting Sps on MLS. The CU introduced diminishing returns and SEAs, basically the better/faster your saber is, the less you will benefit from Speed that MLS grants. Accuracy is good, but can easily be remedided by foods, and SEAs.


There is also the modified saber speed bug which isn't applying to specials, so regardless of what your modified saber speed says, you're only hitting as fast as the base speed of your saber (I believe that's what the bug is) which is why Force Speed is pretty useful atm. Saber Dervish isn't too useful other than to alternate area attacks for grinding (or PVP if you have like 10+ jedi spamming it). The real loss at MLS is saberthrow 3 which does great damage, and the ranged KD. Other than that, you just recieve speed and accuracy mods and experimentation points that are pointless once you have already crafted a saber.


Master Defender is great for PVE and PVP, Master Enhancer is great for PVP, but hurts in PVE due to the consumption of force, but as a fun factor it should be a good/strong template.



011010001010000010011001
000100111111110101000110
110011010010001111101010
010011100100111111010111
:Skwall|Blight:
Crimson
Kn|ghts


TaloKarrde
Wed Sep 21, 2005 4:05 am
#3

thanks for the advice , anyone else have input?



_______________________
Talo Karrde - Elder Jedi
Ronen Karrde - Elder Bounty Hunter Extraordinaire
Still missing pre-cu (and now CU as well)...

SWG Starter Kit

Click here to support the Dream Patch!

In response to the NGE, I shall quote Darth Vader: "NNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!"
Daytona
Wed Sep 21, 2005 4:12 am
#4

I am a MLS/MD and it is boring. I enjoy slicing through opponents, so it must be the defender part that is boring to me....


I am thinking of taking something similar to your 2nd option. Plus, worse case scenario, if you feel like your defenses isn't what it needs to be with your fighting style, you can always grind a bit again. It takes no time at all to grind jedi anymore.





Hooah
Vendors on Rori in Rohal Cross, 1226 -5579, and on Lok in CION's Mall.

- I support a rollback and keeping & balancing the old combat system.
...and making SWG a better place to be.
Your voice counts!
RJUK
Wed Sep 21, 2005 4:13 am
#5


I know a few people would agree with me on this but...


Master Defender is only nice with one template IMO.


Master Sabers // Master Defender // 3000 Healer // Enhancer 0002


Personally I think this template is the best for PvP & PvE.



...:::Rhys-O John- Dark Jedi Knight :::...
...:::Kannible Hector- Master BH / Rifles :::...
...::: Retired Spolitor Of The HLRDivision :::...

RJUK
Wed Sep 21, 2005 4:15 am
#6

If your looking for a wide template with all the extra's then this would be it..


Master Sabers // Healer 4000 // Defender 4440 // Enhancer 3002


This template is just awsome, ok maybe it's not Master Defender...but it sure hell feels like it!!



...:::Rhys-O John- Dark Jedi Knight :::...
...:::Kannible Hector- Master BH / Rifles :::...
...::: Retired Spolitor Of The HLRDivision :::...

Daytona
Wed Sep 21, 2005 4:18 am
#7


RJUK, I have that exact template and I struggle against Jedi with Improved Force Sap. It goes 50/50 for me.


(MLS/MD, Healer 3xxx, and Enhancer xxx2)


My saber isn't great though and I know that is a major factor in it. If I remember right, my max damage is only around 640 or so.


I have yet to fight a Master Enhancer with all those roots though too.


I do well against PvE, but not so hot with PvP.

Message Edited by Daytona on 09-21-2005 04:19 AM



Hooah
Vendors on Rori in Rohal Cross, 1226 -5579, and on Lok in CION's Mall.

- I support a rollback and keeping & balancing the old combat system.
...and making SWG a better place to be.
Your voice counts!
RJUK
Wed Sep 21, 2005 4:23 am
#8






Daytona wrote:

RJUK, I have that exact template and I struggle against Jedi with Improved Force Sap. It goes 50/50 for me.


My saber isn't great though and I know that is a major factor in it. If I remember right, my max damage is only around 640 or so.


I have yet to fight a Master Enhancer with all those roots though too.


I do well against PvE, but not so hot with PvP.





Oh damn. Well... I know 3 people who have this template and i'm 1 of them, the other 2 are infact god's at PvP...but they do have pre-cu pearls in their saber which did turn out to be -9 FC 120 Damage on all 4. But no action modifiers. I gotta tell you I run out of action too...it's not just you bro, but yeah I know what ya mean...it's better to have a really good saber.



...:::Rhys-O John- Dark Jedi Knight :::...
...:::Kannible Hector- Master BH / Rifles :::...
...::: Retired Spolitor Of The HLRDivision :::...

Daytona
Wed Sep 21, 2005 4:31 am
#9

Ya, I am definitely not a God at PvP either.


*drools at thought of having good saber*


I practice against a friend of mine that I think is a Master Healer. Anyone that says Healer sucks, needs to fight them. They will give you a run for their money.



I really feel bad for the people that are only getting post cu pearls. I at least have 2 prems in mine.




Hooah
Vendors on Rori in Rohal Cross, 1226 -5579, and on Lok in CION's Mall.

- I support a rollback and keeping & balancing the old combat system.
...and making SWG a better place to be.
Your voice counts!
RJUK
Wed Sep 21, 2005 5:09 am
#10






Daytona wrote:

Ya, I am definitely not a God at PvP either.


*drools at thought of having good saber*


I practice against a friend of mine that I think is a Master Healer. Anyone that says Healer sucks, needs to fight them. They will give you a run for their money.



I really feel bad for the people that are only getting post cu pearls. I at least have 2 prems in mine.





Not when they get smacked in a face with a pre-CU 918 Max damage saber LOL.




...:::Rhys-O John- Dark Jedi Knight :::...
...:::Kannible Hector- Master BH / Rifles :::...
...::: Retired Spolitor Of The HLRDivision :::...

Kev0r
Wed Sep 21, 2005 5:25 am
#11






RJUK wrote:





Daytona wrote:

Ya, I am definitely not a God at PvP either.


*drools at thought of having good saber*


I practice against a friend of mine that I think is a Master Healer. Anyone that says Healer sucks, needs to fight them. They will give you a run for their money.



I really feel bad for the people that are only getting post cu pearls. I at least have 2 prems in mine.





Not when they get smacked in a face with a pre-CU 918 Max damage saber LOL.







Hehe, I doubt anyone has that high a saber....even with 4 perfect pearls, the base stats would have to be 438 max damage....a more realistic figure is about 740 max damage.


A good pre CU 2h saber and 0404LSwill beat just about any post CU saber, even with MLS. I think players have to get past this mental block regarding the lack of premiums and start making use of what resources we DO have. I'm aware of many players who can tune up to at least 100 from a "good" or "quality". Four of those in a 250 base damage saber will still get you up to 650'ish damage, nothing to moan about I'm sure.


As for templates, the MLS/MDEF mainstay is great for actually achieving goals in the game, but you are basically a top-of-the-range swordsman/doc. The lack of anything "flashy" puts people off; no force run or cloak or roots or meditate. But as far as actually fighting opponents and lasting the distance goes, it can't be beaten by other jedi templates. And that's what matters for me at the end of the day. Ask any MLS/MDEF if they think jedi are 1.5 x the power of other profs, and 99% of them will say yes.





+=Raith Seinar=+
+=Ju' Seinar=+
+= Ju's Trading Outpost - Corellia 481, -6290 =+
Kakov
Wed Sep 21, 2005 5:30 am
#12






TaloKarrde wrote:
Mdef
0404 Lightsaber
4000 Healing
3004 Enhancer

OR

MLS
0040 Defense
4000 Healing
3404 Enhancer





I used to be LS x4x4, MDef, Heal 41xx and Enh 4xx4 - Similar to option1


But i changed to LS x444, MDef, Heal 4xxx and Enh 3xx2 - so that i could have a few more attacks and damage


I have also toyed with the idea of the temp MLS, Def 444x, Heal 4xxx and Enh 3xx3 but i don't really want to lose Master Defender... We'll just have to see how it works out





Kakov Avvau

-----------------------------------------------------------------------
The Enclave (ENC) Founder - Enclave's Rest (Rori)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Farstar

Pday
Wed Sep 21, 2005 5:30 am
#13






Kev0r wrote:





RJUK wrote:





Daytona wrote:

Ya, I am definitely not a God at PvP either.


*drools at thought of having good saber*


I practice against a friend of mine that I think is a Master Healer. Anyone that says Healer sucks, needs to fight them. They will give you a run for their money.



I really feel bad for the people that are only getting post cu pearls. I at least have 2 prems in mine.





Not when they get smacked in a face with a pre-CU 918 Max damage saber LOL.







Hehe, I doubt anyone has that high a saber....even with 4 perfect pearls, the base stats would have to be 438 max damage....a more realistic figure is about 740 max damage.


A good pre CU 2h saber and 0404LSwill beat just about any post CU saber, even with MLS. I think players have to get past this mental block regarding the lack of premiums and start making use of what resources we DO have. I'm aware of many players who can tune up to at least 100 from a "good" or "quality". Four of those in a 250 base damage saber will still get you up to 650'ish damage, nothing to moan about I'm sure.


As for templates, the MLS/MDEF mainstay is great for actually achieving goals in the game, but you are basically a top-of-the-range swordsman/doc. The lack of anything "flashy" puts people off; no force run or cloak or roots or meditate. But as far as actually fighting opponents and lasting the distance goes, it can't be beaten by other jedi templates. And that's what matters for me at the end of the day. Ask any MLS/MDEF if they think jedi are 1.5 x the power of other profs, and 99% of them will say yes.






the main problem with the m.def/m.ls/3-0-0-0 heal/0-0-0-2 enhancer is that it cant keep up with the damage a pre cu saber + m.ls with force speed can dish out.




Iadao

4-4-4-4 Sick inhumane S.O.B

GCW forum motto : Lets all go beat some more DEAD HORSES

yeah it's only a game, but the time and money I invested in it are certainly F'ing REAL.

Page 1 of 3
Previous Next