Bio Engineer Archive

Thread: Did a test with Defense mod Clothing...

evhorizon
Tue Jun 21, 2005 10:03 am
#1

I had heard a rumor that the Defense Mods put in Clothing from BE tissue didn't work/were broken. So I ran a test with my friend and here are the results.

Before Clothing using Ranged shot only.

322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)

With BE clothes on - (Shirt + Pants with +16 ranged/melee defense mods)

322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)

I got the exact same result with the BE clothes on as I did with them off. I suppose this may be an already known bug, I just thought you guys might have an interest.





TAIRA
ILost MyGuild
SHADOWFIRE
I stole Kered'ssiggy toov Cause I love Avar



evhorizon
Tue Jun 21, 2005 10:04 am
#2

I had heard a rumor that the Defense Mods put in Clothing from BE tissue didn't work/were broken. So I ran a test with my friend and here are the results.

Before Clothing using Ranged shot only.

322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)

With BE clothes on - (Shirt + Pants with +16 ranged/melee defense mods)

322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)

I got the exact same result with the BE clothes on as I did with them off. I suppose this may be an already known bug, I just thought you guys might have an interest.





TAIRA
ILost MyGuild
SHADOWFIRE
I stole Kered'ssiggy toov Cause I love Avar



Kaomond
Tue Jun 21, 2005 10:50 am
#3






evhorizon wrote:
I had heard a rumor that the Defense Mods put in Clothing from BE tissue didn't work/were broken. So I ran a test with my friend and here are the results.

Before Clothing using Ranged shot only.

322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)

With BE clothes on - (Shirt + Pants with +16 ranged/melee defense mods)

322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)

I got the exact same result with the BE clothes on as I did with them off. I suppose this may be an already known bug, I just thought you guys might have an interest.




are you sure the md/rd tissues are supposed to effect damage taken? because i'm sure someone told methat it wasn't a damage reduction thing but an avoidence thing, check your log again and see what the varience in the creature/npc missing you is




Kaomond Medi / Kaomir Medi / Belios Goveko / Kao' Medi

Chimaera / Bloodfin


Founding Member of BEta(BE Training Academy) the non-profit
'
BE for fun and research' organization



lammergeier
Tue Jun 21, 2005 11:17 am
#4



evhorizon wrote:
I had heard a rumor that the Defense Mods put in Clothing from BE tissue didn't work/were broken. So I ran a test with my friend and here are the results.

Before Clothing using Ranged shot only.

322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)

With BE clothes on - (Shirt + Pants with +16 ranged/melee defense mods)

322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)
322 Damage (221 since elemental isn't working as intended)

I got the exact same result with the BE clothes on as I did with them off. I suppose this may be an already known bug, I just thought you guys might have an interest.




what was their BASE ranged/melee defense?



---------------------"...race you to the cloner!"

xaq, Ossifrage: bloodfin-----------------------------------------Sechs: tempest
Lammergeier: bria------------------------------------------------Accipiter: ahazi

Jinks, Zaw ZeroEight, Raphael', Shub-Niggurath, Randolph Carter, Belpo
...the thorns of Test Center

-------------------------------lammergeier tracker
lammergeier
Tue Jun 21, 2005 11:23 am
#5



Kaomond wrote:

are you sure the md/rd tissues are supposed to effect damage taken? because i'm sure someone told me that it wasn't a damage reduction thing but an avoidence thing, check your log again and see what the varience in the creature/npc missing you is





accuracy raises damage, defense reduces damage.

avoidance? probably a CL-based calculation.

CL, of course, affects accuracy and defense.

as stat numbers rise, they become less effective (diminishing returns): +25 should be a boost from a base of 0, while +25 on a base of 200 will likely be unnoticeable.



---------------------"...race you to the cloner!"

xaq, Ossifrage: bloodfin-----------------------------------------Sechs: tempest
Lammergeier: bria------------------------------------------------Accipiter: ahazi

Jinks, Zaw ZeroEight, Raphael', Shub-Niggurath, Randolph Carter, Belpo
...the thorns of Test Center

-------------------------------lammergeier tracker
Aynianu
Tue Jun 21, 2005 11:40 am
#6

Argh the badly drawn lightsabres are invading the tailor forums

Aynianu
Tue Jun 21, 2005 11:42 am
#7

Altho to the point...


This bug may be recent as BE mods have been pretty screwed up since pub 18 in crafting, so possibly that existing ones are not functioning atm either.


When they fix the BE crafting bug i hope someone can test this again.


Begining to feel like Tailors are going back to Beta

Barafu
Tue Jun 21, 2005 1:00 pm
#8



evhorizon wrote:
Sorry for the giant LS... Actually thinking of changing my sig because it's getting annoying to me.

I just thought I could help a little, not all Jedi are @$$hats.



Yeah, please keep up the good work and don't let a little saber envy keep you down. We need all the constructive testing information we can get so we know what's working in the game and what's not.

As far as the defense mod clothing goes, it seems to have been broken since at least publish 17 and probably since the CU. This is independent of the broken crafting problems the tailors currently have.



Barafu Firling: Galactic Traveler
Current Assignment: Investigation of Project Eclipse
Read about and join my adventures here
Rub me out at www.swghuntersguild.com
Sign the petition to add writable datapads
ArthurDentOnBria
Tue Jun 21, 2005 1:34 pm
#9

Thanks for sharing this. It was explained to us by I believe it was Blixdev that this should actually make a difference in the damage, but who knows, perhaps he was mistaken. I also don't think that we can explain this and many similar tests as simply reaching a point of diminishing returns, because reducingthe damage by 1 point out of 322 is %0.3. Surely it's not > 0 < %0.3 right?


So I think that leaves 3 possibilities:


1) The tissues are reducing damage, but the display is bugged such that it can't be easily measured.


2) The tissues are reducing accuracy, not damage, despite what we've been told


3) They are completely busted, broken, fubar.





ArthurDent - former Bio Engineer, Tailor, and Droid Engineer
Account cancelled 7/8/05 due to game breaking bugs in these professions that have been neglected for FAR too long. Last day July 27 2005
custom tailoring and droid orders welcome. "making Evil products since July 2003"
Achiever: 80%, Explorer: 60%, Socializer: 46%, Killa 13%


Spazzers
Tue Jun 21, 2005 2:14 pm
#10

I'll pick door number 3 Monty.



Buboopadoo
HOBO Embezzler
A Simple Resource Dealer

A Developer's answer to everything:
"I can't promise to try, but I'll try to try"
RebFin
Tue Jun 21, 2005 5:27 pm
#11

What was the shooter's ranged accuracy?



================
Finwe, Bio-Engineer
Bio Engineered Supplies @ 5520 416 Valinor, Dantooine
BRI Stims @ 159 -5490, CNet
RandDarkstar
Tue Jun 21, 2005 11:02 pm
#12

We did a test, shooting a person with +0 to +62 mods on clothing, and found no changes to the damage done, nor the chances to hit. This was done around Publish 17, so it's a post CU thing.... if it ever worked before CU, I am only guessing.


Food worked though. Trying different foods got the damage to rise and fall.




Jame'thiel Dreamweaver
Master Tailor, Colonel - Rebel Alliance, Gorath Server

evhorizon
Wed Jun 22, 2005 12:18 am
#13

Sorry for the giant LS... Actually thinking of changing my sig because it's getting annoying to me.

I just thought I could help a little, not all Jedi are @$$hats.





TAIRA
ILost MyGuild
SHADOWFIRE
I stole Kered'ssiggy toov Cause I love Avar



Page 1 of 2
Previous Next