Pistoleer Archive

Thread: out of these 2 pistols what seems to be the better one... need some help

Radew
Sun Jul 31, 2005 11:48 am
#1

Pistol 1: HC Scatter w/ damage pup
Speed: 2.30
Damage: 455.76 - 1018.44
Sac - 72
Base DPS: 320.06

or

Pistol 2: HC Scatter w/ sac pup
Speed: 1.71
Damage: 382-926
Sac - 70
Base DPS: 383.35


I get confused, you hear one person say max damage is the most important, then one says dps is the most important. well im confused, which one seems to be better

thanks



__________

radew
____________________
darkstar1313
Sun Jul 31, 2005 11:50 am
#2


first one is definately best the sac on the second one must be a killer

and really sac is what you are lookin for

Message Edited by darkstar1313 on 07-31-2005 11:51 AM





-/||---The Legendary J.Bling---||\-

.<> Jack-Bling on Shadowfire <>.
Radew
Sun Jul 31, 2005 11:53 am
#3

70ish i do ok with
with booster + blob i rarley ever get low
if i do get that low i just disarm shot or stopping shot and chill for a few seconds and its back full again



__________

radew
____________________
BadgerSmaker
Sun Jul 31, 2005 1:27 pm
#4

If I had a character on Gorath, I would buy Pistol 2 from you just so I could destroy it.



1101000001100110111110111110010010010010
0100010101011011110110101001100100110110
1010101000011110100100001000001000100101
0011001100001100110111010101010011010000
0111100000010111111101110100101101000011
0110101101111001011110111101001000101011
0010100110100000010111010001101110011000
1011111100111011110011001111100110100100
"BAD NPC SPAWNER IS HERE!, NO ENTRY IN NPC SPAWNERS DATATABLE"
Radew
Sun Jul 31, 2005 2:06 pm
#5



BadgerSmaker wrote:
If I had a character on Gorath, I would buy Pistol 2 from you just so I could destroy it.





are you saying that because it is good?

so #2 is the better choice?



__________

radew
____________________
Zimal
Sun Jul 31, 2005 2:35 pm
#6

i think he's sayign that cause 2 is not good... but to clerify... can you post stat's BEFORE puping occurs?


if those are stat's AFTER PUP's then 2 does deserve to be destroyed.... that orignal sac must be horendous to pup it down to that





=============================================
Xil - MCM, Mpistol
Instant Aggro Master
Where Mihosi is, Chaos Reigns
Jedi shmedi, I got me a wookie
Don't piss off a programer, WE READ YOUR EMAIL
BadgerSmaker
Sun Jul 31, 2005 2:51 pm
#7






Radew wrote:





BadgerSmaker wrote:
If I had a character on Gorath, I would buy Pistol 2 from you just so I could destroy it.







are you saying that because it is good?

so #2 is the better choice?




If a SAC pup takes it down to -70 then I assume it has monstrous SAC, 90+, and therefore should be destroyed.



1101000001100110111110111110010010010010
0100010101011011110110101001100100110110
1010101000011110100100001000001000100101
0011001100001100110111010101010011010000
0111100000010111111101110100101101000011
0110101101111001011110111101001000101011
0010100110100000010111010001101110011000
1011111100111011110011001111100110100100
"BAD NPC SPAWNER IS HERE!, NO ENTRY IN NPC SPAWNERS DATATABLE"
SpunkyKuma
Sun Jul 31, 2005 3:00 pm
#8

Would you destroy this one? Of course giving me back the ADK after.



Vicci A'Tivo - Elder "in your face" Bounty Hunter
Ekinn A'Tivo - NGE Jedi
XProdigy - Pre-24 Squad Leader
Chac Baal - Elder Jedi (Omen's first Mon Cal Jedi)
BadgerSmaker
Sun Jul 31, 2005 3:20 pm
#9

I'd make you a nice65 SAC, 880 Max damageGorax FW FWG5 and you can put your kit on that.


We are in a very unfortunate situation where there is only really one gun worth using, the FW FWG5. The only other one you will need is an energy gun, and the DL44XT covers that.




1101000001100110111110111110010010010010
0100010101011011110110101001100100110110
1010101000011110100100001000001000100101
0011001100001100110111010101010011010000
0111100000010111111101110100101101000011
0110101101111001011110111101001000101011
0010100110100000010111010001101110011000
1011111100111011110011001111100110100100
"BAD NPC SPAWNER IS HERE!, NO ENTRY IN NPC SPAWNERS DATATABLE"
ChefVomit
Mon Aug 01, 2005 2:45 am
#10



BadgerSmaker wrote:

I'd make you a nice65 SAC, 880 Max damageGorax FW FWG5 and you can put your kit on that.

We are in a very unfortunate situation where there is only really one gun worth using, the FW FWG5. The only other one you will need is an energy gun, and the DL44XT covers that.






This man speaks the truth. There are rare exceptions of other types of pistols that can compete, but they are just that : Rare. In the end, a nice FW-FWG5 or a DL are amazingly easy and inexpensive to make. And with pre-CU components, they are simply stunning.

This isnt too far different from Carbineer though. Carbineers will use either an E11 or an Elite (they have identical speed, SAC, and damage caps). There really are not any other carbineer weapons worth making. Oh there are BH-certed carbs, but neither the Czerka nor the Proton Carbine can match the performance of an E11.

I agree that it would be nicer to have more choices for weapons once you get to master. As a Master Pistoleer who also happens to be a Master Carbineer, I would love to have more choices. But until then I wont waste my time on any pistols other than the DL and the FW-FWG5.



Zemzam Zeman
__________________________________________________________________________
The crafter formerly known as Chef Vomit
New Profession: PURPLE PEOPLE EATER!
PLEASE DROP OFF ALL WINNINGS AT 3079,3154 Revenance, Lok

BadgerSmaker
Mon Aug 01, 2005 3:12 am
#11

The one benefit to all this is that anyone can own a double capped FW FWG5. Gorax are quite easy to farm until you get some good shards.


I've kitted out my guild with Gorax FW FWG5's, pre-CU it would be quite hard to hand out top of the line guns to everyone.




1101000001100110111110111110010010010010
0100010101011011110110101001100100110110
1010101000011110100100001000001000100101
0011001100001100110111010101010011010000
0111100000010111111101110100101101000011
0110101101111001011110111101001000101011
0010100110100000010111010001101110011000
1011111100111011110011001111100110100100
"BAD NPC SPAWNER IS HERE!, NO ENTRY IN NPC SPAWNERS DATATABLE"
SpunkyKuma
Mon Aug 01, 2005 8:34 am
#12

I have some +97 gorax bones from pre-CU, will give a little experimentation on my WS toon, I did sell a 71 SAC FWG5 a few weeks ago.



Vicci A'Tivo - Elder "in your face" Bounty Hunter
Ekinn A'Tivo - NGE Jedi
XProdigy - Pre-24 Squad Leader
Chac Baal - Elder Jedi (Omen's first Mon Cal Jedi)
SpunkyKuma
Tue Aug 02, 2005 4:11 pm
#13

Well I did some experimenting, 2.29 308-745, 11 ACC and 65 SAC before slice, I did one using a +87 bone that turned out 2.28 335-825, 11 ACC 73 SAC, and a scatter (I forget krayt tissue stat) 2.2 319-813 10 ACC 74 SAC.

Are those a bit better? experimented 9 or 10 points into SAC on sub componments then 2 points into damage then 6 points into SAC and rest on damage on final product, or some variant like that.



Vicci A'Tivo - Elder "in your face" Bounty Hunter
Ekinn A'Tivo - NGE Jedi
XProdigy - Pre-24 Squad Leader
Chac Baal - Elder Jedi (Omen's first Mon Cal Jedi)
Page 1 of 2
Previous Next