Droid Engineer Archive

Thread: So, now what do YOU want to do?

TheWoody
Thu Mar 04, 2004 4:11 pm
#1

I said a few weeks ago that we should prepare for this. Told everyone that we were going to have to demand more than they were handing out to us. Now, I think, would be the best time to rekindle the plan.


It may soon be time to lean on the Devs once again, and to do the population will need a clear consise voice. Therefore, here's my proposal.






TheWoody proposal for a short-term DEenterprise




1) let it be realised that critical bug fixes have first priority.



2) Several forum rules will have to be adopted and mandated. If they don't then we lose coherency and the overall message will be lost. As such, we must


a) Agree to accept the decisions of the community as a whole. We'll take a vote on the various core matters of the community. Once a majority consensus has been reached we must agree then to keep dissention to a minimum. We're all intelligent people (DE, by its very hardship nature, tends toweed out 733ts and idiots), and for once we must put our trust in each other. You may not personally feel that a direction is the best direction but if the majority took a look at it and feels differently, then it must be asked that you move on. Making sure that nothing happens is far worse than letting a lesser issue continue to slip (remember our buglist anyone? how long since that changed)


b) Once we set up a coherent forum random flames on the Devs must stop. if we want them to listen we have to beat thim with logic, not insults. If/When we do have the overwealming desire to speak out (like right now) then we must do it intelligently and with fact, not hatred.


c) Realise that things are going to get uglier before they get better. We won't be getting everything we want (it is far too late for that) so now we must work to get at least something constructive out of this situation.



3) We'll have to vote soon on how to decide where to focus the efforts. Here's the way I see it (though you're welcome to post your thoughts in here on how to best proceed): bug fixes first (no question). Second, we vote on:


a) whether to demand double the amount of utility modules they are promising for publish 8 (someuseful thingsat a minimum) or


b) keep the the current utility that is planned (entertainer/barker/covert blocker) and get some medium combat droids in the DE profession trees, turning this into a hybrid profession.


c) continue complainingas we are wont to doand hope that the Devs will come through.


Now, we're not voting here (this is just an example of what I think the first vote should be on). If you have other thoughts on what we should vote on first, post them here.



4) threats are the absolute last resort. We are here to work together, not try and scare devs into doing something. With that said, we'll be looking into new avenues of communication and campaigning, as the old ones must be failing us or something.






So, now, what do YOU want to do? All I'm proposing is that for one month we are nice to one another. After March it'll be too late to do anything anyway (in fact it'll probably be less than that). I think we can do it, but it'll take just a little sacrafice on your part. But being DEs, I think we're used to that anyhow.



-------------------------------------------------------------------
"Never in the field of forum posting has so much bollocks been said to so many by so few"
duncje
Thu Mar 04, 2004 4:32 pm
#2






TheWoody wrote:


So, now, what do YOU want to do? All I'm proposing is that for one month we are nice to one another. After March it'll be too late to do anything anyway (in fact it'll probably be less than that). I think we can do it, but it'll take just a little sacrafice on your part. But being DEs, I think we're used to that anyhow.





Woody:


We tried this. We got nothing. Granted, random personal attacks on Devs and each other won't get us anywhere, but did you see any Dev posts in the DE forum when we weren't full-on complaining? I didn't. If we don't make our voices heard, we'll keep getting "misinterpreted" by the Red-Names.


In the words of I-don't-know-who: "I'm sick and tired and I'm not gonna take it anymore."





Beebo
Master Droid Engineer | Shipwright | Master Artisan
Crazy Beebo's Discount Droids & Ships {-1075 -2924} Bestine, Tatooine

TheWoody
Thu Mar 04, 2004 4:37 pm
#3


I'm not saying we sit down and stop arguing.. I'm just saying we stop arguing with each other. We have less than a month left, and if you want to bicker the entire time and let the Devs do whatever the hell they like then go right ahead. Otherwise, sit down and stop arguing with me!.... oh wait. er,...


(seriously though, propose how to proceed then. the way I see it is we can kick and scream with one single loud voice at the Devs, or we can throw up a thousand lesser incoherent voices and hope for the best. If you know how to proceed otherwise though, we'll go with your plan)


Message Edited by TheWoody on 03-04-2004 03:40 PM



-------------------------------------------------------------------
"Never in the field of forum posting has so much bollocks been said to so many by so few"
TheRealTK421
Thu Mar 04, 2004 4:44 pm
#4






TheWoody wrote:


the way I see it is we can kick and scream with one single loud voice at the Devs.






That singular 'voice' is supposed to be Drashk, if I'm not mistaken.


They always tell us to work through our Correspondent.....don't they?



/bow

Respectfully,




TheRealTK421 a.k.a. "Doughbacca"
SWG DE Correspondent
Co-Founding member of Ahazi DENet & SWG DEA (Droid Engineer Association)
"I think all right-thinking people in this country are sick and tired of being told that ordinary, decent people are fed up in this country with being sick and tired. ...I'm certainly not. And I'm sick and tired of being told that I am."


duncje
Thu Mar 04, 2004 4:49 pm
#5


Edit: I hit submit before I typed anything


Anyway, I guess I wasn't thinking clearly the first time through the post. We do need to collectively scream, but we need a direction in which to focus. There is a huge problem here: The Devs have no idea how DE should fit into this game. Until they decide this, we have no idea where to focus our collective intelligence. They haven't given us one shred of "This will work...", we've gotten a ton of "No extra checkers".


I want one question answered: What is the purpose of DE in this game?


If that question gets answered, I'll be on board with your Focus plan.

Message Edited by duncje on 03-04-2004 04:54 PM



Beebo
Master Droid Engineer | Shipwright | Master Artisan
Crazy Beebo's Discount Droids & Ships {-1075 -2924} Bestine, Tatooine

TheWoody
Thu Mar 04, 2004 4:50 pm
#6

I'm not saying a single voice in terms of a single person, I'm saying a single voice in terms of hundreds of people saying the same thing. Has a slightly greater effect.


Though I have to ask, is the correspondent system working? If it were, why have none of our questions about publish 8 been answered through Drashk, and why does TH still have the 'Deer-in-the-headlights' look on his posts when reading our proposals for more utility modules?



-------------------------------------------------------------------
"Never in the field of forum posting has so much bollocks been said to so many by so few"
TheWoody
Thu Mar 04, 2004 4:59 pm
#7

I'll see what I can do about getting the question answered matey. May take a philosopher, a priest, and a bottle of vodkatodeduce the truth of the matterthough



-------------------------------------------------------------------
"Never in the field of forum posting has so much bollocks been said to so many by so few"
Kilarny
Thu Mar 04, 2004 7:26 pm
#8






duncje wrote:


Edit: I hit submit before I typed anything


Anyway, I guess I wasn't thinking clearly the first time through the post. We do need to collectively scream, but we need a direction in which to focus. There is a huge problem here: The Devs have no idea how DE should fit into this game. Until they decide this, we have no idea where to focus our collective intelligence. They haven't given us one shred of "This will work...", we've gotten a ton of "No extra checkers".


I want one question answered: What is the purpose of DE in this game?


If that question gets answered, I'll be on board with your Focus plan.

Message Edited by duncje on 03-04-2004 04:54 PM






/sit back at table next to Duncje


/pointat Duncje; /agree


/bang head on table

Aeneus
Thu Mar 04, 2004 7:31 pm
#9

awww come on... all I want to do is come home have some fun playing DE... realize we are screwed as a profession and come in here and make a few innocent comments... I do try to be funny about it- or maybe thats the beer that makes it seem funny- weird, this game does drive a person to drink



Glory to the Empire
Shian_Tavkin
Thu Mar 04, 2004 8:41 pm
#10

It seems to me that the biggie needs to be revisited again.


Hybrid or not ?


Then, and only then can we be united (supposing always that the poeple who dont get their way will fall in line.)


Now, we had misleading questions before, so the answers were very ambiguous. Then everyone with an agenda made out the answer supported their camp. As with all Polls, the devil is in the wording of the question.


So, now we know the Devs have programming and artwork ready, and we have a very small window of opportunity (if at all)..what is it to be?


Mediocre development over 2 whole publishes....OR something a little more earth shaking.


I personally cannot get excited over what is proposed, and it sure as hell doesn't come close to the Chef Revamp in terms of added content. We WILL be in the wilderness after these 2 publishes, so for me it's now or never.


So, thats my 2 cents...and to be honest I don't really care what happens so long as something does. Then at least I will know if I should stay or just close up shop.


Depressed really does not come close to how I feel.


The only saving grace I see is that Runesabre is listening..and if nothing else that should make a difference.





Shian -- Master Droid Engineer/ Master Artisan
Lonkley
Thu Mar 04, 2004 10:54 pm
#11

i would still prefer droids for everyone, but failing that.


hybrid would be preferable. It fails less than what we're getting and a lot less than droid handler.


so woody if we're all going to agree on a message, what do you propose is the message?






----------------
There is a special place in hell for necro posters
Sodan-droiddreamer
Thu Mar 04, 2004 11:51 pm
#12






Lonkley wrote:

i would still prefer droids for everyone, but failing that.


hybrid would be preferable. It fails less than what we're getting and a lot less than droid handler.


so woody if we're all going to agree on a message, what do you propose is the message?




I agree with Woody's plan.


My proposal:


1. bug fixes


2. Hybrid: Medium combat droids in one skill tree with a small bonus at master. Dabbler's can dabble and we can sell to them. No risk of CH pet nightmares, becuase of much lower CL lvl for a DE that is 0040.




Sodan Droiddreamer (GEGN)
Sodan's Exotic Droidgarten - In Bohemian Grove (Geigen Shuttle), Tatooine (6156 7275)
Sodan-droiddreamer
Fri Mar 05, 2004 12:35 am
#13

Lets do the math on a potenial Hybrid DE variant. I hate math. If I am wrong in my calculations pls correct them, rather than flame me. This is only one possible configuration, but is grounded in skillpoints and balance by comparison to CH.


It takes takes 77 skillpoints to be a 0044 CH. That gives you +36 max pet lvls and +4 stored pets among many other skills including taming etc. We will focus on the pet lvls only.


Under my hybrid proposal, all droid levels will be in the 0040 tree except for a small bonus at master. DEs -- from novice to master -- will be able to craft the droids and modules they can craft according to DE lvl as usual. To take advantage of the droid certs in the DE tree (0040)however, a DE must have at least one lvl 4 brawler or lvl 4 marksman skill. This reflects a bit of combat knowledge making combat droids appropriate for an otherwise crafting class.


It costs 29 kill points to get one lvl 4 branch in either marksman or brawler. It costs 49 skillpoints to get to 0040 in DE. Thus, under my proposal, a dabbling Hybrid DE would have to spend 78 points to get 0040 DE and a lvl 4 tree in marksman or brawler. In exchange for that skillpoint expenditure the Hybrid DE dabbler would get +35 Droid Lvls and +4 stored pets.


Under my proposal, DEs who care only for crafting may do so and prograss as if combat droids did not exist. Hybrid-minded DEs would get some combat droids to play with AND DE dabblers would get +35 in droid lvls and would also make up a substantial marker that both crafter and hybrid DEs couls sell to.


Some dabblers will want to sell and will no doubt impact our market. Query whether they will have any lidum extrusive ore or any of the new required resources. Also, 0044 DEs might create a market for more components since they will have only certs and blueprints. And if they have more than 0044 they're starting to be real DEs and they should be welcomed to the club. However, we can assume that most dabblers will want to go 0040 DE and a combat class like Master Pistoleer or whatever. The point is they will want to spend points at being good in combat and with 0040 they will NOT be making their own droids.


Dabblers will need droid stims, wound packs and the best combat modules credits can buy. We will sell these to them.


Crafters can craft all they want and never have to pick up a gun. Hybrid DEs can enjoy crafting on occasion and hunting as well. And best of all, my proposal does not dish out more checkers than can be purchased by a CH who spends 77 skill points to become a 0044 CH and gain 36s pet lvls.


This proposal avoids giving DEs free checkers; prevents non-combatants from other crafting professions (or newbies) from getting pet lvls without skills; gives a combat droid and droid stim market; allows combat minded DEs who spend the points access to the droids they love; and allows others to dabble and enjoy droids.


That is the bulk of my initial proposal, on top of this proposal I suggest that MDEs get +5 droid lvls for being MDEs, but we can debate this "perk". (MDEs still need one lvl 4 tree in brawler or marksman to use combat droids).


Pls respond in the spirit of Woody's call for decorum on this forum -- constructively.



Sodan Droiddreamer (GEGN)
Sodan's Exotic Droidgarten - In Bohemian Grove (Geigen Shuttle), Tatooine (6156 7275)
Page 1 of 2
Previous Next