Bio Engineer Archive
Thread: Hard Data on City Research specialization and how it affects crafting
Page 3 of 3
Delbert
Mon Jan 12, 2004 8:23 am
#27
Bermag wrote:
There is one thing I don't understand. You only list crit failure, great success and amazing success. The total number of attempts is the sum of those 3 categories.
But there is a wide range of experimentation results than great (I usually discard all crafting attempts if I get anything less than great success), moderate success, good success, minor failure etc.
Either you list all those experiments as "critical failures" (should be more than or you have not included those in your stats. I think those should be included. Getting more great results is a very important factor.
There is a simple answer for your question. In all my experimenting on those Items.. I only got those 3 results.. either a "critical failure", a "great sucess" or a "amazing sucess" My experiments are 100% accurate for what i did as I listed every result I got. I didn't get a single "moderate success", "good sucess" or "minor failure", and to tell you the truth I can't remember the last time I got one of these last 3 results. Maybe because i'm a Master in my Choosen crafts my chances for them are very low.
If I had gotten one of those results in my experiments I would have recorded it as I know the value of being very accurate in testing things like this.
So basicly I didn't include them in my stats Because I Didn't have any of them.
But you did raise an important point that maybe someone who isn't a Master crafter or someone who crafts stuff that gets a lot of those results should replicate the experiment and see how it affects them.
Page 3 of 3