Jedi Archive
Thread: PVP Survey
KitalGotServed
Sat Oct 01, 2005 2:58 pm
#28
Vlherg wrote:
So there's a bunch of threads arguing over whether the majority want this, that or the other. This may not be very scientific, but it's better than nothing so please take a few moments to post your answers to these questions. No debates in this thread please, there's plenty of other threads for that.
1. Did you make your jedi with PVP as your primary goal?
2. If you are a full template jedi do you enjoy being hunted by bounty hunters?
3. If you are a grinding jedi do you enjoy being hunted by bounty hunters?
4Are you in favour of removing visibility from NPCs?
5. Are you in favour of reinstating sabre TEF?
6. Are you in favour of jedi being allowed to be PVE only and hunted only by NPC bounty hunters in exchange for some sort of penalty (eg not being allowed to enter FRS orPVP jedi being given extra abilities over PVE jedi)?
7. If you are currently against forced PVP, ifxp loss from BH death was removed, would you then be in favour of being hunted?
1. Of course
2. yes
3. yes
4. no
5.no
6. no
7. Im pro-forced pvp (if one enters a frs)
KaiRaene
Sat Oct 01, 2005 3:32 pm
#29
1. Did you make your jedi with PVP as your primary goal?
No, I never PvP and only went Jedi since it was nice to have an alt.
2. If you are a full template jedi do you enjoy being hunted by bounty hunters? N/A
3. If you are a grinding jedi do you enjoy being hunted by bounty hunters?
I have yet to be hunted.
4 Are you in favour of removing visibility from NPC's? Yes.
5. Are you in favour of reinstating sabre TEF?
Sure, so long as I could actually level solo. Instead of fighting 2 critters and then sitting for 20 minutes to regen my force. I really hate that I have to group to level since I think being a Jedi should be a lonely grind. Esp for rp value.
6. Are you in favour of jedi being allowed to be PVE only and hunted only by NPC bounty hunters in exchange for some sort of penalty (eg not being allowed to enter FRS or PVP jedi being given extra abilities over PVE jedi)? Yes, I would favor this.
7. If you are currently against forced PVP, if xp loss from BH death was removed, would you then be in favour of being hunted? I am against forced PvP and I wouldnt mind one bit if I was hunted if I could avoid xp loss. I gain nothing by fighting/winning and have so much to lose.
No, I never PvP and only went Jedi since it was nice to have an alt.
2. If you are a full template jedi do you enjoy being hunted by bounty hunters? N/A
3. If you are a grinding jedi do you enjoy being hunted by bounty hunters?
I have yet to be hunted.
4 Are you in favour of removing visibility from NPC's? Yes.
5. Are you in favour of reinstating sabre TEF?
Sure, so long as I could actually level solo. Instead of fighting 2 critters and then sitting for 20 minutes to regen my force. I really hate that I have to group to level since I think being a Jedi should be a lonely grind. Esp for rp value.
6. Are you in favour of jedi being allowed to be PVE only and hunted only by NPC bounty hunters in exchange for some sort of penalty (eg not being allowed to enter FRS or PVP jedi being given extra abilities over PVE jedi)? Yes, I would favor this.
7. If you are currently against forced PVP, if xp loss from BH death was removed, would you then be in favour of being hunted? I am against forced PvP and I wouldnt mind one bit if I was hunted if I could avoid xp loss. I gain nothing by fighting/winning and have so much to lose.
Zodiac-B
Sat Oct 01, 2005 3:38 pm
#30
Vlherg wrote:
So there's a bunch of threads arguing over whether the majority want this, that or the other. This may not be very scientific, but it's better than nothing so please take a few moments to post your answers to these questions. No debates in this thread please, there's plenty of other threads for that.
1. Did you make your jedi with PVP as your primary goal? No
2. If you are a full template jedi do you enjoy being hunted by bounty hunters? n/a
3. If you are a grinding jedi do you enjoy being hunted by bounty hunters? No
4Are you in favour of removing visibility from NPCs? No, but would consider removing visibility for all non-faction kills.
5. Are you in favour of reinstating sabre TEF? Yes, but in static cities only by Bounty Hunters. Not everyone.
6. Are you in favour of jedi being allowed to be PVE only and hunted only by NPC bounty hunters in exchange for some sort of penalty (eg not being allowed to enter FRS orPVP jedi being given extra abilities over PVE jedi)? No
7. If you are currently against forced PVP, ifxp loss from BH death was removed, would you then be in favour of being hunted? Yes. Either this or give us a positive reason to stay and fight in addition to the risk.
Message Edited by Zodiac-B on 10-01-2005 03:43 PM
Daytona
Sat Oct 01, 2005 4:00 pm
#31
1. Yes and No, but I knew it was a large part of the profession.
2. I enjoy it when I am in the mood, sometimes it is nice to hang with the guild on the guild hunts with my glow stick and not worry about the BH.
3. Didn't enjoy it while I was grinding pre CU, but new it was part of the profession, lol.
4. Keep the visibility with NPCs AND take away the new group vis-free deal.
5. Yes.
6. I would go with it.
7. Heck, bring back the cloning penalty please!!!! That will teach some of us to not show off.
Ford86
Sat Oct 01, 2005 4:10 pm
#32
1 yes
2 yes
3 n/a
4 no
5 no
6 no
7 no there should be a penalty for all jedi....just as i know the moment i step out of my house im fair game
JBushesq
Sat Oct 01, 2005 5:53 pm
#33
1) Yes
2) Very Much
3) NA
4) No
5) Yes, depending on how it was implimented
6) Yes
7) NA
2) Very Much
3) NA
4) No
5) Yes, depending on how it was implimented
6) Yes
7) NA
Vlherg
Sat Oct 01, 2005 9:43 pm
#34
Please keep the answers coming folks. The more opinions we see the better we know what we want.
guitoorbenchi
Sat Oct 01, 2005 10:05 pm
#35
Vlherg wrote:
So there's a bunch of threads arguing over whether the majority want this, that or the other. This may not be very scientific, but it's better than nothing so please take a few moments to post your answers to these questions. No debates in this thread please, there's plenty of other threads for that.
1. Did you make your jedi with PVP as your primary goal? I made it for the power more than the PVP, but I was gonna bite the bullet as far as PVP went
2. If you are a full template jedi do you enjoy being hunted by bounty hunters? Just 1 more tree to go
3. If you are a grinding jedi do you enjoy being hunted by bounty hunters? Wouldn't know, i haven't been hunted yet.
4Are you in favour of removing visibility from NPCs? I think the system needs to be changed,
5. Are you in favour of reinstating sabre TEF? No, visibility is enough, unless we got some reward for the risk...
6. Are you in favour of jedi being allowed to be PVE only and hunted only by NPC bounty hunters in exchange for some sort of penalty (eg not being allowed to enter FRS orPVP jedi being given extra abilities over PVE jedi)? It should be like Covert / Overt, you should be able to switch on and off.
7. If you are currently against forced PVP, ifxp loss from BH death was removed, would you then be in favour of being hunted? Sounds to exploitable, with the credits and all. Give BHs some risk, they already have the rewards end.
Heres my take on Vis:
--Same Faction NPCS shouldnt give it (Why would your own faction Turn you in?)
--Dantooine Cavemen/women and othersecluded NPCs (nightsisters, singing mountain, etc)shouldnt give it (they're primitave, who are they gonna tell?)
--Wearing Robes in public and holding sabers should (Pretty obvious that someone is a jedi when they're wearing a robe, right?)
--Of course, the Jedi abilites should stay the same
--"No Tag Backs Rule" People who leave your groups should be able to give vis for the first 20 seconds of leaving the group
--"You're gonna turn me in NPC? You can't turn me in if you're DEAD!!! HAHAHAHAHAHA!!! Rule" - Give Jedi 30 seconds for the first NPC, and 10 more seconds for each NPC around that gives vis. But hen the Jedi should get the TEF if its an imp or reb group that gets killed, they should be made a target for anyone (NPC and player alike).
I could probably think of more, but this is just the first of stuff that comes to mind
--Same Faction NPCS shouldnt give it (Why would your own faction Turn you in?)
--Dantooine Cavemen/women and othersecluded NPCs (nightsisters, singing mountain, etc)shouldnt give it (they're primitave, who are they gonna tell?)
--Wearing Robes in public and holding sabers should (Pretty obvious that someone is a jedi when they're wearing a robe, right?)
--Of course, the Jedi abilites should stay the same
--"No Tag Backs Rule" People who leave your groups should be able to give vis for the first 20 seconds of leaving the group
--"You're gonna turn me in NPC? You can't turn me in if you're DEAD!!! HAHAHAHAHAHA!!! Rule" - Give Jedi 30 seconds for the first NPC, and 10 more seconds for each NPC around that gives vis. But hen the Jedi should get the TEF if its an imp or reb group that gets killed, they should be made a target for anyone (NPC and player alike).
I could probably think of more, but this is just the first of stuff that comes to mind
BeefStoo
Sat Oct 01, 2005 10:19 pm
#36
1. No
2. I'm not full template. I don't exploit trails.
3. No. What's to enjoy when the lack of good pearls/crystals keeps you from having a good saber?
4. Yes. Opposite factions should be able to report visibility though.
5. Maybeh.
6. I need more thought on that.
7. Sure, why not.
RosaShyanne
Sun Oct 02, 2005 12:00 am
#37
Vlherg wrote:
1. Did you make your jedi with PVP as your primary goal?
2. If you are a full template jedi do you enjoy being hunted by bounty hunters?
3. If you are a grinding jedi do you enjoy being hunted by bounty hunters?
4Are you in favour of removing visibility from NPCs?
5. Are you in favour of reinstating sabre TEF?
6. Are you in favour of jedi being allowed to be PVE only and hunted only by NPC bounty hunters in exchange for some sort of penalty (eg not being allowed to enter FRS orPVP jedi being given extra abilities over PVE jedi)?
7. If you are currently against forced PVP, ifxp loss from BH death was removed, would you then be in favour of being hunted?
1. No, but I understood it was a PvP toon during my unlocking process.
2. Yes, though their timing stinks.
3. Yes, made spin groups fun, but again, their timing stinks.
4. YES, I can't complete in-game content as too many MBH's arrive during my quests.
5. Yes, but only providing Jedi get a big enough boost in power to compensate for the 10on1 daily fights this will bring.
6. YES YES YES.
7. I am not against MBH missions, though I would like a "benefit" for my involuntary involvment, not removal of XP, but maybe a loot drop equivalent to an NPC of equal CL.
EvilAztec
Sun Oct 02, 2005 12:01 am
#38
1. Did you make your jedi with PVP as your primary goal?
Nope, I don't get paid to be someone else's content, so I don't PvP.
2. If you are a full template jedi do you enjoy being hunted by bounty hunters?
I consider a complete and utter waste of my time.
3. If you are a grinding jedi do you enjoy being hunted by bounty hunters?
NA
4Are you in favour of removing visibility from NPCs?
Not really.
5. Are you in favour of reinstating sabre TEF?
Give me my 20x power back along with premium pearls and I won't mind.
6. Are you in favour of jedi being allowed to be PVE only and hunted only by NPC bounty hunters in exchange for some sort of penalty (eg not being allowed to enter FRS orPVP jedi being given extra abilities over PVE jedi)?
I think this whole player hunting system is stupid. It generates a boatload of animosity with no real effect. A *real* system would be get too much vis and you have to fight Lord Vader (or maybe Mara Jade, fill in the blank) and if you get killed you get blue glowie time, increasing time the higher level you are. So a newbie Jedi has very little glowie time while a Full temp might get a week or two (or more).
7. If you are currently against forced PVP, ifxp loss from BH death was removed, would you then be in favour of being hunted?
Actually no, see answer to #6.
BooshkaUK
Sun Oct 02, 2005 12:14 am
#39
Vlherg wrote:
So there's a bunch of threads arguing over whether the majority want this, that or the other. This may not be very scientific, but it's better than nothing so please take a few moments to post your answers to these questions. No debates in this thread please, there's plenty of other threads for that.
1. Did you make your jedi with PVP as your primary goal?
Not really, i became a Jedi as i had nothing else to do, i mainly PvP with my MBH/Rifles/Cm4000 char
2. If you are a full template jedi do you enjoy being hunted by bounty hunters?
Depends, i would prefer the choice to PvP as and when I wish to on my Jedi
3. If you are a grinding jedi do you enjoy being hunted by bounty hunters?
Full temp
4Are you in favour of removing visibility from NPCs?
Yes
5. Are you in favour of reinstating sabre TEF?
No
6. Are you in favour of jedi being allowed to be PVE only and hunted only by NPC bounty hunters in exchange for some sort of penalty (eg not being allowed to enter FRS orPVP jedi being given extra abilities over PVE jedi)?
Not sure to be honest, I would like to see a FRS that supports all playstyles and not just a PvP one
7. If you are currently against forced PVP, ifxp loss from BH death was removed, would you then be in favour of being hunted?
Problem with that is people could find a way to abuse it, might be better just removing the BH v Jedi system, hasn't really stopped people Jedi, then again it might not, but it would get rid ofa lot of hate which fills the forums.