Carbineer Archive
Thread: burned at the stake by TAfirehawk
Page 1 of 1
PacM2512
Fri Jun 25, 2004 8:40 pm
#1
All I have to say is "owwwwwwwwww"
OK.....who rezzed that Dead Horse? You shall be publically flogged and Flamed...
A Stun Carbine....you have got to be sh!tting me.....
Please come over to Chilastra and I will gladly show you that I can take on any 3 profs at once.....excluding CM of course.
Let the One-Star Bandit loose......
We all feel so honored that you approve of the Top 5 List we have.....OMG we are saved as he sent this to SOE.....Nova look out, we got a new Carbineer Hero....
My goodness man, have you ever played Pistoleer and fought a Carbineer.....it is quite humorous as the Carbineer that is smart pwns the Pistoleer every time.
And yes I have been Master Pistoleer with 0040 Smuggler......
Have you ever heard of STUN COMPOSITE ARMOR????? Duh.....I have 37% Stun/82% Base Comp Armor......
Oh and the Imp Experimental PSG (let me spell it out for ya) Personal Shield Generator is 40% Stun or 47% Stun I believe.....don't remember exact numbers.
Please oh please fire those Stun Guns at me, THAT is the I WIN BUTTON for this Carbineer.....
Do some research into FACTS before coming in THIS Forum and pretending to know how to solve "World Hunger"......
Dang.
Doq_Utek
Sat Jun 26, 2004 1:18 am
#2
Heh, don't sweat it man. I read the tread. TAfirehawk can get alittle selfrightous sometimes but he's good for the community. I would say that Nova's response is more appropriate. I'm sure you meant well but I do agree that giving us a stun wepon is just a bandaid solution and doesn't address thereal issues of combat imbalance. Gah, I hate to say it but wait for the rebalance. 
I feel confident that our needs will be addressed then. The way I figure it we've had the short end of the stick for so long what's another month or two gonna matter. Also I have seen TH post several times that there will be an oppourtunity for us to voice our concerns before the CB goes live.
I feel confident that our needs will be addressed then. The way I figure it we've had the short end of the stick for so long what's another month or two gonna matter. Also I have seen TH post several times that there will be an oppourtunity for us to voice our concerns before the CB goes live.
RyushiYoshi
Sat Jun 26, 2004 4:09 am
#3
So much faith into something we have no details on may be hazardous to your mental and even social health once it comes around
Doq_Utek wrote:
Heh, don't sweat it man. I read the tread. TAfirehawk can get alittle selfrightous sometimes but he's good for the community. I would say that Nova's response is more appropriate. I'm sure you meant well but I do agree that giving us a stun wepon is just a bandaid solution and doesn't address thereal issues of combat imbalance. Gah, I hate to say it but wait for the rebalance.
. Though we really have no choice but to wait for it, we still have to have one hand behind our backs crossing our fingers, ya know? 
TAfirehawk
Sat Jun 26, 2004 8:15 am
#4
PacM2512 wrote:
you have to read this thread to get it... you completely mistook what i said.
http://forums.station.sony.com/swg/board/message?board.id=carabineer&message.id=32983
I don't think anybody mistook what you said....
And I am glad nobody will be confused about what I said either....
And for the record I am very emotional and proud of Carbineers....big news there I know 
BUT I WAS NOT ATTACKING YOU PERSONALLY, I was making a stern point about what you were saying and trying to "set the record straight". Of course you are allowed to voice your opinion and I can voice mine that discounts what you posted in that thread. We have had these discussions and all you have to do is read the STICKY posts to know that...
And yes I was a bit over the top and if that has offended anybody then I appologize, but at the same time a person coming into THIS Forum and acting mightier than The Great Nova with respect to the Top 5 and contacting SOE.....well I hope the Flame is still burning.....
EisMan_Buckeye
Sat Jun 26, 2004 11:16 am
#5
The way I see things, it's like "good cop, bad cop". Nova is the good cop, allways being polite and diplomatic. TA is the bad cop, not affraid to rough you up a bit if you get out of line.
Feomatar
Sat Jun 26, 2004 12:09 pm
#6
So you've lost against a carbineer... I understand, if YOU (the master of combat ) loose against a carbineer, the carbineer professionhas to becompletely overpowered.
) loose against a carbineer, the carbineer professionhas to becompletely overpowered.You cry about some carbineers (TAFirehawk doesn't want it, btw) who want a stun damage carbine but some sentences later you tell us that stun damage isn't overpowered at all, because there is stun composite and the imperial psg. So if stun really isn't overpowered, why do you cry that carbineers shouldn't get it?
In my opinion you are only a cheap whin0r who wants all professions except his own to get nerfed, have you posted such a thread in the board of the "overpowered" pikeman profession, too?
Go away...
PacM2512
Sat Jun 26, 2004 12:58 pm
#8
you have to read this thread to get it... you completely mistook what i said.
http://forums.station.sony.com/swg/board/message?board.id=carabineer&message.id=32983
TAfirehawk
Sat Jun 26, 2004 6:31 pm
#9
EisMan_Buckeye wrote:
The way I see things, it's like "good cop, bad cop". Nova is the good cop, allways being polite and diplomatic. TA is the bad cop, not affraid to rough you up a bit if you get out of line.
That is not the first or even the second time that scenario has been brought up.......hmmmmm......
PacM2512
Sat Jun 26, 2004 9:06 pm
#10
aight well here is my thinkin, just to explain:
1) I think that we shouldall send something in to SOE. They have a form for sending in comments. If several hundred people tell them the same thing, they might have a better chance of catching on and fixing the problem. I wasnt tryin to come in here and be like "I know whats goin on better than everyone else, and how to fix it".I was just providing a copy of what I sent to them.
"but at the same time a person coming into THIS Forum and acting mightier than The Great Nova with respect to the Top 5 and contacting SOE.....well I hope the Flame is still burning....."
dangit that wasnt what i was thinkin at all man! I'm a nice person lol!
2) I just thought that nova never gave any specific ways for SOE to fix any problems. This was actually a mistake because I only remembered thissection when nova talked about pvp problems:
Solution: Increase carbine damage.
Solution: Increase the AP1 on the elite carbine to AP2 (the elite carbine is the best choice of carbines for PvP yet lags far behind the AP3 T21)
Solution: increase speed so that carbineers can apply damage faster to overcome healing and regeneration
Solution: Provide a carbine with a damage type that is not easily absorbed by current armors
Solution: Many of the above
Solution: Increase the AP1 on the elite carbine to AP2 (the elite carbine is the best choice of carbines for PvP yet lags far behind the AP3 T21)
Solution: increase speed so that carbineers can apply damage faster to overcome healing and regeneration
Solution: Provide a carbine with a damage type that is not easily absorbed by current armors
Solution: Many of the above
Alternate Solution: Adjust bleeds so that a bleeding target no longer regenerates in the pool that is bleeding. This would have the side benefit of helping other classes that have similar issues in PvP such as Pistoleers.
but in fact I looked again and he HAD said:
Solution: A little speed goes a long way. Bringing the class up to +75 speed at master would help infinitely. We suggest +10 more in the Master Carbineer box and +5 more in the Master Assault Tactics box
Was just throwin in my 2 credits, and I guess ranting a little too .
.
Page 1 of 1