Bio Engineer Archive

Thread: Better resources = worse BSN's?

Physkoris
Sun Dec 19, 2004 12:04 am
#1

After getting Tissues 3 I tried making some BSN's just to see how I compared (at an extremely low level) to the Master BE's. So I grab two stacks of organics: Berries and Fruit and some Carnivore meat..


Berry Stats: Fruit Stats: Meat:

Flav: 715992 743

PE: 924 882 689

OQ: 911 995911


The BSN's with the berries resulted in 67. The BSN's with Fruit resulted in 63. This baffled me, as the Fruit is better than the Berries in all but the PE category. And overall the Berries mixed with the meat it's only 21.5 higher than Fruit/Meat. Can anyone explain what happened here? Is crafting bugged? Are the 3 stats not 33% each?









Scylla Physkoris Elder Jedi
Scylla Australis Macroburst Elder Swordsman Spy
Starsider Australis Macroburst Spy
"Pay attention, because you know you'll have to pay either way.."
Physkoris
Sun Dec 19, 2004 12:22 am
#2

A little update after doing some number crunching..


I saw that in the FAQ's it says that the 33% distribution is incorrect and that it's 20%/30%/50% (F/PE/OQ). After finding this I calculated my numbers again and found that the combo of Fruit/Meat should still result in a higher stat than Berries/Meat.


The overall numbers:

Berries: 843.25

Fruit: 885.65


This still makes me question why I got better results with the berries rather than the fruit. Are there hidden values that I'm not taking into account?


My formula was: [(meat flavor + other flavor) x 0.2] + [(meat PE + other PE) x 0.3] + [(meat OQ + other OQ) x 0.5] = final value









Scylla Physkoris Elder Jedi
Scylla Australis Macroburst Elder Swordsman Spy
Starsider Australis Macroburst Spy
"Pay attention, because you know you'll have to pay either way.."
Physkoris
Sun Dec 19, 2004 12:26 am
#3

Bah.. Just realized that it probably calculates that 60 units of Berries/Fruit compared to 20 Meat. Argh.. I still don't understand how I get lower stats with "better" resources..









Scylla Physkoris Elder Jedi
Scylla Australis Macroburst Elder Swordsman Spy
Starsider Australis Macroburst Spy
"Pay attention, because you know you'll have to pay either way.."
ArthurDentOnBria
Sun Dec 19, 2004 10:52 am
#4


You'd need to repeat your experiment a bunch of times to see the variations in the results. Most of the stuff in the FAQ assumes master level BE, since most of the people doing the research are long time masters. I know that there are "success" levels at assembly just as there are "success levels" during experimentation, so that may be a factor. My guess is that if you compared a "great success" in one with a "great success" in the other, both values would be identical at assembly time, but that one may allow for an extra point of experimentation over the other. That's generally how it works out.


If you really do want to make chef tissues though to use, don't forget to use wood (with high OQ)whenever possible to satisfy the "flora" ingredient. You definitely get much better results that way, and it saves you from having to use as much of the primo berries/fruits etc that are better used for other things.





Physkoris wrote:

At the time I was only 0/3/0/0, so no, I wasn't using any experimentation points. Also.. I went back and tried a few things. I think that the Food/Chemical Crafting tool I was using for the fruit wasn't as good as the one used with berries. After retesting on a 14.9 crafting tool I got 65's on both berries and fruit. So maybe I'm just low level enough that I'm getting random results and I shouldn't be concerned.






Message Edited by ArthurDentOnBria on 12-19-2004 09:56 AM



ArthurDent - former Bio Engineer, Tailor, and Droid Engineer
Account cancelled 7/8/05 due to game breaking bugs in these professions that have been neglected for FAR too long. Last day July 27 2005
custom tailoring and droid orders welcome. "making Evil products since July 2003"
Achiever: 80%, Explorer: 60%, Socializer: 46%, Killa 13%


WaiterFurall
Sun Dec 19, 2004 1:01 pm
#5

According to Lantyssa's Calc.. The Berries should produce a 85 BSN and the Fruit should produce a 87 BSN. Are you using the full 10 experimentation points?



[ Sinsai ]
Armor/Loots
-5020 -5715
Wayfar, Tatooine
[ R.I.S Certified]
Physkoris
Sun Dec 19, 2004 1:32 pm
#6

At the time I was only 0/3/0/0, so no, I wasn't using any experimentation points. Also.. I went back and tried a few things. I think that the Food/Chemical Crafting tool I was using for the fruit wasn't as good as the one used with berries. After retesting on a 14.9 crafting tool I got 65's on both berries and fruit. So maybe I'm just low level enough that I'm getting random results and I shouldn't be concerned.









Scylla Physkoris Elder Jedi
Scylla Australis Macroburst Elder Swordsman Spy
Starsider Australis Macroburst Spy
"Pay attention, because you know you'll have to pay either way.."
Physkoris
Sun Dec 19, 2004 11:41 pm
#7






ArthurDentOnBria wrote:


You'd need to repeat your experiment a bunch of times to see the variations in the results. Most of the stuff in the FAQ assumes master level BE, since most of the people doing the research are long time masters. I know that there are "success" levels at assembly just as there are "success levels" during experimentation, so that may be a factor. My guess is that if you compared a "great success" in one with a "great success" in the other, both values would be identical at assembly time, but that one may allow for an extra point of experimentation over the other. That's generally how it works out.


If you really do want to make chef tissues though to use, don't forget to use wood (with high OQ)whenever possible to satisfy the "flora" ingredient. You definitely get much better results that way, and it saves you from having to use as much of the primo berries/fruits etc that are better used for other things.





Physkoris wrote:

At the time I was only 0/3/0/0, so no, I wasn't using any experimentation points. Also.. I went back and tried a few things. I think that the Food/Chemical Crafting tool I was using for the fruit wasn't as good as the one used with berries. After retesting on a 14.9 crafting tool I got 65's on both berries and fruit. So maybe I'm just low level enough that I'm getting random results and I shouldn't be concerned.







Message Edited by ArthurDentOnBria on 12-19-2004 09:56 AM





Thanks for the explanation. I figured it had something to do with my low-level. Like I said, it was just a test to see what I could do at such a low level. Can't wait til master so I can start with the real deal!









Scylla Physkoris Elder Jedi
Scylla Australis Macroburst Elder Swordsman Spy
Starsider Australis Macroburst Spy
"Pay attention, because you know you'll have to pay either way.."
rahbert
Mon Dec 20, 2004 7:13 am
#8






Physkoris wrote:
I saw that in the FAQ's it says that the 33% distribution is incorrect and that it's 20%/30%/50% (F/PE/OQ).





Seriously? I assumed that it was "fixed" to be 33% since that is what it says in-game. Is it really 20/30/50 eventhough the schematic says 33/33/33 in-game? Why are the devs so lazy?

Zadokk
Mon Dec 20, 2004 7:16 am
#9






rahbert wrote:





Physkoris wrote:
I saw that in the FAQ's it says that the 33% distribution is incorrect and that it's 20%/30%/50% (F/PE/OQ).





Seriously? I assumed that it was "fixed" to be 33% since that is what it says in-game. Is it really 20/30/50 eventhough the schematic says 33/33/33 in-game? Why are the devs so lazy?





Yep. You should read the FAQ more often


*points to clicky in his sig*


rahbert
Mon Dec 20, 2004 10:19 am
#10


I did read the FAQ. You should take the time to read my post more carefully


I thought the FAQ was outdated and foolishlyassumed that SOE took 20 seconds to fix the formula to reflect the 33% weighting.


*points to devs waisting time on adding fake content instead of fixing existingbugs*

Zadokk
Mon Dec 20, 2004 10:24 am
#11






rahbert wrote:


I did read the FAQ. You should take the time to read my post more carefully


I thought the FAQ was outdated and foolishlyassumed that SOE took 20 seconds to fix the formula to reflect the 33% weighting.


*points to devs waisting time on adding fake content instead of fixing existingbugs*






lol it was last updated on the 13th of November - how out of date did you think it was?
Hylidex
Mon Dec 20, 2004 2:49 pm
#12






Physkoris wrote:

A little update after doing some number crunching..


I saw that in the FAQ's it says that the 33% distribution is incorrect and that it's 20%/30%/50% (F/PE/OQ). After finding this I calculated my numbers again and found that the combo of Fruit/Meat should still result in a higher stat than Berries/Meat.


The overall numbers:

Berries: 843.25

Fruit: 885.65


This still makes me question why I got better results with the berries rather than the fruit. Are there hidden values that I'm not taking into account?


My formula was: [(meat flavor + other flavor) x 0.2] + [(meat PE + other PE) x 0.3] + [(meat OQ + other OQ) x 0.5] = final value







Your degree of "success" has an effect on the final outcome. The outcomes are not fixed. Instead there is some sort of random factor built in. Your resources are very close in value, so a "great success" on one combination might outweigh a "good success" on the other one, even with better resources.


Once you have 10 experimentation points to add, you have a high probability of finding the maximum possible value for both combinations. At that time, your results may be a bit more predictable, since less is left to chance.




Hylidex Lightstrider
AFS Outfitters, League of all Factions and Species (LAFS)
-6600, 4440, Theed, Naboo, Gorath
Page 1 of 1
Previous Next