Bio Engineer Archive

Thread: CH boards

Scorus
Fri Feb 06, 2004 7:25 am
#14

I agree with some of what you say but not all. Yes, CHs are a bit lost because Raph Koster's original vision for them was 180 degrees from the way that players played it. This led to ill thought out changes meant solely to balance based upon the old model and not put together a new model that could satisfy everyone.

What I disagree with is that the devs are going to do anything about it. There might be a few changes, but all in all I think CHs are now where they are going to be in another year. The devs cannot give the CHs the ability to get non-BE pets that are as good as BE pets without destroying the BE pet market and once again throwing the skill point system out of balance.

Look at the number of BE/CHs. They have this combo because they need one profession to make the best creatures and the other to control them. If CHs get the ability to produce these creatures on their own, then suddenly they can do the same thing at half the cost. The result is that all those BE points go back into some other combat profession and CHs are once again masters of pet combat, non-pet combat and the economy because they can do all three with their skill points.

That system is now gone. If a CH wants the best weapon then he is going to have to buy it from a crafter, us. Just life pistoleers and pikemen have to buy their weapons from weaponmasters instead of just using the ones they find in the wild.



Scorus
Morda
Fri Feb 06, 2004 8:22 am
#15

It's pointless for the CH community to complain right now no matter what the system is. They just got a complete revamp. No other profession got a revamp and many of them have major issues that need to be addressed. I think the devs have put a check in the box next to CH and won't even consider doing anything further with them for many many months unless there is something that is critically affecting another profession. I also don't think BE's have anything to apologize for to a CH anyway. Of the two professions one is definitely more in tune with the continuity of the SWuniverse....guess which one?
Centurion
Fri Feb 06, 2004 8:39 am
#16

I don't necessarily agree with the CHs that have responded to this but then I got MCH before the profession was revamped so the changes didn't impact me nearly as much as it does people who were lower on the skill trees. Now that BE has gotten some luv I'm working on that.

But I do agree that it's unlikely that CH will be changed in a major fashion in the near future since they were revamped and there are so many other professions that need tweaking (if not complete revamps).

I wouldn't worry about it *too* much since the most vocal people are seldom those who are happy but often those who are miserable. And in this place I think there's not much that will make those vocal, unhappy ones content.



Master Sergeant Banzai Draloh, sVn [W]
Master BE/TK
Wefaki J'org, sVn
Master Tailor/Artisan
Wookiee Wonderland Mall, Theed, Naboo: -4858, 3333 (Wefaki's Bioclothes and BE Pets)
Wefaki's Bargain Bioclothes, Kestrel, Naboo: 106 -4339 & -78 -4025

ImdaREELjedi
Fri Feb 06, 2004 8:41 am
#17

actually, having BE pets more powerful than wild pets was probably on SOE's agenda the WHOLE TIME.


remember all that fuss about how loot would never be as good as player crafted goods? placing a larger emphasis on community and player economy? PRIME EXAMPLE. ok, so you grinded CH, so did i. but i didnt grind CH so that i could have a bunny and a webmaster out and say, look how cute they are together. i grinded CH to say, eat my pets, high level mobs.


a CH saying that they wont use BE pets because they feel cheated out of a profession is EXACTLY like a rifleman complaining that he could have bought a better T21 rifle from a weapons vendor than the one he just looted off of a meatlump.


BE pets are so good because the BE's are so good. BE is not for your average crafter, its a profession that takes a lot more than simply, go here, do this, craft this, sell it, make money.


does anyone else have the feeling that these "purists" are the same people bombing abortion clinics and protesting genetic engineering in our own society. id rather like to think that they are. but that may just be, and that was my 3 cents (yes i get more than you)



Ki'wo - Chilastra
Teras Kasi Master, Battlemaster, Aspiring Chef
Bufano - Chilastra
Master Architect, Master Bio-Engineer
GreenStok
Fri Feb 06, 2004 8:55 am
#18

If you go to the CH boards, the most common post has to do with the pet they are looking to tame.... Has anyone found a baby Bull Rancor yet?... This is what they think about... taming pets.


Check this out... http://forums.station.sony.com/swg/board/message?board.id=creature_handler&message.id=155956


Many of the CH's have left to the next class that will get nerfed and many of the remaining in a land that does not exist.


They have no purpose. They are our customers.





______________________________
______________________________
GreenStok, Master Bio Engineer, proprieter of Green Acres
Shop on Lowca server, Naboo, Theed
/waypoint -5430 3417
Also on Dantooine -595 2891
Draccuss
Fri Feb 06, 2004 9:05 am
#19








ImdaREELjedi wrote:


does anyone else have the feeling that these "purists" are the same people bombing abortion clinics and protesting genetic engineering in our own society. id rather like to think that they are. but that may just be, and that was my 3 cents (yes i get more than you)






LOL! That is great!


I agree with you completely but the depressing part of it is this. I grinded CH for two reasons, one like you said to take on high level mobs, two the thrill of taming that superior creature you finally found in the wild. Well with the changes that kills one of those reasons and slightly dulls the profession for me. I mean sure I could join the futile hunt for the "rare" creatures but what a complete waste of time in my opinion considering BEs can make better creatures in the first place. That is all I was trying to point out.


Justremember that those complaining don't represent the entire community and I have seen more BE pets running around than I have seen wild pets so who cares what a couple of CHs are whining about. You will always have my business!





____________________________________________________
Draccus - Chilastra Server
Swordsman, Fencer, Tera Kasi
IFC - Fooville - Naboo
Cocomono
Fri Feb 06, 2004 9:59 am
#20

A nerf to BEs would be a nerf to CHs, its like shooting yourself in the head to get blood on the other guy. They are complaining about a system that isn't complete. Yes, the natural pets are terrible, everytime I look at one I think about how much better I could make it. The fact is once the combat changes are completely made CHs will quickly rise back to power in PvP and dominate it with BE pets.


This all supports the dependance of classes in SWG. CH is already a fairly independant class already, but to make it a combat class that does not rely on others is trash. I bet those same CHs that complain about BEs go around wearing BE clothing and using pet stims.



Kru'gar
You might be a Red-Neck Jedi if......you hear "Luke I'm your Father, and your Uncle too."
ArthurDentOnBria
Fri Feb 06, 2004 11:44 am
#21

CH has changed, there is no doubt about it. There used to be a whole "subclass" of CH that dedicated themselves to supplying pets to others. The CH nerf and the BE patch killed them, no doubt about it. I was at the starport yesterday listening to a CHhallering about selling pets for 10k. Nice pets too, CL 40ish semi-rare. I actually felt bad for him.


But, they need to get over it and move on. There is simply no way that the system can work if they can tame pets that compete with ours. Whenever a CH makes an argument to me that they should be able to tame as good a pets as BEs can make, I just say, cool, then they should allow MBE's to call pets at MCH level for "fairness" sake. Of course even that wouldn't really be "fair" though, since our skill point requirements are more than theirs.


I saw a big thread in the CH boards a week or so ago, where the person starting the thread said "we're not looking tame uber pets, just give us something with medium armor" lol. Obviously, that's rediculous, and can't be allowed to happen.





ArthurDent - former Bio Engineer, Tailor, and Droid Engineer
Account cancelled 7/8/05 due to game breaking bugs in these professions that have been neglected for FAR too long. Last day July 27 2005
custom tailoring and droid orders welcome. "making Evil products since July 2003"
Achiever: 80%, Explorer: 60%, Socializer: 46%, Killa 13%


fantoq
Fri Feb 06, 2004 12:37 pm
#22

I'm not a purist. Sure I like taming my own pets, and actually, some of them work out pretty well for specific applications. But when I'm doing a mission for $$, unless the group is so overpowered and I really need some CH XP, you can bet your tail I got my best BE pet in there. Hehe, by the time it's done staring (must be all it takes since it never gets close enough to really hit anything, lol) the mob is bloody, poisoned and half dead. I love it!

What happened is, SOE screwed up...twice. First the CH was way overpowered. Then, rather than just toning it down, they trashed major aspects of CH. I don't doubt the balance will work out in the long run, but it is poor planning to trash one profession months ahead of creating the balance of all professions. So to say CH got 'fixed' is a joke. We best hope they don't 'fix' BE the same way. I love the revamp comment; guess you could call getting your car in a wreck a revamp, too.

And there are still many broken things in CH that have been broken since they started.

Aside from the bugs:

Can't sell pets on a vendor. Maybe not a primary thing, but I can sell pretty much anything else I own.

Tamed pets, wild or BE, take a beating in combat yet if you had the same matchup in the wild, the pet would have incapped you several times over.

Mounts are useless since vehicles came out. And maintenance on vehicles isn't going to change that. C'mon, for a few K per day I'll take the bike. It's faster and safer.


GreenStok said:


Many of the CH's have left to the next class that will get nerfed and many of the remaining in a land that does not exist.


They have no purpose. They are our customers.


Yep, and that's as much of a problem for BEs as it is for CHs.




fantoq
MCH
former Medic
App. Carbineer
Society of Interplanetary Mercenaries[SIM]/ stargate/ naboo
Tarnblade
Fri Feb 06, 2004 12:42 pm
#23

Some gen questions for you, seing as a lot of your post doesnt make much sense.





Most consider that the funnest part of being a CH is finding rare catches.



What is wrong with this ?


Yes finding Rare pets is fun.... Hrm let me see why could that be,,,, Because they are RARE and not everyone and there grandmother can get one by going up to a BE and saying.


"I want this particular pet"


Hell even the hard core gamers that hunt 100 + lairs dont allways get a rare pet.





They are a fighting class



Erm were actually a TANK class at the moment, please explain to me how CH by its self is a fighting class.





gathering class



How are we a gathering class ?


Our main skill is taming creatures,,, notice taaammminnng


Id have to asume this is what you are refering to.





and they refuse to gather. Its boreing.



Your loosing me here with your weird logic.


If were a gathering class that isnt gathering how come your anoyd at the supposd CH snobs that dont want to use BE pets.



How exactly is it boring ?


Have you ever even been a CH ?





Why am I bringing this up? Because it is going to affect us if something is not done.





How is it going to afect you ?


People moaning about BE pets quite simply are not going to get their way on the standard pets.

BE pets will allways be better.


BE pets seem to sell pretty well as things are, hows that going to change ?




Please bear in mind that ive nothing against BE's and have a lot of BE pets myself.


I just dont understand a lot of BE's who seem to think that CH's in general are low life scum, and yet they want to sell to us.



Why did any of you become a BE ?


Tier-ra
Fri Feb 06, 2004 2:09 pm
#24

As BE/MCH, I can sympathize.


And I have an easy fix.


The problem is that every single critter of the same species in the wild has exactly the same stats. Every GSP is a carbon copy of every other GSP. In the real wild, this would never be the case.


So allow wild animals to vary in stats, in much the same way that engineered pets vary in stats, and we would have balance back in the galaxy. CH could hunt and tame the BEST GSP they can find. BE could engineer the BEST kitty they can build. Customers would have a choice.


Is this gonna happen? Nah. But you can see this would totally give both professions and their customers reason to rejoice.





--------


RA Enterprises selling Bio-Energetic Foods and Uber Pets
Conveniently located 1km from Theed Starport, -5666 3388, Chilastra

ArthurDentOnBria
Fri Feb 06, 2004 2:39 pm
#25


BE's would certainly not rejoice at such a notion.







Tier-ra wrote:


So allow wild animals to vary in stats, in much the same way that engineered pets vary in stats, and we would have balance back in the galaxy. CH could hunt and tame the BEST GSP they can find. BE could engineer the BEST kitty they can build. Customers would have a choice.


Is this gonna happen? Nah. But you can see this would totally give both professions and their customers reason to rejoice.











ArthurDent - former Bio Engineer, Tailor, and Droid Engineer
Account cancelled 7/8/05 due to game breaking bugs in these professions that have been neglected for FAR too long. Last day July 27 2005
custom tailoring and droid orders welcome. "making Evil products since July 2003"
Achiever: 80%, Explorer: 60%, Socializer: 46%, Killa 13%


Tier-ra
Fri Feb 06, 2004 2:55 pm
#26






ArthurDentOnBria wrote:


BE's would certainly not rejoice at such a notion.








Well, my BE would rejoice if the wild animals I could sample all had different stats and that would flow into my engineering. I see this as a Win-Win situation. But to each its own, Arthur.





--------


RA Enterprises selling Bio-Energetic Foods and Uber Pets
Conveniently located 1km from Theed Starport, -5666 3388, Chilastra

Page 2 of 4