Rifleman Archive

Thread: Masking scent vs. conceal shot

Splackity
Fri Oct 10, 2003 7:35 pm
#1

In the patch, mask scent was made to be removed when entering combat. This makes plenty of sense to me, normally - except when considering conceal shot. The whole purpose of the shot is to remain concealed. However, when you fire you lose your masked scent... so any aggro creature has a good chance of smelling you and going aggro even though you're using a shot which has the intention of making you remain concealed from that which you are shooting. PLEASE, devs, consider reversing this for that shot? It doesn't make sense to reveal yourself using a shot which is meant to conceal.

Unless someone can give me a LOGICAL reason why we shouldn't be able to remain concealed when using conceal shot?



Rossi
Grand Master of the Omniscient Determination
Master Procrastinator
Master Bai...Fisherman
ASBESTOS
Stele578
Sat Oct 11, 2003 2:02 am
#2

your concealing a "shot." once whatever your shooting has been "shot", if its not dead its aware of you.
Ivankils
Sat Oct 11, 2003 4:16 am
#3

aware that it just got hit by something yes.....automatically no exactly where you are and be able to alert everyone else in the area....not likely.


If you're hidden that well and shoot a silent shot from cover...why the hell should every creature in the area jump on you like ants ata picnic?


Nah, left rifleman long ago.....stupid screwed up class if you asked me.....to many dumb things, like this for example.

Barb-Wire
Sat Oct 11, 2003 6:13 am
#4

dont get within 40 meters of at target u dont need maskscent since they will no longer come after you unless your within 40 meters.



Created Account July 2003 - Canceled account Nov 2005. The NGE made me do it.
Barb Wire
Former Dark Force Wielder
Ex-Imperial Navy
Jaelk
Sat Oct 11, 2003 6:41 am
#5

Really! Wow! Could have fooled me since every mob I attacked today was from between 60 and 64 meters and EVERY time I got the BAF attack on me.


Not sure what was intended but I don't think it's workin'


Ja'elk

JohaoCarl
Sat Oct 11, 2003 3:45 pm
#6

Yes, when I am using conceal sjot to attack one creautre, now all the creature friends attack me. The name of the special is CONCEAL shot or is VISIBLE TO EVERYONE shot?



Johao'Carl Baptis
Novice Rifleman (1 1 0 0)
Master Artisan, Novice Droid Engineer
vendor at Jaxian Bay City, Naboo, waypoint -6499 6635
250 meters from the shuttleport! My vendor is selling vehicles!
DesertNomad
Sat Oct 11, 2003 3:55 pm
#7

I believe you are right Rossi. This has got to be an oversight by the devs. Conceal shot should be the exception to losing mask scent when in combat. According to definition, conceal shot, if successful, means that you have hit your target withoutthe targetknowing where the shot came from.


There is no logical reason why you cannot be masked while concealing shots and I think this should be fixed.


In the meantime, other tactics I've triedmay work. Since rangers now know when they are being stalked, you can /peace when this happens, then mask scent, wait a few seconds, then start back up with the conceal shots, until they "find" you again...rinse...repeat.


Anyone know the proper channel to make a request for this fix?


Treltek Soltaran
Ranger/Rifleman
Bria

InimicalDE
Sat Oct 11, 2003 8:59 pm
#8

Mask scent versus conceal shot is a moot point. The description in game says:


/concealshot <target>: This ranged sneak attack, if successful, will damage your target without them knowing where the attack came from.


We know from experience that it really means:


/concealshot <target>: This ranged sneak attack, if successful, will damage your target without them knowing where the attack came from (while everything around them comes to beat you down whether you are /concealed or /maskscented or not). Enjoy!


If C.S. worked like it is advertised, this whole thread would be moot.




-Nexi Ecobap-
Ranger, Rifleman, CH, Eater of Donuts
Myzzter
Sat Oct 11, 2003 11:17 pm
#9

Anyone tried Conceal Shot Using Camo?



Just curious



Myzzter

Fred_Skinner
Sun Oct 12, 2003 1:36 am
#10

camo (/conceal command from Ranger) does not drop until you take damage. I have not yet tested it as a combo, I may later today and tell you what happens (They say Humbas[Corellia] are BAF now?).



Frederick Skinner
Antarian Ranger, Ranger(0030), Master Rifleman, CH(4214)
Ranger is not a profession. It's a lifestyle.


charvakas
Mon Oct 13, 2003 2:39 am
#11

"Really! Wow! Could have fooled me since every mob I attacked today was from between 60 and 64 meters and EVERY time I got the BAF attack on me.

Not sure what was intended but I don't think it's workin' "

yeah, that's not what they're talking about, aggro creatures (red on the map) won't attack you unless you get within 40 meters, pack assist still works from as long a range as you care to try to shoot the thing, only thing that matters for pack assist is how far the creatures are from EACH OTHER.

and yes it is stupid, pack assist is my NUMBER ONE, WITHOUT A DOUBT complaint about riflemen. with my ch/pistoleer I could give a crap, but for my ranger/rifleman who's shtick is not getting seen, well it's a major bummer. sucks to be me, I picked a character concept which is totaly broken, or was never intended to work at all. how silly of me to think a sniper with an ability called "concealshot" could, you know, snipe.



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I bent my wookiee.
Auction ban list: Juado, Setalle
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ZFireDancer
Tue Oct 14, 2003 12:55 am
#12

Now that maskscent's gone, might as well just run into the mobs screaming "I'm meat! Bite me, hungry beasts!"

I could see making maskscent breakable in combat IF conceal shot actually concealed, but having every mob around target you as soon as you use it (except, of course, your initial hapless target) is silly.

We need conceal shot fixed.
Page 1 of 1
Previous Next