Dancer Archive

Thread: Bots do more good than harm

Naish
Thu Aug 05, 2004 9:05 am
#1

Most players in the game like buff bots. It's a good service, if it wasn't my toon wouldn't constantly be busy and people wouldn't tip us 10 to 20K per buff. We will be missed, and when you guys get bored with dancing and playing music. When that happens the combat professions will miss us even more.

In the overall scheme of things we do way more good than harm. I wish more bot owners and bot customers were aware of the topics on this board and would speak up.

I'm in here talking about this with you guys in the interest of my customers and the customers of my fellow bot owners. I don't want them to go away and neither do my customers.

I hope that, at the least very least, my voice will been heard by the Devs. And if I'm lucky, I'll help them make the right decision. The right decision is to keep the macros and keep the bots.



Support your local ATK Entertainers
Sigrun
Thu Aug 05, 2004 9:09 am
#2

No. Buff bots do more harm than good.


They discourage people who want to be Entertainers from frequenting Cantinas. Stated differently, they discourage people who want to play the game from playing the game.


You do not *need* entertainer buffs to enjoy the game. You can achieve the same or better buffs using food and/or spice.


Buff bots need to go.


Now if you're referring to TH's more generic post re crippling looping macros, THAT I'll agree is a mistake. It won't solve the problem and it willamplify other problems in the game.




Ingame Names: Sif @ Bria, Chilastra, Flurry, Naritus, Starsider | Hiordis @ Kettemoor | Freya @ Tempest
Quotable: It's pretty freaking underwhelming when the story turns out to be you, alone, in a field, for two weeks, punching toads. | At least SOE lasted a year before they went Turbine on us.
Naish
Thu Aug 05, 2004 9:13 am
#3

PVP is a perfect example. If you want to last more than a few seconds in an even PVP battle, you you have to have Food, Drink, Spice, doc buff and mind buff from entertainers.

So, yeah, you need to have a mind buff to enjoy the game sometimes.



Support your local ATK Entertainers
Schardour
Thu Aug 05, 2004 9:14 am
#4

I was rather successful for many months PvPing as a Rifleman / Commando and Rifleman / CH without buffs and without armor. Losing every once in a while never took the fun out of the game.




T
IL KISMETA

lTlSlCl
A life spent making mistakes is not only more honorable,
but more useful than a life spent doing nothing.
XzXzXzXzX
Also...Tayel [PLD]

Naish
Thu Aug 05, 2004 9:18 am
#5

As far as discouraging people from becoming entertainers, imagine grinding to master dancer or master musician without macros. Are you kidding me!!!

I've grinding master dancer 3 times and master musician 3 times. Every single time, there is like 1 or 2 guys that stay on and take turns being leader so that the group stays full. Every other person is AFK running an auto join macro, auto heal macro and auto flourish macro.

Talk about discouraging people from becoming entertainers.

And BTW, I do spend time at my keyboard as well. I help loads of people with training. I make instruments for people. I help people make sure they are maxing their XP.



Support your local ATK Entertainers
Sigrun
Thu Aug 05, 2004 9:19 am
#6






Naish wrote:
PVP is a perfect example. If you want to last more than a few seconds in an even PVP battle, you you have to have Food, Drink, Spice, doc buff and mind buff from entertainers.

So, yeah, you need to have a mind buff to enjoy the game sometimes.





If that's true, that indicates the need for better combat mechanics, not for buff bots. I'm not sure it's true. Several of my guildies participate frequently in PvP and do reasonably well, even when they're not buffed by entertainers.




Ingame Names: Sif @ Bria, Chilastra, Flurry, Naritus, Starsider | Hiordis @ Kettemoor | Freya @ Tempest
Quotable: It's pretty freaking underwhelming when the story turns out to be you, alone, in a field, for two weeks, punching toads. | At least SOE lasted a year before they went Turbine on us.
Naish
Thu Aug 05, 2004 9:20 am
#7



Schardour wrote:
I was rather successful for many months PvPing as a Rifleman / Commando and Rifleman / CH without buffs and without armor. Losing every once in a while never took the fun out of the game.





Well you wouldn't be successfull any more. Go try it out if you don't beleive me and do yourself a favor, get cloned and try not to spend too much on your doc buffs.



Support your local ATK Entertainers
Naish
Thu Aug 05, 2004 9:25 am
#8

I'm constantly fighing groups of people that have mind bars over 3500 and extremely high regen stats. People with maxed mind stats that they then stack buffs, food, drink, spice and powerboost on. They can spam specials all day, and regen almost immediately when they get hit.

You have to have it. Especially now with the new doc buff resists against poison and disease.

Combat balance will always be an ongoing thing. PVP templates are constantly changing. When changes are made it takes almost no time at all for people to figure out the next best template.



Support your local ATK Entertainers
Osawa_Scylla
Thu Aug 05, 2004 9:27 am
#9






Naish wrote:
I've grinding master dancer 3 times and master musician 3 times. Every single time, there is like 1 or 2 guys that stay on and take turns being leader so that the group stays full. Every other person is AFK running an auto join macro, auto heal macro and auto flourish macro.

Talk about discouraging people from becoming entertainers.

And BTW, I do spend time at my keyboard as well. I help loads of people with training. I make instruments for people. I help people make sure they are maxing their XP.




They're discouraging people from becoming entertainers who entertain while AFK. They're not taking away macros. They're just changing macros so you have to hit the button periodically. They're making it so you can't go off to sleep and leave yourself logged in to master a profession while you're not even playing the game.


They're encouraging players to actually play the game, instead of writing macros to let it play itself.


Osawa





Osawa Thabri, Master Dancer, Scylla
Osawa Thabri, Master Dancer, Bria


Elhana
Thu Aug 05, 2004 9:28 am
#10

Strangely enough without buffbots people can still get entertainer buffs, then again even if they couldn't you'd all be in the same boat so wheres the problem?



Val'rel Shia
Master Tailor & Master Dancer
Part of [The Firm] Superstore 1200m west of Mos Entha [80 x 3254]
Chimaera
Sigrun
Thu Aug 05, 2004 9:30 am
#11






Naish wrote:
I'm constantly fighing groups of people that have mind bars over 3500 and extremely high regen stats. People with maxed mind stats that they then stack buffs, food, drink, spice and powerboost on. They can spam specials all day, and regen almost immediately when they get hit.

You have to have it. Especially now with the new doc buff resists against poison and disease.

Combat balance will always be an ongoing thing. PVP templates are constantly changing. When changes are made it takes almost no time at all for people to figure out the next best template.






This still indicates a combat mechanics problem.


And you can still get buffs from *gasp* live *gasp*Entertainers if buff-bots do get eliminated. You'll just have to ask them more or less politely for the buffs and maybe even give them some token of appreciation for enabling you to enjoy the game more fully.





Ingame Names: Sif @ Bria, Chilastra, Flurry, Naritus, Starsider | Hiordis @ Kettemoor | Freya @ Tempest
Quotable: It's pretty freaking underwhelming when the story turns out to be you, alone, in a field, for two weeks, punching toads. | At least SOE lasted a year before they went Turbine on us.
Vorpaks
Thu Aug 05, 2004 9:31 am
#12

Naish, you do realize that combat is already considered too easy? The combat balance is supposed to address that. Any buffs, at this point, are unbalancing the game anyway - why get people to depend on them? If they meant people to fight constantly buffed, constantly wearing CoB etc. they would have just built it into they system.

All these people who depend on buffs to fight and consider them "necessary" to their profession are going to be VERY upset when combat is rebalanced and most of them will quit I think. Why continue to wreck three entire professions to benefit people who will be quitting anyway? Its mind-boggling to me.

Eight months of dealing with hordes of afk players and bots have not convinced the Entertainment community that their profession is just as enjoyable as it was before. I doubt any of the current posts on the boards at this moment will do so. All they are doing is making a lot of people VERY unhappy and making the Entertainers even MORE vocal in their dislike of buffbots. Noe bots are to blame not only for ruining the experience in-game, they are responsible for ruining the forum experience as well. You are not going to garner support for bots using your current methods.

EDIT: Damn. Ignore doesnt work like that. I thought I could ignore all the threads I didnt want to look at. Anyone know if there is a way to do this?

Message Edited by Vorpaks on 08-05-2004 12:32 PM

Message Edited by Vorpaks on 08-05-2004 12:35 PM



Paks
Master Ranger/Master Creature Handler
-I support ATK play

Schardour
Thu Aug 05, 2004 9:32 am
#13

You play smart, you don't power your way through the fight. That's going to get you killed. I can tell you that I've never intentionally rushed headlong into a buffed and armored opponent when moving about declared. Chances are, I would have died much more than I did. I recognize the importance of mind buffs, but the disease and poison resists that will now be available reduce the threat of CM's draining your mind pool. If nothing else, that argument supports the idea that mind buffs aren't absolutely necessary to enjoy the game. There are plenty of ways to be victorious without them. They're a bonus, I agree, but a comfort that should be paid for, just as a PSG and composite armor is.




T
IL KISMETA

lTlSlCl
A life spent making mistakes is not only more honorable,
but more useful than a life spent doing nothing.
XzXzXzXzX
Also...Tayel [PLD]

Page 1 of 8
Previous Next