Commando Archive

I feel that field tactics is not worthy of being a stand alone skill line.

sign if you feel it needs Terrain Negotiation so live up to it's name

I am going to have to disagree, now that mounts are out I disagree even more, if anything I don't think CM's should get it either. That is a scout/ranger skill and should only be given to people that spend the skill points to get it.

your 100% right its filed tatics it should have it that and being abel to lay mines and charges and use the train to are atvanteg like runing behind a hill and lobing a gernade over it

I agree, terrain negotiation should be in the Field tactics line. It makes sense. What are some components of "tactics"? Knowledge, power, SPEED, accuracy. These traits accuratly describe someone who is a master in field tactics. Squad leaders get terrain negotiation right? Combat medics get terrian negotiation right? One might say well a CM needs to get to his patients quick on the battlefield. I would retort saying thats why he has ranged healing. I cant see why Squad leaders get terrain negotiation...heh, they can outrun thier troops? But for all sakes Im not crying for a nerf of those professions.. hey congrats to you for having a useful skill. If anything Im envious. I think we as commandos should also get terrain negotiation.

Cresslin

Master Commando

Leader of DFR

/agree

Especially if the CH's /scouts/ ranger nerf herders come on our forum to try and boo the idea down.

Quit trying to rob skills from other classes. Just take exploration 3 from the scout class. It doesn't use many skill points.

---

Paycheck wrote:
Quit trying to rob skills from other classes. Just take exploration 3 from the scout class. It doesn't use many skill points.

---

/sarcasm on

Yea 24 Skill points isn't that much, ohh wait it's ~10% of our total, but that isn't that bad.

/sarcasm off

i don't know if we need a petition, but i think i'd like to see a terrain negotiation +10 somewhere along the line. it'd be nice, and with mounts, theres even MORE reason to add it, because it doesn't matter as much. but why should we need to spend 18 skill credits for just terrain negotiation? give it to use and we can avoid the scout line all together.

Agree

I have to somewhat disagree on this one. Terrain negotiation is another skill trees skill. Hoqw would we like it if those evil chefs said they should get flamethrower certifications to cook with?

I do think your on the right track though, but think we should only be able to up the pase while in combat. Then be able to fortify an area, build entrenchments, or even set up watch towers and mind fields with barb wire. Now that would be cool and feel very commandoish.

after hearing some diferent points I say I agree with you now on this one.

/agree

Hello...boot camp?

Does boot camp not teach a soldier about negotiating terrain?

TN should be in the Field Tactics line...

my sizable bothan faction has agreed to support this (old) yet worthy cause

/sign