Architect Archive

Thread: About Petitions

_-ArchAngel-_
Thu Nov 06, 2003 12:21 pm
#1

Hey folks,


I've noticed an upswing of petitioneers here and I thought I should come right out and address the issue right off the bat. Please don't make petitions here.


I consider this forum a good area of discussion. Many people have proposed good ideas. I send a ton of good ideas off to the devs every day. Often I reply in the threads that I have sent off (but sometimes not because I don't have the time at that particular moment). A good idea is a good idea, and a game-breaking concept isa game-breaking concept. The number of people who sign will not impact on the base idea. If a dev or myself reads an idea, the number of signatures that are attached to it will not impact on weather it is considered good or not. The feedback associated to it will, but simply having 500 /signs attached to it will change nothing. In some cases, petitions have been started on things that have already been discussed to death, or there are already a few petitions running about that subject, just cluttering up our forums.


If there was a petition to increase damage on the T21s to 4000, even if the entire forum signed it, it still wouldn't happen. Even if someone provides an amazing bug report or an idea, and there aren't more than 4 views, I will still take a look at it. If I already sent it off to the devs, petitioning for it again will not make it happen faster.


So please take these things into consideration before posting. If you think you have a really crazy-awesome idea and you're not sure how to get it through, just send it through me via PM, and I'll start a poll for it or have a look at it, but don't clutter up our forum with petitions. We have enough problems with duplicate threads on critical failures etc... to add something else.


Thanks for your consideration.




Dr. Doriann Kalhoon
Master Artisan/Master Architect/Droid Engineer
Bloodfin/TestCenter

Dayln
Thu Nov 06, 2003 12:23 pm
#2

Thanks Angel, I will refrain from posting on a petition thread again.
_-ArchAngel-_
Thu Nov 06, 2003 12:32 pm
#3

Heh don't worry Dayln I'm not mad or anything, just trying to get things moving as smoothly as possible




Dr. Doriann Kalhoon
Master Artisan/Master Architect/Droid Engineer
Bloodfin/TestCenter

_-ArchAngel-_
Thu Nov 06, 2003 2:03 pm
#4

Like I said, it's all good. I didn't want to come across as angry or condecending. I had actually proposed the "lot increase" issue a few weeks back to the devs, for a different reason. Ressource costs are what are killing us, now that we already have a "pre-determined" price for our stuff. Increasing our lots at master would reduce the costs to produce items, effectively giving us more income.


Once again, I apologize to those who think I'm yelling at them, it's just earlier on in the week, I saw 2-3petitions floating around, mainly related to stuff I had already addressed in previous posts.


Ido read the stuff here, you don't need to start a petition to get my attention




Dr. Doriann Kalhoon
Master Artisan/Master Architect/Droid Engineer
Bloodfin/TestCenter

Sithgolf
Fri Nov 07, 2003 1:20 am
#5

If this is in response to my posting about Master Architects getting additional slots I am sorry for making these boards hard for you to read. Had I taken the time to search out and find previous posts concerning this issue and posted my comments on the end of it wouldn't you have been flagged to read it as well? Not trying to stir up debate, just was posting my frustrations and didn't mean to offend.




__ E l d e rDark K n i g h t____________________
______Whyzdom Reigns_____


lnnnnnn
W9
gggggggggggggggggggggg)


Yes this is MY elder jedi account, No i didnt Fight Club for weeks to get a rank so i could brag about it on the forums.
Sithgolf
Fri Nov 07, 2003 12:06 pm
#6

Well said.. please see the new Un-Petition in the Arch section.




__ E l d e rDark K n i g h t____________________
______Whyzdom Reigns_____


lnnnnnn
W9
gggggggggggggggggggggg)


Yes this is MY elder jedi account, No i didnt Fight Club for weeks to get a rank so i could brag about it on the forums.
Jyss
Sat Nov 08, 2003 3:33 am
#7

Is this a petion thread to stop petition threads?


i petition to stick that harvester command thread...


really those are some great commands to know





Jyss
Master Architectress and Master Tailor
Vyss
Master Musicianess
Furniture Shop -3978 3736
Outside of Theed, Naboo, Bria
Griswel
Mon Nov 10, 2003 7:00 pm
#8

I've never started a petition thread, but I have to say that as much as I appreciate your calm take on the matter, petitions and explosions of player anger do have an effect around here.


AA tells Devs - "Five guys complained about this and I think they're right."


vs


AA tells Devs - "All hades is breaking out over this."


Sorry, those two statements will not produce the same result very often.

_-ArchAngel-_
Mon Nov 10, 2003 7:54 pm
#9

Shh, if you don't tell them they won't know


Petitioneers .... you did not see this post biwan:


Seriously it is true, when all hades breaks loose I do tell the devs all about it, but I don't see that it makes much difference to their response time. For sure it makes a huge hubub, and it makes me jump right on it, but it doesn't increase the resolution time and it just gets me stuck between a rock and a hard place. On one hand I get an angry (or just inquiring) mob, and on the other hand I have the devs, which are generally unresponsive (mainly because their job is to develop, and not to respond to players inquiries). So while an overwhelming petitionmight get me to post something on the dev forum within an hour instead of within a day or two,it might still take me a week to get a response (and a month or two to get a fix ).


The development process is sloooowww. The reporting process is fast. Thus, fast complaints will not get a fast response, and hence the reason why petitions do little to get things done, because all it serves is to get folks all excited about something that may or may not happen a month from now, even though they want it RIGHT NOW. That is my humble opinion.


It does make it easy to sort out what should be on the top 5 though




Dr. Doriann Kalhoon
Master Artisan/Master Architect/Droid Engineer
Bloodfin/TestCenter

netguro2001
Wed Nov 12, 2003 5:30 pm
#10

Have the devs mentioned anything relating to repeat business for architects? Or are they ignoring that issue?
_-ArchAngel-_
Thu Nov 13, 2003 7:07 am
#11

I wouldn't say they are ignoring it, they just aren't saying anything about it. I'm confident that they are working on something, thought no official statement has been released about it.



Dr. Doriann Kalhoon
Master Artisan/Master Architect/Droid Engineer
Bloodfin/TestCenter

EricTheAwful
Mon Nov 17, 2003 10:43 pm
#12

Archangel,


The development process is slow because they want it to be.


The "monthly publish" is a really bad idea now. If the game was working correctly, once a month would be fine. In it's current state, I'd say a weekly publish would be a PR boon, even if it was only the monthly publish broken in to 4 parts.


Doingit weekly at least makes it look like you're doing something. Instead we get, "Yeah, yeah.. We know... Next publish, I promise..." over and over.



Marduke Akkad




Marduke Akkad
Master Architect
Talus
TheNeoPatch
Tue Nov 18, 2003 8:28 am
#13

Actual publish time is not slow it's kinda perfect, maybe even a bit too fast...


One month for a publish is :


2 weeks development


1 week test and prepare publish


Publish


1 week to (hot)fix publish bugs



If you shorten the time between publishes you unbalance even more the ratio "dev time" / "publish test-fix time" not a good idea as the only productive time is the 2 weeks developpement time.


I'm kinda slightly exagerating but I'm a dev in RL and I know that the more you make publish, the more time you lose for developpements.





Akanassi - CH/Weaponsmith
Akanassi Industries Weaponshop and Vespera Dream House Designs at 196 -6148 near Anchorhead - Tatooine - Eclipse !!!
For all your need in weapons, houses, factories and furnitures !!!

"Fought Dark Jedi Masters... What a blast !!!
Still got my 2 hands ... Nice !!!"

Page 1 of 3
Previous Next