Combat Medic Archive

Thread: CMS IMBALANCED YES OR NO? vote here

Wispxrush
Sat Mar 20, 2004 7:56 pm
#1

Yes or NO? Please vote!



ELYAS MACHERA
Rifleman/Combat Medic
Imperial Colonel
a.k.a Gas Chucker

maddogs
Sat Mar 20, 2004 8:07 pm
#2

depends on how tour asking that


i think you mean


are cms over powerd


then the answer is yes



===============================================================


Daniel' Judson-Leonheart

Rchuno
Sat Mar 20, 2004 8:36 pm
#3

WT F mate? You can't vote on a power scale.


I would say no.


look our DPS is lower than any other Combat profesion (barring the venum that spawned for 2 days)


We have no Defense Mods


We spend tons of money on our components


So to balance it out we get to hit every time... yeah realy unbalancing


If you want to complain about balance then nerf us but for goodness sakes everyone else has to spend 1 credit minimum for every point of damage they deal.



****************************
* Niccaurra {} Master DOC / Aspiring Merchant
*Niqe {DRUNK} TKM/Pist
****************************
maddogs
Sat Mar 20, 2004 10:07 pm
#4






Rchuno wrote:


If you want to complain about balance then nerf us but for goodness sakes everyone else has to spend 1 credit minimum for every point of damage they deal.






try a commandos RL you pay 50x that much



===============================================================


Daniel' Judson-Leonheart

kimirahi
Sat Mar 20, 2004 10:51 pm
#5

Yes, 800 tick area poison has ruined pvp



AOnokoA
Rchuno
Sat Mar 20, 2004 11:00 pm
#6

Thats a dang nice poison if I may say so. Cost the guy at least 500 every time he throws one. Unless it was venum enhanced then you must realize that those will become incredibly rare soon. 100 DPS realy isn't that out of line with everyone else. Sure Comando is gimped but we only do our DOT we don't have another attack. If you don't have a CM who is healing the mind of your side you have CMs that are too selfish. with Muon, brandy, milk, dancer buff I can heal peoples minds all night long, (well only non-stop for like 10 minutes) If you don't have docs to heal you, you shouldn't be PvPing. Not my fault your docs aren't smart enough to clear all the poisons. Oh and BTW the CM had to sit there for 4 seconds doing no movement while the animation runs. So if you were paying attention you could have caught them and killed their non-defended arse.



****************************
* Niccaurra {} Master DOC / Aspiring Merchant
*Niqe {DRUNK} TKM/Pist
****************************
maddogs
Sat Mar 20, 2004 11:24 pm
#7






Rchuno wrote:
Thats a dang nice poison if I may say so. Cost the guy at least 500 every time he throws one. Unless it was venum enhanced then you must realize that those will become incredibly rare soon. 100 DPS realy isn't that out of line with everyone else. Sure Comando is gimped but we only do our DOT we don't have another attack. If you don't have a CM who is healing the mind of your side you have CMs that are too selfish. with Muon, brandy, milk, dancer buff I can heal peoples minds all night long, (well only non-stop for like 10 minutes) If you don't have docs to heal you, you shouldn't be PvPing. Not my fault your docs aren't smart enough to clear all the poisons. Oh and BTW the CM had to sit there for 4 seconds doing no movement while the animation runs. So if you were paying attention you could have caught them and killed their non-defended arse.





try 1k every time you fire ensted of 500 commandos have that proplem with RL and they only hit one target


and as for a doc in a group of 20 ya most smart pvp have 2 in a group of 20 but when this cmcan attack your hole group and your tring to take out a base


your all within 20-40 m now thats atlest haf of you group posion or dised including your docs


the docs have about 30 secs befor every singel one of thos guys gos incap or has no mind and with realy good posion it can take a doc 2 trys to remove the possion or dises on just one guy now you may be abel to stop this 2-3 rounds


and even kill the guy every time but he just clones and come right back and dose agen


but after 5 times your all black mind and incapand he just mops up


this one guy just killed 20 ppl




and ya he stands there for 4-8 secs casting his dedly crap and ya he dies but he dont care he come right back and in the end he wins



no other profesion can pull stunts off like this







===============================================================


Daniel' Judson-Leonheart

CaanonWeathers
Sun Mar 21, 2004 12:13 am
#8

Yes. For PvP CM is the "I win button" and I wish to see it stop being pushed.




---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Petra Zorski - Starsider
Cecelie - Kettemoor

ZenTripper
Sun Mar 21, 2004 2:25 am
#9

Not my fault your docs aren't smart enough to clear all the poisons. Oh and BTW the CM had to sit there for 4 seconds doing no movement while the animation runs. So if you were paying attention you could have caught them and killed their non-defended arse.






You couldn't possibly PvP with a statement like this!


As for DPS being the lowest, I am wondering if that is fact. This happened to me in PvP just this evening


-----------------------Mind-------Focus-------Willpower

Base----------------+800-------+125--------+450

Moun---------------+500-------+500--------+500

V Brandy(x2)-----+820--------+820--------+820

Ent Buff--------------------------+250--------+450

PowerBoost-------+400-----------------------------


Total------------- +2520 ------ +1695 ---- +2220


I got mind incapped. I was with a team of 9 people. Guess what 70% of them got incapped from. Ya, you guessed it mind poison/disease. I lasted the longest which was probably a full minute 30secbecause of my stacking on the mind.


YOU DO NOT PvP. No way, no how. Your statements are absolute fabrication. I never saw the CM that applied the poison on me nor anyone else. It happened so fast when blaster fire and 20 peeps are running around with AT-ST and pets, there is no way to keep track of the cowardly CM that area poisons and runs.


Not to mention if your lucky you have 30 secs before you incap in PvP cuz you also take fire from everyone else.


People are sick of hearing the DPS whine. You fail to mention its on the ONLY pool that cannot be healed reasonibly and is not subjected to the 75% PvP dmgreduction.Once you are mind poisoned you know your going down. Its that simple.


Imbalanced = YES
ArkanIrami
Sun Mar 21, 2004 3:04 am
#10






PinheadDoC wrote:

You choose your stradegy You pick your defense and then you die.... By the hands of the Combat Medic.. Keep up the great work Guys.. You guys bring balance to the I am going to group TEF Kill everyone with my defesive template all day long.. and i am not smart enough to bring a doc to cure me......


Combat Medics rule..


My vote is NO




Don't try to play combat medics as the solution to stackers, combat medics are the solution to everything. 800 tick area poisons are very real and getting more common by the day. Even with 2 docs in a group of 10, a cm will be able to mind incap them all,the docs will not be able to keep up with the constant mind poisons and disease barrage.




Arkan Irami, Retired MSF Co-Leader
CMMaster
Sun Mar 21, 2004 3:13 am
#11

Commandos dont have to use RLs, and is not their only form of fire...


Combat Medics in grou pvp imbalalnced = yes only due to LoS bugs and ranged bugs if those were removed imbalanced = no


Combat Medics in general imbalanced = No





Don't Bother______________
Masta' Shake
I really have no more witty statements to say anymore about this damn game

maddogs
Sun Mar 21, 2004 3:37 am
#12

look at thees and tell me if there imbalenced


http://www.imagedump.com/index.cgi?pick=setandget&tp=52800&poll_id=0&category_id=20&warned=y


http://www.imagedump.com/index.cgi?pick=get&tp=52801







===============================================================


Daniel' Judson-Leonheart

Loonytic
Sun Mar 21, 2004 3:45 am
#13






ZenTripper wrote:

You fail to mention its on the ONLY pool that cannot be healed reasonibly and is not subjected to the 75% PvP dmgreduction.Once you are mind poisoned you know your going down. Its that simple.








and finally we come down to the real problem... The mind pool which I'd like to addis being resolved
Page 1 of 4
Previous Next