Bounty Hunter Archive
Thread: Who would win?
Page 1 of 4
Thror
Tue May 04, 2004 1:39 pm
#1
The Saijan would wail all over the Jedi Knight because last time I checked, Jedi can't FLY!
Also Goku has that cool kamehameha(sic?) wave thing. Force powers just can't touch that. 
Message Edited by Thror on 05-04-2004 01:40 PM
roguestrike
Tue May 04, 2004 2:20 pm
#2
You can't forget Goku's spirit bomb he could take out a whole planet with that if he wanted.
Dozier316
Tue May 04, 2004 3:07 pm
#5
pfff it wouldnt even be close. Lukes whiny ass vs Goku's calm collect self. Goku woudl pwn him. faster, stronger, and he can shoot **edit**ing energy beams.
Corran_Horne
Wed May 05, 2004 12:15 am
#6
Me and mt friends have been having a debate about who would win in a fight: A SuperSaijan(DBZ) or a JediKnight?
Rastalin Majire
Starsider
Master TKA
Master Marksman
Master Scout
Novice BountyHunter
Novice Pistoleer
glorydragon
Wed May 05, 2004 1:18 am
#7
Thror wrote:
The Saijan would wail all over the Jedi Knight because last time I checked, Jedi can't FLY!
Also Goku has that cool kamehameha(sic?) wave thing. Force powers just can't touch that.
Message Edited by Thror on 05-04-2004 01:40 PM
what he said.
Thror
Wed May 05, 2004 3:04 am
#8
glorydragon wrote:
Ianril wrote:
Jedi: "Yes, Goku, you will use spirit bomb on yourself."
Goku: "Okay"
but I like this too...
You're forgetting that Force Persuasion only works on the weak minded or weak willed. While I'll grant that Goku isn't the brightest bulb in the bushel (sometimes) he's definitely an incredibly strong willed individual. I doubt even Palpatine could get a FP past Goku's will save.
Although, in the end Yoda > All
Message Edited by Thror on 05-05-2004 03:06 AM
LepusProeliator
Wed May 05, 2004 5:08 am
#9
Fists and Kicks vs Lightsaber?saiyan may lose an arm or 4...
Even though SuperSaiyan's are fast as heck i think jedi reflexes would kick in for the defense part, and i don't think punching through a lightsaber blade would be the best choice....
Plus Super Saiyan's energy attacks... think about it... ENERGY attacks... lightsabers can deflect
The fight sounds close. Give the Jedi a full set of buffs and 90% comp armor and he'll walk all over Saiyan.
And if somehow the jedi loses.... we'll just nerf the Super Saiyan
Even though SuperSaiyan's are fast as heck i think jedi reflexes would kick in for the defense part, and i don't think punching through a lightsaber blade would be the best choice....
Plus Super Saiyan's energy attacks... think about it... ENERGY attacks... lightsabers can deflect
The fight sounds close. Give the Jedi a full set of buffs and 90% comp armor and he'll walk all over Saiyan.
And if somehow the jedi loses.... we'll just nerf the Super Saiyan
Macellarius
Wed May 05, 2004 5:22 am
#10
hhhmmm...would be interesting but if it went by the DBZ tv shows then...
Jedi from us wins everytime.
Last I checked DBZ guys like to talk for 5 minutes about what they are going to do and how bad they will kick your ass.
DBZ " I'm the most awesome the universe has ever seen, I have defeated 12000 opponents on 800 worlds..."
Jedi...doo-di-doo-di....
...walk up next to DBZ, plant lightsabre against chest.
...'snap, hzzzzzzz'
...hmmm I wonder, should I have eggs or pancakes for breakfast, thinks Jedi.
....doo-di-doo-di...
Zari_Ivale
Wed May 05, 2004 5:28 am
#11
lol, all a Jedi would have to do is find a majorartery in Goku's brain... you really don't need to tell me the rest do you?
Laeren
Wed May 05, 2004 6:25 am
#12
Things Goku would have to deal with involving Jedi:
Force Choke
While the Jedi is busy choking Goku, Goku blows a mile wide crater where the Jedi is standing simply by powering up. Goku has been in choke-holds many times before and gotten outta them. Being choked is nothing new to him, unlike unlucky captains of starships.
While the Jedi is busy choking Goku, Goku blows a mile wide crater where the Jedi is standing simply by powering up. Goku has been in choke-holds many times before and gotten outta them. Being choked is nothing new to him, unlike unlucky captains of starships.
Light Saber
Many high-leveled DBZ chars can deflect energy bolts and fieldswith their bare hands, especially Goku. Block, block, block, block. In fact, Goku can catch the lightsaber with his bare hands, since he's caught many energy effects with his bare hands before, including the planet-destroying ball Majiin Buu threw at the Earth. Also, throughout all of the DBZ energy attacks and battles, no one but Piccolo has lost limbs (and he regenerates them).
Many high-leveled DBZ chars can deflect energy bolts and fieldswith their bare hands, especially Goku. Block, block, block, block. In fact, Goku can catch the lightsaber with his bare hands, since he's caught many energy effects with his bare hands before, including the planet-destroying ball Majiin Buu threw at the Earth. Also, throughout all of the DBZ energy attacks and battles, no one but Piccolo has lost limbs (and he regenerates them).
Jedi Mind Trick
Speculation about whether it works on Saiyans or not aside (if it doesn't work on Toydarians, what other species doesn't it work on?), let's assume Vader tried it on Leia while interrogating her, and of course it didn't work. If Goku has a similar willpower to Leia (becuase of determination or just plain stubborness) then it wouldn't work on him either.
Speculation about whether it works on Saiyans or not aside (if it doesn't work on Toydarians, what other species doesn't it work on?), let's assume Vader tried it on Leia while interrogating her, and of course it didn't work. If Goku has a similar willpower to Leia (becuase of determination or just plain stubborness) then it wouldn't work on him either.
Force Lightning
Just another deflectable energy attack.
What the Jedi would have to deal with
Energy Bolts
It's unclear whether the larger types would be deflected. Remember that so far in any source except for the Clone Wars anime on Cartoon Network we've only seen them deflect blaster bolts, which barely do any damage to structures and walls when deflected, perhaps only leaving small burn marks. Blasts from the DBZ series tend to knock down buildings, blow apart walls and destroy major land masses. So the order of magnitude may be a bit much to expect a jedi to deflect with a 1.5" wide lightsaber blade. Even in the Cartoon Network Clone Wars, during the underwater fight, the Jedi there didn't even try to deflect the large cannon's bolt, which seemed to be on the same level as some of the medium-large DBZ blasts.
Hyper Speed
Both DBZ chars and Jedi have forms of hyper speed, though it's unclear how they would affect each other. We've never seen a Jedi do much more than run at hyper speed (except for Yoda who seemed to use the Force to accelerate his movements somewhat), but DBZ chars attack fully in their hyper speed mode, so much so that they are invisible to the naked eye. Again, it's a matter of order of magnitude, and I think the Saiyans have the advantage here.
Flight
Jedi can't fly, only leap, and their leaping seems to have limits. So all the Saiyan has to do is flight-kite the Jedi while continuously firing energy bolts at either the Jedi or the ground around him.
Solar Flare
It's been shown that Jedi don't necessarily need to see in order to hit their targets or defend themselves, but when facing an opponent on the order of magnitude of a Saiyan, a blinded Jedi is at a serious disadvantage.
Instant Transmission
Jedi should be able to sense Goku in his new position and be able to defend against his attack once he rematerializes.
Destructo Disk
Jedi defenses aren't perfect, and one bad slash with one of the and a Jedi could lose a hand...
Spirit Bomb
What's funny is the similarity between the essence of the Spirit Bomb and the Force itself. Perhaps the Jedi could sieze control of the bomb as it was coming towards him.
Ok..I totally geeked out on this one...but I'm at work with nothing to do, so why not eh 
My $$'s on the Saiyan.
Fig182
Wed May 05, 2004 8:42 am
#13
Ok we first need to determine if Goku is the DBZ Goku or GT
Goku is DBZ would most likely not power up to waste the Jedi in one shot since he always looking for new opponents and a Jedi would be something that he has never seen.
Lightsabers would not affect Goku. He has demonstrated that his hand can be just as effective as a energy laced sword (trunks) which could be considered as a lightsaber in some senses. He repelled trunks as fast as he could move and then proved that he was much faster.
Instant Transmission will be close to impossible for the Jedi to sense since he converts his body mass into energy and he is gone. Whenever Goku used transmission in the series it could not be picked up by a scouter (think of a scouter as a midochlorian counter that is worn on the head). Now since the Jedi have a Active Sense of the Force they could technically see that he is in the force but for it to tell them where Goku is would be hard. Since its quite fast the Jedi would still be lagged since he would see the energy and then try and determine where it is but by that time Goku would be in his face.
The Spirit Bomb can only be controlled by the Pure of Heart. Dark Jedis need not apply. Light Siders may be able to manipulate the bomb and it may not kill them but Goku would always have control unless he were dead or out of ernergy.
the Kamaheha is not like this. Goku has full control over its direction. A Jedi can reflect this. He would die as soon as he tried to touch it to deflect it.
The Only Jedi that has a Chance is Yoda. His powers have never been fully exercised.
Goku is close to being a god though.
Lots of Pros and Cons and sense i am a fan of both SW and DBZ i thought i would try and splice this battle up. Good question though. Start the Flames lol
Page 1 of 4