Carbineer Archive

---

pentjaksilat wrote:

---

TAfirehawk wrote:

I think your first line sums it up. I too have had some luck against Rifleman, until my Canape wears off......but of course I can't damage him in 80% comp armor, doc and food buffs.

---

and there-in lies the riddle.

it's not that i'm wondering how you didn't die so quickly...they could just not be so hot on the PVP side of things...it's...that like TAfirehawk said, w/ 80% comp, doc & food buffs...even w/ +85 carbine speed & a 2.6spd krayt elite carbine...you just can't kill them. if you ever get them near death it'll be to health, and that just takes a quick stim, & would take a long time to get that low.

now...i /salute you for your win, and i wish i could believe against an array of decent fighters a carbineer can win...but that just shouldn't be the case, especially at +60carb speed...the issue has been hashed out numerous times...the numbers speak for themselves.

~pentjak

---

I /salute you on your wins too, but lets not mislead the rest of the community into thinking we even are equal let alone better than those other profs.

Nobody here is calling you a liar at all My "fishy" comment referred to the apparent lack of detail/weaknesses of those "other" profs.

And you bring up something most don't realize.....done correctly a Carbineer CAN be effective in PvP. But most people want the "twitch-style" PvP and that style just doesn't fit Carbineer so "those people" say we suck, even when it is the PLAYER, not the profession.

Our counter-points were to keep things in "balance" since there is still plenty to fix.....but plenty to be thankful for in Carbineer

yeah its a little fishy to me, how you applied " stun " um, I've been a carbineer since release and I use full auto 2, charge 2 [ recent fix ] and it sort of works but that doesn't mean there going to stay down, most of the time people get right up and that charge 2 is null.

I think maybe the enhance e11 you stacked a horrific bleed to kill them, i swear i never was able to accurately kill anyone unti lI turn riflemen doc [ with a +19 carbine speed attachment ]

So , maybe in better detail of what specials you used, other than that reading this its vague and fishy man, because all of those professions should have owned up on you, seems like they didn't know how to play there profession.

what exactly does the stun state do? i've heard so many things that i have no idea which is true?

blind is obvious

intimidated lowers damage (not sure how much) and supposedly stops defensive mods (dodge,counterattack,block)

dizzy just dizzies?

stun does ?

---

Ovo111 wrote:

what exactly does the stun state do? i've heard so many things that i have no idea which is true?

blind is obvious

intimidated lowers damage (not sure how much) and supposedly stops defensive mods (dodge,counterattack,block)

dizzy just dizzies?

stun does ?

---

In the description of it it says 'it lower some stats'. What stats those are and how much they are lowered is anyones guess. My guessis that it lowers defensive stats by half. I have attempted to test this against mobs using charge shot1 and seeing if they were easier to kd while stunned. My results were inconclusive.

all your story proves is how overpowered doctor is in PVP.

CMs cannot heal their own minds. I just dropped CM and tested this beforehand.

Well done on beating these players. You used your skills effectively, but the facts are that if they had used their skills as effectively as you used yours, you could never have won. Tactics are what won these fights, not templates.