Smuggler Archive

Thread: Wes, what are they doing to Concussion Shot?

riotcontrol
Mon Jun 20, 2005 4:58 am
#14



AngusMacGregor wrote:


riotcontrol wrote:

But what would Pistoleers get as their "defining" move then?



I don't know... and frankly, I really don't care. Let them figure it out. I worry about this profession. I may have Master Pistoleer skills, but I'm not a Pistoleer, I'm a Smuggler.




Don't be silly.

In the current CURB system, contrary to what was promised, there's just not enough skilss (especially CC and Position Control-related) to go around... It's very different from what was expected - professions now have just one or two specials that are actually in line with their role descriptions, and I don't see how giving redundant specials to different professions can be a good thing in such a system. Adding new ones to further strenghten the profession roles, yes... but cloning the current ones and distributing them all around?

First of all, there should be some post-CURB vision document for each profession officially released, because... well, modifying each one individually without a larger plan will just create FOTMs, overpowered professions and unneeded nerfs. That's a large part of what got us into the whole mess in the first place, wasn't it?



__
wieland argosy <gunslinger>
AngusMacGregor
Mon Jun 20, 2005 5:22 am
#15

I think it should be a mez, as it's supposed to be.


And I don't think anyone can debate that a 40 second root is just too much. I'd love to have just a nice little 10 second root. I don't think that would be unbalancing. Let the Pistoleers keep their 20 second root all to themselves.


And riot, root is not a Pistoleer defining move. If it was, then Jedi wouldn't have it, too. And shame on you for thinking about every profession as a whole, and not selfishly thinking about only us poor Smugglers.




"C O L O N E L A N G U S" M A C G R E G O R
DEAD SMUGGLER - KILLED BY LACK OF CONTENT AND COMMUNICATION
I am Jack's ignored profession.
My account payment has been moved to a long term implementation.
riotcontrol
Mon Jun 20, 2005 5:30 am
#16


AngusMacGregor wrote:
And riot, root is not a Pistoleer defining move. If it was, then Jedi wouldn't have it, too.




But Jedi have variations of pretty much all combat/healing profession-specific skills in their various sub-profession trees. They are... "special", remember? (Seriously, that's why they weren't even in the CURB diagram, their template defines the role really.)



__
wieland argosy <gunslinger>
AngusMacGregor
Mon Jun 20, 2005 5:33 am
#17

Yeah, they're "special" all right.


In fact, I think most of them are just about ready for the Special Olympics.




"C O L O N E L A N G U S" M A C G R E G O R
DEAD SMUGGLER - KILLED BY LACK OF CONTENT AND COMMUNICATION
I am Jack's ignored profession.
My account payment has been moved to a long term implementation.
Jaguarrr
Mon Jun 20, 2005 6:03 am
#18






AngusMacGregor wrote:

Yeah, they're "special" all right.


In fact, I think most of them are just about ready for the Special Olympics.






Ooooh, the lightsaber high jump, syncron saber swinging, long range saber throw, 1000m forcesprint...



We couldn't play SWG without Tiggs. Now we can =)
AngusMacGregor
Mon Jun 20, 2005 6:06 am
#19


I was thinking more along the lines of Freestyle Whining.


Or maybe the Nerf Call Decathalon.

Message Edited by AngusMacGregor on 06-20-2005 09:10 AM




"C O L O N E L A N G U S" M A C G R E G O R
DEAD SMUGGLER - KILLED BY LACK OF CONTENT AND COMMUNICATION
I am Jack's ignored profession.
My account payment has been moved to a long term implementation.
Nezodon
Mon Jun 20, 2005 6:18 am
#20

Looking at the discription of concusion shot the planned changes seem fair especially since a 40 sec root would be very lethal against a lot of players.


I would love them to revisit reckless shot, panic shot andlow blow (kd please) i wouls also add overwhelming shot because after testing it and testing it to see if the states land more often i have come to the conclusion it has no effect what so ever.


Yes by all means change concussion shot to "working as intended" but while your at it how about looking at the other specials.





Jorrai Takkori
Elder jedi
Force explorer

BladePride
Mon Jun 20, 2005 6:23 am
#21

Cant Rate it until I can play it. Until its live only god knows what mezz will be like, we could see any thing to 40 sec root that cant do anything to 5 sec root that cant do anything. Hack, we may shot them and they walk around like a chicken for all we know or dance a jig. But were all Smugglers so we will find a way to use it one way or the other.



-----------------------------------------------
AngusMacGregor
Mon Jun 20, 2005 6:30 am
#22

Or we'll get pissed because we got shafted once again, then drown our sorrows in beer and pie while waiting for the Devs to neuter our beloved profession once again...



Just saying... it could happen.







"C O L O N E L A N G U S" M A C G R E G O R
DEAD SMUGGLER - KILLED BY LACK OF CONTENT AND COMMUNICATION
I am Jack's ignored profession.
My account payment has been moved to a long term implementation.
Page 2 of 2