Architect Archive

Thread: which is better?

Geeto
Wed Jun 22, 2005 4:28 pm
#118

Which is better than katarn knuckler or the necrosis nightblade one?


Just a wondering question.





Turanko Ravaov-Shadowfire-Jedi
OWNZ
(gggggggggggggggg]WXgg[w]g]]]g g[[[g[w]ggWX[gggggggggggggggg)
Warriors For The Empire
Ronaj
Wed Jun 22, 2005 4:31 pm
#119

Personally I'd say the katarn, higher base dps (320 I think), lower sac at 75. The necrosis is 270something base dps, higher sac and while it does have those 2 modifies, speed and damage I think, the damage one won't actually do anything since those particular mods only kick in when you fight with no weapon at all.



IGN Ronaj Anatil - Master Ranger

Contract Miner For Hire

9,080,937 units mined under contract since CU and counting


Painting Vendor 3314, -867 Commerce City, Lok

Melakum
Wed Jun 22, 2005 4:34 pm
#120


matter of opinion and what pup and slice you have on it, otherwise pretty equal, katarn 715 +120 elemental nightblade is 755 or so techincally katarn is better





Melakum
Master Spy
Former Teras Kasi Master

Elder Player (Pre-Order, Pre-Publish Six, Pre CU, Pre NGE, and still here)

Master Spy -JKO-

-JKO-
OneGaiFromTokyo
Tue Jun 28, 2005 3:59 pm
#121

Both =)
RedRaider1
Fri Aug 19, 2005 3:11 pm
#122

The Grievous ship or the Heavy X-Wing? I'm about to be 4333 and I'm just wondering which one is better or is one better for PvE, the other good for PvP? If so, please let me know. Any info is appreciated thanks in adavnce.
S-1-l2-H-C
Fri Aug 19, 2005 3:30 pm
#123


that depends on what kind of pve were talking about here. if you are trying to do smoething dangerous like the lord cyssc mission, i would suggest the GSF since its much harder to hit and therefor alot more survivable. if you are just farming tier5s in kessel or deep space for loot i would take the heavy x since you are at no risk from the npcs and the only thing that matters to you is how fast you can 'vape them and move on to the next spawn.


that said the heavyx can do anything that the GSF can, but the GSF leaves more room for inexperianced pilots.




____________________________
Starsider:
Harotak, Imperial Ace, pilot of the RGI "No Quarter" and the "ISS Enforcer"
Katorah, Corsec Security forces, Captian of "The Unrelenting
Harotak', Rebel Terrorist
Zotux
Fri Aug 19, 2005 3:39 pm
#124






S-1-l2-H-C wrote:


that depends on what kind of pve were talking about here. if you are trying to do smoething dangerous like the lord cyssc mission, i would suggest the GSF since its much harder to hit and therefor alot more survivable. if you are just farming tier5s in kessel or deep space for loot i would take the heavy x since you are at no risk from the npcs and the only thing that matters to you is how fast you can 'vape them and move on to the next spawn.


that said the heavyx can do anything that the GSF can, but the GSF leaves more room for inexperianced pilots.






I agree, except for taking the heavy x into DS. It is good to farm with, but if an enemy player jumps in with a JSF you are toast. Unless you get the jump on him before he see's you. Unless I'm just goofing around(plan on taking KSE up against the ISD) I never go into DS with anything bigger than the GSF or a-wing.




Galio Lan'Dofo
BOSS
R9D14
Fri Aug 19, 2005 4:20 pm
#125

would people please look a few threads below the one you jsut make? http://forums.station.sony.com/swg/board/message?board.id=pilot&message.id=108202

Message Edited by R9D14 on 08-19-2005 04:20 PM



Stuu Pididiot
Rebel Ace Pilot
Crimson 5----Pilot of Hunk-o'-Junk I-XII
Eater of Pie
Zotux
Fri Aug 19, 2005 5:32 pm
#126






R9D14 wrote:

would people please look a few threads below the one you jsut make? http://forums.station.sony.com/swg/board/message?board.id=pilot&message.id=108202

Message Edited by R9D14 on 08-19-2005 04:20 PM





You know that nobody ever listens to this advice, so why keep cramming down ppl's throats?


Same goes for "read the faq" while it is good advice, the lazy ones just won't do it.


sometimes these posts can just be missed.(except the stickied ones.)


And sometimes a person may not have time to read through a bunch of threads to get this info.

So basically you are just wasting your own time to leave comments like this.

*just my opinion*




Galio Lan'Dofo
BOSS
Attacca
Fri Aug 19, 2005 6:32 pm
#127

1. Heavy X-Wings do quite well in Deep Space. In fact, a good pilot who knows what they're doing can be very successful, especially since the X-Wing can soak up quite a bit of damage properly managed (but wait, waaaaah, PvP is one hit kills! LIES!). It has the mass to hold components to make up for it's slightly slower handling.


2. Telling people to read the FAQ is in the hopes that they will learn, since most people posting that are new to the forums.


3. To the original poster - why not try flying both and decide for yourself? Belbullab's are running 200-300k on the servers I play, and the Heavy X-Wing is free when you do the quest.






~ Captain Nesanya / Murphey ~
Rebel Alliance A-Wing Pilot
...has mastered the Pilot profession
Are you a pilot and not using Droid Commands?

Kryxal
Fri Aug 19, 2005 9:38 pm
#128








Zotux wrote:


You know that nobody ever listens to this advice, so why keep cramming down ppl's throats?


Same goes for "read the faq" while it is good advice, the lazy ones just won't do it.


sometimes these posts can just be missed.(except the stickied ones.)


And sometimes a person may not have time to read through a bunch of threads to get this info.

So basically you are just wasting your own time to leave comments like this.

*just my opinion*





The funny thing about not having time to look it up and starting a new thread is this:if the information isn't too hard to find, you'll almost certainly get it LATER than by looking yourself. Now, it requires less ACTIVE time on your part, but also ends up spending other people's time.


Oh, and as for dying in DS with the Heavy X, so what? If somebody shows up in DS you can expect not to have so much time to fight PvE even if you win, since there's a good chance they'll be back soon ... it might be worth it to farm elsewhere.



...has mastered the Pilot profession

Kryxal Lightsky - Radiant - Cancelled Dec. 7
Kagami Lightingdark - Radiant - Cancelled Dec. 7
Kikuko Inoue - Starsider - Cancelled Dec. 7
Momoko - Radiant - Cancelled Aug. 22
RedRaider1
Sat Aug 20, 2005 10:07 am
#129


Thanks for the responses, at least to those that were helpful. As for not looking into other posts to find the info: I didn't see any other threads that indicated I might get an answer to this question. I also know about the differences between each ship but i thought picking other players brains would be more beneficial in terms of getting useful information.


To the poster that suggested trying both ships: thanks I will do that. I already looted the Belbullab from NK and I'm finishing the Advanced X-wing mission today. After that I'll test each of them out.

Zotux
Sat Aug 20, 2005 3:41 pm
#130








Kryxal wrote:


The funny thing about not having time to look it up and starting a new thread is this:if the information isn't too hard to find, you'll almost certainly get it LATER than by looking yourself. Now, it requires less ACTIVE time on your part, but also ends up spending other people's time.


Oh, and as for dying in DS with the Heavy X, so what? If somebody shows up in DS you can expect not to have so much time to fight PvE even if you win, since there's a good chance they'll be back soon ... it might be worth it to farm elsewhere.






My message about posting "look at the other threads" is more aimed at people who seem to love posting for just that reason....not to help anyone, but just troll repeat subjects and saying "read the faq" and "look at other posts" those are both good peices of advice. but at the same time, while a person is spending time making that message, they can at the same time say, "and check this link out" or "check out the post named 'xxx' it has some info for you"


Now as for the heavy x, I have not PVP'd in it yet, but herad it is a death trap. I do plan on trying it though. That and probably the KSE just for laughs.




Galio Lan'Dofo
BOSS
Page 10 of 11