Droid Engineer Archive

Thread: Did I get taken?

Icarus-6
Tue Oct 07, 2003 1:40 pm
#14

Stacking modules isn't an exploit (as near as I can tell). It take multiple slots to max out the ability, preventing you from making the LE 110 Medical/10 Storage/Chemical Crafting droid. In fact it says somewhere in game (I think under the description of the modules in the skill boxes) that modules can be stacked for greater effect.

That said, I won'r comment on the price but he should have told you up front that you were only going to get 6 items. Even when I make a droid that will store 10 items I make sure to tell people before hand so they aren't assuming it will store 50 items and be disappointed. Likewise I make sure people getting data modules know they only store schematics.

While it is the buyers responsibility to be informed it is also the seller's responsibility to make sure they are informed.




Tallin Rose
Master Droid Engineer
Starsider

At Tallin Industries we strive ever day to up our standards. Now, up yours.



-Stinky
Tue Oct 07, 2003 3:50 pm
#15

No, you weren't taken.



You failed to specify your exact requirements. That is not the engineers bad, that is in your ball court. There are two sindes in communication, the speaker and the listener. As the speaker, the owness is on you to insure your point was made. It is the listeners responsibility to listen with intent and ask for cvlarification when they are unsure.



And the price seems reasonable to me.



=D




Stinky, Master Smuggler ` Master DE `
Colonel - Imperial Army
General, SoL - Sect of Laereth
Wanderhome

Custom and BH droids.
Nailliar
Tue Oct 07, 2003 5:13 pm
#16

Sorry, mis-stated my reasoning, since he purchased a LE Repair droid which only has 2 General Socket slots, a droid with 3 modules installed would be an exploit..ie.. using a Cluster module in a General socket module, they are named explicitly for the intended installed module. Stacking modules in the intended module slots is designed as stated in other threads to a DE the option to make a higher functional droid at the Expense of using the additional slots for something else. That is the point of becoming a master, the top items only require one slot to reach the functional cap, whereas a novice DE would have to stack modules using more slots to achieve the same functionality. etc etc ramble blah blah blah....



Rialia Darkstar
"You have failed me for the last time, SOE"
Nailliar
Tue Oct 07, 2003 5:24 pm
#17

Gah, I feel like Madcat here or something, but are you guys/gals seeing that he bought just a Standard Le Repair droid and paid 30K for that?


Sorry, that is Way too high compared to what most of the top masters on Intrepid are charging for that range of Droid. Std. Le Repair only has two general sockets, requires No specific resources, No advanced parts, No factory parts, and is only a BluePrints 3 requiring 400 resources .


If you can get 30K for that, thats you're deal I guess, but I've priced out many my peer's shops and even the high ones don't sell for that much. Or was there a Droid Union meeting I wasn't told about to fix prices?




Rialia Darkstar
"You have failed me for the last time, SOE"
Gron_DM
Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:11 pm
#18

if the droid was a r2 adv i could have all that with lvl 4 mods. and i sell those for 28k....so maybe a little





Vilance -Retired from SWG
MDE for most of it, Guildleader as well
EGC Founding leader August 03
Corbantis
Founding Mayor Of Rhuidean, Tatooine
placed Nov 03.
Nailliar
Wed Oct 08, 2003 12:09 am
#19

IMO you got taken, sorry, but that seem high even for Intrepid, especially for non-master components. If you were sold a standard LE Repair droid withstacked modules, then the DE was using an Exploit, or a Broken feature if you like. Additionally I don't think storage works in conversational droids, but I honestly havent built anything other than surgicals & adv.surgicalsto test it out and it definitley doesnt work on those.



Rialia Darkstar
"You have failed me for the last time, SOE"
ajag
Wed Oct 08, 2003 1:53 am
#20

First of all, I am BH who visits this DE forum all the time in order to see when you guys will get fixed and hopefully be able to make nice kickass Battledroids so my knowledge about droids is very limitted. However, last monday I bought an R2 droid (intrepid server) with: clothing/armor crafting station, medical chip (110 to medic), repair module, storage module and a data module for 20k. I dont know how it goes, but I think I got a good price for my droid. I do not have the 10 for storage but hey, got 5 modules intead.


AJAG




AJAG
<SToD> - Teamspeak Ninja
I'll kick your... *Player left*
SToD

-I support the wholesale slaughter of Rebel terrorists...You can too!

aerofool
Wed Oct 08, 2003 7:58 am
#21

Well, I would say yes and no.


You did get what you asked for which was a droid with item storage. If someone asks me to make one for them and does not specify capacity, I usually build the best single lvl item storage module I can make.


As for price, you got jipped on both your droids. Your lil' R5, I usually sell the exact same droid for 8200 and the LE with that exact storage, medical rating and desired crafting station for only 10100. My advice to you is to shop around next time. Check out all the droid shops on the global map and talk to your in game friends about how much their droids run them. Also, be speciffic when ordering a droid. make sure you specify every detail from storage capacity, medical rating AND armor to make sure you get what you desire.




Z

Valcyn Server
Xygnis
Wed Oct 08, 2003 8:21 am
#22

Could someone please explain to me why using a socket cluster in a general service module is a bug? This seems perfectly normal to me. In fact I think it actually says that it fits general sockets. It's really simple, The Socket Cluster IS a general service module, that happens to accept more modules. If the reason people think its a bug is because some schematics have a slot specifically for the socket cluster, to me that means that it's just being more specific, kind of like requiring Extrusive Ore instead of just general Ore.


I don't see this as a bug, in fact, I would be very dissapointed if it worked any differently than it does currently. Just my opinion.





-----------------------------------------------
Ackoma Omipie - Masada, Naboo (Valcyn)
Master Droid Engineer
Master Artisan
Master Merchant
Novice Pistoleer

------------------------------------------------
Ackoma Droidworks
Ackoma Mining
Icarus-6
Wed Oct 08, 2003 10:35 am
#23


Nailliar wrote:

Gah, I feel like Madcat here or something, but are you guys/gals seeing that he bought just a Standard Le Repair droid and paid 30K for that?




It is almost a certainty that he purchases and Advanced LE Repair droid. Consider that the person making it was not an MDE but somehow got the Medical Rating to 110 and the Storage to 6 items. While it is possible he had a Med VI module crafted by another DE it is more likely that he simply used 2 Med IV modules and one storage IV module. That's 3 modules which would require an Advanced LE (if memory serves me correctly. SWGCraft is down and the game is being patched so I can't check).

It is possible that the DE used a General Service Module Cluster, but at that point he could have used two, one in each slot and the droid would have had 110 Medical and 10 item storage, so I find that unlikely.




Tallin Rose
Master Droid Engineer
Starsider

At Tallin Industries we strive ever day to up our standards. Now, up yours.



Icarus-6
Wed Oct 08, 2003 10:41 am
#24


Xygnis wrote:

Could someone please explain to me why using a socket cluster in a general service module is a bug? This seems perfectly normal to me. In fact I think it actually says that it fits general sockets. It's really simple, The Socket Cluster IS a general service module, that happens to accept more modules. If the reason people think its a bug is because some schematics have a slot specifically for the socket cluster, to me that means that it's just being more specific, kind of like requiring Extrusive Ore instead of just general Ore.

I don't see this as a bug, in fact, I would be very dissapointed if it worked any differently than it does currently. Just my opinion.




It is a bug because otherwise it actually makes a R2 unit -less- effective than an R4, which I am sure everyone can agree is wrong.

The reason it does this is because an R4 has 2 general service module slots. If those accept General Service Module Clusters than your R4 can be loaded with up to 6 modules (not including nesting exploits). An R2 on the other hand can only accept a single GSMC, limiting it to 3 modules.




Tallin Rose
Master Droid Engineer
Starsider

At Tallin Industries we strive ever day to up our standards. Now, up yours.



Icarus-6
Wed Oct 08, 2003 2:21 pm
#25


Xygnis wrote:
...Could someone please explain to me why using a socket cluster in a general service module is a bug?...

...I can't say I buy that as an answer.




You say 'Why is it a bug'?

I say, 'Because it obviously is working in a way not intended (making R4 units more powerful than R2 units)'.

You say 'I can't accept that as the answer. They should alter the schematics for other droids'.

Why can't you accept it? Is there a flaw in the logic? I point out that this appears to be what they intended because it makes sense. If they alter how this one thing works then what they have created has a certain logical consistency. Your response is you can't accept that answer and that they should alter the stats on all the droids.

Which seems more likely, that the function of a module is off (GSMCs going into General Service Module slots) or that the stats on most of the droids is messed up?

As for your suggestion that they just give the better droids more module sockets, let's see how that plays out. Since you have the ability to put 1 module into an R5, how many modules would you need to put into an Advanced R3 to keep progression between the various models (assuming you gain a single module per 'step up').

R5 - 1 module
R4 - 2 modules
R2 - 3 Modules
R3 - 4 modules
Advanced R3 - 5 modules.

Hmmm....So I load all those slots up with GMSCs; 15 modules in a single droid. Nope. Doesn't seem like an acceptable solution.




Tallin Rose
Master Droid Engineer
Starsider

At Tallin Industries we strive ever day to up our standards. Now, up yours.



Xygnis
Thu Oct 09, 2003 12:08 am
#26

I can't say I buy that as an answer. If that's the only reason it seems to me that the solution would be to change the R2 so that it had normal module slots, not to change the socket cluster so that it didnt work in them.



-----------------------------------------------
Ackoma Omipie - Masada, Naboo (Valcyn)
Master Droid Engineer
Master Artisan
Master Merchant
Novice Pistoleer

------------------------------------------------
Ackoma Droidworks
Ackoma Mining
Page 2 of 2