Chef Archive

Thread: Poll: Would a 5% Resource Bonus be good for chefs?

HanBaby
Sat Aug 27, 2005 1:22 pm
#1

I would be for it as well but most of the food and drinks now that are bought like spiced tea/blob candy are artisan made items. So would be nice to see something for all food or drink crafted items.



All auctions can be dropped at my vendors in Aviano, Rori.
Max's Food and Drink Vendors -6144,4760 Aviano, Rori
Used to enjoy being jedi in this game now just waiting for the next Combat Downgrade!
audioslaves
Sat Aug 27, 2005 1:45 pm
#2

/shrug


Do I think it would be fair to the other profs? Nope. Especially artisan. Do I like the devs being reminded that our profession is more diverse and complicated than others? Nope, because I certainly don't think we should be invitiing the nerf bat our way to make things "easier" like they've done to other profs.


I don't think one specific profession should get a higher buffs than others just because it can "handle" it in the minds of some people.


Does it matter to me personally whether or not we get the 5% buff? Meh, kinda done caring either way.




Lark

Lark's Heavenly Food and Drink
-108 -5530 Coronet and -3899 4890 Theed
Current Menu: Semi-stocked
HEXCORP Stims Weapons Clothes Armor etc
"I don't know where bin Laden is. I have no idea and really don't care. It's not that important. It's not our priority." - GWB

Higginsis
Sat Aug 27, 2005 1:51 pm
#3



audioslaves wrote:

/shrug

Do I think it would be fair to the other profs? Nope. Especially artisan. Do I like the devs being reminded that our profession is more diverse and complicated than others? Nope, because I certainly don't think we should be invitiing the nerf bat our way to make things "easier" like they've done to other profs.

I don't think one specific profession should get a higher buffs than others just because it can "handle" it in the minds of some people.

Does it matter to me personally whether or not we get the 5% buff? Meh, kinda done caring either way.






Obviously thats up to them. But this asking on whether we would want one. Thats all.

Not commenting on the fairness of us only having one (as thats not what i'm really asking for) but frankly as the WS and AS communities have stated quite cleary they don't want it, and other have been half and half i don't see why the profs that would benefit from the extra % get left out because it would hurt others. The way the buffing system has been set up with each prof getting a seperate buff it makes sense that % can be tailored to the needs of each profession.

Bare in mind i'm not promising if i do ask for this, we'll get it, i just want to know if asking for it is what the community wants. After thats what my job is, to rely what the community as a whole is doing.



Higginsis Great[REJEK] : Solicitation Expert
Bum Sexing-Crixx- until until he gives up...

audioslaves
Sat Aug 27, 2005 2:13 pm
#4

I don't know. I don't even get why artisans only get 1%. A lot of artisans that actually sell artisan items (except for foods) tend to be pretty new to the game. So how did this idea of "helping" noobs go to actually hurting them in a sense? I was against the 10% buff because it seemed unfair to me, but the 1% artisan buffs seems just as unfair in the other direction... /sigh. And yes I know artisan isn't an "elite" profession.


I think that asking for a higher buff for chefs is just opening another can of worms. All chefs will never agree. Then, on top of that, folks in other profs will be like HEY WHAT ABOUT US. So, dunno.




Lark

Lark's Heavenly Food and Drink
-108 -5530 Coronet and -3899 4890 Theed
Current Menu: Semi-stocked
HEXCORP Stims Weapons Clothes Armor etc
"I don't know where bin Laden is. I have no idea and really don't care. It's not that important. It's not our priority." - GWB

Strategiry
Sat Aug 27, 2005 3:16 pm
#5

Well personally I think the 2% buff is better, (Although I have no real desire to see any resource quality buff, it just adds yet another step to crafting...), since others have previously stated that since chef resources depend on multiple stats, it would be very difficult to cap out at 100%. And I agree with the fact that if chef does get a bigger buff, we will hear the cries of nerf! nerf! nerf! from other professions.


In my dream world, I would have no resource buff...but I prefer 2% to 5% atm.



Fory Tavira -
Member of MEGACORP

G'luv-12pt Master Chef
G'luv's Fancy Food and Drinks now at Theed Mini Mall!(-5318, 3401)
[The MEGACORP Menu (Taking A Break)]
(PM or E-mail Fory or G'luv with any Chef request!)
phant0mTA
Sat Aug 27, 2005 5:21 pm
#6

i think 5% is reasonable and it will help chef foods to get a step up on artisan foods.



pha'ntom


OldManDog
Sat Aug 27, 2005 5:39 pm
#7


It's Simple ~ YES 5% for Chefs, 4 Stats on resorces, whether it's icing on the cake or not, It seems alot harder these days to get icing on cake than it is to get on armour.



Chef vs Artisan food is a hot issue and should have been resolved before an issue of who gets better insperation buffs. IMO





$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

Opie76
Sat Aug 27, 2005 5:51 pm
#8


I'm in favor of the 5% buff for Chefs also. I feel that the Devs need to do something to give Chefs an edge again.



-Avenir

jfarr
Sat Aug 27, 2005 6:01 pm
#9

im also for the 5% bonus




Gannonn
-MaCeR-
Sat Aug 27, 2005 6:06 pm
#10

WOOT 5% plus the million perfect resorces that eerif is going to talk the DEVs into giving all chefs might pull some of us out of retirement.



/rofl Yea right!


Lets see a 200% bonus on Chef Food Duration so thatit can compete, as the lower filling @ lower cost foods aredominating the market.




Macer
Retired Master Chef "12 points"
Quemine
Sat Aug 27, 2005 7:35 pm
#11

No... no.. no...


I don't like 10% buff... I don't like 2% buff.. certainly don't like 5% buff either..



Sure, we got many lines to experiment on, but there's always one line that dominates the others. So there's really no difference from our profession than the WS in my opinion...


I can think of so many other buffs that would help us all in a better way than this one.. schematic complexity reduction for example.. mhhm.. yummy..



Quemine Aweron / Caeron Auger
NWW Ranger
Medical Resources, Components, Supplies, Food & Drinks Vendor
Vesania, Corellia, 4639 -6000
MeciniaLua
Sat Aug 27, 2005 8:42 pm
#12

I think 5% would be good for us.


We mostly have 4 lines to experiment on ( 3 in a few cases ) which means I don't think we'll see anyone get 100% in all categories.


I think 5% would be a help, not a hindrance to chefs. I don't seefolks turning out perfect foods with 5% ( or even the original 10% the devs had put forth )





-Wanderhome- Mecinia, Mecinea
-Intrepid- Yovi
-Radiant- Enoorea, Bienurdau
Collected Expansion Ideas and Game Upgradesi


"There is no emotion, there is peace; There is no ignorance, there is knowledge; There is no passion, there is serenity; there is no choas, there is order;There is no death, there is the Force" from the Jedi code.
Higginsis
Sun Aug 28, 2005 12:17 am
#13

I was going to suggest to the devs that as our crafting is wildly different from AS and WS (the main people who had problems with the Ent buff as they were) if we could have our prof specific one bumped up to a 5% bonus. Now i know i'd be happy with it, and i know a couple people here would, and a couple really rather wouldn't.

So lets lay it out. Should i suggest a 5% Resource buff for our Specific Ent buff, or should it be left at the blanket 2%?



Higginsis Great[REJEK] : Solicitation Expert
Bum Sexing-Crixx- until until he gives up...

Page 1 of 4
Previous Next