Teras Kasi Archive

Thread: Why Cant TKA have A DOT?

BScary
Wed Mar 03, 2004 9:55 pm
#1

Every other combat class in the game has a DOT attack, one form Heavy Swordsman bleeds to Commando's flame. Why dont we? Wouldn't it be nice to be able to have that damm Ranged Weapon Armed Marathon runner who's just out of reach atleast have a bleed action so it even things up a bit when we are bleeding to death chasing him? I know this post will be meet with throngs of people who have had the pleasure of getting dismantled by a TK screaming "No Way, the class is overpowered already!" But fair is fair, If you can bleed/disease/set us on fire, why cant we have a DOT as well.


Scary

TKM



Scary
Master of too many to list besides by the time you read this there'd be another to add to the list anyway.
KnightHawk420
Wed Mar 03, 2004 10:12 pm
#2

Because no other class can sit sit down on they're legs and magically cure themselves of all they're wounds/poisons/diseases.


Besides.... dots are now pointless.




Cheylin Mena - R.I.P.
Menon Mena - R.I.P.
Hunglo Bavmador - R.I.P.
KeyTokikoMima
Wed Mar 03, 2004 10:17 pm
#3

Well... if I had to say why, it would be.. a balancing measure.



TKAaloneget:


-- the highest Damage Per Second in pure melee


-- the ability to go without a weapon


-- Meditation Techniques which includes


---- Self only no HAM cost Poison healing


---- Self only no HAM cost Disease healing


---- Self only no HAM cost Bleed healing


---- Self only no HAM cost Wound healing


---- Free Primary Attribute buffs of ~500


---- At some point in the future: 'Force of Will' which I have never had work for me.



For these abilities TKA alone pay the following costs:

-- No Bleeds

-- Light or No Armor Piercing only

-- Kinetic damage only


I personally think we make out like bandits. Every other combat profession should be so lucky.
Defconn
Wed Mar 03, 2004 10:45 pm
#4

This is a personal opinion only. I think we should put this issue of beating a ranged opponent kiting TKM's to rest. A TKM, from my understanding at least, is an unarmed martial arts exponent. Hence :

a) He should only be able to damage his opponent if that opponent is within reach of his hands or feet.

b) He should NEVER run after a man with a gun, in the open, Accepting a challenge from a man with a gun, on open ground, is suicide. So, if the TKM dies because of it, he deserves it. Combat balance be damned. It would be completely unrealistic to have an unarmed exponent face off and beat a man with a rifle from 30m's away.

c) Having a dot? The fastest and easiest way for an unarmed exponent to cause a bleed is to punch someone in the nose. Yet, I sincerely doubt that anyone has ever died of a nose bleed. To cause a heavier bleed, a cutting weapon is needed AND once you have a cutting weapon in your hands, you are no longer TKM but swordsman, fencer or pikeman.

d) I'm 50/50 on the use of simple weapons. Martial arts exponents of so called "empty fisted" arts all have various ways and means to turn simple daily items into weapons. A rolled up magazine, for example, makes a very nice baton if correctly used, and a towel works wonders even against a sword. But one thing for sure...no thrown weapon short of a a spear, is going to be armour piercing, and contrary to the opinions of Hollywood, no light dagger nor shuriken or "throwing stars" are ever going to cause really much damage at any distance further than 10 feet.

What I am really trying to say here is that TKM are masters of close quarter fighting. Much better than a swordsman, pikeman or fencer in close quarters. We do not and in fact, should not, excel in open field combat. So, we should not be asking and insisting for ranged abilities.

Personally, whenever I have ever been challenged, it's usually another friendly TKM wanting to test a new macro, or a particular defence stack, or a ranged fighter wanting to prove how macho he is. To the ranged fighter, I simply ask him if he is aware that my effective range is only 20m? He says yes. Then I proceed to ask him, loudly and in public, about making the duel fairer and more interesting...by doing one my pistol against his pistol...followed by me unarmed against him unarmed.

They usually lose interest round about this time....



Boars Power-ups & General Store
Shop Location : Correlia, 3 minutes NNE of Coronet, Loc : -219, -3324.
Crates of Power-Ups, Furniture & Structures by Akairo, Vehicles, High Effectiveness Crafting Stations.
IVIafioso
Wed Mar 03, 2004 11:07 pm
#5






KeyTokikoMima wrote:

Well... if I had to say why, it would be.. a balancing measure.



TKAaloneget:


-- the highest Damage Per Second in pure melee


-- the ability to go without a weapon


-- Meditation Techniques which includes


---- Self only no HAM cost Poison healing


---- Self only no HAM cost Disease healing


---- Self only no HAM cost Bleed healing


---- Self only no HAM cost Wound healing


---- Free Primary Attribute buffs of ~500


---- At some point in the future: 'Force of Will' which I have never had work for me.



For these abilities TKA alone pay the following costs:

-- No Bleeds

-- Light or No Armor Piercing only

-- Kinetic damage only


I personally think we make out like bandits. Every other combat profession should be so lucky.







amen brother



it really bugs me that so many "uber" TK's are running around trying to make their prof. better when they can plainly see that that other melee (and most other) profs are still so far behind. how about we keep the "lets improve TK by adding <insertsomethingthatwouldmakeTKmoreoverpoweredthanitalreadyishere>......." to a minumum.


and come on...asking for a bleed for crying outloud. fencers are currently trying to get rid of their bleed and get something that is actually useful in its place.



*shakes head* pathetic....




Lenoc wrote: Behold my awesome might as I fearlessly chase you across Talus with my stick and butterknife, deftly catching every bolt of energy you kindly toss into my face!!! I will remove all of my clothes to hit you better! Nudity saves!! Armor and Clothes kills!! I will laugh as you kite me, since you do not know the glory of the naked butterknife/stick wielder! Your pets will whine and cringe, licking at my unshod feet just before they DB me and still I will laugh! Why?! They are naked and do not wield a butterknife or carry a stick! Only a fool does not fully follow the true path of the Fencer! Long live nudity, sticks and butterknives!!!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cakins7005
Thu Mar 04, 2004 12:00 am
#6

Hold on to what you have already. You are overpowered without bleeds. They nerfed bleeds so much already. Go ahead and have a 50 point bleed in PvP. Its not going to do anything.



Eti Vauspavim
Dark Jedi Templar
Imperial Pilot Ace
Defconn
Thu Mar 04, 2004 12:13 am
#7

Still trolling, Cakins?...I thought you were going to level TKM...shouldn't you be getting to it instead of yapping here?



Boars Power-ups & General Store
Shop Location : Correlia, 3 minutes NNE of Coronet, Loc : -219, -3324.
Crates of Power-Ups, Furniture & Structures by Akairo, Vehicles, High Effectiveness Crafting Stations.
Cakins7005
Thu Mar 04, 2004 12:23 am
#8

Capped on unarmed exp for now. I will get lame chef done tommorrow. Don't mess with me though. I learned new moves from the movies. Charging Grand Pa will make you run away from the stench of an old geezer named Obi-Wan. In episode 3 it turns out that Luke is actually Obi-Wan's son and that makes Anakin turn to the dark side.

Message Edited by Cakins7005 on 03-03-2004 11:24 PM



Eti Vauspavim
Dark Jedi Templar
Imperial Pilot Ace
Defconn
Thu Mar 04, 2004 12:33 am
#9

Level first...learn skills first...learn to USE skills properly first...

Open mouth later...



Boars Power-ups & General Store
Shop Location : Correlia, 3 minutes NNE of Coronet, Loc : -219, -3324.
Crates of Power-Ups, Furniture & Structures by Akairo, Vehicles, High Effectiveness Crafting Stations.
Slickmink
Thu Mar 04, 2004 2:44 am
#10

Yeah I've found that I end up giving random conditions to what ever I hit with Hit3 and sometimes its a bleed, but I never find out what it is either as the target usually dies to fast.
tntkiller
Thu Mar 04, 2004 6:23 am
#11

i only wish we could dip our VK in some acid or do stun damage when i take the VK off(or does it do that?? dunno) or use some pertol on my VK and make it do fire damage or lay it in the fridge do do cold damage



in short no DOTs thats ok let us at least have some other damage types other then kenetic






Mornie Utulie

Master Smuggler / Master TKA


Aynsun
Thu Mar 04, 2004 6:33 am
#12

We don't need bleeds. We have meditation, accuracy and speed instead of bleeds, another damage type and AP2+ Let the other professions have that in their offence arsenal.



Account cancelled and business closed, Bye bye all
Valor
Thu Mar 04, 2004 6:58 am
#13

i'd take a bleed, it'd be nice

i already have mind poison VKs and Health Fire DOT VKs (which both ROCK in pvp)...too bad limited uses lol





LordValor/LadyValor/DukeValor
.......:::: Proud member of Oasis ::::.......
.......:::: Lt Colonel in the Imperial Navy ::::.......
.......:::: Vendor: East Crystal Oasis, Dantooine -2965 6673 ::::.......
| Master Smuggler; Master Pilot/Elder Dark Jedi Master/Architect-Shipwright |
Page 1 of 2
Previous Next