I'll start by listing my credentials, I started playing the first week or two of launch. The very first profession I ever wanted to be was a rifleman. Partly because the strategy guide made all the professions sound much cooler then they were but mostly because I wanted to be the lone sniper, tramping through the wilds, one shot one kill the whole deal. This turned out to be one of many fatal errors I made when starting this game, another being I chose a Wookiee. Who knew the the battle raging powerful Wookiee race had been reduced to teddy bears? I sure as hell sh*t didn't. Anyway that's another topic in itself. So there I began on my road to a rifleman ranger.
Months and months passed without the production of our expert weapon the T21 (described in the strategy guide as a repeater rifle) and when it finally showed up they were over 200k credits. I know that doesn't sound like much now but back then it was a small fortune for anyone who wasn't a weaponsmith. Aside from that they were far from being a repeater rifle (and still are).
Armed with my sub-par weaponry (laser rifles, tusken rifles ect.) and a 2.5x melee damage modifier I was never informed of, I sought to make the best of it and did what I could as an unarmored wookiee with a few broken ranger traps and my trusty tusken rifle.
One night I was feeling particularly brash and decided to play my forseen role as the lone sniper. I took up a laser rifle went overt in AH and headed north to Bestine. I began to circle the perimeter of the city in search of targets, I spotted a few, worked myself into position and blew their heads off with one swift shot. This was to be the one and only night I truly felt like a rifleman, since soon after the 75% PvP damage reduction went live.
Thoroughly crippled by that fateful patch I stuck to PvE. Although this was proving to be equally unfulfilling. Since most creatures are melee and my unarmored wookiee ass exposed to the world this was very difficult even with doc buffs. The 2.5x dmg modifier was 100% unjustified and really took away all the fun I could have been having. This and the PvP reduction effectively killed my vision of the lone sniper, and to top things off our one move most dedicated to this idea "Conceal Shot" would alert every agro in the area but the person you were shooting at. You can start to see how frustrating this was becoming for me.
With my initial plans crumbling to dust in my hands, and my recent reading of the "Han Solo Trilogy" I decided to drop ranger (2 days before they fixed it) and take up smuggler (which I still am today). Bearing the frustration as long as I could, and talk of nerfing rifleman even then,I finally gave up rifleman and took up commando as well. After grinding commando and coming to the realization of how worthless my wookiee actually was in combat I took a break, made some toons on other servers which opened my eyes to the wookiee plight,and eventually got my hands on a second account and createda Zabrak toon in hopes of returning to my original desire to be a rifleman.
Now I have a new toon pursuing this profession, and once again I hear talk about nerfing, it really got me thinking of what the real problems with the profession are. What I concluded is that the rifleman profession is one giant fallacy.
How are we supposed to be stealthy snipers when there is a radar that cannot be bypassed, or someone can simply hit tab and target you through terrain? How can we counter-snipe (which we have an entire skill tree dedicated to) when there is no sniping to begin with, not to mention the fact that going prone in combat equals certain death. What sense would it make to cap the speed of a master rifleman? Some masters we would be huh?
There are several other small points to be made but since this is already getting too long, these are the MAIN reasons why a rifleman cannot work in SWG without sacrificing what it means to be a rifleman/sniper.
I do have some ideas but I'll let this sit with you for now, I apologize for making this so long but this has been bothering me for a while, and I thank you for reading the entire post.
*** sig changed by moderator - inappropriate ***