Carbineer Archive

Thread: Wepons Rating / Comparision

TAfirehawk
Fri May 07, 2004 8:21 am
#14






Subedeimatt wrote:

@TAfirehawk


Don't take this the wrong way as I've no intention of picking holes in your post, quite the contrary: I think there's somehing going wrong with my DPS calculations and I'm *edit*ed if I can see where the problem is and hope you can help. You posted you do 2,500 DPS with cripplingshotusing the DH17. Speed mod of +84. I make that DPS of 1,972 using a damage modifier of 7.5 (taken from the excellent stickey on the subject). Any ideas where my calculation's going wrong here? For reference, I'm calculating DPS as (((Min damage+Max damage)/2)*7.5)/Actual Firing Speed. In this case I make your AFS as 1.04.


Any help you could give would be great as I'veexpanded my spreadsheet to include DPS taking into account of Ranged Mitigation and hope to add armour rating etc to fathom exactly how much damage is being done in PvP (likely not much but would be nice to put an actual figure on it). Anyway, if I've got the basic calcs wrong the rest is much use!!


Any help you could give would be great, and sorry all this going off-subject.







No, you are absolutely correct. The only thing I can figure is that I was running my numbers with powerups, as the actual weapons have them right now, but for clarity sake here I posted them without. My bad, with 32/16 Max/Min powerup the DPS is 2513.


My main point here was the new DH17 is 25% than my old one which was/is pretty sweet



On the spreadsheet thing, remember the PvP reduction too And it is wise to have a target's resistance in there as well.





Iebas Feania
Former Correspondent of the Former Profession, CARBINEER

Lihpson
Fri May 07, 2004 8:58 am
#15

My speed mod is a weak +69


Enhanced E11 krayted/FFS (damage slice)


125-300 spd 1.9


Enhaced E11 kratyed/FFS (speed slice)


100-245 spd 1.3


Laser Carbine (Krayted w/ visable stock, scope, and barrel)


*this thing looks like a bis ass rifle!!!


95-459 spd 3.2



I refuse to buy elite's and DRX6's because of speed issues.





********************************************
Gihpson
Master of Polearms
Personal Motto: "The more the better!"
Theme Song: "Burnin Ring of (mind) Fire"!
Doq_Utek
Fri May 07, 2004 10:23 pm
#16

It's made with +96 tissues (I think) and stocked. I'm pretty sure I got a 27% damage slice on it. I payed 1.5M for the gun and tipped the smuggler 25K for the slice of the laser, dxr6 and the ee3 (all got damage slices over 25%).



Doq Utek Master Carbineer
fs911
Sat May 08, 2004 12:08 am
#17

This is addressed to Doq Utek. I'm just curious of the worth, in dollars, of that EE3 Krayt Carbine. Thats exaclty what I want.


FleshShintai


Bounty Hunter 0400


Carbineer 4404


Ranger 0040





soklam moonwaver
Godswarrior493
Sat May 08, 2004 7:12 pm
#18

Sorry to burst your fun guys, but here it goes.


Laser ap2


AS = 2.6


dam. 84 - 394


-50 point blank


+60 ideal


-50 max


HAM= 44-56-35 ,respectivley (in that area may be off by a few)



Elite ap1


AS = 2.5


dam. 201-435


-60 point blank


+55 ideal


-40 max


HAM ,about 45-55-35 (averaged)



plus several other laser exactly like taht one but with 3.5 - 4.1 AS



another question how do you determine DPS??





Omiem---Imperial Colonel----a smuggler from before, to after...
Godswarrior493
Sat May 08, 2004 7:16 pm
#19

ooh yea and soory bout this to


my speed mods are +115 so i could have a 4953.3487 AS carbine and still CAP it

[])_ (()) [])_


and accuracy is quite nice as well, only +201 gah



Omiem---Imperial Colonel----a smuggler from before, to after...
mmx1
Sat May 08, 2004 9:52 pm
#20

Isn't the formula (100-(+speed skill)) * Special Delay * Weapon Speed/100, with a 1 sec cap?

In that case, wouldn't +100 automatically cap anything?



Markx Omi, Carbineer/ TKM / Master Swordsman
Mobes Brack'n Weaponsmith/ Master Swordsman
KKND
Einatos, Tarquinas

M'ar! What is Good in life? Three Hour Buffs, Vasarian Brandy, and Ahrisa!
rhian_tarq
Sun May 09, 2004 3:37 am
#21






mmx1 wrote:
Isn't the formula (100-(+speed skill)) * Special Delay * Weapon Speed/100, with a 1 sec cap?

In that case, wouldn't +100 automatically cap anything?





You're correct...hence why rifles can cap a T21 so easy...just get +10 speed tapes or +5 for master marksmen...



Rhiannon
Tarquinas Galaxy
TAfirehawk
Sun May 09, 2004 3:49 pm
#22






Godswarrior493 wrote:

ooh yea and soory bout this to


my speed mods are +115 so i could have a 4953.3487 AS carbine and still CAP it

[])_ (()) [])_


and accuracy is quite nice as well, only +201 gah







Nice try on the Speed Forumula but you fail higher math.....


At +100 and higher, you cap on the positive approaching side of infinity





Iebas Feania
Former Correspondent of the Former Profession, CARBINEER

Godswarrior493
Sun May 09, 2004 4:03 pm
#23

Your here questioning my math, when its right? lol


First of all i just picked a random number and used it as an example. I cap allcarbines you silly,


Sorry if you misunderstood that.



Omiem---Imperial Colonel----a smuggler from before, to after...
TAfirehawk
Sun May 09, 2004 9:05 pm
#24

Just picked up the other 5 new Krayt Carbines....unfortunately I got totally ganked on 3 of the slices and the other 2 were nothing to write home about....



DXR6 - 20% Speed Slice
2.1 Speed
141/264 Min/Max - with powerup 163/350
37.8% Wound
+72 @ 22m
47/64/40 HAM


Elite- 33% Speed Slice
1.7Speed
136/267Min/Max - with powerup 157/354
33.4% Wound
+81 @ 40m
49/65/41 HAM


Enhanced E11- 15%Damage Slice
1.5Speed
116/274Min/Max - with powerup 134/363
31.1% Wound
+71 @ 30m
48/56/36 HAM


Laser- 23% Speed Slice
1.8Speed
69/362Min/Max - with powerup 80/480
35.2% Wound
+77 @ 50m
46/63/40 HAM


EE3- 23% Speed Slice
2.2 Speed
128/271Min/Max - with powerup 148/359
28.6% Wound
+68 @ 27m
86/79/64HAM



All of these cap, some way too easy.... The CripplingShot DPS on the Laser is 2100, which is over 400 less than the DH17 Short Carbine I just got. But of course the Laser is AP2 and the DH17 is AP0, for when that matters





Iebas Feania
Former Correspondent of the Former Profession, CARBINEER

TAfirehawk
Sun May 09, 2004 9:22 pm
#25


For comparison, my old Krayt Carbines....



DXR6
2.4 Speed
116/216 Min/Max
25.3% Wound
+25 @ 22m
34/49/25HAM


Elite
3.4Speed
163/308Min/Max
30.8% Wound
+42 @ 40m
62/79/55HAM


DXR6
4.0Speed
190/309Min/Max
35.6% Wound
+33 @ 22m
61/78/53HAM


Laser
3.3Speed
54/399Min/Max
22.1% Wound
+18 @ 50m
33/50/25HAM


EE3
1.8 Speed
88/237Min/Max
15.6% Wound
+23 @ 27m
43/35/20HAM



DH17 Short
2.0 Speed
98/331Min/Max
18.9% Wound
+26 @ 25m
28/29/16 HAM



Those are without powerups as that is how I have them recorded. I use Speed powerups on anything above 2.5 speed, the rest get Max/Min powerups.


Message Edited by TAfirehawk on 05-10-2004 12:24 AM



Iebas Feania
Former Correspondent of the Former Profession, CARBINEER

Doq_Utek
Sun May 09, 2004 9:23 pm
#26

I don't know if I should say congrats or condolenses That's a nice lineup but I know you were hoping for better. The same kinda thing happend to me on the first 3 or 4 Krayt wepons I got. Bittersweet isn't it. At least you hit the top shelf with your DH17 That one maybe the best of it's kind I've ever seen.



Doq Utek Master Carbineer
Page 2 of 3