Items And Loot Archive

Thread: Mwahahahaha! AFK fighting Macros are gone!

jlainejr
Mon Feb 28, 2005 4:05 pm
#14

Wouldn't it just be better to remove the /loot command?



Lt. Elcith Weiri
Executive Officer

The Crimson Order
Owet Weiri
Master Crafter of Rocket Launchers


Milgram
Mon Feb 28, 2005 4:54 pm
#15

Saying that people who use recursive macros are just lazy is like saying people who use google arelazy.Someone who e-mails a friend instead of snail mailing it is using an exploit that god didn't intend. Driving to work is the antithesis of lazy.Putting an attack up on your toolbar instead of typing /melee2hheadhit3 into your command line is lazy. Automation is a great tool for accomplishing a task quicker, better and more accruately.


Most of those who want recursive macros removed are pissed that others are able to use game rules and systems and accomplish more than the complainer. Recursive macros don't hurt you, and they help others. Obviously the solution is to remove them so that everyone else sucks like you. I know some people use shift+Fxx fortheir second bank of commands. I, on the other hand, set imy controls so i can just press 1.It won't be longuntill people call exploit and demand the devs remove key pad customization. After all, shouldn't I be forced to try to hold shift with my pinky and stretch my index finger up to F7 just like everybody else?


I really, really hope I don't get banned for admiting to using the key customization exploit .




I'm With-Stupid n I-am With-I'm
The Jedi Jeweler - Outside Theed at -3990 4485
I go Bakersfield Chimp on Krayts and Nightsisters. You Savvy?
- I support keeping & balancing the current combat system You can too


Israth
Mon Feb 28, 2005 5:12 pm
#16






Milgram wrote:

Saying that people who use recursive macros are just lazy is like saying people who use google arelazy.Someone who e-mails a friend instead of snail mailing it is using an exploit that god didn't intend. Driving to work is the antithesis of lazy.Putting an attack up on your toolbar instead of typing /melee2hheadhit3 into your command line is lazy. Automation is a great tool for accomplishing a task quicker, better and more accruately.


Most of those who want recursive macros removed are pissed that others are able to use game rules and systems and accomplish more than the complainer. Recursive macros don't hurt you, and they help others. Obviously the solution is to remove them so that everyone else sucks like you. I know some people use shift+Fxx fortheir second bank of commands. I, on the other hand, set imy controls so i can just press 1.It won't be longuntill people call exploit and demand the devs remove key pad customization. After all, shouldn't I be forced to try to hold shift with my pinky and stretch my index finger up to F7 just like everybody else?


I really, really hope I don't get banned for admiting to using the key customization exploit .







They don't hurt me? So when I'm a new ent, trying to get XP, and I can't because there's a bot in there who got their skills by AFKing rather than playing, that doesn't hurt me? Or when there's a fully templated Jedi attacking NPCs to get loot to add to his millions of credits already whereas I'm trying to get the loot to use it for myself instead of sell it? Exactly.


We didn't say get rid of macros, we said get rid of RECURSIVE macros. They don't help the game, they help destroy it. If you don't want to play the game, why buy it?

Milgram
Mon Feb 28, 2005 5:33 pm
#17






Israth wrote:





Milgram wrote:

Saying that people who use recursive macros are just lazy is like saying people who use google arelazy.Someone who e-mails a friend instead of snail mailing it is using an exploit that god didn't intend. Driving to work is the antithesis of lazy.Putting an attack up on your toolbar instead of typing /melee2hheadhit3 into your command line is lazy. Automation is a great tool for accomplishing a task quicker, better and more accruately.


Most of those who want recursive macros removed are pissed that others are able to use game rules and systems and accomplish more than the complainer. Recursive macros don't hurt you, and they help others. Obviously the solution is to remove them so that everyone else sucks like you. I know some people use shift+Fxx fortheir second bank of commands. I, on the other hand, set imy controls so i can just press 1.It won't be longuntill people call exploit and demand the devs remove key pad customization. After all, shouldn't I be forced to try to hold shift with my pinky and stretch my index finger up to F7 just like everybody else?


I really, really hope I don't get banned for admiting to using the key customization exploit .







They don't hurt me? So when I'm a new ent, trying to get XP, and I can't because there's a bot in there who got their skills by AFKing rather than playing, that doesn't hurt me? Or when there's a fully templated Jedi attacking NPCs to get loot to add to his millions of credits already whereas I'm trying to get the loot to use it for myself instead of sell it? Exactly.


We didn't say get rid of macros, we said get rid of RECURSIVE macros. They don't help the game, they help destroy it. If you don't want to play the game, why buy it?








I did entertainer for holocron, and i had no trouble doing it in a sea of bots. As long as you are grouped with the rest, you get the exact same amount of healing exp as you would have otherwise. If you happen to like hitting buttons to do different flourishes, well, that's your buiseness. The most popular buff bot Dancer/Musician team on our server often have "guest performers" who perform with them so that they can get the healing exp needed for master. I love AFK dancers/musicians because they are on at 3 AM when i need healed. If macros are removed, the cantinas will be a) empty or b) staffed by one really creepy guy, because after all, anyone who sits actively at his/her computer at 3 AM hitting flurish buttons over and over has got to be creepy.


As for Jedi and Nyax, your real problem is with Nyax, and not recursive macros. If macros were removed, and nyax continued to drop really good stuff, all that would happen is nyax would be camped 24/7 by live people instead of their bots, and you still wouldn't get anything. On the nice side, it would be agood change of pace for you, because now instead of complaining about AFK macros, you could complain about how everyone is better than you at camping mob xxx.


Just because you like to do everything the hard way does not mean that everyone else should be forced to slave alongside you.





I'm With-Stupid n I-am With-I'm
The Jedi Jeweler - Outside Theed at -3990 4485
I go Bakersfield Chimp on Krayts and Nightsisters. You Savvy?
- I support keeping & balancing the current combat system You can too


Skawtt
Mon Feb 28, 2005 5:52 pm
#18

Just make caves instanced (sp?)




Retired Bothan Jedi Elder


Blue Glowie at one with the cancel button.
Milgram
Mon Feb 28, 2005 5:55 pm
#19






Skawtt wrote:

Just make caves instanced (sp?)






Nerfs are always better than good game content.


-SWG Developer Team




I'm With-Stupid n I-am With-I'm
The Jedi Jeweler - Outside Theed at -3990 4485
I go Bakersfield Chimp on Krayts and Nightsisters. You Savvy?
- I support keeping & balancing the current combat system You can too


mopcog
Mon Feb 28, 2005 6:03 pm
#20




hmmm Take out recursive macros.....CoB Macro!



Message Edited by mopcog on 02-28-2005 06:05 PM



lAnaste Malanzol
lMaster Swordsmenl
lMaster Doctorl
Twitchie
Mon Feb 28, 2005 6:41 pm
#21






Milgram wrote:





Israth wrote:





Milgram wrote:

Saying that people who use recursive macros are just lazy is like saying people who use google arelazy.Someone who e-mails a friend instead of snail mailing it is using an exploit that god didn't intend. Driving to work is the antithesis of lazy.Putting an attack up on your toolbar instead of typing /melee2hheadhit3 into your command line is lazy. Automation is a great tool for accomplishing a task quicker, better and more accruately.


Most of those who want recursive macros removed are pissed that others are able to use game rules and systems and accomplish more than the complainer. Recursive macros don't hurt you, and they help others. Obviously the solution is to remove them so that everyone else sucks like you. I know some people use shift+Fxx fortheir second bank of commands. I, on the other hand, set imy controls so i can just press 1.It won't be longuntill people call exploit and demand the devs remove key pad customization. After all, shouldn't I be forced to try to hold shift with my pinky and stretch my index finger up to F7 just like everybody else?


I really, really hope I don't get banned for admiting to using the key customization exploit .







They don't hurt me? So when I'm a new ent, trying to get XP, and I can't because there's a bot in there who got their skills by AFKing rather than playing, that doesn't hurt me? Or when there's a fully templated Jedi attacking NPCs to get loot to add to his millions of credits already whereas I'm trying to get the loot to use it for myself instead of sell it? Exactly.


We didn't say get rid of macros, we said get rid of RECURSIVE macros. They don't help the game, they help destroy it. If you don't want to play the game, why buy it?








I did entertainer for holocron, and i had no trouble doing it in a sea of bots. As long as you are grouped with the rest, you get the exact same amount of healing exp as you would have otherwise. If you happen to like hitting buttons to do different flourishes, well, that's your buiseness. The most popular buff bot Dancer/Musician team on our server often have "guest performers" who perform with them so that they can get the healing exp needed for master. I love AFK dancers/musicians because they are on at 3 AM when i need healed. If macros are removed, the cantinas will be a) empty or b) staffed by one really creepy guy, because after all, anyone who sits actively at his/her computer at 3 AM hitting flurish buttons over and over has got to be creepy.


As for Jedi and Nyax, your real problem is with Nyax, and not recursive macros. If macros were removed, and nyax continued to drop really good stuff, all that would happen is nyax would be camped 24/7 by live people instead of their bots, and you still wouldn't get anything. On the nice side, it would be agood change of pace for you, because now instead of complaining about AFK macros, you could complain about how everyone is better than you at camping mob xxx.


Just because you like to do everything the hard way does not mean that everyone else should be forced to slave alongside you.








Whoa, slow the boat. You can't compare an internet search engine to AFK macros. That's idiotic. That's like saying a phone book is lazy.......you want to call a local shop to find out if they have SWG game cards in stock, you have to dial every number sequentially? Get real, bud.


AFK looters on Nyax, or any other spawn? Let me clue you in........if they're so bored that they can't stay there 5 minutes to fight in person, what makes you think they'll sit there actively waiting for an hour or better???? You're out of your mind. Let's take your example of 3am.....there's hardly anybody online, entertainers, docs, or otherwise, but I can always find a mininum of 4 people camped at a POI, all with AFK over their heads. Yet you expect me to believe they'll be there at 3am, if they can't stay online, AFK, and loot while they're sleeping.


Dude, again, IT'S A GAME. There's controls to be pressed, buttons to be pushed, playing to be played. Once more, if you can't be bothered to play the game, which might involve pushing a few keys, then go back to watching TV, and let the players play. Quit whining about it, trying to make macros and exploiting a game feature sound cool, it's not. Bottom line is you're not playing the game...........sometimes you need to press a key or two.


Oh, and in case you didn't notice, you don't have to type /meleehit2 et al, you have nice, neat little buttons you can drop into your toolbar, and press one key per hit. Try Ctrl-A if you didn't see them. Saves you alot of typing.




& Twitchie &

Eclipse's Fattest Wookiee
Forget Maul, Sidious, and Vader.........
I'm terrified of Darth Razor.
@
MeciniaLua
Mon Feb 28, 2005 6:45 pm
#22

There needs to be another step taken.


Some suggestions


1) Remove the ability to turn off autoafk.

2) Put a time limit on POIs, make it so you can't stay more than a hour then it boots you out.

3) Make it such that if you do not use the mouse or keyboard for say 20 minutes the game autoboots you, afk or not.



To me the simplest solution would be 1.

2 Might be useful but there are plenty of static spawns that are not POIs ( and we can't make it 1 hour everywheres or we'd be crippling Jedi's ....though I don't like em but they are in the game and thus do require some consideration ).



-Wanderhome- Mecinia, Mecinea
-Intrepid- Yovi
-Radiant- Enoorea, Bienurdau
Collected Expansion Ideas and Game Upgradesi


"There is no emotion, there is peace; There is no ignorance, there is knowledge; There is no passion, there is serenity; there is no choas, there is order;There is no death, there is the Force" from the Jedi code.
Twitchie
Mon Feb 28, 2005 6:54 pm
#23

I think they've taken the simplest solution, and just removed the ability altogether. Macros still exist, and are useful in some circumtances, they're just removing the ability to start your macro and go out for a beer with the boys, and come back a few hours later, get some training, sell your loot, then go back, set your macro, and go to bed. Use a macro, sure, but you'll have to manually start it every time.


1. It removes campers effectively, unless they really like boring gameplay, in which case, more power to them.

2. It actually makes you work for your XP.

3. If you didn't get my point the first few times, PLAY THE GAME, or go do something else. Let those of us who actually enjoy the gameplay get on with it.


I don't think you'll find much argument, really........except from the people who abuse the ability.



& Twitchie &

Eclipse's Fattest Wookiee
Forget Maul, Sidious, and Vader.........
I'm terrified of Darth Razor.
@
Israth
Mon Feb 28, 2005 7:02 pm
#24






Twitchie wrote:





Milgram wrote:





Israth wrote:





Milgram wrote:

Saying that people who use recursive macros are just lazy is like saying people who use google arelazy.Someone who e-mails a friend instead of snail mailing it is using an exploit that god didn't intend. Driving to work is the antithesis of lazy.Putting an attack up on your toolbar instead of typing /melee2hheadhit3 into your command line is lazy. Automation is a great tool for accomplishing a task quicker, better and more accruately.


Most of those who want recursive macros removed are pissed that others are able to use game rules and systems and accomplish more than the complainer. Recursive macros don't hurt you, and they help others. Obviously the solution is to remove them so that everyone else sucks like you. I know some people use shift+Fxx fortheir second bank of commands. I, on the other hand, set imy controls so i can just press 1.It won't be longuntill people call exploit and demand the devs remove key pad customization. After all, shouldn't I be forced to try to hold shift with my pinky and stretch my index finger up to F7 just like everybody else?


I really, really hope I don't get banned for admiting to using the key customization exploit .







They don't hurt me? So when I'm a new ent, trying to get XP, and I can't because there's a bot in there who got their skills by AFKing rather than playing, that doesn't hurt me? Or when there's a fully templated Jedi attacking NPCs to get loot to add to his millions of credits already whereas I'm trying to get the loot to use it for myself instead of sell it? Exactly.


We didn't say get rid of macros, we said get rid of RECURSIVE macros. They don't help the game, they help destroy it. If you don't want to play the game, why buy it?








I did entertainer for holocron, and i had no trouble doing it in a sea of bots. As long as you are grouped with the rest, you get the exact same amount of healing exp as you would have otherwise. If you happen to like hitting buttons to do different flourishes, well, that's your buiseness. The most popular buff bot Dancer/Musician team on our server often have "guest performers" who perform with them so that they can get the healing exp needed for master. I love AFK dancers/musicians because they are on at 3 AM when i need healed. If macros are removed, the cantinas will be a) empty or b) staffed by one really creepy guy, because after all, anyone who sits actively at his/her computer at 3 AM hitting flurish buttons over and over has got to be creepy.


As for Jedi and Nyax, your real problem is with Nyax, and not recursive macros. If macros were removed, and nyax continued to drop really good stuff, all that would happen is nyax would be camped 24/7 by live people instead of their bots, and you still wouldn't get anything. On the nice side, it would be agood change of pace for you, because now instead of complaining about AFK macros, you could complain about how everyone is better than you at camping mob xxx.


Just because you like to do everything the hard way does not mean that everyone else should be forced to slave alongside you.








Whoa, slow the boat. You can't compare an internet search engine to AFK macros. That's idiotic. That's like saying a phone book is lazy.......you want to call a local shop to find out if they have SWG game cards in stock, you have to dial every number sequentially? Get real, bud.


AFK looters on Nyax, or any other spawn? Let me clue you in........if they're so bored that they can't stay there 5 minutes to fight in person, what makes you think they'll sit there actively waiting for an hour or better???? You're out of your mind. Let's take your example of 3am.....there's hardly anybody online, entertainers, docs, or otherwise, but I can always find a mininum of 4 people camped at a POI, all with AFK over their heads. Yet you expect me to believe they'll be there at 3am, if they can't stay online, AFK, and loot while they're sleeping.


Dude, again, IT'S A GAME. There's controls to be pressed, buttons to be pushed, playing to be played. Once more, if you can't be bothered to play the game, which might involve pushing a few keys, then go back to watching TV, and let the players play. Quit whining about it, trying to make macros and exploiting a game feature sound cool, it's not. Bottom line is you're not playing the game...........sometimes you need to press a key or two.


Oh, and in case you didn't notice, you don't have to type /meleehit2 et al, you have nice, neat little buttons you can drop into your toolbar, and press one key per hit. Try Ctrl-A if you didn't see them. Saves you alot of typing.







You're my hero.
xixi
Mon Feb 28, 2005 7:30 pm
#25

Someone else said this in another thread: Guns don't kill people, people kill people.


Same deal with macros, recurrsive or otherwise: Macros don't tick people off, people tick people off.


Unless we can slap a patch on certain players, no coding will solve this problem. So don't look to the devs to solve this problem. There's no way they can without messing up non-exploitive players' game experiences. (ie. CoB macro, /loot hotkey, etc) /shrug


Perhaps all the energy we expend toward a possible mechanical/code fix to this problem would be better spent figuring out how to condition people against this behavior in game.


Any ideas?

Trenkor
Tue Mar 01, 2005 1:01 am
#26

I agree that recursive macros are irritating, especially from people that are spamming messages you don't want to read the 18th time, but it really helps when grinding. About a week ago I grinded the entire medic line in a couple hours using the "amazing medical crafting macro". I remember doing that same grind earlier on a different toon without a macro and it took about four times longer.
Page 2 of 3