Doctor Archive

Thread: Doctor Poll Would you trade heal strength for speed?

TheTemplar2
Thu May 26, 2005 9:41 am
#14

I would like this:


  • Bacta Shot Increased power at current or slightly longer recasting speed.

  • Bacta Jab about the same power but very fast recasting speed.

  • A final heal with a wind-up timer healing alot of damage.



- Diekid Murmalon
Temporary account, currently on a break

The deathstar destroyed a planet, SOE destroyed galaxies...
blacke
Thu May 26, 2005 12:29 pm
#15



Caelrie wrote:


MataHairy wrote:
The devs evidently see the doctor profession as one providing small, frequent cures. Currently, the strongest heal is Master Doctor Bacta shot for around 800 points. Judging from the forums many Doctors aren't happy with having low powered heals and would like to have heals at least as strong as the 1500 power heal from a 4000 jedi healer.

You can have my 1500 Jedi heal when I can have your armor, def mods, buffs and rez.




Ehm..... Since when did a 4000 force healer become a "better" healer according to the profesion role chart SOE put up? I know, Jedi aren't on it but if you place the different disciplines on it from Jedi, where would a 4000 healer end, and where would a master force healer end up. In my oppinion, the only prof that should have a chance to out rank a MD in healing would be a master force healer, never a 4000 force healer.

And for the other stuff:
buffs?? they are not that effective as they once where. Food do an equal, if not even better, job.
Defence mods?? MD get +50 melee and ranged in total. It's not that much compared to other profs.
Rezz?? Get the cyber arm if you are desperate to heal others.
Armor?? Ok, maybe we have an advantage there but you have a much higher heal power with a much lower SP cost which means you can spend more SP on defense and/or offense.

Not to try to start a flame here, but you have to consider what we invest into getting this heal compared to what you get to your investment.






Tizzossk Dun'Daro -- Master Commando / Master Bounty Hunter / 0400 Carbiner -- Rebel Colonel
Katabhi -- future Pikewoman / Master CH

Giftmacher
Thu May 26, 2005 1:55 pm
#16






MataHairy wrote:

The devs evidently see the doctor profession as one providing small, frequent cures. Currently, the strongest heal is Master Doctor Bacta shot for around 800 points. Judging from the forums many Doctors aren't happy with having low powered heals andwould like to have heals at least as strong as the 1500 power heal from a 4000 jedi healer.


The questions for this poll are:


(1) Would you prefer Doctor's Bacta Shot:

(a)to be of increased power with longer recharge time (same heals/time), or

(b) keep as currently working.


Got to be (a)


If you answered (a) above,

(2)Would you prefer for Master Doctor to have:

(a) 1600ish heal with 2x current ramp and recharge rate, or

(b) 2400ish heal with 3x current ramp and recharge rate.


Love (b) but realistically (a) would be fine.


Please vote only once and keep comments short with no extended discussions. Thanks!


Ok quick note on why, Bacta Jab can't keep up with damage delt by the meaner mobs. Even even with shot you know a tank is going down when they agro anything tough (and that assumes you don't get hate LOL a whole other problem); it's the slippery slope..

Gift.






Farrs
Thu May 26, 2005 2:52 pm
#17






MataHairy wrote:


The devs evidently see the doctor profession as one providing small, frequent cures. Currently, the strongest heal is Master Doctor Bacta shot for around 800 points. Judging from the forums many Doctors aren't happy with having low powered heals andwould like to have heals at least as strong as the 1500 power heal from a 4000 jedi healer.


The questions for this poll are:


(1) Would you prefer Doctor's Bacta Shot:

(a)to be of increased power with longer recharge time (same heals/time), or

(b) keep as currently working.


If you answered (a) above,

(2)Would you prefer for Master Doctor to have:

(a) 1600ish heal with 2x current ramp and recharge rate, or

(b) 2400ish heal with 3x current ramp and recharge rate.


Please vote only once and keep comments short with no extended discussions. Thanks!



Votes as of 5/26 14:00 PST

Question #1

Option A (increase heals/longer recharge) = 6

Option B (keep as is) = 2

None of the above (only interested in higher strength if same duration) = 3


Question #2

Of those voting stronger with longer recharge, a 1600ish heal is the overwhelming favorite ATM.



Message Edited by MataHairy on 05-26-2005 02:18 PM





Most important for me - decrease the recharge/Speed next would be increase the heal but that is best of both worlds.





- Farrs


Dr. Farrs Marek / Mayor of Rogue's Roost, Coreilla
-RR- Revenant Regiment

(g/cccccc/gxWXggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg)

Bunklung
Thu May 26, 2005 3:52 pm
#18

1b


Onone hand, I really likethe idea of a much larger heal. I wouldn't have to focus onjuggling heals.


However, hitting 1k with a droid is perfect. It'll even keep the DE busy making money. I guess the problem is droids need to be tougher


Keep up the good work Mata!





CANCELLED - Ex-Jedi@Ahazi
Master Enhancer - 0404LS,0040D,4000H,0400P
GET A REFUND ON TooW

MataHairy
Thu May 26, 2005 4:34 pm
#19






Bunklung wrote:

1b


Onone hand, I really likethe idea of a much larger heal. I wouldn't have to focus onjuggling heals.


However, hitting 1k with a droid is perfect. It'll even keep the DE busy making money. I guess the problem is droids need to be tougher


Keep up the good work Mata!








I dunno. It doesnt seem right to me that a Master Doc or CM needs to have a droid following him/her around in order to perform a decent heal.


Oh, and as a side comment: I'm sure all doctors would all like to see both an increase in speed and heals. But the devs might feel more heals per time is overpowered (hard to believe but true). I put these options together with heals per time constant,to present an alternative approach to thedevsIF there is a consensus in the community.


Message Edited by MataHairy on 05-26-2005 04:40 PM



Matta
Healer's Haven, Corellia (2120,4300)
Proprietor of Matta's Meds --- Ahazi's Finest Meds
One of the first Master Combat Medics, and the very last Medic Correspondent
Page 2 of 2