Artisan Archive

Thread: ThunderHeart dropped the ball on a new Correspondant, Vehicles are broken and being ignored.

Ke_la
Tue Feb 17, 2004 2:03 am
#27

The company I work for develops software. We are paid to maintain (ie. monthly charges) and upgrade the system continually. If the system breaks we are required to fix it. If a production patch turns sour architects, project managers, developers, testers, etc.are all called in to correct the problem. We have a very simple rule when it comes toany production patch or release: Thelatest patchor release must not unintentionally alter or in any way negatively impact exisiting functionality. This is the reason for strict regression testing. At no time should a newer patch unintentionally corrupt existing functionality. If it does then it'srollback time. We implement this religiously. If only all companies adopted the same mentality




BWT, a company that is a customer of mine bought that type of software a YEAR AGO and there ARE STILL minor bugs in it, so you can't tell me that they have been paying overtime for a YEAR of 24/7 work. and the car HAM issue IS minor.





Ke'la Korian, Waylon Korien, Me'na Korien
Ke'la is a Master Rifleman/retireing Ranger and Waylon is an ID/DE
Me'na is the mayor of the City of Obalisic
"Have fun storming the castle". -- Miracle Max
"I knew it I am surrounded by %##@&!$# " -- Dark Helmet
"I am not Dead yet!" -- Guy from Holy Grail

Ke_la
Tue Feb 17, 2004 2:07 am
#28

Windows and Office products are a pay once form of software.





Yes they are pay once but I PAYED for a BUG FREE program. There are BUGS therefor they did not test enough therefor I should have a MS tech in my house FIXING all the bugs by YOUR logic.





Ke'la Korian, Waylon Korien, Me'na Korien
Ke'la is a Master Rifleman/retireing Ranger and Waylon is an ID/DE
Me'na is the mayor of the City of Obalisic
"Have fun storming the castle". -- Miracle Max
"I knew it I am surrounded by %##@&!$# " -- Dark Helmet
"I am not Dead yet!" -- Guy from Holy Grail

Bugbait
Tue Feb 17, 2004 2:16 am
#29




Ke_la wrote:



Sorry to burst YOUR bubble but ONLY Certified Tech can call Techincal Assitance Center and second if a PHONESYSTEM goes down on a saterday at a customer that is open on saterdays I think that it is slightly MORE improtaint the a GAME, and I would like to know the name of the company you work for so that I can do all my bussiness with the befor they GO OUT OF Bussiness by paying OVERTIME because I can't get my screen saver to work.



Let me spell it out for you since you clearly missed the point. I've commentingon SWG from a professional and business point of view. SWG is a service, ie. Customers pay real money for something in return, arguably entertainment (sometimes frustration). Whether it's a game or not is irrelevant in the content in which I'm analysing. No point counter your other "points" since they have no relevance. Go out of business? Not likely. With revenue growth at 75%+ each year (maybe over 100% now) it's not going out of business any time soon. Not my company so wouldn't worry me either way. There's something called professionalism that you should look up in the dictionary.




Rildan Urgess - Zabrak ???
Zugat Urtan - Trandoshan Rifleman: RETIRED
Bugbait
Tue Feb 17, 2004 2:20 am
#30




Ke_la wrote:

Yes they are pay once but I PAYED for a BUG FREE program. There are BUGS therefor they did not test enough therefor I should have a MS tech in my house FIXING all the bugs by YOUR logic.



Nope, once again you've completely missed the point. You paid once for a bug free program, you are correct. The program is not bug free so you're correct again there. This next point is important so pay attention: Microsoft do not charge you extra for the bug fixes. This is where you derailed. Using your flawed logic I would be expecting the SWG developers to come to my house to fix the bugs in their game. That's just silly. No cookie for you.




Rildan Urgess - Zabrak ???
Zugat Urtan - Trandoshan Rifleman: RETIRED
Bugbait
Tue Feb 17, 2004 2:32 am
#31




Ke_la wrote:

BWT, a company that is a customer of mine bought that type of software a YEAR AGO and there ARE STILL minor bugs in it, so you can't tell me that they have been paying overtime for a YEAR of 24/7 work. and the car HAM issue IS minor.




Strike 3, you're out! Let me try it from another angle. If Microsoft charged people to download Service Pack 1 then we would be one step closer to a parallel between your warped logic and SWG vs Microsoft. However, Microsoft don't charge for patches so let's just drop that for now. Side note: Overtime is not required when you have competant staff, good work practice, and enough human resources so no need to harp on it too much.


No, the condition of vehicles in itself is not a big deal. What it represents (ie. lack of regression testing and/or issue and source trakcing controls) is a big issue. Yes, yes, it's a minor annoyance inthe game. However you're misisng the big picture. The fact that it was reported multiple times on Test Center and has been introduced since the last publish (ie. negative impact on existing code) only amplifies an already poor track record on the part of the SWG development team. If you worked in or had even a vague knowledgeof the software industry I wouldn't even have to waste my time trying to explain why this is such a bad thing. I can accept new features not quite working as intendned (barely) but breaking existing functionality as they have cleary done here is a big no-no. It's not like the vehicle condition bug happens occasionally, randomly, or even most of the time. It happens every single time. If their testing team missed this, whichI doubt they trullywould beincompetant. It's more likely some clown signed this off as being "okay" to release into production. That's sloppy.





Rildan Urgess - Zabrak ???
Zugat Urtan - Trandoshan Rifleman: RETIRED
Shaladim
Tue Feb 17, 2004 5:39 am
#32

Just so that people know. I generated two vehicles on patch day from deeds created prior to the patch and they do not suffer from this bug. I guess it might only affect deeds created post-patch.
Firetracker
Tue Feb 17, 2004 9:41 am
#33






Shaladim wrote:

Just so that people know. I generated two vehicles on patch day from deeds created prior to the patch and they do not suffer from this bug. I guess it might only affect deeds created post-patch.






All my vehicles are pre-patch but in crates - they are all affected (at least 10 vehicles generated - all types). I am not willing to test any more until this issue is addressed.
CraftAddict
Tue Feb 17, 2004 2:13 pm
#34

I'd like to reiterate tha this bug is minor at best. Go repair your vehicle at the garage, take a trip on a shuttle with your vehicle out (another bug, but likely related), or die and get yourself cloned with your vehicle still out and it will reset you vehicle to show the proper hps that it should have. The problem only exists after you first call the vehicle out from the deed. I have both a swoop and speeder, and both are now showing proper hps.

Chill, you guys act like it's the end of the world or something. I understand many of you believe and expect SOE to put out a flawless product, but that is just wishful thinking you know. I for one can acknowledge that the devs have made HUGE strides in getting issues resolved, communicating with the community, and getting new content in the game. Now there is always room for improvement, but I for one will encourage SOE to continue working on it, but I'm not gonna ack like they are the slimiest, most unethical game developer to come along. I believe more contructive criticism would be in order here instead of the blanket criticisms we hear far too often on these boards.

You ask for perfection, and it is something that can not be obtained, but mearly strived for.



Aeriwen Bjorin
Staff Sergeant
Imperial Outpost, Dantooine
----------------------------------
Master Rfileman - Master Marksman - Combat Medic
Astronaut_jones
Tue Feb 17, 2004 2:21 pm
#35

I stopped making vehicles the day after they were patched in. 8k quality resources for something I can only sell for 25k? I save my resources for more important things.
Esharra
Tue Feb 17, 2004 10:34 pm
#36






Shaladim wrote:

Just so that people know. I generated two vehicles on patch day from deeds created prior to the patch and they do not suffer from this bug. I guess it might only affect deeds created post-patch.






It effects deeds generated post-patch. As far as the database is concerned, it isn't a deed until it is removed from the crate (until then its just a count on the crate). So yes, it only effects Deeds created post-patch..regardless of whether those deedsare createdfrom pre-patch crates, post-patch crates or manually made post-patch.



Esharra ěsh-äŕ-rä, noun
1. Entertainer
2. Bounty Hunter
3. Smuggler

"One man's oddity is another man's routine." -Bertos Goodner (a dancer)


Esharra
Tue Feb 17, 2004 10:44 pm
#37


Well, looks like Thunderheart has responded in the Weekly Roundtable thread. When asked for an ETA on a fix for the vehicle hitpoint bug, he replied:


"ASAP. Within the next couple of weeks..."


At least we've gotten an acknowledgement now.




Esharra ěsh-äŕ-rä, noun
1. Entertainer
2. Bounty Hunter
3. Smuggler

"One man's oddity is another man's routine." -Bertos Goodner (a dancer)


Whrlwnd13
Wed Feb 18, 2004 6:47 am
#38






"ASAP. Within the next couple of weeks..."





I hope that means from the time the bug started. A couple more weeks is a long time to go without being able to craft any vehicles.




Xyrek Lok
Master Weaponsmith
12pt WS, +20 FS Experimentation
Crafting High Quality Weapons Since 03/2004

WP 1190 -3620 1km NE of Coronet at the Omega Force Guildhall

- I supported keeping & balancing the old combat system SOE didn't care and gave us the WoW/EQ2 clone anyway
Ke_la
Wed Feb 18, 2004 9:22 pm
#39

Ke_la wrote:

Yes they are pay once but I PAYED for a BUG FREE program. There are BUGS therefor they did not test enough therefor I should have a MS tech in my house FIXING all the bugs by YOUR logic.




Nope, once again you've completely missed the point. You paid once for a bug free program, you are correct. The program is not bug free so you're correct again there. This next point is important so pay attention: Microsoft do not charge you extra for the bug fixes. This is where you derailed. Using your flawed logic I would be expecting the SWG developers to come to my house to fix the bugs in their game. That's just silly. No cookie for you.





YOU ARE PAYING FOR THE NEW CONTENT and A WORKING NETWORK. First of I think we need a change in terms here a "patch" in the world of MMORPG is an "UPGRADE" in '99 I bought an UPGRADE to Windows 95. By your logic this upgrade should be completly bug free. As we ALL know it wasn't and infact required a MAJOR fix Service Pak 1, ok again this the should be bug free right? LOL. How about 98s upgrade ME that was a backword step, and now we are on XP and there are still hundereds of bug. Oh, and my bugs go to the CORE of the proffesion and not just a minor HP problem.




Ke'la Korian, Waylon Korien, Me'na Korien
Ke'la is a Master Rifleman/retireing Ranger and Waylon is an ID/DE
Me'na is the mayor of the City of Obalisic
"Have fun storming the castle". -- Miracle Max
"I knew it I am surrounded by %##@&!$# " -- Dark Helmet
"I am not Dead yet!" -- Guy from Holy Grail

Page 3 of 4