Force Sensitive Archive

Thread: Medical exp FS conversion now 30:1 Why?

Persamus
Sat Aug 06, 2005 7:24 pm
#1



I am trying to be patient, calm, and polite. Yet I find it difficult to do because I just converted some med exp and found it had also changed, and is now at 30:1, same as any weapon and combat exp now. What I would like to know is, why?


I started a couple of threads earlier, to express that the changes made to combat exp conversion would only make it worse for everyone, but it would hurt casual players most. Grinders will always be grinders, they don't really care.Many (not all)who are jedi now probably like the change, because many are, in my opinion, the worst kind of griefers and exploitation masters. You have given the worst people on the servers more reason to be proud of their exploits and grinding capability. Again I ask, why?


It would be difficult to think of a worse way to deal with the problems you created by a questionable combat upgrade. I have worked in the computer gaming industry, and with a relative still working in the industry, I have a rather good view into the business. Because I can understand a lot of what is going on, I am quite frankly mystified that you could be capable of such blunders. I have tried to be reasonable in past posts, because I thought that perhaps someone might rethink the strategy you now have implemented.


Let's take stock. Previously, the only path to jedi as secret, and combined blindly grinding a personal set of professions. Those who got through this were not what I would call good teammates, because they did not help to develop the game for other players. Then, holocrons were added, and this trend got even worse. Then came the village, and the requirements were spelled out, yet heavily favored combat classes and grinders yet again. Now we have the combat upgrade, and along with it a whole new set of issues.


By badly implementing the combat upgrade, you have only made a bad situation worse. Now you have changed the goalposts yet again! By changing combat exp and med exp (which can ONLY be received in combat now, go figure why the med centers are empty now) you have yet again moved the goalposts and made it even harder for casual gamers. This means, among other things, that you are falsely representing yourselves as catering to a casual gaming audience. That lie is now exposed, and it has been made clear that the only people that can succeed in this game are grinders, mindlessly grinding.


I can only imagine that the people in charge at SOE are the same kind of people you cater to. Just because that particular group (the squeeky wheels) shout a lot and demand things, does not mean they represent a majority of your customer base. Just like the world did not fall apart when people did not have TEF anymore (though the griefers assured you it would), making it harder to grind jedi WILL NOT FIX THE PROBLEMS!!! Once again, you have simply substituted one set of problems for another set, one which could possibly destroy your game by making people SO disgusted they quit, as I am about to.


From the vantage point I am at, it does not seem that you care about anything except making people play as long as possible to get jedi, so that you can keep their accounts going. Does it not occur to you that if the GAME WAS FUN MORE PEOPLE WOULD STAY? Instead you take the path of greed and ease, not bringing content, but by nerfing. THis approach only works for so long.


I actually appreciate and would like to thank the programmers, who typically spend many many thankless hours over game code with little thanks or respect. I understand that it is not (mostly) your fault for these changes, but likely the producers and executives who make decisions. The producers and executives tend to want to cut staff, get more code, not buy into any project that actually takes time and effort beyond the minimum necessary to keep the ship afloat while planning another expansion they can make people pay for. I also want to send an apology to the customer service cadre who actually read these messages, and my gratitude that it gets read at all. I plead with you to make these decision makers read these posts and see what they are doing to their own profits! I can only hope that something I used to enjoy, and may again one day, might actually be fun to play again, and not a grinders paradise.


Persephea Lightheart

Intrepid

Message Edited by Persamus on 08-06-2005 07:36 PM

Edited for content, tochange offensive phrase. Perephea Lightheart

Message Edited by Persamus on 08-07-2005 04:41 PM

ga1352
Sat Aug 06, 2005 10:12 pm
#2

didn't really read it but i agree i skimmed it also medical xp should convert to reflexes and combat because doc and cm and medic are considered combat profs as they were respecable at first. also you can only get the xp in combat. nuff said



There is no death; there is the Force.Spetygeyy,Jedi Elder
The Jedi is the crystal of the Force. Pociny, Crafter
The Force shall set me free.SYN CITY Talus: 635, -413
All are intertwined. You are one.
Babafetish
Sun Aug 07, 2005 3:03 am
#3


Am I right in saying a doc healing and someone shooting get the same amount of xp fighting if theyre the same level? Ive never compared it myself to take notice.


But if thats the case ( which I'm sure it is ) then the 30 to 1 ratio was inevitable - same amount of xp, same ratio, different xp gained.


wanabjedi55
Sun Aug 07, 2005 3:34 am
#4






Persamus wrote:


I am trying to be patient, calm, and polite. Yet I find it difficult to do because I just converted some med exp and found it had also changed, and is now at 30:1, same as any weapon and combat exp now. What I would like to know is, why?


I started a couple of threads earlier, to express that the changes made to combat exp conversion would only make it worse for everyone, but it would hurt casual players most. Grinders will always be grinders, they don't really care.Many (not all)who are jedi now probably like the change, because many are, in my opinion, the worst kind of griefers and exploitation masters. You have given the worst people on the servers more reason to be proud of their exploits and grinding capability. Again I ask, why?


It would be difficult to think of a worse way to deal with the problems you created by a questionable combat upgrade. I have worked in the computer gaming industry, and with a relative still working in the industry, I have a rather good view into the business. Because I can understand a lot of what is going on, I am quite frankly mystified that you could be capable of such blunders. I have tried to be reasonable in past posts, because I thought that perhaps someone might rethink the strategy you now have implemented.


Let's take stock. Previously, the only path to jedi as secret, and combined blindly grinding a personal set of professions. Those who got through this were not what I would call good teammates, because they did not help to develop the game for other players. Then, holocrons were added, and this trend got even worse. Then came the village, and the requirements were spelled out, yet heavily favored combat classes and grinders yet again. Now we have the combat upgrade, and along with it a whole new set of issues.


By badly implementing the combat upgrade, you have only made a bad situation worse. Now you have changed the goalposts yet again! By changing combat exp and med exp (which can ONLY be received in combat now, go figure why the med centers are empty now) you have yet again moved the goalposts and made it even harder for casual gamers. This means, among other things, that you are falsely representing yourselves as catering to a casual gaming audience. That lie is now exposed, and it has been made clear that the only people that can succeed in this game are grinders, mindlessly grinding.


I can only imagine that the people in charge at SOE are the same kind of people you cater to. Just because that particular group (like right wing Republicans) shout a lot and demand things, does not mean they represent a majority of your customer base. Just like the world did not fall apart when people did not have TEF anymore (though the griefers assured you it would), making it harder to grind jedi WILL NOT FIX THE PROBLEMS!!! Once again, you have simply substituted one set of problems for another set, one which could possibly destroy your game by making people SO disgusted they quit, as I am about to.


From the vantage point I am at, it does not seem that you care about anything except making people play as long as possible to get jedi, so that you can keep their accounts going. Does it not occur to you that if the GAME WAS FUN MORE PEOPLE WOULD STAY? Instead you take the path of greed and ease, not bringing content, but by nerfing. THis approach only works for so long.


I actually appreciate and would like to thank the programmers, who typically spend many many thankless hours over game code with little thanks or respect. I understand that it is not (mostly) your fault for these changes, but likely the producers and executives who make decisions. The producers and executives tend to want to cut staff, get more code, not buy into any project that actually takes time and effort beyond the minimum necessary to keep the ship afloat while planning another expansion they can make people pay for. I also want to send an apology to the customer service cadre who actually read these messages, and my gratitude that it gets read at all. I plead with you to make these decision makers read these posts and see what they are doing to their own profits! I can only hope that something I used to enjoy, and may again one day, might actually be fun to play again, and not a grinders paradise.


Persephea Lightheart

Intrepid

Message Edited by Persamus on 08-06-2005 07:36 PM




It seems to me like they are trying to actualy enhance the community and make it more fitting to the time this saga portrays. They are trying to reduce the amount of Jedi because keep in mind there were not many Jedi around this erra(If any, but they must put it in there to intise people). But at the same time they have people ranting and raving that Jedi is not easy enough to obtain.. Now they have two aspects they have to think about:


1. What is best for the game and it's customers who understand what is REALLY important for the game. And trust that what SOE is doing is for the best. Because after all they ARE the makers in a large corporation and most likley know quite a bit about the business....


and:


2. What the customers want, but may regret in the future because of their impatients....


"If the GAME WAS FUN MORE PEOPLE WOULD STAY?"


That is completely TRUE..But what many seem to not realize is that what may seem good for the community now, may not be the best decision in the long run. Plans do back fire, and SOE has taken that into account.



Those are my views...



Message Edited by wanabjedi55 on 08-07-2005 04:36 AM



Ahazi!
Super_nice_jedi
Sun Aug 07, 2005 4:14 am
#5






wanabjedi55 wrote:






Persamus wrote:


I am trying to be patient, calm, and polite. Yet I find it difficult to do because I just converted some med exp and found it had also changed, and is now at 30:1, same as any weapon and combat exp now. What I would like to know is, why?


I started a couple of threads earlier, to express that the changes made to combat exp conversion would only make it worse for everyone, but it would hurt casual players most. Grinders will always be grinders, they don't really care.Many (not all)who are jedi now probably like the change, because many are, in my opinion, the worst kind of griefers and exploitation masters. You have given the worst people on the servers more reason to be proud of their exploits and grinding capability. Again I ask, why?


It would be difficult to think of a worse way to deal with the problems you created by a questionable combat upgrade. I have worked in the computer gaming industry, and with a relative still working in the industry, I have a rather good view into the business. Because I can understand a lot of what is going on, I am quite frankly mystified that you could be capable of such blunders. I have tried to be reasonable in past posts, because I thought that perhaps someone might rethink the strategy you now have implemented.


Let's take stock. Previously, the only path to jedi as secret, and combined blindly grinding a personal set of professions. Those who got through this were not what I would call good teammates, because they did not help to develop the game for other players. Then, holocrons were added, and this trend got even worse. Then came the village, and the requirements were spelled out, yet heavily favored combat classes and grinders yet again. Now we have the combat upgrade, and along with it a whole new set of issues.


By badly implementing the combat upgrade, you have only made a bad situation worse. Now you have changed the goalposts yet again! By changing combat exp and med exp (which can ONLY be received in combat now, go figure why the med centers are empty now) you have yet again moved the goalposts and made it even harder for casual gamers. This means, among other things, that you are falsely representing yourselves as catering to a casual gaming audience. That lie is now exposed, and it has been made clear that the only people that can succeed in this game are grinders, mindlessly grinding.


I can only imagine that the people in charge at SOE are the same kind of people you cater to. Just because that particular group (like right wing Republicans) shout a lot and demand things, does not mean they represent a majority of your customer base. Just like the world did not fall apart when people did not have TEF anymore (though the griefers assured you it would), making it harder to grind jedi WILL NOT FIX THE PROBLEMS!!! Once again, you have simply substituted one set of problems for another set, one which could possibly destroy your game by making people SO disgusted they quit, as I am about to.


From the vantage point I am at, it does not seem that you care about anything except making people play as long as possible to get jedi, so that you can keep their accounts going. Does it not occur to you that if the GAME WAS FUN MORE PEOPLE WOULD STAY? Instead you take the path of greed and ease, not bringing content, but by nerfing. THis approach only works for so long.


I actually appreciate and would like to thank the programmers, who typically spend many many thankless hours over game code with little thanks or respect. I understand that it is not (mostly) your fault for these changes, but likely the producers and executives who make decisions. The producers and executives tend to want to cut staff, get more code, not buy into any project that actually takes time and effort beyond the minimum necessary to keep the ship afloat while planning another expansion they can make people pay for. I also want to send an apology to the customer service cadre who actually read these messages, and my gratitude that it gets read at all. I plead with you to make these decision makers read these posts and see what they are doing to their own profits! I can only hope that something I used to enjoy, and may again one day, might actually be fun to play again, and not a grinders paradise.


Persephea Lightheart

Intrepid

Message Edited by Persamus on 08-06-2005 07:36 PM




It seems to me like they are trying to actualy enhance the community and make it more fitting to the time this saga portrays. They are trying to reduce the amount of Jedi because keep in mind there were not many Jedi around this erra(If any, but they must put it in there to intise people). But at the same time they have people ranting and raving that Jedi is not easy enough to obtain.. Now they have two aspects they have to think about:


1. What is best for the game and it's customers who understand what is REALLY important for the game. And trust that what SOE is doing is for the best. Because after all they ARE the makers in a large corporation and most likley know quite a bit about the business....


and:


2. What the customers want, but may regret in the future because of their impatients....


"If the GAME WAS FUN MORE PEOPLE WOULD STAY?"


That is completely TRUE..But what many seem to not realize is that what may seem good for the community now, may not be the best decision in the long run. Plans do back fire, and SOE has taken that into account.



Those are my views...




Message Edited by wanabjedi55 on 08-07-2005 04:36 AM





Which I think is a load of BS!


I don't see the relevance of making things more long winded in the FS stages, but should be more long winded during the Jedi grind after you become Padawan, the devs have completely switched everything round. The FS taking longer means longer to get to the 2nd slot, and if Jedi was harder then people will have their 2nd slots to play with to get away from the hard Jedi grind, or may not bother being Jedi at all, and make one a normal Combat profession instead of Jedi, and another a crafter. What do FS grinders have? Just their one char to progress with, with the thought that once they get their 2nd slot, they can calm down on the grinding, but now with these conversions, makes people want to give up.


A Jedi Padawan is not a fully functional Jedi. A kreetle can kill a Jedi Padawan!



---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
You're out of time, SOE The whole 2.5 months shouldn't have been. The game was fine up until Nov 15th. If the CU was worked on, instead of devoting time to the NGE (including the many months prior to November), the game could possibly be totally bug free by now.

My account cancels on 2nd Feb, which was a waste as only played game for 1 day to get the life day gifts, will be resubbing when creature handler, Bio-engineer, scout, and ranger return, oh and the FS village.
ObsidianWrath
Sun Aug 07, 2005 4:18 am
#6

Persamus:


When I first began reading your post, I was pleasantly surprised to find how articulate it was. Furthermore, the message was primarily something that I agree with wholeheartedly, which really made for a positive connection between yourself and, in this case, your audience. As I was reading your thread, I found myself nodding my head from time to time in agreement with your assertions, but then I came across this paragraph, and was completely horrified:




Persamus wrote:



I can only imagine that the people in charge at SOE are the same kind of people you cater to. Just because that particular group (like right wing Republicans) shout a lot and demand things, does not mean they represent a majority of your customer base. Just like the world did not fall apart when people did not have TEF anymore (though the griefers assured you it would), making it harder to grind jedi WILL NOT FIX THE PROBLEMS!!! Once again, you have simply substituted one set of problems for another set, one which could possibly destroy your game by making people SO disgusted they quit, as I am about to.


Persephea Lightheart

Intrepid

Message Edited by Persamus on 08-06-2005 07:36 PM




Why would you do something like this? You had a completely articulate, respectable post going in your favor, and then you completely blew it out of the water making a shallow and baseless attack against a broad political spectrum. Such commentary is forbidden on the SWG forums, to the best of my knowledge, so I will not even begin to defend against such a blatant ad hominem. In that single comment, you managed to completely shed yourself any remote token of respectability that I once held for you in the reading of your post. I am a registered Republican, but I am not "frothing at the mouth" and screaming to the heavens as you have portrayed. I believe that I am a completely logical, rationale being who understands that both sides of the political spectrum maintain certain strengths and inherent weaknesses that are quintessential to the formation of their platforms. I also firmly believe that there are overspoken individuals on both sides of the political coin, and I feel that singling one out in a shallow attempt to further your baseless, hateful political agenda is shameful.


Shame on you.






. o O ( Larrendias du'Noctile-et'Senex ) O o .
C/OIC: 533rd IMCAGTF (SOC) // X/OIC: SECTION 8

[ Imperial Operator ] // [ Sunrunner Galaxy ]


NACHODEWI
Sun Aug 07, 2005 4:24 am
#7

You need to get over your own selfishness and see something had to be done.



Dweibokyt RotaenMaster Bounty Hunter
shub-niggurath00
Sun Aug 07, 2005 5:05 am
#8


1. I get my carbine out and blast away at that Piket. Net gain. 6000 ish combat xp

2. I put my carbine away and just heal everyone else. Net gain. 6000 ish medic xp

3. I do a bit of both. 4000 is combat xp, 2000 ish medic xp


You get exactly the same xp payout whether you're shooting, healing or any combination of the two. Combat xp to FS xp hasalways been 30:1. All that's changed is that the medic xp conversion rate has been brought in line with the combat professions. The grinder who's grinding doc will still grind away irrespective. They'll just joina group as a healer. The casual players are going to be no worse off than anyone else because they won't get any more or less than they would have anyway.


The ONLY thing this change has made is to level the FS xp playing field between medics and combat profs. Now you could possibly argue that instead of making medic xp 30:1 they should have broughtcombat xp down to 10:1 (or whatever medic was ), thereby making it a shorter grind for the combat profs..


But that's a whole different can of worms..

wanabjedi55
Sun Aug 07, 2005 5:11 am
#9






ObsidianWrath wrote:

Persamus:


When I first began reading your post, I was pleasantly surprised to find how articulate it was. Furthermore, the message was primarily something that I agree with wholeheartedly, which really made for a positive connection between yourself and, in this case, your audience. As I was reading your thread, I found myself nodding my head from time to time in agreement with your assertions, but then I came across this paragraph, and was completely horrified:




Persamus wrote:



I can only imagine that the people in charge at SOE are the same kind of people you cater to. Just because that particular group (like right wing Republicans) shout a lot and demand things, does not mean they represent a majority of your customer base. Just like the world did not fall apart when people did not have TEF anymore (though the griefers assured you it would), making it harder to grind jedi WILL NOT FIX THE PROBLEMS!!! Once again, you have simply substituted one set of problems for another set, one which could possibly destroy your game by making people SO disgusted they quit, as I am about to.


Persephea Lightheart

Intrepid

Message Edited by Persamus on 08-06-2005 07:36 PM




Why would you do something like this? You had a completely articulate, respectable post going in your favor, and then you completely blew it out of the water making a shallow and baseless attack against a broad political spectrum. Such commentary is forbidden on the SWG forums, to the best of my knowledge, so I will not even begin to defend against such a blatant ad hominem. In that single comment, you managed to completely shed yourself any remote token of respectability that I once held for you in the reading of your post. I am a registered Republican, but I am not "frothing at the mouth" and screaming to the heavens as you have portrayed. I believe that I am a completely logical, rationale being who understands that both sides of the political spectrum maintain certain strengths and inherent weaknesses that are quintessential to the formation of their platforms. I also firmly believe that there are overspoken individuals on both sides of the political coin, and I feel that singling one out in a shallow attempt to further your baseless, hateful political agenda is shameful.


Shame on you.






Oh get over yourself. Everyone has a right to express what they wish. And just because you don't agree politicaly doesn't mean you HAVE to disagree in every other aspect, be it life or a game idea...(Republicans...pshhh) lol


"You had a completely articulate, respectable post going in your favor, and then you completely blew it out of the water making a shallow and baseless attack against a broad political spectrum."


By saying "had" you mean that after one coment he completely lost articulation?....Riiiiiight...







Ahazi!
crackhed
Sun Aug 07, 2005 5:16 am
#10

while i think that med xp should convert the same as any weapon xp does due to the fact that it is gained the exact same way as weapons xp, i feel that you should gain combat xp as well when you are healing in the battlefield. i realize that this too converts to 30:1, but that added 300k of xp helps.
Super_nice_jedi
Sun Aug 07, 2005 5:19 am
#11







NACHODEWI wrote:
You need to get over your own selfishness and see something had to be done.







If that was intended for me then I'm not posting for selfish reasons as I have my Jedi.


I've had it easy all the way through, easy grinding FS before CU, and now Jedi are easy to grind now too, but think it stinks that the devs make the FS grind the area to slow the Jedi population.


I just think making Jedi only lose XP when only killed by a BH, instead of what it was - everything - you die (even if by a kreetle), you lose XP, and getting rid of visibility in a group, (which I accepted when being Jedi) and then making FS grind tougher, is just all totally dumb, in the plan to thin Jedi. Once your done with the village, its quite easy now, to grind through Jedi, and less likely chance to get on the terms, so less BH after you, if at all.


If the combat XP conversion of 30:1 sticks I reckon people should be able to get their 2nd slot once become glowy and got access to the village, so they can work on their alt when the FS grind gets too much, or do another totally unrelated quests to Jedi/FS for those not interested in Jedi or as most other MMORPGs do, let people have them from the get go.

Message Edited by Super_nice_jedi on 08-07-2005 05:20 AM



---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
You're out of time, SOE The whole 2.5 months shouldn't have been. The game was fine up until Nov 15th. If the CU was worked on, instead of devoting time to the NGE (including the many months prior to November), the game could possibly be totally bug free by now.

My account cancels on 2nd Feb, which was a waste as only played game for 1 day to get the life day gifts, will be resubbing when creature handler, Bio-engineer, scout, and ranger return, oh and the FS village.
BrugofIntrepid
Sun Aug 07, 2005 8:01 am
#12

dude, you say republicans shout, but what about Howard Dean and his "OOOHHHH YEEAAHHH!!!" lol
Sirisandir
Sun Aug 07, 2005 8:05 am
#13





_______________________
-) §irisandir )-
- I support the takeover of teh ò army.
!
Quality of SWG::-
Totally Awesome -----------------------------------------|---- Lame
Thanks for destroying two years of work, SOE.
/end two year non-stop subscription
Page 1 of 3
Previous Next