Swordsman Archive
Thread: What are the best stats for an unsliced Cleaver??
Really depends upon the server but I can crank out the following on Starsider (I'm also a Master Weaponsmith BTW)
2H Cleaver: 101-219 3.4speed
Vibro Axe: 112-242 4.6speed
2H Axe: 134-196 3.7speed
charvakas,
Granted you exaggerating to make your point but in reality, you have to take each weapon/configuration and factor in the mitigation. A wider range is affected more by the mitigation than a narrower range, but as your illustration actually shows, a weapon with a wide range but much higher max will still usuallybe the weapon of choice. Using your example, after mitigation, the stats would be:
Weapon 1: 200 - 200
Weapon 2: 1 - 4001
Thus, the second weapon will still be averaging 10 x the damage of the max of the first even though mitigation reduced the max damage of the second weapon by nearly 6,000 points.
My point is just that you have to look at each weapon and circumstance and figure out what has changed and go from there.