Bio Engineer Archive

Thread: Critical Failures

Destryr
Thu Dec 04, 2003 6:24 am
#92

42.? station , 14.85 tool and since last patch using same materials for some harvies..mineral in particular experimentation failures on final combinehave gone through the roof. yes they are all very very good materials.



Cardish
selling rare/ high quality resources
Master Heavy swordsman, TKA, fencer, master brawler
Asylum City, Naboo
Any auction wins please drop off at " loot for less" vendor,merchant tent by shuttle, Asylum city,Naboo.
By_Tor
Thu Dec 04, 2003 6:53 am
#93

I know I am stating the obvious to many, but I saw someone mention using high OQ resources. For almost everything we make OQ means nothing. It used to be all UT, but now it is UT 50%, SR 25%, and HR 25%. Read the draft schematics and it will tell you what matters.



By-Tor
Bytorette
meagor
Thu Dec 04, 2003 11:28 am
#94

Man the crit failures have been sooo frustrating lately. I used to have a doc and would notice periods of time when crit failures would increase for unknown reasons, only to have them magically return to normal levels at a later date. I never once saw anything from the devs on this issue and was not able to track a pattern. Just one day crit failures out the wazoo and a couple of days/weeks later, back to normal levels.


With the recent rise I'm witnessing in my Architect character, I'm beginning to wonder if there is a simple variable the devs are tweaking which effects the crit fail rates. It's starting to seem like these crit. fail rates are shifting like resources, with our superior crafting tools/stations being totally absent from the calculations.


Sure wish I'd saved my money on that nice +35% food/chem station and those +14 tools because theydon't seem to change anything.




Spendor Galgon (Tirel) - Shadowfire
Lord-Brisbane
Thu Dec 04, 2003 11:44 am
#95



JeCy wrote:

I have posted this many times and will post it again. Its all about the tools and your crating stations get a 40+ statino and a 14+ tool and you will notice a huge difference. Also make schems and have your factory make the stuff thats what they are for. It shouldnt take you more than 1-4 trys for a great schem and then guess what no fails for the next 1000 items if you soo choose.. or at least 100 depending on what you are making.

JeCy Dax

Merchant, radiant







Bull crap


I am a master architect I have a +42.75 and a +14.71 tool i crit fail all the time in 1 day of crafting in about 1 hr i failed 35 times and 3 were heavy harvesters


I have been a master architect since week 3 this game came out the Devs dont care just like they dont care about me missing neary 30 buildings from my vendors im talking tatooine shuttle ports, hopstials,Large houses,Medium house,small houses ETC



Brisbane
The holo grind is over.... as of 6/1/04

CEO Dewback Industries Merchant shop
Planet: Dantooine city of New hope
Location: 3412 -3316
RotorofCorRng
Thu Dec 04, 2003 11:57 am
#96

I've been lucky so far.

Made my second Guild Hall last night, no probs. Failing on the small stuff like crazy, but better than failing on teh Guild Hall.

So far Fluffy The Virgin Sheep has been spare, the hail marys seem to be working ok.



Rotor - Will cease to exist May 3rd.
GizMoc
Thu Dec 04, 2003 12:07 pm
#97

All I know is after the last patch, I have been getting crit fail all the time. After crit fail 10 times in a row, yes I said 10 time in a row, I logged for the night and did not craft ANYTHING for a few days. I have a crafting station with 39.6% eff. and 4 tools with 13 or higher eff. All 4 tools crit failed on me that night. I think the Devs need to look at the percentage of critical failures and lower it to pre-patch levels.
khslammer
Thu Dec 04, 2003 12:31 pm
#98

For me making BER 13 harvestors is almost impossible. I get CF's on experimenting almost every time. That leaves me with an 11 or 10 BER that I can't sell and yes I use really good tools and materials. Does anyone really make heavy harvestors in a factory?
_Stinger_
Fri Dec 05, 2003 1:00 am
#99

Something is definately askew with the crit forumlas. Today I trained my last twoboxes to get my Master Architect. (Large house and Master). I went to my shop and started crafting (using the same resources I've used for the last 2 weeks and using the same tool and station).


After 18 items, I had crit 5 times on final assemblies. I got so frustrated I logged off.


So the higher the craftingprofession ladder you climb, you become less profiecent at that profession.

PhazeDistortion
Fri Dec 05, 2003 4:31 pm
#100

Relax. In the next patch, crit failures on assembly wont be an issue. On installations, the resources will stay, and you will be able to simply click the assemble button again. I've tested this on TC with personals at least, and it does work. It was posted in a dev comment, in the TC forum I beleive.





Phaze Distortion
Kauri Architect of the Year nominee
GoodAshe
Fri Dec 05, 2003 5:21 pm
#101

You may also want to looking into using factories for final combines.

Use of factories in final combines substantially reduces your risk.

A few notes...

- You only take risk on the first combine, the schematic.
- Factories do work with heavy installations, I use them for mine all the time.
- While generators, small structure storage modules and extraction sub components (light ore, Tubo Fluidic etc.) need to be the same as the schematic the walls do not. You can use any wall from any lot with your installations.
- Factories correctly pull from crates for all subcomponents that I have used (light ore, fluidic, manufacturing)
- Making walls in a factory works, and it does not require the original structural modules. All you need is the original resources and any lot of structural modules will work.

For lvl 10 mineral extractors factories are a must, and with some planning you can do very effective runs of larger installations in factories as well. If you figure failure rates that sit at about 10% for critical on assembly and more so on experimentation not using factories is not really an option and the cost of the schematic more than pays for itself after even a run of 10.

Total cost of a run of Heavy Minerals + Schematic

Low-Grade Ore 169,400
Metal 82,280
Steel 16,940
Alumimum 11,000
Carbonate Ore 5,500
Chemical 5,500
Copper 5,500
Inert Gas 1,650
non-Ferrous 3,300
Reactive Gas 400


Sure it costs a fair amount of resources, about a weeks worse, but you only have to risk making one harvester instead of 11. Also you could work with other architects to make the run and split the final result.



kMm Theo's Droid Depot & EDO Starship Division mMk
EDO DEPOT - NW Coronet (-939 -3764) & EDO Mercantile - Pax Veritas Naboo, Shuttleport
Master DE & Now Master Shipwright Ready to Take Your Order!

Cafa
Fri Dec 05, 2003 5:47 pm
#102






JeCy wrote:

I have posted this many times and will post it again. Its all about the tools and your crating stations get a 40+ statino and a 14+ tool and you will notice a huge difference. Also make schems and have your factory make the stuff thats what they are for. It shouldnt take you more than 1-4 trys for a great schem and then guess what no fails for the next 1000 items if you soo choose.. or at least 100 depending on what you are making.


JeCy Dax


Merchant, radiant





+15 tools, +43.3 structure station, critted almost always on the finals only. Ruined 4 fusion reactors to get 7 least night. 4 out of 7 on the final. Tell me that makes sense.


Fivo Asia
Master Artisan - Master Architect - Merchant 3/4/2/4
Tempest - Dantooine - Vesnia




- Strength In Numbers - Loyal Subjects of the Empire
Asia Brothers Industries - Asia Hall SiN CiTY, Dantooine (Offers Vendor at -4703 -1404)
A player bodyguard can't protect you either, something agroes you, you are dead. The
only difference between a pet and the person, is you pay the person to stand there
and watch you die. -- Straker Atrella

GenChaos
Fri Dec 05, 2003 5:49 pm
#103

I have to agree that it is something with a recent patch. My tools and stations have not changed. I have a 43.4 stations and a 14.9 tool and since the last patch I have criticaled more than the previous 2 months. They did something to fork us up again.
Ato_Ioto
Fri Dec 05, 2003 11:49 pm
#104

I might as well jump on this bandwagon of screwed over architects also.. Just criticalled on two heavy minerals in a row.. not to mention the failures of experimenting on earlier things.. and when I say critical.. it was not experimentation, I criticalled the whole gosh darn thing. PLEASE FIX THIS SOE.. being a master arch that critically fails 1/2 the time is not very entertaining.. maybe im weird and just dont like wasting 60k material a day.. Id have more fun just deleting them knowing they will never amount to anything



-Ato Ioto Jr.-Mayor of Sagi, Lok-
Page 8 of 12