Armorsmith Archive

Thread: General opinion of armorsmiths regarding the crafting of Wookie armor

JaatoWaals
Tue Mar 23, 2004 8:53 am
#1


I'd like to gather a general consensus of the armorsmiths regarding whether wookie armor should be wookie-only craftable (as bowcasters are) or craftable by any armorsmith (as wookie clothing is). Feel free to provide a rationale for your position if you would like.


Note: This survey is not determinative of whether wookie armor will be/will not be craftable only by wookies. However, I will take whatever position the majority endorses to the developers as the position of the armorcrafting community. The more support for a particular position we have, the more weight it will carry. To that end, please do not use this thread to argue the merits and weaknesses of each side and please post only once.

Message Edited by JaatoWaals on 03-23-2004 09:01 PM



Waals Industries

-Armor for the new Imperium-

www.hrafnwarband.org
Slider067
Tue Mar 23, 2004 9:04 am
#2

As much as I'd like to try my hand at crafting it and want more options, I think the wookies should get the job. Or at least a bonus in it's crafting.


I would be more supportive of a "bonus" in it's making. Not more points, just a better chance for successful experiments.


2 reasons:


1 - I think it follows the path of the bowcaster in the congruity of the game.


2 - I have plenty of reasources to keep track of already.





__________________________________________
Slyder, FS Master Crafter, 12point maker of brand-X armor 2894 5097 Tatooine
Come shop at SPS...it's just as good as the next guy's...
For a small fee, I'll train your chimpanzee how to make armor under the new system
jhfries
Tue Mar 23, 2004 9:17 am
#3

Though I would love to have another type of armor available to craft, I really believe the ability to create Wookie armor should only belong to the Wookies. It would seem to make sense and follow the path of the Wookie culture. In this way, any Wookie can craft their own personal armor, take pride in collecting the required resources and building a work of art, yet only the best Wookie armor would be made by Wookie armorsmiths.



§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§
§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§
§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§
§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§
§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§
XAvad Cousmew X
Obsidian Dagger Squadron
AvCom Corporation

Srednii
Tue Mar 23, 2004 9:26 am
#4

If the devs are going to put all this huge amount of work into the game creating a new armor type for armorsmiths to make, then it should be content for all of us.


Not just the 2 or 3 wookiee armorsmiths per server.





------------------------------------------------------------

Sre'dni Vashtar - Bria
sv Armoury -4976, 2712 Corellia
AtPlay
Tue Mar 23, 2004 9:30 am
#5

As a Wookiee I say no way, I want everyone to have it. The problem is that if only Wookiees can Armorsmiths can make it, the price will be dictated by the 1 or 2 people on each server. So they will be too rare and overpriced, just like Bowcasters are currently.

If the devs want to have it make more sence, have a series of quests to get the schematic (not as difficult as the RIS quest) from a Wookiee NPC.



Sagax/Chilastra
Master Creature Handler forever...
dingwog1
Tue Mar 23, 2004 9:36 am
#6

It is just a uninformed guess that thier are "2 or 3" wookie armorsmiths per server. Even if that is the case I think wookies should be able to craft only. Clothing is a different as any race should be able to make a few loin clothes to wrap around the wookie. However, just like bowcasters,wookie armor technology should be something only understood by wookies.



Darko Sifo-Dyas Dark Jedi Apprentice

Musicka Master Shipwright

[ dub federation ]

shops @ [5480 -1380] New Freedom, Tatooine


CharPrime
Tue Mar 23, 2004 9:38 am
#7

i don't know a single wookie armorsmith on intrepid.



Vendor location kor vella -2931 1721.
Drop of vendor location kor vella -2897 1698

RIS quest and set completed on 6-12-04,

Manbush
Tue Mar 23, 2004 9:41 am
#8

I vote to make it craftable by everyone, however I have no problem with wookies getting a bonus during crafting.


Another idea would be to give wookies extra colors to choose from, or even be able to choose from a few tribal patterns or similar while non-wookies were confined to the standard palette.



I have several reasons, most based on supply and demand. The armor would be harder to find, the pricing would be more open to abuse, there would be less variety, wookie smiths would be overrun by requests (cutting into their regular market), etc.


We don't even know how good it will be yet. I'm sure wookie smiths won't be happy sacrificing income to meet demand on wookie armor if it is average quality (and therefore less profitable). So they will stop. Then we will have wookies complaining that nobody makes armor for them.


I also suggest making it available fairly early in the personal armor tree. This will help counter the fact that an armorsmith can't make anything worth selling until he is (nearly) amaster.


I don't buy the continuity rationale. If there is a market, people of all species would attempt to fill it. The only way it would be ignored by non-wookies was if it was poor quality and mainly traditional in function (unlikely), or if it required some feat during crafting that only a wookie was capable of.


Basically, if you make it only craftable by wookies you will be forcing all future armorsmiths toplay wookies if they intend to get the most out of their profession. I thought this was a trait of other mmorpgs that SWG was hoping to avoid.
UmmonPrime
Tue Mar 23, 2004 9:50 am
#9

As much as I understand this is "wookiee" technology, all ASs are in need of something new. I would be all for it being a wookiee only armor if another type was also released that all could make.


If that is not possible, then make it so it could be obtained through a wookiee npc in a set of quest.


It would be unfair for only wookiees to get this since we have all been waiting for a new armor to craft.




Elood- Trader - Retired AS/SW

Elood'- Jedi- I know, I suck. Bite me

Dark Sword, Naboo 6932 2054 Loots


WetPipple
Tue Mar 23, 2004 10:33 am
#10



I agree w/ jhfries. AllWookiees would be able to make their own armor, but they'd have to be a smith to make the best. Same way it works for bowcasters.




Le'roy
Master Armorsmith
Master Gunfighter
Tantive, Corellia - Chilastra
AegolinAdaron
Tue Mar 23, 2004 10:48 am
#11

I see no reason to have class-specific armor (or clothing) only be made by that class. It will severly limit the availability of the armor andraise the price. I agree with someone who said that if the developers finally put so much effort in making new armor available, it should be for all armorsmiths, not just a few.


Emily


StarchMonkey
Tue Mar 23, 2004 11:03 am
#12

I agree thatideally it should be wookiee only, but we need something else for all of us. Perhaps there should be some wookiee armorsmith on Endor somewhere that we have to visit to teach us how to make it. I'm not talking an RIS quest thing, but something where you pay him 20k for the schematics or something to role play actually having to learn about Wookiees and making their armor. I think that would be more fun anyways than just dumping the schematics in our Datapad.

Message Edited by StarchMonkey on 03-23-2004 12:04 PM



-------------------------------------------------------
Joryn Sunnrae
Master Swordsman
Master Medic
-------------------------------------------------------
Ceroshin
Tue Mar 23, 2004 11:03 am
#13

Make it craftable by any AS.


It'll be a lot better quality, and lower price that way.



"Very true, if there was one thing that Hitler, Stalin, Napoleon, and Castro all had in common, it was their total and absolute hatred of helvectica fonts."
--Welwood

"Dad...The Combat Balance ran away...the Devs can't seem to find it"
--Garvin
Page 1 of 6
Previous Next