Entertainer Archive

Thread: My Favorite Recursive Macro Is In Peril?

MarinhaTiga
Wed Aug 25, 2004 2:24 pm
#1

I'm sure people have beat this horse into the ground many times but I have been away from the game for quite awhile, so please forgive me. That being said, I just returned to find out that recursive macros may be going away. At first I thought "hey that's great, no more afk dancers and musicians" and then i thought about it a bit more.


No matter what the devs do, people will find a way to play afk. I remember reading a post from thunderheart where he even mentioned something along those lines. The people that created these afk buffbots aren't going to just drop the accounts, they're still going to use those characters to get buffs whenever they want in a place that is more convenient for them. Recursive macros may be going away, but those buffbots arent going away anytime soon.


Why do I even care about this? Well the answer is a silly one but it's an answer that's just as valid as any other. I haev this recursive macro that equips a new Grand Ball Gown every 2 seconds in the following order. It looks something like this-

Red

Orange


Orange

Yellow


Yellow

Green


Green

Blue


Blue

Purple


Purple

Red


...and then they cycle all over again. The colors on the Grand Ball Gown look like they are flowing up, it's a really neat effect and something i get alot of comments on. I could always just make my macro a bit longer to do this but I would still have to activate it and it would stop being a neat attraction and it would become a hassle. Kinda selfish I know but my little rainbow dress switching routine is something that I enjoy in the game and it's also something that makes me stand out a bit more.


The same thing can be said about flourishing I suppose, to me and many other people..... pressing F6 over and over again is not my idea of a good time. I'd rather spend that time talking to the customer or chatting with the group. Surely I cant be alone.


So what else could be done to combat the afk buffbot situation? Nerf recursive macros.... that's an easy fix and typical from what i've come to expect. But what if we left the recursive macros in the game but gave a bonus to at the keyboard play? Create a dialog box between the customer and client similar to the Image Designer interface. The entertainer could select a button and the customer would have to select the same button to get a BONUS to the buff. The buttons on the customer and client interface would randomize each time to combat 3rd party button clicking devices. It would then be in the customer's best interest to seek out an at the keyboard entertainer to get the best buff available. This isn't totally my idea, I read a post once from one of the devs that said something very similar to this.


Maybe the bonus could be a time increase plus extra HAMI dont really know, I just hope that other alternatives are considered.


Thanks for taking the time to read my whine



Marinha Tiga
Master Image Designer
Master Dancer
Master Entertainer
Musician 0-0-3-0
Artisan 0-0-0-4
Ikewe
Wed Aug 25, 2004 2:34 pm
#2

Well you might be in for a bit of a surprise. There is now a delay in changing clothes if you are skill animating. It was initially announced as a delay in changing armor and weapons in combat but it also affects entertainer costume changes. Unless you add in a smoke bomb effect you will for a brief period be dancing in your underclothes rather than a colorful gown.


Ikewe, Master Dancer



Ikewe, Master Dancer, Shadowfire
When you wish upon a falling star, your dreams can come true. Unless it's really a meteorite hurtling to the Earth which will destroy all life. Then you're pretty much hosed no matter what you wish for. Unless it's death by meteor.


MarinhaTiga
Wed Aug 25, 2004 2:38 pm
#3






Ikewe wrote:

Well you might be in for a bit of a surprise. There is now a delay in changing clothes if you are skill animating. It was initially announced as a delay in changing armor and weapons in combat but it also affects entertainer costume changes. Unless you add in a smoke bomb effect you will for a brief period be dancing in your underclothes rather than a colorful gown.


Ikewe, Master Dancer







Well my macro equips a new dress every 2 seconds and I am never seen in my undies. I've been doing this for the last 3 days (since i've been back) and havent had any trouble at all while either dancing or playing music. /shrug




Marinha Tiga
Master Image Designer
Master Dancer
Master Entertainer
Musician 0-0-3-0
Artisan 0-0-0-4
Ranalla
Wed Aug 25, 2004 3:42 pm
#4

Speaking as one of the folks that have seen her Rainbow dress (I had to check my settings the first time I saw it, to be sure they where ok) it is a really cool change effect. Like MarinhaTiga (big waves) I hope the recursive macro doesn't go away.


I just feel they keep nerfing and nerfing every thing into there is only one person left in the game. And then were is the fun in that? Cantina's now seem like they where in the old days (I played SWG when it frist came out and left for a while when the nerfs came down hard the first time) Folks talking and laughing, Joking with one another or just being quiet. I can only hope they don't mess with the macro to much because if they do I'll just take my 30 bucks and go to another game.
Metis_Onea
Wed Aug 25, 2004 6:01 pm
#5

From the Stratics chat:


Brekkee - *Rennio{Flurry}* "With the proposed removal of looping macros, will entertainers still be able to use /ui action toolbarSlot00 loops in order to communicate with customers, or will they still be forced to keep repunching short macros? The removal of looping macros solves our buff bot problems, but limits us in the customer service we are allowed to provide to patrons.
TH - *Rennio and to everyone who is concerned about recursive macros, we are not going to remove the /ui macro commands. We are going to use a different method to encourage people to play "at the keyboard". Removing those basic abilities for players to use the GUI command would be a huge inconvenience and we dont want to do that.





Festila Ravo
Retired Enterainer
Voted Best Image Designer of 2003
Miss Kauri Galaxy 2004
Bye-bye Photo!
Xyrdre
Wed Aug 25, 2004 6:50 pm
#6






Ikewe wrote:

Well you might be in for a bit of a surprise. There is now a delay in changing clothes if you are skill animating. It was initially announced as a delay in changing armor and weapons in combat but it also affects entertainer costume changes. Unless you add in a smoke bomb effect you will for a brief period be dancing in your underclothes rather than a colorful gown.


Ikewe, Master Dancer







There is no delay on clothing changes that I've noticed, either on live servers or on TC. Armor and weapons changes are going through the combat queue, clothing items are not. I have severalquick-change hotkeys using multiple garments in each, and none of my testing has resulted in delays. Just be careful that your outfits don't contain more than one item that's classified as armor, and there should be no problems.


That said... if someone is having clothing changes go through the combat queue resulting in delays, could you provide specific information about whatgarments are experiencing delays so that I can do some further testing on these things?






Deila Karlossi , Blue Glowie of Dancers, and become more powerful than you could possibly imagine...
FuschiaD
Wed Aug 25, 2004 9:43 pm
#7

Marinha, I have to make a series of these dresses and try this... I bet the visual effect is absolutely awesome.




~*~ F U S C H I A D A R K W A L K E R ~*~
Yes, I'm a respec Jedi. Get over it.
~*~ A V A D I H A L O N A - S O E P ~*~
Entertainer For Life - COMPNOR Eye Candy

"You don't really rank around here unless you've been flamed by Oben, trolled by Mono, set straight by Geen, got caught in a love triangle between Cherry and Anoq, had your house decorated by Kipera, hugged by Esin, fondled by Fuschia, had IG respond with something inane and nonsensical, or at the very least been (a.) asked "can I have your stuff" or (b.) been accused of being a Todd by any number of random Tarquinian posters." --TalonKarrdeTN/Tyndaleon


Ikewe
Thu Aug 26, 2004 6:07 am
#8


There is no delay on clothing changes that I've noticed, either on live servers or on TC. Armor and weapons changes are going through the combat queue, clothing items are not. I have severalquick-change hotkeys using multiple garments in each, and none of my testing has resulted in delays. Just be careful that your outfits don't contain more than one item that's classified as armor, and there should be no problems.


That said... if someone is having clothing changes go through the combat queue resulting in delays, could you provide specific information about whatgarments are experiencing delays so that I can do some further testing on these things?



Hmm once again I feel so ...special... that I am experiencing a feature that others don't... Any way,, I just tested again to be certain I wasn't losing my mind and here's what happened:


If Ichange from a one piece outfit (skinsuit, jumpsuit, fleshwrap, gown, etc..) into a two-piece outfit (leather pants with sportswrap or low cut top for example) then for a brief moment people will see first my underwear and then my bra. I did verify that one person in my group also saw the delay so that I know it's not just my system. I see no delay if I change from a one piece to a one piece or a two piece to a two piece or from a two piece to a one piece. And no I am not using any armor pieces in my costume changes- no ubese armor shirts for example.




Ikewe, Master Dancer, Shadowfire
When you wish upon a falling star, your dreams can come true. Unless it's really a meteorite hurtling to the Earth which will destroy all life. Then you're pretty much hosed no matter what you wish for. Unless it's death by meteor.


Tiaga
Thu Aug 26, 2004 6:24 am
#9

When going from 1 piece to 2 piece, you can only put one thing on at a time, and putting the first on takes the whole 1 piece off, leaving you half naked. If you throw on a Robe of Honor or Double Robe, you can hide this.



Inside my heart is breaking, my make-up may be flaking
But my smile still stays on
My soul is painted like the wings of butterflies
Fairytales of yesterday will grow but never die
I can fly - my friends
SWG Entertainer.com Fashions by TK

fett3041
Thu Aug 26, 2004 12:47 pm
#10

Folks, once again, they're not getting rid of your favorite macro. Just making it so it won't loop. You can still adjust your macro to make it last a good chunk of time. And then, a friend of mine had these suggestions:


"Make a macro that's decently long, then have it send yourself a /tell when it's done that says "restart the macro" and hit the key again.
You can also have the macro do /echo to put up a message on your screen, or use "/alarmaddin h m message" at the beginning of the macro to sound an alarm when the macro has finished."


So, you can still have that beautiful effect, can still flourish, can still converse with your friends and patrons.


I admit this isn't the BEST cure to stop unattended gameplay (buffbots, lootwhores, etc.), however, it IS at least SOE admitting there is a problem, and taking a step to fix it. Perhaps down the road, we'll have a better fix. Just think of this as a quick fix.






Mo'Ste Elosk
Mo'Set Elosk
-----------------------------------------
May the Force grant us
the Wisdom to discover the Right,
the Will to choose it,
and the Strength to make it endure.
mochloD
Thu Aug 26, 2004 3:42 pm
#11






fett3041 wrote:

Folks, once again, they're not getting rid of your favorite macro. Just making it so it won't loop. You can still adjust your macro to make it last a good chunk of time. And then, a friend of mine had these suggestions:







I have seen mar's crazy dress and its really sweet. If youll reread her post again you'll see that she acknowledges the fact that she could just make the macro longer and just simply reactivate it when its time, but thats not the point.


Thefact some people have purchased a second account and created a buffbot for their own personal use or guild use, is not a good enough reason to get rid of creative macroes like this one (or make them less convenient).


Im a TKM and I dont even run the recursive center of being macro so this doesnt really bother me one little bit. But man, i'm sure there are tons of macroes out there like this one that add a little spice to the game that shouldnt be hindered because of some afk buffbots. I've always had a policy that i dont tip an entertainer unless they hold a conversation with me, many other people are the same. I have a good time messing around in the cantina and starin at the pretty ladies with their skimpy clothes on so i want people to be at the keyboard, i ignore the afk people when i can. Sometimes though I cant ignore the afk people because often, theyre my only option.



  • There are a few problems with recursive macroes, camping on a loot spawn is one of them. Why dont the devs just take out the /loot command and make people drag the crap into their inventory manually? solves that problem.

  • There used to be a problem with afk merchant spam but now we can stop afk chat from being seen in our spatial window plus there is always /addignore.

  • Another major problem is the afk entertainers WHO ARE HOLOGRINDING, next tuesday these people are done with the cantinas (end of the hologrind) and they may actually be fun and full of active people again. Like Mar said, its a better idea to wait and see if the death of the hologrind is enough to fix the sitiuation first instead of taking something very useful out of the game.

  • The people who bought another acount wont be just forgetting these accounts, they created a musician or dancer for their own needs and they wont stop using them, they dont need to be in two places at once to buff another character.

If the above bullet points are all correct (and come on, you know they are), would getting rid of recursive macroes be the answer to any problem that we are currently experiencing or would it just take away something from others?


(i said my piece for ya mar, now im going back to beating the snot out of things)





mochloD'tmos
Order of Teras Kasi
~ Teras Kasi Master ~
~ Shock Trooper/Heavy Infantry/Trickshot/Medic ~

Ikewe
Fri Aug 27, 2004 10:35 am
#12

When going from 1 piece to 2 piece, you can only put one thing on at a time, and putting the first on takes the whole 1 piece off, leaving you half naked. If you throw on a Robe of Honor or Double Robe, you can hide this.


I seem to be unable to put even the first piece on without first being in my underwear. For example, instead of seeing me change from a dress into a pair of pants and bra before the top appears, you see me in my underwear and bra. Then you'll see pants and bra and then finally I get to put my shirt on. I know I'm a dork but surely I can put one item of clothing on without being in the buff first Ah well, people like the smokescreen clothing change so I'll keep using that.



Ikewe, Master Dancer, Shadowfire
When you wish upon a falling star, your dreams can come true. Unless it's really a meteorite hurtling to the Earth which will destroy all life. Then you're pretty much hosed no matter what you wish for. Unless it's death by meteor.


Amythen
Fri Aug 27, 2004 11:01 am
#13






MarinhaTiga wrote:


I just hope that other alternatives are considered.





I am pretty sure that all of the options have been considered by the development team. We have given them probably hundreds of ideas how to deal with the problem of AFK playing. The loss of recursive macros is a very small price to pay to get back a lively game all around. It is not solely about buffbots, not even just about entertaining. Its about people taking advantage of a perfectly good macro tool and exploiting it for their own gains. There are legitimate uses of recursive macros that we will lose. Yet, the accumulation of losses still does not out weigh they gain of a game that is far better off in the end.




    =-- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --=

Adolai Danst - Dead Man Walking & Master Musician / Master Entertainer / Master Artisan

Page 1 of 2
Previous Next