Doctor Archive

Thread: Why the hostility towards the Docs that crafted the buffs/stims that you use?

Zulu_Dawn
Sun Apr 03, 2005 5:45 pm
#1

Just curious as to why the majority of the posters on thisforumappear to have such a negative opinion of the people that crafted & sold buffs/stims for a living.


A Chef/AS/WS/(insert crafting profession) does exactly the same thing, makes a product & sells it at a profit.


Why is/was it wrong fora Docto do the same with buffs/stims?


*Disclaimer - Yes, I know I can pickup the med crafting line of BE and craft 'enhancers/stims' post-CURB.





Zulu Dawn - Merchant/ex-BE/ex-12pt Doc
Vendors at 156 -5516 Coronet & 5899 4699 Mos Vegas
Please offer auction winnings to the Buffpacks vendor in Coronet
TarMangani
Sun Apr 03, 2005 6:40 pm
#2






Zulu_Dawn wrote:

Just curious as to why the majority of the posters on thisforumappear to have such a negative opinion of the people that crafted & sold buffs/stims for a living.


A Chef/AS/WS/(insert crafting profession) does exactly the same thing, makes a product & sells it at a profit.


Why is/was it wrong fora Docto do the same with buffs/stims?


*Disclaimer - Yes, I know I can pickup the med crafting line of BE and craft 'enhancers/stims' post-CURB.




I don't believe that to be the case, and I'm a crafting doc. I think you'll find most people are antagonistic against what they label "buff-bots" and the ever-so-stereotypical "people who went doc just to get rich."


In reality there really aren't that many "buff-bots." As in people who only enter the game and buff all the time...As a doc who has done his share of buffing, it gets very, very boring quickly, and the 12-15K you may be making per buff really doesn't seem as worth it when you consider your time wasted.


Now if they're speaking of the AFK buffer, well that's another story. As for me, I see nothing wrong with a player who sets up his toon in a house and offers a buff service. I see some frustration with those who setup camp at a starport and buff using a macro and are AFK, but again, I can't say that the majority of docs do that either, though they do exist.


People believe that the AFK macro style of healing is the downfall of the profession, (hence the reason for the change). To some like My_T Chicken, even afk tumblers and the like are cheaters... it just depends on your interpretation...


To the puritanical style of healer, the CU is their dream come true. The look upon the crafting and buffing doctors asobjects of scorn or pity, and say things to us like "well if you want to craft, just go BE!" However what they're really saying is "find another profession, you no longer have any place within our noble ranks..." They put quotes around our words when the quote us when we call crafting or buffing a play style, as if the very idea of such a thing were foreign to them.


The CU has produced it's own fair share of frustration, flaming, glee and all other areas of the spectrum...It's to be expected...


However in the end the combat healer playstyle wins out. The devs are forcing a re-org of the professions and we players simply need to pick up the pieces and move on...





JEYHREL FOXAUMER
Iconic Profession Nomad
Because sometimes being ruthless just isn't good enough...
Aspraven
Iconic Trader or soon to be cancelled account
Saving you money so you'll give more of it to me...
Vendors: 200, -3200, SUNS Mall, Kor Mesa, Corellia



Zulu_Dawn
Sun Apr 03, 2005 6:57 pm
#3

I wasn't referring to afk(or not) buff-bots.


I'm asking why a 'crafting' Doctor is seemingly a second-class citizen in the Doctor community.



Zulu Dawn - Merchant/ex-BE/ex-12pt Doc
Vendors at 156 -5516 Coronet & 5899 4699 Mos Vegas
Please offer auction winnings to the Buffpacks vendor in Coronet
TarMangani
Sun Apr 03, 2005 7:13 pm
#4






Zulu_Dawn wrote:

I wasn't referring to afk(or not) buff-bots.


I'm asking why a 'crafting' Doctor is seemingly a second-class citizen in the Doctor community.







I don't see that as being the case. The debates I'm having is that, to the healers, we crafting docs have to move to BE which we don't want to do. The healing docs are pretty much saying "tough S**T, life's a B****H.


They're right of course, it IS a B****H where the CU is concerned...


Do you see something besides that?




JEYHREL FOXAUMER
Iconic Profession Nomad
Because sometimes being ruthless just isn't good enough...
Aspraven
Iconic Trader or soon to be cancelled account
Saving you money so you'll give more of it to me...
Vendors: 200, -3200, SUNS Mall, Kor Mesa, Corellia



Zulu_Dawn
Sun Apr 03, 2005 7:30 pm
#5






TarMangani wrote:






Zulu_Dawn wrote:

I wasn't referring to afk(or not) buff-bots.


I'm asking why a 'crafting' Doctor is seemingly a second-class citizen in the Doctor community.







I don't see that as being the case. The debates I'm having is that, to the healers, we crafting docs have to move to BE which we don't want to do. The healing docs are pretty much saying "tough S**T, life's a B****H.


They're right of course, it IS a B****H where the CU is concerned...


Do you see something besides that?







No I don't see anything else.


I'm just suprised at the hostility from somepeople on this forum towards those of us who crafted (such as myself & yourself) and who stand to lose that ability as part of the CURB.





Zulu Dawn - Merchant/ex-BE/ex-12pt Doc
Vendors at 156 -5516 Coronet & 5899 4699 Mos Vegas
Please offer auction winnings to the Buffpacks vendor in Coronet
TarMangani
Sun Apr 03, 2005 7:44 pm
#6






Zulu_Dawn wrote:


No I don't see anything else.


I'm just suprised at the hostility from somepeople on this forum towards those of us who crafted (such as myself & yourself) and who stand to lose that ability as part of the CURB.




Well for the crafters, it is a big thing to complain about. For the healers, they're taking the "let's make the best of it and I'm excited about this" approach, and we crafters and buffers are raining on their parade.


This is a major shift for the profession too. Think about it, the doctor forums are no longer going to have ANY sort of crafting questions. The questions will be solely about healing and the like. To me that will make the doctor boards kind of boring to a degree, and I think you'll be finding subects will remain on the first page of the forum without needed to a /bump... but that's only speculation...





JEYHREL FOXAUMER
Iconic Profession Nomad
Because sometimes being ruthless just isn't good enough...
Aspraven
Iconic Trader or soon to be cancelled account
Saving you money so you'll give more of it to me...
Vendors: 200, -3200, SUNS Mall, Kor Mesa, Corellia



gibsonSG
Mon Apr 04, 2005 2:51 am
#7






Zulu_Dawn wrote:


No I don't see anything else.


I'm just suprised at the hostility from somepeople on this forum towards those of us who crafted (such as myself & yourself) and who stand to lose that ability as part of the CURB.







You probably noticed a few posts from those that only bought meds and never made them. I crafted as a non-commercialself-sufficient doc and always found the crafting posts the most informative.


I learnt a lot about crafting from all the threads here, shame they killed doc profession and turned it into a nurse. Group healing is one major aspect of the game, not the be-all and end-all of doctor. Can't believe they killed doc, Im gutted


/salutecraftingdocsofswg


You will be missed



Pembroke Castle <Dominus Nihil>
Panthu
Mon Apr 04, 2005 4:50 am
#8






SinfulDoom wrote:

lol, thats funny. Never looked at the future of the boards in that way.

What did you do today?

I healed a group of 6. What did you do?

I healed a group of 8.

Ah, cool. well, cya tomorrow.




Oh yeah, because real Healer gameplay isso boring thatthere is nothing to talk about other than how many were in your party. *rolls eyes*


Personally, I can't wait till this forum is full of chat about healing strategiesand whines about squishy damage dealers that run away from you and tanks who go nuts and ag more than you can heal them through, lol. Real Healer strategy and chat is fun! Most people would expect to find that on a Healer board... not more crafting talk. *shrug*


I'm not hostile towards crafting Docs, but I'm glad for the move to Healer play personally. The ones that really have my sympathy are the ones like Texxie, who are worried about the loss of downtime rewards and social spaces. That is a unique thing in SWG Doctors have always been tied to and I hate to see that slipping away... but the crafting? Pfft, won't be missing that.




P A N T H U Y GlitterUsagi
M i n d B o d y S p i r i t
Dancer ImageDesigner Doc

MyT_Chicken
Mon Apr 04, 2005 6:49 am
#9






TarMangani wrote:





Zulu_Dawn wrote:

Just curious as to why the majority of the posters on thisforumappear to have such a negative opinion of the people that crafted & sold buffs/stims for a living.


A Chef/AS/WS/(insert crafting profession) does exactly the same thing, makes a product & sells it at a profit.


Why is/was it wrong fora Docto do the same with buffs/stims?


*Disclaimer - Yes, I know I can pickup the med crafting line of BE and craft 'enhancers/stims' post-CURB.




I don't believe that to be the case, and I'm a crafting doc. I think you'll find most people are antagonistic against what they label "buff-bots" and the ever-so-stereotypical "people who went doc just to get rich."


In reality there really aren't that many "buff-bots." As in people who only enter the game and buff all the time...As a doc who has done his share of buffing, it gets very, very boring quickly, and the 12-15K you may be making per buff really doesn't seem as worth it when you consider your time wasted.


Now if they're speaking of the AFK buffer, well that's another story. As for me, I see nothing wrong with a player who sets up his toon in a house and offers a buff service. I see some frustration with those who setup camp at a starport and buff using a macro and are AFK, but again, I can't say that the majority of docs do that either, though they do exist.


People believe that the AFK macro style of healing is the downfall of the profession, (hence the reason for the change). To some like My_T Chicken, even afk tumblers and the like are cheaters... it just depends on your interpretation...


To the puritanical style of healer, the CU is their dream come true. The look upon the crafting and buffing doctors asobjects of scorn or pity, and say things to us like "well if you want to craft, just go BE!" However what they're really saying is "find another profession, you no longer have any place within our noble ranks..." They put quotes around our words when the quote us when we call crafting or buffing a play style, as if the very idea of such a thing were foreign to them.


The CU has produced it's own fair share of frustration, flaming, glee and all other areas of the spectrum...It's to be expected...


However in the end the combat healer playstyle wins out. The devs are forcing a re-org of the professions and we players simply need to pick up the pieces and move on...






Again I wish you would stop pointing fingers at me like everything happening is my fault just because I realize the potential of the changes. And next time you use my name I would appreciate it if you spelled it correctly.





h Egri p
§ If you don't know; you'll find out soon enough! §

SinfulDoom
Mon Apr 04, 2005 12:56 pm
#10

lol, thats funny. Never looked at the future of the boards in that way.

What did you do today?

I healed a group of 6. What did you do?

I healed a group of 8.

Ah, cool. well, cya tomorrow.





Quality Stims*Meds*Cures*CM Products

KOBO Industries (-1675 2500 Naboo)

V 12 pt. Master Doctor V 11 pt. MasterCMV

Kobo Doomshadow President



- I support keeping & playing the game I purchased prior to the CU. I'm just another Victom of the CU. Dev's are like diapers, they need changed often for all the same reasons. R.I.P. SWG
Jalinsol
Tue Apr 05, 2005 11:40 am
#11






TarMangani wrote:


I don't believe that to be the case, and I'm a crafting doc. I think you'll find most people are antagonistic against what they label "buff-bots" and the ever-so-stereotypical "people who went doc just to get rich."





I went doc to get rich. Now I own a mansion and a yacht! ~ ~


Sorry, just felt like some levity needed to be interjected. Have some Serotonin.





Jalinsol Apollyon
Prodigal Exile (PE)
12 Point Chef - Teras Kasi Master
Exodus, Lok (Radiant) -- Moving to City of Exile, Tattoine, near 300, -4000
Vendors at -580, 4800 on Lok
SinfulDoom
Tue Apr 05, 2005 7:28 pm
#12

Panthu wrote:


Personally, I can't wait till this forum is full of chat about healing strategiesand whines about squishy damage dealers that run away from you and tanks who go nuts and ag more than you can heal them through, lol. Real Healer strategy and chat is fun! Most people would expect to find that on a Healer board... not more crafting talk. *shrug*


lol, Ok. Give me some strategy here. If the person I am healing is taking damage should I wait till they are down to 1/2 life or should I wait till they are down to 1/4 life to heal em? Or since the timer on my heal is "X" amount I should wait "X" amount before I should try to heal them again? Was that good strategy? I know what you can do if you want whiners crying about a lack of heal now. Go to Tat and wait for a few new player to enter the game, group em up and go kill rancors. You will determine all the healing strategy you ever wanted from that encounter.


Interesting that this is a "Doctor" board and not a "Healer" board. Until the day comes that they remove crafting from doc's your gonna have to live with crafting talk. I guess the alternative is to ignore any post with "Crafting" in the name.




Quality Stims*Meds*Cures*CM Products

KOBO Industries (-1675 2500 Naboo) Starsider

V 12 pt. Master Doctor V 11 pt. MasterCMV

Kobo Doomshadow President





- I support keeping & playing the game I purchased prior to the CU. I'm just another Victom of the CU. Dev's are like diapers, they need changed often for all the same reasons. R.I.P. SWG
SinfulDoom
Tue Apr 05, 2005 7:57 pm
#13


maybe I was a little to harsh there. I will fix my former post.



What did you do today?

I healed a group of 6. I went with a group of6 to hunt rancors. I kept the tanks healed while the ranged professions cleaned up.

What did you do?

I healed a group of 8. I went with a group of 8 to hunt NS Elders. I kept the tanks healed while the ranged professions cleaned up.

Ah, cool. well, cya tomorrow.





Quality Stims*Meds*Cures*CM Products

KOBO Industries (-1675 2500 Naboo) Starsider

V 12 pt. Master Doctor V 11 pt. MasterCMV

Kobo Doomshadow President




- I support keeping & playing the game I purchased prior to the CU. I'm just another Victom of the CU. Dev's are like diapers, they need changed often for all the same reasons. R.I.P. SWG
Page 1 of 2
Previous Next