Entertainer Archive

Thread: Entertainers must be Bards!

Rasst
Thu Jul 14, 2005 12:26 am
#1

The only way to make entertainers playable is to convert them to bards. Short-time combat bufs, root/snare-songs etc.will help a lot and make profession useful. And you can perform in cantinas too!!! Everybody will be happy.



Ra'sst Rassi - Elder Ranger
/t Sunrunner.Ra'sst /t Sunrunner.Rys /t Sunrunner.Rasst
Drop vendor: All purpose, Dantooine (-922 2182)
/t Eclipse.Ryss
Warryyr
Thu Jul 14, 2005 12:30 am
#2

A LOT of Entertainers don't want a combat role.


I know that some do, but putting us into combat roles will make people assume that that's our place...which could lead to a less than pleasant cantina of people yelling at Entertainers to come with their group, to kill some stuff.


The Devs have said that they don't want Ents to be bards, and they're working to stick with that concept.


I do, however, think we should gain some kind of "escape" skill that negates aggro somehow - for travelling around. Cannot be applied to anyone with Novice Brawler or Marksman.


NeillM
Thu Jul 14, 2005 3:04 am
#3






Rasst wrote:

The only way to make entertainers playable is to convert them to bards. Short-time combat bufs, root/snare-songs etc.will help a lot and make profession useful. And you can perform in cantinas too!!! Everybody will be happy.





In a fantasy MMO you can justify having music/dance do this via magic... however in a system where music/dance operate under the same rules as they would in the real world buffs/effects of this nature cannot be explained/justified.



- Neeill Orkaorchi, Elder Entertainer/Elder Musician, Intrepid
- Nai'ren, Trader, Intrepid
- ATK and enjoy your day

Drop Off Vendor: FOE Canyon, Talus (4408, 2199)

Arrogance is unavoidable. The trick is to find an arrogance you can live with
Bionic
Thu Jul 14, 2005 5:18 am
#4



Warryyr wrote:

A LOT of Entertainers don't want a combat role.

I know that some do, but putting us into combat roles will make people assume that that's our place...which could lead to a less than pleasant cantina of people yelling at Entertainers to come with their group, to kill some stuff.

The Devs have said that they don't want Ents to be bards, and they're working to stick with that concept.

I do, however, think we should gain some kind of "escape" skill that negates aggro somehow - for travelling around. Cannot be applied to anyone with Novice Brawler or Marksman.




Woooah, I love that idea!



'
Who decided every addition to SWG should be a rutabaga?

Rasst
Thu Jul 14, 2005 7:16 am
#5

Some combat skills will help profession to be more "game related". After p20 it will be useless for game. I dont think there can bein-cantina buffs which can make it useful. F.e. I dont use any doctors bufs, but I prefer to be in group with doc for heals. The same thing would be nice for entertainers - additional root/snare or debuff removing songs. And as I said everyone can still play his cantina roles.


Yellingsat entertainers to join group?In my opinionit is better than no cantina visitors at all.


Developers converted doctors to clerics, this is unfair not to give the same option to entertainers.



Ra'sst Rassi - Elder Ranger
/t Sunrunner.Ra'sst /t Sunrunner.Rys /t Sunrunner.Rasst
Drop vendor: All purpose, Dantooine (-922 2182)
/t Eclipse.Ryss
NeillM
Thu Jul 14, 2005 8:59 am
#6

Just imagine the only way to get dance or Music XP would be in a group when they killed a creature/NPC! That is what we would become if we got field abilities.



- Neeill Orkaorchi, Elder Entertainer/Elder Musician, Intrepid
- Nai'ren, Trader, Intrepid
- ATK and enjoy your day

Drop Off Vendor: FOE Canyon, Talus (4408, 2199)

Arrogance is unavoidable. The trick is to find an arrogance you can live with
Dmux
Thu Jul 14, 2005 9:04 am
#7

Absolutely not. I've played bards in many other games, and I've loved it. However, I do not pay $15 a month to play a bard, I pay $15 a month to play an entertainer. It is near impossible to entertain or perform while trying toroot a krayt. I play an entertainer because I join putting together a creative performance. If entertainers were to become bards there would be no way to do such a thing. In your opion, a large group ofplayers whining at us to join them in a combat group is better than a small group of real patrons who appreciate the work that is put into entertaining. I strongly dissagree with you there! I would get far much more enjoymentout of a couple of players who appreciate being entertained and socailized with rather than a dozen players shouting at me "Combat Group!". Sure, if we were bards there might be more players coming into the cantina, but that would be a mute point being as they would have no desire to be entertained, and it would be near impossible to give them this desire.


Ari'Ess, The Lucky Despot,Eclipse


Chessack
Thu Jul 14, 2005 10:48 am
#8


Rasst wrote:
Some combat skills will help profession to be more "game related". After p20 it will be useless for game. I dont think there can be in-cantina buffs which can make it useful. F.e. I dont use any doctors bufs, but I prefer to be in group with doc for heals. The same thing would be nice for entertainers - additional root/snare or debuff removing songs. And as I said everyone can still play his cantina roles.




So wait...

Because YOU do not use buffs, we should be turned into bards? This reads like, "Devs! Make the entertainer playstyle suit MY playstyle."

There are a lot of people in this game, not just you. Most entertainers have said over, and over again (and to this, at least, the devs have thankfully listened) that we do not want to be bards. It is not in-theme for the Star Wars universe (when did you EVER see a dancer using dancing "powers" in battle?) and it is not the role most of us want.

Go troll a combat profession forum or something, will you, and stop trolling ours?

C



=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-

Dejah Thoris
Dancer, Musician, Image Designer
Kor Spera, Corellia, Naritus
Ikewe
Thu Jul 14, 2005 10:51 am
#9


Perhaps an alternative would be to create opportunities for the entertainers like they have for the MA and DE in the DeathWatch Bunker. Performing during combat to grant bonus or to apply a "state" to a target just doesn't really fit well in my opinion. However having an entertainer "coax" a clue or key to allow a group to either bypass a tough area or have access to something extra might work well. It's doubtful this option would result in random "/yell looking for entertainer to join DWB group " spam as I suspect these groups are much more likely to ask an entertainerthey already know through previous encounters.


But I think it's important that there be opportunities for both styles of entertainers. Those who joined the profession to have an active "healer" role are going to need something equally fulfilling as though who joined the profession to have an active "performance" role. If we only get activities that support one of these roles, the others will lose interest and move on.



Ikewe, Master Dancer, Shadowfire
When you wish upon a falling star, your dreams can come true. Unless it's really a meteorite hurtling to the Earth which will destroy all life. Then you're pretty much hosed no matter what you wish for. Unless it's death by meteor.


NeillM
Fri Jul 15, 2005 2:38 am
#10






Ikewe wrote:


Perhaps an alternative would be to create opportunities for the entertainers like they have for the MA and DE in the DeathWatch Bunker. Performing during combat to grant bonus or to apply a "state" to a target just doesn't really fit well in my opinion. However having an entertainer "coax" a clue or key to allow a group to either bypass a tough area or have access to something extra might work well. It's doubtful this option would result in random "/yell looking for entertainer to join DWB group " spam as I suspect these groups are much more likely to ask an entertainerthey already know through previous encounters.


But I think it's important that there be opportunities for both styles of entertainers. Those who joined the profession to have an active "healer" role are going to need something equally fulfilling as though who joined the profession to have an active "performance" role. If we only get activities that support one of these roles, the others will lose interest and move on.





I think it would be cool to have the type of thing you just proposed in the game.


I think that would probably cause some Entertainer tostart bugging the full-templatecombatants to take them to all the dangerous palces so they can do the side quests! I bet some of the combatants would rather enjoy the challenge/attention it would get them





- Neeill Orkaorchi, Elder Entertainer/Elder Musician, Intrepid
- Nai'ren, Trader, Intrepid
- ATK and enjoy your day

Drop Off Vendor: FOE Canyon, Talus (4408, 2199)

Arrogance is unavoidable. The trick is to find an arrogance you can live with
Petronela
Fri Jul 15, 2005 4:25 am
#11



Ok, first of all I have absolutely nothing against Bards. In all the games I have played, which had Bards as a playable class, they were always my favorites. Hell even my EQ2 main character is a Troubadour.


However, converting Entertainers into Bards would be a very bad move due to many reasons of which two I see as main. First of all, it wouldn’t fit the game at all. And second of all, this game already has a class which fulfills Bard’s role. They may be called Squad Leaders but essentially they are Bards, they have all the traditional roles usually associated with Bards.


Our class needs a LOT of help from Dev team, but “going Bard” would be a totally wrong direction in my opinion.




~Deli'ah~
Sylow
Fri Jul 15, 2005 5:35 am
#12






However, converting Entertainers into Bards would be a very bad move due to many reasons of which two I see as main. First of all, it wouldn’t fit the game at all. And second of all, this game already has a class which fulfills Bard’s role. They may be called Squad Leaders but essentially they are Bards, they have all the traditional roles usually associated with Bards.




Check this:







Profession: Entertainer


  • Added a New Dance - Bunduki (an interpretive dance from the planet on which the Teras Kasi fighting style originated)

  • Added a New Song - Swing

  • Add new particles to the old healing branch

    • New dance particles:

      • Center Stage

      • Color Swirl

      • Dance Floor


    • New music particles:



      • Featured Solo


      • Laser Show


      • Fire Jet 2

  • Exotic flourishes now function properly.

  • Battle Fatigue is no longer acquired and entertainers can no longer heal it.


    • Entertainer's and elite professions' skill branches have been reworked to accommodate these changes.

    • Merged the modifiers and abilities of Squad Leaders into the now unused branches of Musician's Wound Healing and Musician's Fatigue Healing.

    • removed the Squad Leader profession

    • respec tokens are issued to anybody with Squad Leader abilities in their current build

  • Add NEW dance props to old healing branch

    • Staff


    • Sword


    • Sparkler


    • Glowstick


    • Torch


    • Ribbon


    • Double Ribbon


    • Mystical Ribbon


    • Double Mystical Ribbon


    • Sparkle Ribbon


    • Double Sparkle Ribbon


    • Also, at novice dancer or higher, dancers can dual wield props.




Any more questions? *grin*







Learn to sing!
Infinity - Papyn Biboon
MSL, MCarb Grunt Leader
Cuit
Fri Jul 15, 2005 7:09 am
#13

quick question . . . Master Dancer used to give combat bonuses to defense . . . havent checked in a while but . .are they still there? If it is . . this mod kinda puts entertainers in a combat view . . . which would indicate a change in CL


granted this has nothing to do with the pro/antin bard topic . . it is about combat mods for entertainers.





Bis Cuit

pre NGE:
FormerTKM, Master Swordsgirl, brawler 4/4/4/0, scout 4/0/4/0, nov CH
Jedi Paddy unlocked 11/13/05, 11:00 pm est
Master Dancer - retired 9/18/05

I like shiny things ^_^
Page 1 of 3
Previous Next