Artisan Archive

Thread: Pickup/Dropoff/Storage Vendors

Eleutherios
Sun Sep 11, 2005 1:02 pm
#1

Hypothetical situation that I've been mulling over.


Let's say you make a backpack called "Some Rare Component" (insert name of rare components there.) You end up filling it with something inane like W/D/G crafting tools. You then pop it up on your storage vendor for millions of credits so nobody will buy it.


If they buy it off your storage vendor, and then they find it's not what the label says, are you going to get in trouble if they /report you? On one hand, they shouldn't have bought it as it's on a STORAGE vendor and not meant for them, but on the other hand, it wasn't what the bag said.


What do you think?



Colonel ||
Asada Tiberius ||
TXF || Elder Bounty Hunter
|| Elder Carbineer
|| Elder Pistoleer
|| Elder Teras Kasi
|| Elder Brawler
|| Elder Marksman





THE PEOPLE'S CHAMP
Elyssa
Sun Sep 11, 2005 1:07 pm
#2

Yes.

It's called fraud.
CSR's will come down hard on you for this.

There is no such thing as a "storage" vendor.
Any item on any vendor is legally bought by any player who is willing to pay for it.

If you want to hide things in bags on vendors, give them generic labels like "stuff1" or "my components"that cannot be interpreted as being a specific item offered for sale.
At that point, it becomes the buyer's responsibility for buying something blindly.



------
Elyssa Alexander (Elder Merchant Correspondent)
12pt. Master Structures Trader / Elder Jedi / Mayor, City of Metropolis
Shop Crazy Durni, Inc., now open in Metropolis, Corellia (885 -6605 Gorath)

"Why the big secret? People are smart, they can handle it."
"A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky, dangerous animals and you know it."

Elyssa was 1000% correct
-Pawlin

Seekyn
Sun Sep 11, 2005 3:31 pm
#3


Isn't that what the popup warning window is for when you buy any container? and as long as you refunded the creds for the item in return there should be no issue.




Seekyn
CANCELLED NOVEMBER 2, 2005
Elyssa
Sun Sep 11, 2005 3:34 pm
#4

Feel free to try it, but you have no one to blame but yourself when the CSR's land on you and take disciplinary action against your account.



------
Elyssa Alexander (Elder Merchant Correspondent)
12pt. Master Structures Trader / Elder Jedi / Mayor, City of Metropolis
Shop Crazy Durni, Inc., now open in Metropolis, Corellia (885 -6605 Gorath)

"Why the big secret? People are smart, they can handle it."
"A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky, dangerous animals and you know it."

Elyssa was 1000% correct
-Pawlin

Giamai
Sun Sep 11, 2005 5:53 pm
#5

if you are actually trying to store something wouldn't it be better to label it something boring like "extra crafting tools" with some rare loot in it and price it at 9999999asopposedto labeling something like "flawless krayt pearls" and have tools in it?


if you put some tools in the backpack along with the rare loot...is that really fraud? there is after all at least one tool as labeled





TGiamai Oewai (Elder Jedi without a clue)T
T Giaman Srawhe, 12 pt MWS [GS] Weapons, near Theed -3955, 3322T
TGiavamai Oewai, Where's the lewt?T
T Ahazi T
T*Not everyone who wanders is lost...*T
Erahth
Sun Sep 11, 2005 9:19 pm
#6

The issue with this isn't the fact that you've put something nearly worthless on your vendor for millions.

The issue is the name.

If you label it "4 premium pearls" and put it up for 10 mil and someone finds out it's 4 crafting tools, then that is fraud, and despite the warning, CSRs may take action.

However, if you label it "Customer A's Pearls" then put it up for 10 mil, it's not fraud.

However, some sneaky bastage might try to ninja-buy it, and get a very rude shock. This is where the warning box comes in.

It's all about the name. If you put a name which is advertising, such as "Uber krayt guns" or something, then it can be construed as a legitimate sale, thus coming under fraud.



The "Dark Purple" Licky Fish of Bria
SOE 'fixed' SWG, just like my cat's been fixed...

...Has mastered the pilot profession

Star Wars Galaxies really captured the elusive Star Wars feeling....with every new publish you instantly think: "I've got a bad feeling about this!"
Consoles = bad
Elyssa
Sun Sep 11, 2005 9:38 pm
#7

I would go so far as to remove the word "pearls" from the name as well.
"Customer A's Order" is sufficient and leaves NO grey area between decoy and fraud.
CSR's do not acknowledge "custom orders" since any item on any vendor may be legally bought by any player who is willing to pay the price for it.

In fact, naming a container with something that is not inside it can be considered griefing since you did it with the intention of deceiving another player.

Bottom line:
If what you say is in the bag isn't in the bag, you're leaving yourself wide open for disciplinary action.





------
Elyssa Alexander (Elder Merchant Correspondent)
12pt. Master Structures Trader / Elder Jedi / Mayor, City of Metropolis
Shop Crazy Durni, Inc., now open in Metropolis, Corellia (885 -6605 Gorath)

"Why the big secret? People are smart, they can handle it."
"A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky, dangerous animals and you know it."

Elyssa was 1000% correct
-Pawlin

Dimear
Mon Sep 12, 2005 7:25 am
#8

I used to have a backpack on my vendor named "Customer A's Order", but with the customer's name in it. It was just a few chance cubes, but priced at 5 mil. It was an actual order though - not a fraud. One of the weaponsmiths on my server was sick of people buying other customers' orders, so he asked that merchants on my server fill this order for him. He wanted 5-10 chance cubes in a backpack, and since he valued our time, he was willing to pay 2-10 million for them. But he wouldn't be able to pick them up for a long time, so he asked that we keep them on our vendors for several months .

So I did - I placed a pack of chance cubes on my vendor, clearly labelled that it was for him. That was about a year ago or so, but now the pack isn't there. I'm pretty sure the intended customer didn't buy it. Guess I'll have to look back through my emails to find out what fool bought his order and ended up with 5 mil worth of chance cubes .





Thus sayeth Dimear

LordRetep
Mon Sep 12, 2005 10:14 am
#9


If you put 5 krayt pearls in the backpack. name it "5 krayt pearls" and price it at say 5 mill. The customer/retard buys em only to discover that they are already tuned... not nice but you where just storing them for future decoration purposes and ppl pay a bunch for all other kinds of decorations
I know not very nice but thats life.



poo Locutus &Jadzia'Dax ppp

pppBorg Cube Shopping Mallppp

ppp Bestine!, -688 -4637 ppp


Eleutherios
Mon Sep 12, 2005 11:03 am
#10

Interesting replies!



Colonel ||
Asada Tiberius ||
TXF || Elder Bounty Hunter
|| Elder Carbineer
|| Elder Pistoleer
|| Elder Teras Kasi
|| Elder Brawler
|| Elder Marksman





THE PEOPLE'S CHAMP
Seekyn
Mon Sep 12, 2005 6:37 pm
#11


I just price all my storage bags at max price...not much in game is worth that much


label --"Full Suit of Mando Armor"- price "999999999"creds


hmmmmmm That might be worth it.






Seekyn
CANCELLED NOVEMBER 2, 2005
Elyssa
Mon Sep 12, 2005 6:39 pm
#12

Until someone pays that much for it and then complains to a CSR and they 1) refund the player's money and 2) take disciplinary action against you up to and including termination of your account.


Don't think for an instant that they won't do it, either.



------
Elyssa Alexander (Elder Merchant Correspondent)
12pt. Master Structures Trader / Elder Jedi / Mayor, City of Metropolis
Shop Crazy Durni, Inc., now open in Metropolis, Corellia (885 -6605 Gorath)

"Why the big secret? People are smart, they can handle it."
"A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky, dangerous animals and you know it."

Elyssa was 1000% correct
-Pawlin

Dimear
Tue Sep 13, 2005 12:52 am
#13



LordRetep wrote:
If you put 5 krayt pearls in the backpack. name it "5 krayt pearls" and price it at say 5 mill. The customer/retard buys em only to discover that they are already tuned... not nice but you where just storing them for future decoration purposes and ppl pay a bunch for all other kinds of decorations
I know not very nice but thats life.




I'm betting that would be fraud too. I doubt the CSR's are so legalistic that they would see you met the letter of the rule, and ignore that you were still trying to defraud people. This isn't the legal system - this is a game where the CSR's are allowed to use their common sense. If I were them, and someone pulled that sort of scam, I'd certainly take action. And if I were a CSR, I'd probably be angry and irritable most of the time (more than now anyway). So the action I took probably wouldn't be pretty. I'd say a good rule of thumb is to run your business in such a way that the innocent shopper isn't going to get scammed. Also, the more work you create for a CSR, the more likely you are to get stomped on...





Thus sayeth Dimear

Page 1 of 2
Previous Next